As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

March 1898

5 articles

In the story →

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz. · and 1 other paper

R.H. Paul, former Pima County sheriff, writes to the Tucson Citizen to correct inaccuracies in an earlier account of the Clanton story, clarifying who was present at the O.K. Corral fight and the sequence of events leading to Frank Stilwell's killing in Tucson. He also notes Phin Clanton's later conviction for cattle theft and Ike Clanton's eventual death.

Arizona Republican · 3 March 1898 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

STORY OF PHIN CLANTON. Ex-Sheriff Paul Sets the Press Right in Regard to the Feud.

R. H. Paul, ex-sheriff of Pima county, has written a letter to the Tucson Citizen in which he corroborates the substance of a story published in The Republican some time ago. He says:

See moreSee less

"Editor Citizen: I see in your issue of the 18th where you seek to correct the Phoenix Republican's biography of Phin Clanton, and in which you are a little off in some of your statements. Phin Clanton was not in the fight with the McLowries. There were only two McLowries in that fight, Tom and Frank. Ike and Billy Clanton were also there. The two McLowries and Billy Clanton were killed and Ike ran away into the back end of Montgomery's stable or corral. Ike was killed on the Little Colorado some time afterwards. Phin was convicted of cattle stealing and was sent to the Yuma prison. After his release he went to Globe and has made that vicinity his home since.

"Wyatt Earp did not follow Stilwell to Tucson. Ike Clanton and Frank Stilwell came to Tucson and about two weeks later the Earps came on the train as an escort to Virgil Earp, who had been shot, as you say, on Allen street and was on his way to Colton where his father and mother lived, for medical treatment. While the train was standing in Tucson, Frank Stilwell was seen standing on a gravel car peeking in the window of the car that Virgil Earp was in. Wyatt Earp and the balance of the escort started after him, overtook him and killed him as you say. The train pulled out before the shooting was over. The Earps then started on foot for Benson, where they left their horses. A freight train overtook them about eight miles from Tucson. They made signals and the train stopped and took them to Benson, where they got tehir horses and were in Tombstone before daylight.

"The next morning a warrant was sworn out and placed in my hands (I was then sheriff), and Judge Alex Campbell was district attorney. We went to the telegraph office together and wired the warrant to Behan, and when Behan received the message all of the Earp party that were in the killing of Stilwell were upstairs in Billike's hotel. As soon as they heard that Behan had a warrant for them they sent to Montgomery's stable in the block below where their horses were, to have them saddled, which was immediately done. When informed that their horses were ready they walked to the stable, mounted and rode out of town.

"Behan had collected all his deputies and Dave Nagle, who afterwards killed Judge Terry, was city marshal, and Behan had Nagle and all the police at the door of the hotel as the Earps passed out. Behan said: 'Wyatt, I want to see you,' and Wyatt without stopping, said, 'You might see me once too often.' There was no further attempt made to arrest them.

"The next day I started for Tombstone and met Behan and his posse about five miles this side of town. One of Behan's deputies gave me his horse and I went with the posse. We went to Contention that night, and next day we went to Tombstone. As I had had no sleep since leaving Tucson I went to sleep in the express office and told Behan where I could be found. He agreed to call me if he heard where the Earps were, as I wished to go with him. He got his posse of rustlers and brought up at Hooker's ranch, where the Earp party had been. They told Hooker where they were going to camp and that if Behan and posse came where there looking for them to tell them where they were, as they intended to remain there four or five days. When the Behan posse arrived at the Hooker ranch Hooker told them where the Earp party was, but Behand did not want them.

"I had a horse engaged to go with Behan and he agreed to call me if he started out again, but he did not do it and I returned to Tucson. If I were in Tucson I would give you some 'reminiscences,' as I have the published accounts of them. I had nothing to do today and thought I would set you straight.

"Yours respectfully, "R. H. PAUL. "Solomonville. Feb. 27, 1898."

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Florence Tribune · Florence, Ariz · 5 March 1898

The Florence Tribune · Florence, Ariz

Writing to the Tucson Citizen, former Sheriff R.H. Paul corrects an earlier Phoenix Republican biography of Phin Clanton, clarifying who was present at the gunfight with the McLaury brothers and recounting the killing of Frank Stilwell in Tucson as Virgil Earp was escorted out by train. He also notes Phin Clanton's later conviction for cattle theft and imprisonment at Yuma, and Ike Clanton's eventual death near the Little Colorado.

