As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

January 1908

1 article

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Connecticut

The article recounts the famous 1896 boxing match where Fitzsimmons battered Sharkey until an eighth-round knockout blow, after which referee Wyatt Earp declared a foul and awarded Sharkey the win. It notes suspicions that Fitzsimmons avoided certain tactics against Earp due to the lawman's reputation with firearms.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 29 January 1908 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

livan was the winner.

Hardly second to the Tate decision in deliberate unfairness was that rendered by Wyatt Earp when Bob Fitzsimmons knocked out Tom Sharkey in the eighth round of a bout in San Francisco in 1896. Fitz outclassed Sharkey and had the Sailor at his mercy at all stages of the game, but Sharkey had an ace in the hole. The referee was with him, and the Sailor had been coached to yell "Foul!" any time he felt he was on the verge of defeat. Another angle to the battle is the rather well understood fact that Fitz and his clique had laid their money in the pool rooms on the proposition that Sharkey would last six rounds and the Cornishman was to play with the Sailor till after the sixth round and the bets were won, when Fitz was to finish Sharkey in a hurry.

See moreSee less

It is on record that Fitz had great difficulty in delaying the knockout till after the sixth round and that several times he was compelled to slow down in order to permit the Sailor to recover from the effects of a particularly vicious blow. In the fifth round it is said that Fitz deliberately sought Sharkey when the Sailor was about to drop and held him up, with a feigned clinch, till the gong sent him to his corner.

In that way Fitz managed to keep Sharkey going till the end of the sixth round and when the gong called them to the center for the seventh round Fitz started in to end the affair. He gave the Sailor a terriffic beating in the seventh, but Sharkey managed to survive till the eighth, when Old Freckles cut loose with his left shift. After feinting with his right a few times Fitz shifted and drove his left to the pit of the stomach, which doubled up Sharkey like a contortionist. Then Fitz uppercut with the same hand to the jaw and the Sailor went down in a heap. He was knocked out, but as soon as he found his voice, he yelled "Foul!" and writhed about the ring floor in apparent agony. Fitz grinned and began to count up the profits of the bout.

"Sharkey wins on a foul," said Referee Earp, and Fitz turned so pale that all his freckles stood uot like copper pennies. There was some litigation, but Fitz did not get anything except the short end of the purse.

See the clipping