As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

May 1894

5 articles

The Weiser Signal · Weiser, Idaho · and 1 other paper

A 1894 newspaper feature looks back at 1880s Tombstone, describing a feud between marshal Virgil Earp and sheriff John Behan. It portrays Behan as honest and brave while casting Wyatt/Virgil Earp as a dishonest leader of desperadoes and stage robbers.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 24 days earlier.

The Weiser Signal · 10 May 1894 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

WERE ALL KILLERS

The glory of Tombstone has departed and the Tough Nut, Contention and a score of other mines are no longer fountains of wealth, but the town is still an interesting one and the tales of the early days told by its old inhabitants more interesting still. In 1880 Virgil Earp was the city marshal and John H. Behan was the sheriff of the county. Between these two officials there was a deadly feud. Behan was an honest man and a good official. Earp was the head of a band of desperadoes, a partner of stage robbers and a friend of gamblers and professional killers. It was the custom that the friends of Behan should occupy the boxes on the left of the stage of the "Bird-Gage" opera house. What pleased the Behan people was certain to displease the Earp people, and if applause or dissent on one side or the other became too enthusiastic shooting was sure to ensue.

Behan would fight a buzz saw in full motion, and after doing up his worst enemy he would give him his last cent if the prostrate foe needed it. Earp was equally brave, but he was dishonest. Virgil was the eldest of the Earp family. At that time the people of Conchise county, of which Tombstone was the county seat, were in reality divided between two factions—the stage robbers and cow robbers. The current name for the stock thieves was the rustlers, while the stage robbers were known as such. Sheriff Behan, though not a cowboy or a rustler himself, was solidly supported by the cowboys, the ranchmen and the wandering cavaliers who had nothing today, but were possessed of their neighbor's live stock tomorrow.

See moreSee less

The connection of the Earps with the stage robbers was a matter of question, suggestion and suspicion for some time. Agent Williams of Wells, Fargo & Co.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Caldwell Tribune · Caldwell, Idaho Territory Idaho · 9 May 1894

The Weiser Signal · Weiser, Idaho · and 4 other papers

A newspaper retrospective describes the Earps as corrupt lawmen running an express-robbery combine with a stage agent, then recounts a shootout killing the McLowrys, Billy Clanton, and Frank Stilwell, followed by a tense armed standoff with Ike Clanton's rustler faction in Tombstone. It portrays the town continuing its business amid the siege, ending with Warren Earp venturing out to gamble after days cooped up.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Weiser Signal · 10 May 1894 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

TOMBSTONE IN OLDEN DAYS

How the Earps Were Driven Out and the Tragic Romance Which Followed —Four Men Shot as a Starter.

See moreSee less

The glory of Tombstone has departed and the Tough Nut, Contention and a score of other mines are no longer fountains of wealth, but the town is still an interesting one and the tales of the early days told by its old inhabitants more interesting still. In 1880 Virgil Earp was the city marshal and John H. Behan was the sheriff of the county. Between these two officials there was a deadly feud. Behan was an honest man and a good official. Earp was the head of a band of desperadoes, a partner of stage robbers and a friend of gamblers and professional killers. It was the custom that the friends of Behan should occupy the boxes on the left of the stage of the "Bird-Gage" opera house. What pleased the Behan people was certain to displease the Earp people, and if applause or dissent on one side or the other became too enthusiastic shooting was sure to ensue. Behan would fight a buzz saw in full motion, and after doing up his worst enemy he would give him his last cent if the prostrate foe needed it. Earp was equally brave, but he was dishonest. Virgil was the eldest of the Earp family. At that time the people of Conchise county, of which Tombstone was the county seat, were in reality divided between two factions—the stage robbers and cow robbers. The current name for the stock thieves was the rustlers, while the stage robbers were known as such. Sheriff Behan, though not a cowboy or a rustler himself, was solidly supported by the cowboys, the ranchmen and the wandering cavaliers who had nothing today, but were possessed of their neighbor's live stock tomorrow.

The connection of the Earps with the stage robbers was a matter of question, suggestion and suspicion for some time. Agent Williams of Wells, Fargo & Co. and the Earps were like brothers; Virgil Earp was the city marshal of Tombstone, his brother Wyatt was the boss killer of the region, and another brother, Warren, was the chief express guard on board stages carrying valuable express freight between Tombstone and the railroad station at Contention. Whenever the stage was robbed, as it was whenever there was anything worth taking aboard, the city marshal and his brothers always organized a posse to pursue the robbers.

It was discovered after a while that Agent Williams and the Earps had formed a combine for express robbery. Whenever the agent had a valuable consignment of bullion or currency he gave Virgil Earp the tip, and he posted his trusty men along the road, and his brother Warren, on the stage front as guard, was careful to be caught so that he had to obey an order to throw up his hands when ordered. Of course, the Earps always put the blame of the robberies on the rustlers.

