As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

August 1889

4 articles

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A retrospective article mythologizes Wild Bill Hickok's marksmanship and lists other famous Western gunmen, including the Earp brothers, as sharing his supposedly unerring, aim-free shooting style. It includes a dramatic anecdote claiming Hickok managed to draw and cock both pistols after being shot in the back of the head.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 72 days later.

Wrong

St. Paul Daily Globe · 1 August 1889 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

HANDY WITH THEIR PISTOLS.

way imaginable. All the killers with big records and private graveyards shot in much the same manner. Billy the Kid, Clay Allison, Bat Masterson, Sam Holliday, the Earp brothers, "Comanche," Jack Stillwell, and other worthies of the frontier all shot with no apparent aim. All of them were professional killers, and in their later days, when abundance of practice had made them dexterous in the art of murder, most of them shot their victims always between the eyes, in imitation of Wild Bill. To show how quick these men were,

See the clipping

Los Angeles Daily Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

A Los Angeles personals column reports that Wyatt Earp, described as 'the great Tombstone Deputy Sheriff of ten years ago,' was in the city and returned to San Diego. The item appears among many other brief notices of visitors and local residents.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Los Angeles Daily Herald · 7 August 1889 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

PERSONAL.

city, has been transferred to Buffalo, New York.

Wyatt Earp, the great Tombstone Deputy Sheriff of ten years ago, was here in the city. He returned to San Diego yesterday.

See moreSee less

I. W. Hellman will sail for Europe to

See the clipping

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I. · and 1 other paper

This retrospective piece on western outlaws describes Wild Bill Hickok and other famous gunmen, including the Earp brothers, as nearly superhuman marksmen who could perform incredible feats of shooting. It claims they typically shot victims precisely between the eyes in imitation of Hickok's supposed signature style.

Narragansett Herald · 17 August 1889 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

All the killers with big records and private graveyards shot in much the same manner. Billy the Kid, Clay Allison, Bat Masterson, Sam Holliday, the Earp brothers, "Commanche" Jack Stillwell, and other worthies of the frontier all shot with no apparent aim. All of them were professional killers, and in their later days, when abundance of practice had made them dexterous in the art of murder, most of them shot their victims always between the eyes, in imitation of Wild Bill.

Beds Were Bundles of Straw.

See moreSee less

In the early period of modern history beds were almost universally in Europe nothing but bundles of straw. As late in England as the time of Queen Elizabeth no carpets were used and the floors were strewn with rushes, and the beds were hardly anything better than a rude bench or any rude framework which lifted it above the floor.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · 14 July 1889

Los Angeles Daily Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

A miner recounts rumors and anecdotes about Dave Neagle's violent past, including an alleged killing of a mining partner and a brutal beating of a woman. The account also mentions Neagle's promise to disarm the Earp brothers and Doc Holliday in Tombstone, though he reportedly never did.

Los Angeles Daily Herald · 19 August 1889 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

KILLED HIS PARTNER.

"The last of Dave Neagle's exploits, though, that I know about, was up in Butte. He was mining up there, and he had a partner. After working together amicably for some time the two had a falling out over money matters. I believe the partner had some coin he would not 'divy on.' They had some high words, and Neagle just out with his pistol and killed him dead as a door nail.

See moreSee less

"But he's a cunning fellow, though," continued the miner. "He hastened back to the mine and told all the boys that his partner was bolting, and that he shot him to secure their money for them. Well, they thought he was all right, and did nothing."

"How did Neagle get elected Chief of Police of Tombstone?" was asked.

"By promising something he did not perform. Tombstone was a pretty rough place in those days and a family of five boys—the Earps—assisted by a chap named Doc Holliday, sort of run the town. They used to march round with big revolvers, firing here and there as they pleased. Neagle promised to disarm them if he was elected, and on the strength of his promise he was put in. Do you know he never touched an Earp as long as he was in there—never laid a finger on one of them? He was beaten for the same place next year, however. Why, there's thousands of things told about him. I believe he has been accused of every crime in the calendar, but some how or other he has had good luck and never got arrested.

WHAT HE WAS IMPORTED FOR

See the clipping