As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

March 1906

11 articles

Mohave County Miner · Mineral Park, Ariz.

A local prospector named Lafave returned from a trip along the Colorado River and reported encountering Wyatt Earp, described as well known in Arizona's early days, working some promising mining claims. Earp was said to hope he might yet become a millionaire from his mining ventures.

Mohave County Miner · 3 March 1906 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

the end of the Santa Fe road now building from Wickenburg to the Colorado river, where he outfitted and "hit the trail." He crossed the river at Parker and then struck into the mountains, where he spent several weeks. He found many promising leads and made several locations which he will prospect more thoroughly later. While in that section he met Wyatt Earp, well known in Arizona in early days, who is working some good claims, and hopes yet to become a millionaire. Mr. Lafave reports that Globe is now the center of the boom in the southwest, though all sections seem prosperous.

See moreSee less

At Globe from three to four hundred men are compelled to sleep in chairs, or roll up in their blankets in the rear end of saloons. Houses are being erected just as fast as material can be had. The boom is caused by the development of the mineral resources of the Globe district, which is fast coming to the front.—Copper Era.

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Deputy Sheriff Tom Worden of San Bernardino was struck and killed by a Santa Fe train near Seligman, Arizona, while chasing a fleeing criminal across the tracks. The report recounts his career as an early-day gunfighter, including service as first sheriff of Phoenix and later marshal of Tombstone, where it claims the Earp brothers served as his deputies.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 23 days later.

Wrong

Los Angeles Herald · 3 March 1906 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Special to The Herald. SAN BERNARDINO, Cal., March 2. —Deputy Sheriff Tom Worden of this city was killed this afternoon at Seligman, Ariz., by a Santa Fe train, as he was pursuing a criminal across the track.

Worden was one of the most daring of the early day "gun fighters." He was the first sheriff of Phoenix, and later marshal of Tombstone, his deputies being the Earp boys. During his first term at Tombstone, Worden put six notches in his gun, but every man he killed was shot while Worden was performing his duty.

See moreSee less

Worden was deputy sheriff under Sheriffs King, Cole, Rouse and Ralphs of this county, and deputy marshal of San Bernardino under Henderson, Thomas and Wall. While deputy sheriff under Cole, he made two trips into Old Mexico after Jose Ortega, who had escaped from here after killing John Sigsby. Overtaking Ortega sixty miles from the international line, he compelled the Mexican to walk back to the United States. Ortega was sent to prison for life, and is now pharmacist at San Quentin.

See the clipping

River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · and 2 other papers

Boxer Bob Fitzsimmons narrates in first person his bout against Tom Sharkey, describing how Wyatt Earp served as referee. After Fitzsimmons landed a solar plexus punch that dropped Sharkey, Earp controversially awarded the fight to Sharkey on a foul claim.

River Falls Journal · 8 March 1906 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

One of the hardest things any pugilist has to battle against in this world is public opinion, and I'm not shooting wide of the mark when I say that I've had a bit more than my share of adverse criticism. In fact, I've been up against it good and hard a lot of times, and while I've tried to hold my temper in the face of unjust charges and still more bull-headed wrong opinion, sometimes I've let go when I couldn't hold out any longer—and I've been sorry for it.

Every man, woman and child has been misunderstood at one time or another, so maybe what I'm going to tell now may get me a little sympathy, though I'm not looking for it to any extent, because I've always found that I could take care of Bob Fitzsimmons pretty well without any outside interference. Still, a man sort of looks around the circle when he gets into a mean corner, and if there's a friendly look in the chap's eye in the corner, he feels that much better.

See moreSee less

What I started with in my mind this week was that little affair that came off out in San Francisco about nine years ago. I mean the go I had with Tom Sharkey out there, when a bunch of pikers and a lot of sure-thing crooks jobbed it to give me the worst of it anyway it happened to go.