A presidential proclamation had at length the effect of making the criminals the law officers and the law officers the disturbers of the peace, and notwithstanding certain revelations the Earps continued to lord it over Tombstone. But only for a time.

One day the McLowrys and Frank Stillwell rode into town and put up their horses at a corral on Fremont street. Just as they emerged from the corral the Earps and Halliday confronted them and in a minute the two McLowrys, Billy Clanton and Stillwell were dead. Word was sent to their friends, who were camped in the Huachuca mountains, and they prepared to march to Tombstone in force to clean out the Earps. The Earps recruited and fortified in an adobe building in the west end of town. The rustlers, thirty strong, under command of Ike Clanton and Jack Ringo, marched to town and took up headquarters in a corral at the extreme end of the town. Here were the honest people of Tombstone between the hostile camps, but Tombstone went right along about its business and rather enjoyed the sensation. The saloons and gambling houses did a thriving business twenty-four hours daily. The banks were open and in the evening four mines were operated by 3,000 hardy workmen, and more than 1,000 men and 300 mules were busy hauling ore from the mines to the reduction mills at Contention, eight miles distant. The rustlers circulated through the town and the Earp or stage robber faction confined themselves to their camp.

Ike Clanton, the rustler leader, sent several messages to Wyatt Earp, the leader of that faction, daring him to come out and show his nose. Earp sent back invitations to Clanton to come and visit him. This thing continued for three days, and at last the Earps began to get tired. In fact, their liquor was exhausted and they were on the verge of a thirst famine.

Warren Earp, one of the brothers, heeled himself properly with two revolvers and a shotgun and walked up town one evening about 8 o'clock. He walked into a saloon, took a drink at the bar and walked back to the faro department in the rear. He hadn't bucked the tiger in five days and his appetite was whetted. He sat down in front of the dealer, pulled out a handful of $20 gold pieces and coppered the queen. Just as he did so a report was heard and Warren Earp fell off his stool dead. A bullet had penetrated his brain. When the report of his death reached

See the clipping

Also printed in 4 papers
  • The Caldwell Tribune · Caldwell, Idaho Territory Idaho · 9 May 1894
  • The Philipsburg Mail · Philipsburg, Mont. · 10 May 1894
  • Red Lodge Picket · Red Lodge, Mont. · 12 May 1894
  • The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont. · 12 May 1894

The Philipsburg Mail · Philipsburg, Mont.

This 1894 article recounts Tombstone's early days, portraying Virgil Earp as the corrupt leader of a gang of desperadoes and stage robbers, while Sheriff John Behan is depicted as an honest, brave official supported by cowboys and rustlers. It describes a deadly feud between the two factions playing out even at the local opera house, where rival supporters would shoot at each other over disagreements.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

The Philipsburg Mail · 10 May 1894 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TOMBSTONE IN OLDEN DAYS

one side or the other became too enthusiastic shooting was sure to ensue. Behan would fight a buzz saw in full motion, and after doing up his worst enemy he would give him his last cent if the prostrate foe needed it. Earp was equally brave, but he was dishonest. Virgil was the eldest of the Earp family. At that time the people of Conchise county, of which Tombstone was the county seat, were in reality divided between two factions—the stage robbers and cow robbers. The current name for the stock thieves was the rustlers, while the stage robbers were known as such.

See moreSee less

Sheriff Behan, though not a cowboy or a rustler himself, was solidly supported by the cowboys, the ranchmen and the wandering cavaliers who had nothing today, but were possessed of their neighbor's live stock tomorrow. The connection of the Earps with the stage robbers was a matter of question, suggestion and suspicion for some time. Agent Williams of Wells, Fargo & Co. and the Earps were like brothers: Virgil Earp was the city marshal of Tombstone, his brother Wyatt was the boss killer of the region, and another brother, Warren, was the chief express guard on board stages carrying valuable express freight between Tombstone and the railroad station at Contention. Whenever the stage was robbed, as it was whenever there was anything worth taking aboard, the city marshal and his brothers always organized a posse to pursue the robbers. It was discovered after a while that Agent Williams and the Earps had formed a combine for express robbery. Whenever the agent had a valuable consignment of bullion or currency he gave Virgil Earp the tip, and he posted

See the clipping

The Philipsburg Mail · Philipsburg, Mont. · and 4 other papers

This retrospective newspaper account describes factional strife in 1880s Tombstone between the Earps and local cowboys/rustlers, alleging that Wyatt's brother Virgil colluded with a Wells Fargo agent to stage robberies. It also recounts a street confrontation in which the McLaurys, Billy Clanton, and Frank Stillwell were killed by the Earps and Holliday.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 185 days later.

