The item quips that Wyatt Earp calls Sharkey the greatest fighter ever, and that Sharkey calls Earp the greatest referee. It's a sarcastic aside referencing the controversial Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight Earp refereed.
Lyon County Times · 1 May 1897 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
BRIEF MENTION
—Wyatt Earp declares that Sharkey is the greatest fighter that ever lived.—Exchange. And Sharkey says Earp is the greatest referee. Hoss and Hoss!—Appeal.
This report gives a career history of boxer Bob Fitzsimmons, noting that Referee Wyatt Earp awarded his 1896 bout with Tom Sharkey to Sharkey on a foul call widely viewed as a robbery. It details Fitzsimmons' fighting record from 1880 through 1894, including his unsuccessful San Francisco court case to overturn the result.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 19 days later.
Wrong
San Antonio Daily Light · 3 May 1897 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
KING OF THE SLUGGERS
...ing James Corbett at Carson, Nev., on March 17, won the title of "champion heavyweight pugilist of the world," was born at Helston, Cornwall, England, June 4, 1862. "Bob" is a fighter by inheritance, his father having been recognized as one of the best athletes in a country famous for its wrestlers and pugilists. "Bob's" brothers were also natural fighters. "Fitz" migrated with his family to New Zealand, where he took up the horseshoeing trade. The art of boxing was first taught him by his brother Jairet. His first appearance in the ring was at "Jem" Mace's amateur tournament, held at Timaru, New Zealand, in the fall of 1880. Although but a lad of 19 years, "Bob" knocked out four men that night, thus winning the amateur championship of New Zealand.
Since that time Fitzsimmons has met almost every fighter of note in England and the United States, his last great meeting before the Carson event being that with Tom Sharkey, the "sailor lad," late in 1896. Referee Earp gave that fight to Sharkey on a foul which has been, and always will be, looked upon as a robbery. Fitzsimmons fought the case in court in San Francisco and there received his first "knockout," as Sharkey was allowed to retain the $10,000 stake, which it is conceded he had never fairly won.
See moreSee less
Fitz is the son of Irish and English parents. His height is 5 feet 11¾ inches; stretch of arms 6 feet two inches. In fighting style he is, as his 14 rounds with Corbett proved conclusively, the typical knockout hitter of the ring. His average fighting weight is 165 pounds. His American earnings of battle, if he had collected all owing him, should be nearly $100,000.
A humorous miscellany item notes that Wyatt Earp calls Sharkey the greatest fighter ever, while Sharkey calls Earp the greatest referee. The brief aside pokes fun at their mutual flattery following the controversial fight.
Walker Lake Bulletin · 5 May 1897 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
SAMPLES.
Wyatt Earp declares that Sharkey is the greatest fighter that ever lived and Sharkey says Earp is the greatest referee. Hoss and hoss!—Appeal.
Bob Stewart will soon have a pan running in connection with his mill at Soda. The pan and necessary machinery passed through on Monday's train.
See moreSee less
Frank Thomas, an inmate of the County Hospital from Columbus, was pronounced insane by Drs. Brierly and Lewis last week and taken to the
A colorful, dialogue-heavy anecdote describes Wyatt Earp pulling his revolver in the ring to shield boxer Bob Fitzsimmons from an angry mob after a bout. The piece ties the incident to Earp's earlier referee decision in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight that cost Fitzsimmons $10,000.
Morning Appeal · 9 May 1897 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Visions of death in his fighting shoes passed swiftly before the pugilist's mind. He could feel that the gun was clasped by a muscular hand, and then he felt the arm of the gun wielder thrown about his left shoulder.
The boxer was preparing to make a mighty effort to save his life or to sell it as dearly as possible when a voice hissed in his ear, "Keep quiet, Bob; you're perfectly safe. The first galoot that moves a finger at you will get perforated with lead till he looks like a porous plaster. Wyatt Earp's your friend."
See moreSee less
Bob stood perfectly quiet until the commotion had subsided, and then, when the gun was withdrawn, the boxer heaved a sigh of relief and retired in good order.
This was the unique method employed by Wyatt Earp to square himself with Fitz, who was deprived of a little matter of $10,000 by Earp's decision in the bout with Sharkey in San Francisco, and Mr. Earp no doubt considers that the production of his trusty shooting iron and the preservation of Fitz from real or imaginary danger wipes out any claim that Fitz may have had. The Cornishman makes a wry face when he thinks of that $10,000, but he evidently considers it wise not to oppose Mr. Earp and his handy gun.
A rumor claimed Wyatt Earp had secretly arrived in New York to be in Sharkey's corner for his fight with Maher. A reporter visited Sharkey's training quarters and both the champion and his manager denied Earp was in the East or expected.
New York Journal and Advertiser · 10 May 1897 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
WYATT EARP NOT ON HAND
its tale, and it can readily be supposed that the excessive use of stallions, the breeding from cheap mares, for money's sake, must have left evil results which it may take years to eradicate. Although the Juvenile brought out a reasonably good-looking bunch of two-year-olds, the kind that were seen at Aqueduct and Washington were, with very rare exceptions, [illegible]
Brockton, Mass., May 9.—Twelve birds belonging to the Brockton Homing Club were among the many released at North Adams this morning. The first two arrived in this city at 11:58, having taken two hours and forty minutes for the almost 114 miles. This is thought to be a very good record, as the weather was somewhat hazy and not favorable for the birds.
