As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

December 1907

3 articles

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

This 1907 retelling recounts how Bat Masterson banished a troublemaker named Driscoll with help from the fearsome Allison's friend, sparking rumors of a Texas cowboy uprising led by Allison. It describes Allison riding unarmed into Dodge City to confront Masterson, who secretly held him at shotgun-point while summoning Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, and other gunmen to prepare for a feared mass attack by Texans wearing big hats.

Omaha Daily Bee · 8 December 1907 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

KILL EVERY MAN WITH A BIG HAT

terson introduced himself to the offensive Mr. Driscoll. Being coldly advised, however, by Mr. Masterson, Mr. Allison was not wearing his hardware. In the day that followed the banishment of Mr. Driscoll, the whisper went the Dodgian rounds that the Texas cow people, then and there in large numbers, were making war medicine, and would presently "turn loose" under the leadership of Mr. Allison. With that the careful Mr. Masterson made preparations, and such berserks as Mr. Earp, Mr. Brown, Mr. Kelly, Mr. Holiday, Mr. Bassett, Mr.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

The passage recounts a later-written newspaper narrative of Bat Masterson covering gunman Clay Allison with a shotgun while Wyatt Earp and others waited armed along the street, defusing a potential massacre in Dodge City. Allison eventually backed down, claiming a premonition, and the confrontation ended without bloodshed.

Omaha Daily Bee · 8 December 1907 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

A Thoughtful Drink. The warning word went down the line, and Mr. Allison was left unmolested in his eloquence. But that very fact made him uneasy. He was not without a working knowledge of homicide as a science; and the sight of the several heads of Messrs. Earp and Holiday and Bassett and Short and a score besides protruding in an

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

The anecdote describes Bat Masterson confronting a man named Bell, holding him at gunpoint, then striking him with the pistol rather than firing, sending him to bed for two weeks. Masterson later explains he judged Bell as too theatrical to warrant deadly force, contrasting him with Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, Luke Short, and Ben Thompson, whom he would have shot without hesitation.

Omaha Daily Bee · 8 December 1907 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Masterson, gun unwaverlingly upon Mr. Bell, began slowly to advance. Mr. Bell never moved. Coming within reach, Mr. Masterson suddenly let down the hammer of his pistol and smote Mr. Bell such a jealous blow upon the head that he went to the floor, and from the floor to his bed for two weeks. Years later I asked Mr. Masterson why he withheld his fire. "I didn't think I had to shoot," he said, "I once saw Bell jump over a bar-counter to get at a man, when he might just as well have gone round, and it struck me all at once that he was much too dramatic.

See moreSee less

If it had been Wyatt Earp now, or Doc Holiday, or Luke Short, or Ben Thompson, I'd have begun to bombard him out of hand. But I didn't think such extreme measures were demanded in the case of Bell;" and here Mr. Masterson smiled peacefully at the retrospect. "My size-up of Bell may have been wrong," he concluded, "and if it was I hope he'll pardon me. He ought to; for, between us, it was all that saved him that day."

See the clipping