As I said before, I'm not looking for sympathy, but when a fellow has had it handed to him in the rawest kind of a way, it salves the sore spot a whole lot to get a chance to tell just how it happened. Maybe some of you folks who read this can remember how you felt when a sneak thief belted you on the nose as you walked down the street and took your week's salary out of your right-hand pocket just as you were going home to hand it over to the wife. Perhaps you can remember how you felt when some fellow you thought was all the cards, handed you the double cross and set you back hustling for the breakfast money, and you never got a chance to tell even the sergeant at the police station how it happened. Well, that's just the way I feel about it, and the more I think of it, the sorer I get. I'd been working pretty hard to get on a match with Sharkey for some time, and it was pretty hard sledding to get a wallop like that for all my pains. If I'd been whipped, I'd never have said a word, not a peep from yours truly, but to be sandbagged, and by a gun fighter at that was all the worse. Of course, it all happened a good while ago, but it's like an old gun shot wound—it aches on rainy days.

But I've been gassing about my feelings long enough. As I say, I hadn't been over here so long, anyway. When I first showed up in this country the Fitzsimmons stock was selling a long way below par, and I guess a good many of the public had an idea it was watered stock at that. That stacked me up against the Black Pearl first as a sort of trial horse, and when I put him away in four rounds, it looked easy. Sharkey was coming along then as the champion of the navy, and he had his eye out for Jim Corbett's scalp. I worked quite a while to get a line on Sharkey, but I had to whip Jack Dempsey first and then Abe Congle. After him they trotted out Pete Maher, and he tossed up his arms in 12 rounds. Jim Farrel was handed over, and he remained with me just seven minutes, all told. I thought Sharkey was in line, but I had to make a chopping block of Joe Godfrey for one round. I argued with Jerry Slattery for a couple more, and they shoved a dead one named Millerd Zender over the table at me and I ate him in a round.

So it went for four more years, and then came the time when I got Sharkey into a corner, and he couldn't get away. There was a neat little purse of $20,000 up for that mill, and I thought it was mighty useful money. Anyway, I counted it as good as mine, and the wake-up was all the worse when it came.

We drifted into the ring that night out in 'Frisco, and the house looked mighty good to me. I saw a lot of men I knew, and some of them wagged the finger at me to show they had a bit on, and counted it already spent. That made me feel a little bit better, and I commenced to wonder about this referee they had selected. I never was much of a stickler for referees. Any man that looked right to me was plenty good enough, and though I'd heard something about this chap, Wyatt Earp, I didn't take much account of what they said about him. One fellow leaned over the ring as I loafed in the corner, and said:

"There's a job out to do you, Bob. if they have to kill you to get away with it. Watch out for the gun—"

And then some one dragged him off the ropes, and I didn't get the rest. I didn't pay much attention to it, anyway, because I never believed I was going to be shaken down like a come-on. and the tip the chap handed me faded away. When Sharkey came into the ring and we walked over to this boy Earp, I took a good look at him. He didn't look crooked to me, though he had a sort of a set eye that read like it wouldn't stand for any argument. When he talked, he made it pretty plain that what he said had to go, and I guess both Sharkey and myself felt we'd be as good as a pair of Sunday school lads.

Well, nearly everyone knows how the fight went. I had the sailor gassing about for seven rounds, and I was getting ready to hand him the wallop that would put him down in dreamland. That solar plexus punch was coming along towards my way of thinking, and when the eighth was going along well, I just stepped in and handed it to Tom. He went down as if he'd been hit with a pile driver, and then he began to act. It wasn't so much real acting though as a lot of folks think. That punch

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Washington Times · Washington, D.C. · 4 September 1905
  • The Virginia Enterprise · Virginia, Minn. · 9 March 1906

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Connecticut

This report discusses a wave of scandals rocking San Francisco sporting circles in the winter, including rigged fights and fraudulent turf practices. It specifically mentions the 'Sharkey-Wyatt-Earp fake' as one of the most notable incidents alongside other boxing and racing scandals.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 9 March 1906 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

BE SQUARE TO PUBLIC

lines, but nothing like the Fitz-Sharkey-Wyatt-Earp fake and the Walcott-Lavigne sell-out. Yet the game goes on right merrily and the public apparently believes in it implicitly.

See the clipping

The Virginia Enterprise · Virginia, Minn.

