Boxer Bob Fitzsimmons reminisces about his career leading up to the famous bout with Sharkey, refereed by Wyatt Earp. He recounts being warned before the fight that something was rigged against him, foreshadowing the controversial decision Earp would make.
The Washington Times · 4 September 1905 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image
many of the public had an idea it was watered stock at that. That stacked me up against the Black Pearl first as a sort of trial horse, and when I put him away in four rounds, it looked easy.
Sharkey was coming along then as the champion of the navy, and he had his eye out for Jim Corbett's scalp. I worked quite a while to get a line on Sharkey, but I had to whip Jack Dempsey first and then Abe Congle. After him they trotted out Peter Maher, and he tossed up his arms in twelve rounds. Jim Farrel was handed over, and he remained with me just seven minutes, all told. I thought Sharkey
The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands
A sports gossip column remarks that if Wyatt Earp had officiated the Gardner-Ryan boxing match at Colma, the outcome might have differed. The comment references Earp's notoriety from a past controversial refereeing incident.
The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 14 September 1905 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Sportlets.
If Wyatt Earp had been officiating at Colma when Gardner and Ryan battled things might have been different.
See moreSee less
Although Gardner gave him considerable attention Buddy Ryan failed to blossom.
The house where James Monroe died was destroyed by fire recently, but the big house on Larkin street, San Francisco, in which Jack Munroe should have died is still standing.
Stanford will have to do some rough work to retain its football supremacy. Berkeley has announced its intention of using Force.
"Yank" Kenny is living up to his nickname. According to the dispatches from the East, a policeman yanked him a few days ago for yanking a purse.
Neither Kuroki nor Oyama got a piece of the Futurity prize. Wait until they run to their Manchurian form.
Had Jockey Hilderbrand a little better Timber, Harry Payne Whitney would have duplicated his father's
Years after the disputed Sharkey-Fitzsimmons bout, Fitzsimmons publishes his own account claiming he knocked out Sharkey fairly and that referee Wyatt Earp never actually rendered an official decision. He calls Earp a 'yellow cur' and accuses him of improperly awarding Sharkey the $10,000 stake.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Salt Lake Herald · 24 September 1905 · page 5
BY BOB FITZSIMMONS
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A witness recounts that after Earp's foul decision favored Sharkey, Tom Sharkey lay motionless until a man from the crowd instructed him to feign agony, and Sharkey complied. The witness says doctors later injected something to make the injured area swell before bandaging, which he says was proven in court.