As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

December 1904

2 articles

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

This passage recounts frontier legends, including Clay Allison's disgraced marshal story and a tale of Wyatt Earp riding to confront Bat Masterson after Masterson ran off Virgil Earp from Dodge City. It claims Wyatt Earp held nothing but contempt for Masterson before ever meeting him.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 69 days later.

Wrong

The Salt Lake Herald · 11 December 1904 · page 13 · transcribed from the page image

was only his quickness and luck that pulled him through. But he didn't consider those elements, but just went ahead and won out when the odds were way against him. The disgraced marshal drilled out of Durango before the next daylight, unable to stay along and face the shame of the thing that Clay Allison had put on him. Allison went back to the Pecos country after finishing the job he had started out for, and only a year afterward met so measley and onnery a death as falling from a freighter's six-mule wagon and having the wheels pass over his head.

Earp and Masterson.

See moreSee less

"I was present, too, once when a very well-known bad man of the southwest, Wyatt Earp, no less, deliberately and recklessly gave so noted a killer as Bat Masterson the edge on him in the

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A 1904 retrospective account describes Wyatt Earp storming into Dodge City to confront Marshal Bat Masterson after Masterson allegedly ran Earp's brother out of town. The story depicts a dramatic saloon showdown where Earp berates Masterson as a coward who hides behind the law to do his gunfighting.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 140 days later.

Wrong

The Salt Lake Herald · 11 December 1904 · page 13 · transcribed from the page image

of Dodge, but when he got down to Arizona he told his brother Wyatt, the hardest nut of that craggy-family, how Masterson had given him the hot-foot out of Dodge.

"Wyatt rode right up to Dodge to see Masterson about it. Wyatt Earp had never met Bat Masterson, but he had all kinds of contempt and scorn for the marshal of Dodge, as he had for any man who did all of his slaughtering in the name of the law. He looked upon any man who got behind the screen of the law's authority to do his gun fighting as a piece of paste, and it was for the purpose of expressing this opinion to Bat Masterson that he hurried up to Dodge.

See moreSee less

"As soon as Wyatt Earp got into Dodge he made hurried inquiry as to where he'd be able to find Masterson, and somebody told him that Bat was playing seven-up in the back room of

See the clipping