Boxer Bob Fitzsimmons bitterly recounts the 1896 San Francisco bout with Tom Sharkey, claiming he was unfairly disqualified by a 'gun fighter' referee (Wyatt Earp) after crooked gamblers conspired against him. He likens the lingering sting of the loss to an old gunshot wound that aches on rainy days.

The Virginia Enterprise · 9 March 1906 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

1876."

The book is printed on blue paper, and abounds in fallacious and dogmatic statements. One of his dicta is: "Light is the great source of terrestrial electricity, magnetism, and heat."

See moreSee less

What I started with in my mind this week was that little affair that came off out in San Francisco about nine years ago. I mean the go I had with Tom Sharkey out there, when a bunch of pikers and a lot of sure-thing crooks

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah

In this 1906 reminiscence, former heavyweight champion John L. Sullivan reflects on old-style prizefighting where winners took the entire purse. He recalls the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, noting that Sharkey won according to Wyatt Earp's decision, which gave Earp a lasting reputation while Fitzsimmons got nothing.

The Salt Lake Tribune · 11 March 1906 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

I used to try to fight on a loser-take-all basis, but it was hard for me to get that kind of an agreement, as the other fellows didn't want to take the chance of getting nothing for their trouble and doctors' bills afterward. I think that the fight between Fitz and Sharkey was the last one carried out with the whole of the purse going to the winner, which was Sharkey, according to Wyatt Earp. Tom got all there was, and Earp got a reputation that has lasted him, while Fitz got

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

This 1906 article recalls a series of infamous boxing 'fakes' over the years, including the 1896 Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout in which referee Wyatt Earp awarded the fight to Sharkey on a foul after Fitzsimmons had clearly won. It also recounts other notorious fixed fights like Corbett-Britt, Fitzsimmons-Hall, and Walcott-West.

The Salt Lake Herald · 18 March 1906 · page 6

TOPNOTCHERS WHO FAKED

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Albuquerque Evening Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.

The report recounts the career of railroad detective Worden, who died in an accident just before his planned retirement with a mining fortune. It credits him with making Tombstone 'comparatively orderly' as marshal and claims the Earp brothers served as his deputy marshals early in their careers.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 23 days earlier.

Wrong

Albuquerque Evening Citizen · 26 March 1906 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

KILLED AT SELIGMAN.

resorts of the United States. "Worden made his big reputation as a peace officer during the riotous boom days of Tombstone. He was marshal of that town whe nit was notorious as one of the toughest places in the southwest. He killed six men during his first term as marshal. His ready use of the gun caused a wholesome fear of the law to enter into the hearts of the desperate element who had been running things with a high hand in Tombstone, and the town was comparatively orderly after he had kiiled the fourth or fifth man. The Earp boys, who afterwards became famous throughout this part of the southwest, received their early training under Worden. They served as deputy marshals of Tombstone while Worden was mar

See the clipping

River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · and 4 other papers

Fitzsimmons recounts the Sharkey fight, claiming he knocked Sharkey out fairly but referee Wyatt Earp fled the ring without announcing a decision, leaving Fitzsimmons to declare himself the loser on a foul. He alleges Sharkey faked injury at another man's instruction after Earp had already left the building.

River Falls Journal · 29 March 1906 · page 3

When I told the story of the Sharkey fight I omitted a lot of things because I couldn’t see any useful purpose in telling them. Since then, as I’ve said. I’ve had a few letters and I’m going to answer those by opening the subject again. I’m going to take the Sharkey fight first, because it came first, and some of the things that occurred there had a bearing on the Carson City busi ness. I tried to let Wyatt Earp down easy, but it doesn’t seem to be appreciated, so I’ll say he acted like a yellow cur, in spite of his record.

