As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

November 1891

2 articles

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A San Francisco Chronicle retrospective describes the lawless stage road between Benson and Tombstone around 1881, recounting how driver Budd Philpot was shot dead during a robbery attempt. The piece frames this as part of Doc Holliday's violent criminal trail through the western states.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 21 November 1891 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

DOC HOLLIDAY, STAGE-ROBBER.

Trail of Blood That Followed Him through the Western States.

See moreSee less

San Francisco Chronicle.

In 1881 the stage road between Benson and Tombstone was a bad route to travel by night or by day. Benson was inhabited mostly by rustlers and toughs, and Tombstone was infested by Doc Holliday and other people of that sort. The Earps managed to hold things level in Tombstone, but the road agents bossed the highway, and in Benson a man was liable to be held up at noon on the depot platform while waiting for a train. Budd Philpot, brother-in-law of Charley Foss, the king of stage-drivers, was driving the Benson and Tombstone stage, and one night some one tried to hold him up not many miles from Tombstone. Philpot had had experience with road agents, and when he heard the order to halt come from the darkness a little behind the off-fore wheel he concluded that the robber was a green hand at the business, and instead of putting on the brake he gave the horses the silk and sent them ahead on the run.

In nine cases out of ten the trick would have won, as the robber would have thought it hardly worth while to fire at a rapidly escaping stage, and the darkness would have spoiled his aim if he did fire. But the crack of Philpot's lash was answered by the crack of a Winchester, and Philpot half sprang to his feet, dropped back with a moan, and swayed in his seat. The messenger who sat beside him threw his right arm around the driver, and, with his left, seized the lines as they fell from Philpot's relaxed fingers.

The Winchester cracked again and again, and a cry from the inside of the coach told that one of the passengers had been hit. The frightened horses flew over the road. The messenger held the dying driver with one arm and with the left hand tried to arrange the tangled lines, while the bullets whistled by in the dark. He got the stage into Tombstone with the express box safe, but two dead men were taken from the coach.

That was not the work of a professional road agent. The main purpose of the robber is to secure plunder, and if he does any killing it is either to prevent somebody from killing him or to insure the success of the robbery. The attack upon the Tombstone stage was the work of a mankiller who had turned road agent for one night only, and for that and other good reasons the job was generally attributed to Doc Holliday, a man who left a trail of blood across every State and Territory between the Mississippi and the Sierras.

The Sun's Latest.

New York Post.

Unless the usual symptons are misleading, the Sun's long search for a presidential candidate to run in its columns next year in place of Benjamin Franklin Butler and David Bennett Hill, retired, has at last met with success. Three column of space are given up this morning to an enumeration of the remarkable qualities of Governor Gray, of Indiana as a statesman and a Democrat; and in the headlines, the text of the article, and in the editorial reference thereto, the Governor's name is spelled in every instance Isaac Pusey Gray. Had it been written simply Isaac P. Gray, we should have had some doubt about the meaning of the outbreak; but, when the middle name is displayed in full beauty and glory, no reader of the Sun can doubt that the editor "means business." It will be sad business for Governor Gray, who, so far as we are familiar with his caeer, has done nothing to deserve such a fate.

Two Constructions.

Kansas City Times.

Jerry Simpson is in Indianapolis whooping it up for the third party. His enthusiasm may, however, be open to two constructions—either he has figured it out or he is doing some high C whistling.

General Butler Not Dangerously Ill.

Boston, Nov. 20.—Gen. B. F. Butler's physician says his patient's illness is painful, but not dangerous.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A San Francisco Chronicle feature from a decade later retells the 1881 attempted stage robbery on the Benson-Tombstone road in which driver Bud Philpot was shot and killed by a hidden gunman. It frames the episode as an illustration of old frontier lawlessness, noting the Earps' presence in Tombstone and Doc Holliday's reputation.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 8 days earlier.

The Morning News · 29 November 1891 · page 13 · transcribed from the page image

ROBBERY AS A FINE ART. THRILLING STORIES RECALLED BY RECENT EXPLOITS.

Instances by Way of Illustrations. From the San Francisco Chronicle. In 1881 the stage road between Benson and Tombstone was a bad route to trave by night or by day. Benson was inhabited mostly by rustlers and toughs, and Tombstone was infested by Doc Holliday and other people of that sort. The Earps managed to hold things level in Tombstone,

See the clipping