As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

December 1920

4 articles

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

The piece recalls the December 2, 1896 Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight in San Francisco, where Wyatt Earp served as referee and awarded the bout to Sharkey on a foul claim after Fitzsimmons had knocked him out. It notes the resulting riot, days of court cases, and accusations that Earp had fixed the outcome.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 9 December 1920 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

FOUGHT TWENTY-FOUR YEARS AGO

Bob Fitzsimmons (left) and Tom Sharkey. On December 2, 1896, one of the most memorable contests was staged in San Francisco, when Bob Fitzsimmons and Tom Sharkey fought eight rounds in Pavilion Hall. Fitzsimmons caught the burley sailor Sharkey and floored him for the full count. Thousands of dollars had been bet on the outcome, with 4 to 1 that Fitz would win. Wyatt Earp, Arizona gunman, was referee and gave the fight to Sharkey, claiming a foul. A riot took place; court cases went for days, no one willing to pay their bets, declaring that it was a put up fight on part of the referee. Many will remember that memorable contest, and many still think that it was the greatest of all time.

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

Boxing champion James J. Corbett recalls the controversial 1896 Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight in San Francisco, focusing on the fierce dispute over naming Wyatt Earp as referee. He claims Sharkey's manager wanted Earp while Fitzsimmons' camp resisted, fearing a rigged decision against their fighter.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 12 days later.

Wrong

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 13 December 1920 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Gruelling Battle

By JAMES J. CORBETT

See moreSee less

It is nearly 25 years since Bob Fritzsimmons and Tom Sharkey put on their famous bout in Frisco—but it is well remembered among the most sensational in fight history.

The battle date was December 2, 1896. When Fritz signed articles for that fight, a warning was sent to him to watch out for Sharkey and his rough tactics and possible jobbing by representatives of a gambling fraternity out there. I had gone against Sharkey only a few months before in what was supposed to be an exhibition bout—and what happened then caused me to anticipate almost anything in connection with the fight.

Martin Julian, manager of Fitzsimmons, kept the warning in mind and made a strenuous fight on the referee question. A dozen names were suggested but those which were favored by Julian were rejected by Dan Lynch, who was managing Sharkey at the time. Lynch wanted Wyatt Earp to referee the contest. Julian and Fitzsimmons opposed Earp.

QUICK ON THE DRAW

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

This reminiscence recounts how Wyatt Earp was chosen to referee the 1896 Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight despite objections from Fitzsimmons' camp, who feared Earp's reputation as a fast gunslinger and rumors of a fix. The account also narrates the brutal early rounds of the fight itself, with both men trading heavy blows.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 13 December 1920 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

QUICK ON THE DRAW

anybody refereeing."

FITZ A TITLE CONTENDER

See moreSee less

Fitz, at the time was the outstanding contender for my title. Sharkey was practically unknown. The betting favored Fitz at 3 to 1 at the outset. But as the fight began, there was a terrific play on Sharkey and so much money was put on the novice heavyweight that the odds were broken down to 1½ to 1.

Sharkey, as usual, started out using his famous rough-house tactics. He got Fitz in an early clinch and nearly snapped his arm off. The freckled warrior broke loose, shot a left to Sharkey's body and a right to the jaw. Tom went down, but bounced right to his feet again, whereupon Fitz landed a right to the heart and once more Tom hit the canvas. Then the gong rang.

TERRIFIC FIGHTING

See the clipping

The Connecticut Labor Press · New Haven, Conn.

The article recalls the December 1896 Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout in San Francisco, where referee Wyatt Earp awarded the fight to Sharkey on a foul claim despite Fitzsimmons having knocked him out. The decision sparked a riot and lengthy court battles as bettors refused to pay, believing the fight was rigged by the referee.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 12 days earlier.

The Connecticut Labor Press · 25 December 1920 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

PUGILISTIC MEMORIES OF THE PAST

On December 2, 1896, one of the most memorable contests was staged in San Francisco, when Bob Fitzsimmons and Tom Sharkey fought eight rounds in Pavilion Hall. Fitzsimmons caught the burly sailor and floored him for the full count. Thousands of dollars had been bet on the outcome, with 4 to 1 that Fitz would win. Wyatt Earp, Arizona gunman, was referee and gave the fight to Sharkey, claiming a foul. A riot took place; court cases went for days, no one willing to pay their bets, declaring that it was a put-up fight on the part of the referee. Many will remember that memorable contest, and many still think it was the greatest of all time.

See the clipping