See moreSee less

I knocked Tom Sharkey out fair and square, and Earp knew it, but when it came to announ cing the decision he never made it. In fact no decision was ever rendered out side of the one I made myself. When I dropped Sharkey and he lay there like a log until his seconds picked him up, Earp merely walked over to his corner, put the check for $20,000 in the hands of Tom’s seconds and walked out of the ring and out of the build ing. He didn’t have the nerve to stay there and face the music, in spite of the fact that he wore a gun. I knew then for absolutely certain that I’d been trimmed, and it was myself who called for order and shouted to the crowd: "The referee says I’ve lost on a foul, gentlemen." All this time Tom lay like a dead man, until a certain man well known in Ran Francisco came down from his seat in the balcony and stooped over him. possibly five minutes after Earp had left the building. As I say, he stooped over him and his words are as plain to me now as they were then. He said: "Put your hands on jour abdomen and groan as if you were in great pain." Those weren’t, the exact words, for I can’t give them here, but they are close enough for all practical use. In the fog that was hanging over him Sharkey heard them, anyway, and did as he was told. lie drew up his logs and his groans could be heard all over the ring. I said before tnat I didn’t think he was in on the original play. I can bay that still, but he was In on the finish to it. and did just what he was told. I know and proved later In court that the doctor the Sharkey

See the clipping

Also printed in 4 papers
  • Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif. · 24 September 1905
  • Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Connecticut · 27 February 1906
  • The Virginia Enterprise · Virginia, Minn. · 25 May 1906
  • Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis. · 14 July 1906

The Yale Expositor · Yale, Mich. · and 1 other paper

Walter 'Scotty' Scott has been arrested and will face charges of assault with a deadly weapon against mining expert Owen near Ballarat, Death Valley, allegedly part of a scheme to fake a mine and collect $100,000 from investors. Wyatt Earp, now in Los Angeles, is quoted suggesting Scotty was involved in past misdeeds in the Klondike, while an accomplice, 'Shorty' Smith, is reportedly in jail and has confessed.

The Yale Expositor · 30 March 1906 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

BAD MAN SCOTTY

and is said to have confessed. Wyatt Earp, now in Los Angeles, is quoted as hinting that "Scotty" was once concerned in some dark deeds in the Klondike. Los Angeles newspapers call "Scotty" a "faker," a "swindler," and have for a month been waging a campaign of exposure to show that "Scotty" has no mine in Death Valley; that he swindled Capitalist Girard, of Los Angeles, out of $4,000 for "grubstakes," and to imply that he is a bandit of unexampled boldness and perhaps with a startling record.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Belding Banner · Belding, Mich. · 29 March 1906

The Arizona Range News · Willcox, Ariz.

The article profiles a retired railroad detective named Worden who made his reputation as marshal of Tombstone, claiming he killed six men and that the Earp brothers served as his deputies there. It also recounts his pursuit of a fugitive sixty miles into Mexico.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The Arizona Range News · 30 March 1906 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SOLOMONVILLE, - - ARIZONA

ooker, of the Sierra Bo- t Tuesday in Willcox Mr. Hooker is the pio- ion of the community ving the finest Here- outs, also devotes con- ion to the breeding and orses. He is conceded od blood in the horse ound anywhere.

See moreSee less

vely Tussle

enemy of the race, often ends in appendi id all serious trouble Liver and Bowels, g's New Life Pills. y regulate these or- pain or discomfort. gists.

d at Seligman

n, who met a tragic man a few days ago. roughout the south- e officer. He belonged ool, who derived its uence over desperate bad men generally al and timely use of rden met his death in of his duty and his he "would die with came true, although omotive of a railroad ught him to his end

dred dollars to $160,000 he and his partners sold out.

With his share of $40,000 placed safely in a bank, Worden wrote out and forwarded his resignation as railroad detective, to take effect on March 1. He decided that he would take things easy for the remainder of his life. He and his wife had planned to take an extended trip to Mexico and to spend the coming summer in visiting the eastern pleasure resorts of the United States.

Worden made his big reputation as a peace officer during the riotous and boom days of Tombstone. He was marshal of that town when it was notorious as one of the toughest places in the southwest. He killed six men during his first term as marshal.

His ready use of the gun caused a wholesome fear of the law to enter the hearts of the desperate element who had been running things with a high hand in Tombstone, and the town was comparatively orderly when he had killed the fourth man.

The Earp boys, who afterward became notorious throughout this part of the southwest, received their early training under Worden. They served as deputy marshals of Tombstone while Worden was mar-

See the clipping