The Florence Tribune · 5 March 1898 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

STORY OF PHIN. CLANTON.

Ex-Sheriff R. H. Paul Becomes Reminiscent and Tells of the Earp-Behan Feud.

See moreSee less

[From the Tucson Citizen.]

EDITOR CITIZEN: I see in your issue of the 18th where you seek to correct the Phoenix Republican's biography of Phin. Clanton, and in which you are a little off in some of your statements. Phin. Clanton was not in the fight with the McLowries. There were only two McLowries in that fight, Tom and Frank. Ike and Billy Clanton were also there. The two McLowries and Billy Clanton were killed and Ike ran away into the back end of Montgomery's stable or corral. Ike was killed on the Little Colorado sometime afterwards. Phin. was convicted of cattle stealing and was sent to the Yuma prison. After his release he went to Globe and has made that vicinity his home since.

The Earps did not follow Stilwell to Tucson. Ike Clanton and Frank Stilwell came to Tucson, and about two weeks later the Earps came on the train as an escort to Virgil Earp, who had been shot, as you say, on Allen street, and was on his way to Colton, where his father and mother lived, for medical treatment. While the train was standing in Tucson, Frank Stilwell was seen standing on a gravel car peeking in the window of the car that Virgil Earp was in. Wyatt Earp and the balance of the escort started after him, overtook him and killed him, as you say. The train pulled out before the shooting was over. The Earps then started on foot for Benson, where they left their horses. A freight train overtook them about eight miles from Tucson; they made signals and the train stopped and took them to Benson, where they got their horses and were in Tombstone before daylight.

The next morning a warrant was sworn out and placed in my hands (I was then sheriff and Judge Alex. Campbell was district attorney). We went to the telegraph office together and wired the warrant to Behan, and when Behan received the message all of the Earp party that were in the killing of Stilwell were up stairs in Billike's hotel. As soon as they heard that Behan had a warrant for them they sent to Montgomery's stable, in the block below where their horses were, to have them saddled, which was immediately done. When informed that their horses were ready they walked to the stable, mounted and rode out of town.

Behan had collected all his deputies and Dave Nagle (who afterwards killed Judge Terry), was city marshal, and Behan had Nagle and all the police at the door of the hotel as the Earps passed out. Behan said: "Wyatt, I want to see you," and Wyatt, without stopping said, "You might see me once too often." There was no further attempt made to arrest them.

The next day I started for Tombstone and met Behan and his posse about five miles this side of town. One of Behan's deputies gave me his horse and I went with the posse. We went to Contention that night and next day we went to Tombstone. As I had had no sleep since leaving Tucson I went to sleep in the express office and told Behan where I could be found. He agreed to call me if he heard where the Earps were, as I wished to go with him. He got his posse of rustlers and brought up at Hooker's ranch, where the Earp party had been. They told Hooker where they were going to camp and that if Behan and posse came there looking for them to tell them where they were, as they intended to remain there four or five days. When the Behan posse arrived at the Hooker ranch, Hooker told them where the Earp party was but Behan did not want them.

I had a horse engaged to go with Behan and he agreed to call me if he started out again, but he did not do it and I returned to Tucson. If I were in Tucson I could give you some "reminiscences," as I have the published accounts of them. Had nothing else to do to-day and thought I would set you straight.

Yours respectfully,

R. H. PAUL.

Solomonville, Feb. 27, 1898.

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

Previewing the upcoming Sharkey-Choynski fight, the article reviews Sharkey's pugilistic record, including his controversial foul-decision win over Fitzsimmons. It bitterly recalls Wyatt Earp as referee, accusing him of stealing the decision for Sharkey and costing Fitzsimmons $10,000.

The Evening Times · 11 March 1898 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY-CHOYNSKI FIGHT.

on entering the ring. Tom Sharkey holds a unique position in pugilism. Although he has met nearly every prominent heavyweight in the world, not a decision has yet been rendered against him. Sharkey is a strong man, and would make an excellent fighter

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A report on the Sharkey-Choynski boxing match describes dangerous overcrowding at the venue and a lengthy delay in selecting a referee. The writer criticizes referee George Green's controversial draw decision, comparing it unfavorably to Wyatt Earp's infamous rank decision in an earlier fight.

