As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

August 1905

2 articles

The St. Louis Republic · St. Louis, Mo.

A 1905 newspaper piece about boxing controversies references the earlier Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, noting Wyatt Earp's involvement as part of a cautionary tale about rigged matches. It uses this older incident as a historical comparison point for the current Britt-Nelson fight scandal.

The St. Louis Republic · 15 August 1905 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

on this financial basis.

It is known that, after Danny Lynch had affixed his signature for Sharkey to the articles which bound the tar to fight the dingo, Sharkey was a very blue fellow.

See moreSee less

Rather a green fighter at the time, the thrifty sailor possessed a head for business. He did not fancy being matched to fight such a past master of the Queensberry cult as Fitzsimmons without a loser's end to salve probable wounds of body, pride and reputation.

Lynch, however, builded better than Sharkey knew. When Daniel signed the "winner-take-all" articles he did a good turn to Sharkey. All the time Sharkey was worrying, Lynch was planning.

He knew he would be referee if he could make him. He had the press box moved from its former location by the ringside to a distant gallery. This was done with a view to handicapping men who write reports of the fight for public information and perusal. The result of the fight is history.

It seems that the fact that all the money goes one way incites to fierce desire to get it all, if not by fair means by foul.

It does not follow that because the Fitz-Sharkey battle went foul the Britt-Nelson fight should go the same way. As far as can be seen, nothing but bitter rivalry found expression in the Britt-Nelson articles. Fighters are not in the pastime for their health, and every precaution should be taken to avoid a fiasco of the Earp-Fitzsimmons-Sharkey kind.

San Francisco has always been a town full of cozenage, nimble jugglers, etc. There is nothing in the record of either man which entitles him to a certain victory over the other. In view of the paternal, maternal and fraternal leniency with which the Native Son is treated in California, Britt's willingness to go beyond twenty rounds, his insistence on the winner-take-all clause, etc., and of Nelson's apparently foolish acquiescence, it will be well for all concerned to use especial prudence in the selection of the referee. Having done that, it will be well to have a care to the police that the match be not stopped at an interesting point, as matches have been stopped in the past.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A boxing column looks back at the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight where Wyatt Earp served as referee and controversially called a foul favoring Sharkey. The piece reflects on Sharkey's career and his willingness to fight despite being an underdog, contrasting him with John L. Sullivan's attitude toward no-decision fights.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Sun · 23 August 1905 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

TIMELY BOXING TALK

vantage of the cheaper cost of living.

"The economical moment for the abolition of the zone had arrived, chiefly because the cause of its creation, the isolation of the cities located therein, had ceased to exist. It is reasonable to assume that the reform will act as a stimulus, resulting in an unprecedented era of commercial and industrial development along the Rio Grande, and that the most sanguine expectations of the Finance Department of Mexico may be realized."

See moreSee less

Wants Eminent Domain for Irrigation.

PORTLAND, Ore., Aug. 22.--Judge Rakas of Alturas, Cal., offered a resolution in the irrigation congress to-day recommending that the United States Congress grant the right of eminent domain to the reclamation service. By this it is urged irrigation in the arid belt would be hastened.

JARRED IN BUMP OF CARS.

Bruised Lot of Passengers After a Little Rear End Collision.

In a rear end collision between two southbound Eighth avenue cars at Greenwich street and Battery place last night a score or more persons were slightly injured.

The first car came to a standstill about ten feet above Battery place to allow a Belt Line car to pass. The car behind, in charge of Motorman Joseph Kiely of 422 West Forty-eighth street, ran into it. Sister Agnes of St. Peter's Church in Barclay street was crossing in front of the foremost car and was thrown to the street, escaping with a few bruises. Many others who were slightly injured were attended in a nearby drug store.

furnish you may desire th Dr. Herma Health Depa Mr. Smellie: "Your lette ton, asking f Board of He tients sufferi city of New Y say that as has not been upon the que tion has not that it is pro on certain da "I think th sured that as in dealing wi of tuberculos there will be dealing with

[illegible] of 65 per cent. to the winner and 35 per cent. to the loser. No fighter, no matter how confident he may be of his ability to vanquish his rival, is willing to hazard a chance whereby the successful man is to take all the fruits of his efforts.

The last pair who fought on an all or nothing basis were Tom Sharkey and Bob Fitzsimmons in Mechanics' Pavilion, San Francisco, back in 1896. Although the quondam sailor at the time was far from being near the top of the heap he was satisfied to go against the great Cornishman with no provision for a loser's end. Whether Sharkey at the time believed that he possessed the requisite ability to mow down the lanky fighter without much trouble is not clearly known, but the fact remains that with the aid of Wyatt Earp, the referee, and an alleged foul in the region of his solar plexus, Sharkey got everything.

When John L. Sullivan was the king of the heavies he never demurred about a loser's end. He wanted all or nothing, but his wishes in this respect were never gratified. Naturally, his reputation and knack of jarring his opponents into temporary slumber made his rivals a bit apprehensive about agreeing

See the clipping