Wrong

The Philipsburg Mail · 10 May 1894 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TOMBSTONE IN OLDEN DAYS

motion, and after doing up his worst enemy he would give him his last cent if the prostrate foe needed it. Earp was equally brave, but he was dishonest. Virgil was the eldest of the Earp family. At that time the people of Conchise county, of which Tombstone was the county seat, were in reality divided between two factions—the stage robbers and cow robbers. The current name for the stock thieves was the rustlers, while the stage robbers were known as such. Sheriff Behan, though not a cowboy or a rustler himself, was solidly supported by the cowboys, the ranchmen and the wandering cavaliers who had nothing today, but were possessed of their neighbor's live stock tomorrow.

The connection of the Earps with the stage robbers was a matter of question, suggestion and suspicion for some time. Agent Williams of Wells, Fargo & Co. and the Earps were like brothers; Virgil Earp was the city marshal of Tombstone, his brother Wyatt was the boss killer of the region, and another brother, Warren, was the chief express guard on board stages carrying valuable express freight between Tombstone and the railroad station at Contention. Whenever the stage was robbed, as it was whenever there was anything worth taking aboard, the city marshal and his brothers always organized a posse to pursue the robbers.

See moreSee less

It was discovered after a while that Agent Williams and the Earps had formed a combine for express robbery. Whenever the agent had a valuable consignment of bullion or currency he gave Virgil Earp the tip, and he posted his trusty men along the road, and his brother Warren, on the stage front as guard, was careful to be caught so that he had to obey an order to throw up his hands when ordered. Of course, the Earps always put the blame of the robberies on the rustlers.

A presidential proclamation had at length the effect of making the criminals the law officers and the law officers the disturbers of the peace, and notwithstanding certain revelations the Earps continued to lord it over Tombstone. But only for a time.

One day the McLowrys and Frank Stillwell rode into town and put up their horses at a corral on Fremont street. Just as they emerged from the corral the Earps and Halliday confronted them and in a minute the two McLowrys, Billy Clanton and Stillwell were dead. Word was sent to their friends, who were camped in the Huachuca mountains, and they prepared to march to Tombstone in force to clean out the Earps. The Earps recruited and fortified in an adobe building in the west end of town. The rustlers, thirty strong, under command of Ike Clanton and Jack Ringo, marched to town and took up headquarters in a corral at the extreme end of the town. Here were the honest people of Tombstone between the hostile camps, but Tombstone went right along about its business and rather enjoyed the sensation. The saloons and gambling houses did a thriving business twenty-four hours daily. The banks were open and in the evening four mines were operated by 3,000 hardy workmen, and more than 1,000 men and 300 mules were busy hauling ore from the mines to the reduction mills at Contention, eight miles distant. The rustlers circulated through the town and the Earp or stage robber faction confined themselves to their camp.

Ike Clanton, the rustler leader, sent several messages to Wyatt Earp, the leader of that faction, daring him to come out and show his nose. Earp sent back invitations to Clanton to come and visit him. This thing continued for three days, and at last the Earps began to get tired. In fact, their liquor was exhausted and they were on the verge of a thirst famine.

Warren Earp, one of the brothers, heeled himself properly with two revolvers and a shotgun and walked up town one evening about 8 o'clock. He walked into a saloon, took a drink at the bar and walked back to the faro department in the rear. He hadn't bucked the tiger in five days and his appetite was whetted. He sat down in front of the dealer, pulled out a handful of $20 gold pieces and coppered the queen. Just as he did so a report was heard and Warren Earp fell off his stool dead. A bullet had penetrated his brain. When the report of his death reached his friends they rallied out in force. They were met by the Clanton party on the street and an exchange of shots took place. The casualties were three killed and two wounded. The Earps retreated and left the town. When they were gone and there was no hope of catching them the sheriff became energetic. He organized posses to give pursuit that subsequently cost the taxpayers of the county $7,000. The Earps being absent, the sympathy, of course, was against them.