The San Francisco Call · 12 March 1898 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Sharkey certainly received the worst of it in the decision and was given the same treatment last night that he gave to Fitzsimmons at the Mechanics' Pavilion over a year ago. In the way of giving rank decisions Wyatt Earp has certainly got a partner in iniquity in George Green, for to declare a twenty-round bout a draw in the eighth round because one of the contestants is knocked through the ropes has not a parallel in ringside history.

Now for the fight.

See moreSee less

After the customary preliminaries, the seconds and sporting men yelling like mad. Cries of "Foul" heard from all parts of the house at the way Sharkey is fighting and hitting Joe in the clinches, but the referee paid no attention except to raise his hand for the fight to go on. Both men swinging both hands and fighting like bulldogs as the round ends, and neither heard the bell and had to be broken from a clinch by their seconds.

ROUND 6—This was another spectacular round. Both men rush at each other, swinging rights and lefts. Choynski the cooler of the two and fighting hard. Sharkey backing away. Choynski lands two hard left swings and receives a stiff right on the neck. Both men landing hard in the clinches. Sharkey knocks Choynski down with a right swing on the head and Joe remains on the floor the full nine seconds. Sharkey rushes Joe to the ropes as he arises and hits him fiercely when on the ropes and in the clinches. Everybody standing and yelling "Foul!" at the referee on account of Sharkey's tactics. Both men very tired but fighting hard as the gong sounds.

ROUND 7—They come up quickly and Choynski lands a hard left on the jaw. Sharkey rushes, swinging right and left, and landing hard on the body. Both men seemingly too weak to knock the other out, but fighting as hard as they can. Sharkey rushes Joe to the ropes, landing left and right swings on the head and body, Joe returning on the face. Both men taking and giving a great deal of punishment. Choynski lands a straight left in the mouth and receives a hard right swing on the neck. Sharkey rushes his man to the ropes and punches him hard in the resulting clinch, and again the cry of foul is raised all over the house.

ROUND 8—Sharkey came up rushing, and was met with a straight left in the ribs. Both exchanged left swings on the head. Both jab their lefts into the face. Sharkey lands hard left and right swings on the jaw, and Choynski returns with a hot one on the body. Choynski lands another hard one on the body and a light left swing on the jaw. Sharkey rushes Choynski across the ring to the ropes in Sharkey's corner and Joe goes clear through the ropes and falls to the floor below, about four feet lower than the ring, directly in front of Captain Lees. The Chief of Police arose and raised his finger, and the police commenced to clamber into the ring. The referee yelled "Draw," and Sharkey rushed over to him and tried to expostulate, but was hustled to his corner by the police. Choynski was lifted back through the ropes by friends and walked to his corner unaided. The house was in a terrible uproar all the while.

The preliminary events to the evening's sport opened with a four-round bout between Hugh Dougherty of Chicago and Joe Sullivan of this city. Dougherty was awarded the fight in the middle of the last round by Referee Frank Allen, he having Sullivan completely at his mercy.

Frank Babcock of Pennsylvania and Grant Rogers of this city then came together for four rounds. Babcock knocked Rogers down twice in the second round. He forced the fighting in the fourth, and had Rogers so nearly out that the bout was stopped and Babcock given the decision.

Next came Pat Lynch and Jack Hall, both of this city, in a six-round contest. Lynch was clearly the best man, as was demonstrated early in the first round, so the police stopped the bout, and under the rules the referee had no recourse but to declare it a draw.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

A boxing report about Sharkey's upcoming fight criticizes his foul-filled career, mentioning in passing that Fitzsimmons was 'robbed' of a decision against Sharkey in a bout Wyatt Earp had refereed. The piece is primarily about a Sharkey-Choynski match and Sharkey's reputation for dirty fighting.

Omaha Daily Bee · 20 March 1898 · page 24 · transcribed from the page image

As a result of his fight with Choynski George Green has proved himself a good competitor of Wyatt Earp. Despite the fact that Sharkey's fouls were most flagrant, Green did not have the nerve to declare the fight against him. It is said that he waved

See the clipping