As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

September 1889

2 articles

Jeffersonian-Plaindealer · Philippi, W. Va.

The passage describes the legendary marksmanship of Wild Bill Hickok and other Old West gunmen, including the Earp brothers, Billy the Kid, and Bat Masterson, claiming they shot with no apparent aim and often killed victims with precision shots between the eyes. It presents exaggerated and romanticized accounts of their deadly skills, such as Hickok allegedly hitting a tossed oyster can twelve times before it landed.

Jeffersonian-Plaindealer · 19 September 1889 · page 1

All the killers with big records and private graveyards shot in much tlie same manner. Billy the Kid, C.av Al lison, Bat Mastcrson, Sam Holliday, the Earp brothers, “Cotmnanche” Jack Stillwell, and other worthies of tho frontier all shot with no apparent aim. AH of them were professional killers, and in their later days, when abundance of practice had made them dexterous in the art of murder, most of them shot their victims always between tho eyes, in imitation of Wil 1 Bill.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 1 other paper

An 1889 Chicago Herald interview with former Tombstone alderman Martin Joyce disputes claims that Deputy Marshal Dave Nagle (who killed Judge Terry) was a hero, calling reports that he drove out the Earp brothers 'nonsense.' Joyce describes Nagle as a trigger-happy lawman who was forced to resign as Tombstone police chief after shooting a fleeing Mexican man in the back.

Evening Star · 26 September 1889 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Marshal Nagle's Ready Gun. From the Chicago Herald. "Yes, I know Deputy Marshal Nagle, who killed Judge Terry, as well as I know anybody," said ex-Alderman Martin Joyce of Tombstone, Ariz., the other day. "There has been a good deal of nonsense written about Nagle. Of course he did right in the Terry matter, but for all that I don't think, nor does any of us think down in Tombstone, that he ought to be made a hero of. Dave Nagle was not near the holy terror to the roughs and toughs of that region that his friends are trying to make out.

See moreSee less

I see it is claimed for Nagle that while he was the chief of police of Tombstone he drove out the famous Earp brothers from that place. That is nonsense. Nagle would no more dare tackle an Earp than he would tackle the devil himself. He was a ready man with his gun—a little too ready, in fact. You know down our way a man with a gun is supposed to give the other fellow a chance, and if he gets the drop on him he is not supposed to kill so long as the other fellow has his hands up. Nagle was known down there as a fellow who never took chances. He never'd care whether a man was armed or not—if he had the reputation of being tough Nagle would shoot him. The only man he ever killed outright, however, was a thieving Mexican who was sneakin' off in the bush to escape arrest. Nagle shot him in the back. That act got the boys in Tombstone down on him and we forced him to resign his office as chief of police, and not long after he left town. How he ever got an appointment as deputy marshal under the government I don't know. He couldn't have got it down in Arizona. Yes, Nagle is a quick and good shot—but then that's nothing down in our country. We're all good shots. When a man our way undertakes to carry a gun he's supposed to know how to use it. If he doesn't his gun'll be mighty little use to him."

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn. · 6 October 1889