The rustlers then had supreme command of the tough element of Tombstone. The leader of the gang, Ike Clanton, was a handsome fellow, six feet high, with yellow, curling locks, and a rare complexion, in spite of the Arizona sun. He was a ready and straight shooter. He faced death a hundred times and met it at last. He hated the Earp brothers with all the intensity of an unbridled passion and loved their sister with an equal force. Jessie Earp was a beautiful girl of 19 at the time. Ike Clanton and Jessie Earp met at a dance at Tombstone. It was a case of love at first sight. Jessie's brothers became furious when they heard it, and Virgil, the eldest of the family and the keeper of the family headquarters, wanted to turn her out of the house and disown her. But Wyatt, the brains of the family, said this would be playing into the hands of the arch enemy, Clanton. He would immediately marry her and both would be happy. This would not suit the Earps, and they resolved to keep the girl away from Clanton and prevent meeting or communication between them if possible. The girl was a real heroine. She was educated in a California convent, and, while full of romance, had a sense of honor that made her sustain her family in the quarrel with the faction of which her lover was the chief. It was a marvel to many people why the Clanton gang did not attack the Earp headquarters immediately after reaching Tombstone to revenge the death of the McLowry boys and Billy Clanton. The reason was that Jessie was confined in her brother's headquarters and Clanton would not run the risk of killing her. When the Earps retreated from Tombstone they took their sister with them.

Three months later, however, when the Earps were living in Gunnison, Col., and, of course, were running the town, their sister mysteriously disappeared one night. The result of inquiry convinced them she had fled in company with Ike Clanton. This was pouring salt and vinegar into their festering wounds. The whole band, comprising Virgil, Wyatt and Julian Earp, Doc Halliday, Curley Bill, Sam Saunders, Texas Ike and Monroe Tucker, armed, mounted and pursued. The lovers had four hours the start, but were easily trailed. They expected pursuit and lost no time. They reached Lake City, eighty miles from Gunnison, in twelve hours. Both were on horseback.

From Lake City they started for Ouray, 100 miles by regular roads, but, getting afraid of pursuit, they left the road and crossed over the trackless mountain, going 13,000 feet above sea level, and finally reached San Miguel—thirty hours without food. Here they rested for two days, being convinced that the pursuit they expected was off their trail. The Earp party went to Ouray and, finding no trace of the fugitives, became convinced that they had made a short cut to San Miguel. From Ouray to San Miguel is less than thirty miles, but the way is over a pathless mountain, yawning gulches and impassable canons. The Earps, however, essayed the journey and made it in twenty-four hours. They reached San Miguel about 10 o'clock in the morning, and as they rode down the winding trail the fugitives saw them. Clanton and the sister of his arch enemy had been man and wife about twenty minutes, an Episcopal clergyman having tied the knot.

Clanton, though brave as any man, knew that it was hopeless to combat with seven or eight men practiced in the use of fire-arms. But, being accustomed to danger, he knew how to act. He grasped his trembling bride, rushed from the cabin where they were resting and made his way to the nearest mine tunnel. The miners were just

See the clipping

Also printed in 4 papers
  • The Caldwell Tribune · Caldwell, Idaho Territory Idaho · 9 May 1894
  • The Weiser Signal · Weiser, Idaho · 10 May 1894
  • Red Lodge Picket · Red Lodge, Mont. · 12 May 1894
  • The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont. · 12 May 1894

The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont. · and 1 other paper

A newspaper feature looks back at 1880s Tombstone, describing the deadly rivalry between city marshal Virgil Earp and Sheriff John Behan amid warring factions of stage robbers and cattle rustlers. It portrays Behan as honest and brave while casting Earp as a dishonest leader of desperadoes allied with outlaws.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

The New North-West · 12 May 1894 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

WERE ALL KILLERS

The glory of Tombstone has departed and the Tough Nut, Contention and a score of other mines are no longer fountains of wealth, but the town is still an interesting one and the tales of the early days told by its old inhabitants more interesting still. In 1880 Virgil Earp was the city marshal and John H. Behan was the sheriff of the county. Between these two officials there was a deadly feud. Behan was an honest man and a good official. Earp was the head of a band of desperadoes, a partner of stage robbers and a friend of gamblers and professional killers.

See moreSee less

It was the custom that the friends of Behan should occupy the boxes on the left of the stage of the "Bird-Gage" opera house. What pleased the Behan people was certain to displease the Earp people, and if applause or dissent on one side or the other became too enthusiastic shooting was sure to ensue. Behan would fight a buzz saw in full motion, and after doing up his worst enemy he would give him his last cent if the prostrate foe needed it. Earp was equally brave, but he was dishonest. Virgil was the eldest of the Earp family. At that time the people of Conchise county, of which Tombstone was the county seat, were in reality divided between two factions—the stage robbers and cow robbers. The current name for the stock thieves was the rustlers, while the stage robbers were known as such. Sheriff Behan, though not a cowboy or a rustler himself, was solidly supported by the cowboys, the ranchmen and the wandering cavaliers who had nothing today, but were possessed of their neighbor's live stock tomorrow. The connection of the Earps with the stage robbers was a matter of question, suggestion and suspicion for some time. Agent Williams of Wells, Fargo & Co.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Red Lodge Picket · Red Lodge, Mont. · 12 May 1894