See moreSee less
current that Wyatt Earp, man of the notched gun stock, referee of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons bout, and protector of the champion at Carson, had arrived incognito in New York and would be in Sharkey's corner in the bout with Maher. In order to ascertain the truth of the report, a Journal reporter yesterday went to New Dorp, S. I., where Sharkey is training. The sailor champion, his manager, Dan J. Lynch, and Joe Choynski were all found at Boemer's Hotel, on the beach, enjoying a Sunday's rest. All emphatically denied that Earp was in the East, and Lynch and Sharkey said they did not expect him. Therefore, those who expect to see Earp and his agile seven-shooter in Sharkey's corner are apparently doomed to disappoint[ment]
[illegible] from, who fashion, is thinking ser[illegible] Among the were Ross a[illegible] Wheelmen, [illegible] tity, of the a spectator. Q. C. W. speed, and t[illegible] ing champio[illegible] start in a r[illegible] Club Wheel[illegible] the season.
The report recounts a circulating story claiming Wyatt Earp drew his gun to protect Bob Fitzsimmons from the chaotic crowd after the Corbett fight in Carson. The paper explicitly frames this as an exaggerated tale showing the extent of some people's imagination, rather than vouching for its truth.
The Scranton Tribune · 11 May 1897 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
STORY OF CARSON FIGHT. Wyatt Earp and His Gun Were in Bob Fitzsimmons' Corner---Squared Himself with Fitz. There is a story of the big fight at Carson going the rounds that is worth
The report recounts a colorful tale of Wyatt Earp drawing a pistol to protect boxer Bob Fitzsimmons from a hostile crowd after Earp's controversial referee decision cost Fitzsimmons $10,000 in the Sharkey bout. Earp reportedly whispered reassurances while holding the gun to Fitzsimmons' neck, warning onlookers not to move.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Scranton Tribune · 11 May 1897 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
This was the unique method employed by Wyatt Earp to square himself with Fitz, who was deprived of a little matter of $10,000 by Earp's decision in the bout with Sharkey in San
Champion Bob Fitzsimmons, in an interview, downplays rivalry with Corbett and recounts how referee Wyatt Earp offered him protection and friendship after the controversial Sharkey bout. Fitzsimmons says he did not want Earp's friendship, given the fight's reputation as a robbery of $10,000.
The Times · 13 May 1897 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
A CHAT WITH FITZSIMMONS
can't go in New York."
ing the congratulations of friends, Corbett rushed to attack me, and I paid no attention to him. He was dragged away, and made the second rush, and, by the way, I believe I would have given it to him good and hard that time had the crowd not interfered. As it was, I remember saying, somewhat angrily: 'Let him come on.'
See moreSee less
"What was my surprise at this time to see Wyatt Earp, the man who refereed my fight at San Francisco with Sharkey, in which I was robbed of $10,000. Referring to the threatening looks of men who had lost their all on the fight, Earp said: 'It's all right, Fitz. Remember, I'm your friend, and I'll stand by you. I'll shoot any man full of holes who lays a hand on you.' This took my breath away. I didn't want any of Wyatt Earp's friendship."
"How about settling down and leaving the stage? Well, I intend to do that as soon as I am allowed to do it. Of course, the present condition of affairs opens op-
This short editorial aside remarks that 'Referee Wyatt Earp and John L. Sullivan's challenge are already well down the road to oblivion.' It treats the earlier controversy over Earp's refereeing as rapidly fading from public attention.
The Saint Paul Globe · 14 May 1897 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Referee Wyatt Earp and John L. Sullivan's challenge are already well down the road to oblivion.
Will New York and Brooklyn have as many people as London when they celebrate their golden wedding?
Boxer Tom Sharkey claims that a film device (vitascope) would prove referee Wyatt Earp was correct in awarding him the fight by disqualifying Fitzsimmons for a foul. The item argues this undermines Fitzsimmons' claim to the heavyweight title and suggests he must fight Corbett.
Eureka Weekly Sentinel · 22 May 1897 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
shouldn't Elko prosper, and why shouldn't she be encouraged by every paper in Nevada?
A Foul Fighter.
See moreSee less
Sharkey now claims that if he had had a vitascope at the ringside when he mixed up with Fitzsimmons, the decision of a foul given by Wyatt Earp would be clearly proven. He claims that the Australian is a foul fighter. Be that as it may, Fitzsimmons' claim to the championship has been given a severe blow. He will now have to give Corbett another fight. If he still insists on posing as champion in the face of this incontestable proof, and refuses to step in the ring again with Corbett, he will lose all caste and be relegated to the list of fake fighters.—Bee.
A brief local item notes that Wyatt Earp and his wife are leaving the next morning for San Francisco. It describes Earp simply as a well-known sporting man of the Pacific Coast.
The Arizona Sentinel · 29 May 1897 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Mr. and Mrs. Jones, proprietor of the Jones Hotel, returned from a visit to Los Angeles, Thursday.
Wyatt Earp and wife leaves to-morrow morning for San Francisco. Mr. Earp is a well-known sporting