As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

November 1904

4 articles

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The report covers a boxing match where Britt defeated Gans, with crowd reactions to referee Graney's decision. It notably mentions that the general verdict was 'Wyatt Earp was not such an incompetent referee after all,' referencing an earlier controversy involving Earp.

The San Francisco Call · 1 November 1904 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

From Portland and the Far North.

The crop of visitors from the interior was not so large as in former seasons, still many took a chance and braved a trip to the metropolis. Everybody of any note in town felt compelled to be present and the general verdict was that Wyatt Earp was not such an incompetent referee after all.

See moreSee less

To make sure that all the choice seats were not grabbed up on him, Jim Hayes, proprietor of Harbin Springs, reached the city on Saturday. Jim was an admirer of Britt and departs for home this morning to lay in the winter wood supply.

Herbert Baker, the well-known hotel man of Bakersfield, chaperoned a crowd of sports from the southern country.

From away up in Amador County, Randall Ellis and J. Cook came down to see that Jackson found representation at the fight.

Salinas had a big collection of sporting people, and Jim Tynan, Joe Connors and George Jeffries showed the way for the others.

Among the bunch from San Jose were Jim Woods, Billy George and Jack Gilpin.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A stockman named Frank Councelle mocks eastern writers' fictionalized accounts of western gunfighters, criticizing their dramatized portrayals of marshals challenging each other. He begins to recount his own version of how Wyatt Earp supposedly called Bat Masterson's bluff in Dodge City.

Evening Star · 19 November 1904 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

SHAL OF DURANGO.

And How Wyatt Earp Called Bat Masterson's Bluff in Dodge City.

See moreSee less

"I notice that a lot of these Philadelphia and Boston fiction manufacturers who write stories about western life and

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 1 other paper

The article recounts a tale of Earp storming into Wingate's hotel bar, confronting Bat Masterson over a disputed gunfighting reputation, and threatening him in front of card players. Masterson, described as flustered, reportedly backed down from the encounter.

Evening Star · 19 November 1904 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

Earp and Masterson.

"I was present, too, once when a very well-known bad man of the southwest, Wyatt Earp, no less, deliberately and recklessly gave so noted a killer as Bat Masterson the edge on him in the heat of an extreme soreness against Masterson, who was then the marshal of Dodge.

See moreSee less

"There were a number of the Earp boys, and one of them, Virgil, upon the occasion of a visit to Dodge, had been told by Masterson that that section was too far north for any of the Earps, and recommended Virgil Earp to get back to the cactus country quick and sudden. Masterson, in fact, enforced this recommendation at the point of one of his guns, and Virgil didn't see any sense in arguing against that kind of persuasion. So he ducked out of Dodge, but when he got down to Arizona he told his brother Wyatt, the hardest nut of that craggy family, how Masterson had given him the hot-foot out of Dodge.

"Wyatt rode right up to Dodge to see Masterson about it. Wyatt Earp had never met Bat Masterson, but he had all kinds of contempt and scorn for the marshal of Dodge, as he had for any man who did all of his slaughtering in the name of the law. He looked upon any man who got behind the screen of the law's authority to do his gun fighting as a piece of paste, and it was for the purpose of expressing this opinion to Bat Masterson that he hurried up to Dodge.

"As soon as Wyatt Earp got into Dodge he made hurried inquiry as to where he'd be able to find Masterson, and somebody told him that Bat was playing seven-up in the back room of Pack Wingate's hotel bar. Earp hiked for Wingate's like a button drummer making for an early morning train.

"Earp clomped into Wingate's bar and asked the barkeep which of the two seven-up players at the table was Masterson. The barkeep nodded in the direction of the marshal. Earp got over to the seven-up table in a couple of strides. He gave the table a bang with his fist that made the cards dance. and he stuck his face within four inches of Masterson's.

" 'You're a law-murderin' son of a coyote, Masterson,' Earp said to the marshal of Dodge. 'and for two bits and a poncho I'd take them law guns away from you and run 'em down your throat.'

"Masterson, who never was a first-rater in his business—and I know—looked flustered. He didn't know Earp, but he saw that the man who was talking to him was the real thing.

" 'And I'll give you this much the best of it, at that, you squaw's dog,' said Earp.

"Then he deliberately pulled both guns from his belt, slammed them down on the table beside Bat Masterson, the killing marshal of Dodge, and stepped five paces back from the table, feeling of his knive.

"Far from wanting an edge, Earp was deliberately giving the edge to the man who at that time had the record for his quick-

The North Atlantic Fleet Will Soon Be Greatly Augmented.

It has been practically decided by the Navy Department to discontinue the practice of having independent squadrons on the European and the South Atlantic stations, and to send vessels to those waters hereafter only when their services are required.

The vessels of both squadrons are under orders to come to the United States within the next few weeks for the purpose of taking part in the naval maneuvers in the Caribbean sea this winter. The flag officers of both squadrons already have been relieved. Rear Admiral Jewell, commanding the European squadron, will be placed on the retired list in a few days and will remain in Europe for about a year. Rear Admiral Chadwick, commanding the South Atlantic squadron, has been detached from that duty at his own request, for "family reasons," and has started home from Rio de Janiero, by way of England.

When the North Atlantic fleet is reinforced by the vessels of the squadrons recalled and the new war ships shortly to be put in commission it will constitute the largest and most powerful aggregation of war ships in any single fleet of the United States navy. Rear Admiral A. S. Barker, who commands the fleet as now organized, will retire for age in March next. His successor has not yet been finally selected, but it is expected that an official announcement will be made on that point in a few weeks. Owing to the great importance of the assignment, it will undoubtedly go to one of the senior rear admirals, of whom Rear Admiral R. D. Evans, chairman of the lighthouse board, is now said to be the only one now available.

The Value of Charcoal.

FEW PEOPLE KNOW HOW USEFUL IT IS IN PRESERVING HEALTH AND BEAUTY.

Nearly everybody knows that charcoal is the safest and most efficient disinfectant and purifier in nature, but few realize its value when taken into the human system for the same cleansing purpose.

Charcoal is a remedy that the more you take of it the better; it is not a drug at all, but simply absorbs the gases and impurities always present in the stomach and intestines and carries them out of the system.

Charcoal sweetens the breath after smoking, drinking or after eating onions and other odorous vegetables.

Charcoal effectually clears and improves the

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah · 11 December 1904 · an extract

The Arizona Sentinel · Arizona City Yuma, Ariz.

This is a county board of supervisors' official proceedings listing elected and appointed precinct officers for Yuma County, Arizona. Wyatt Earp is named as Constable for Cibola Precinct No. 16.

The Arizona Sentinel · 30 November 1904 · page 1

Remeis M Swain. Constable Wyatt Earp, Kofa Precinct No. 17, Justice of the Peace . J J Maynard. Constable D Rillos. On motion board adjournedr';

See the clipping