As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

June 1886

8 articles

Seattle Daily Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash.

A reporter records a frontier old-timer's reminiscence about the deadly feud between the Earp brothers and the Clanton-McLowry group, framing it as the bloodiest impromptu duel in border history. The account claims the conflict stemmed from the Earps wanting the Clantons to lure stage robbers into an ambush for reward money, which Ike Clanton refused.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Seattle Daily Post-Intelligencer · 6 June 1886 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

NOT A HEALTHY CLIMATE.

SOME OF THE FORMER DESPERADOES.

"What has become of the notorious ones who have not been killed?"

See moreSee less

"Oh, I don't know. It isn't a hard matter to keep track of them, either, there are so few left. A good proportion of them have gone into Mexico, and others have drifted into the cattle regions of Utah and Montana, and still a few continue to reside in the Territory."

Pursuing this branch of the subject the reporter induced his friend to rehearse the story of the war between the Earp brothers and the Clanton and McLowry brothers. This was probably the bloodiest and most desperate impromptu duel that ever took place in any border country, and half a dozen men died violent deaths afterwards in consequence of it. The eight men engaged in the fray were Tom and Frank McLowry and Ike and Billy Clanton on one side, and Wyatt, Morgan and Virgil Earp and Doc Halliday on the other. The four former were cattlemen on adjoining ranches, and up to a short time before the feud commenced, they were on the best of terms with the Earps, who held various positions in Tombstone, Virgil at the time this story opens, in 1882, being City Marshal. Halliday was a gambler, and supposed to be something of a stage robber also, but he was on terms of intimacy with both parties, and only inclined the more to the Earps because of their inclination to overlook his little infractions of the law.

THE PRIME CAUSE OF THE TROUBLE,

It is generally believed, was a certain stage robbery, in which considerable blood was shed by the robbers. A heavy reward was offered for the robbers, dead or alive, and it lay in the power of the Clantons to inform the Earps who the robbers were. Virgil Earp had his brothers as a posse, and he desired that the Clantons should lead the highwaymen into an ambush, where he and his party could kill them, and obtain the reward without having to make a fight in effecting their arrest. Ike Clanton sat on the proposition at once, and hard feeling was engendered. No immediate trouble grew out of the refusal, however, and the

See the clipping

Seattle Daily Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash.

This report recounts the lead-up to and details of the Tombstone gunfight near the O.K. Corral, describing the confrontation between the Earp party and the Clantons/McLaurys that left three dead. It also briefly introduces the later killing of Morgan Earp by an unknown assailant tied to the feud.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 588 days earlier.

Seattle Daily Post-Intelligencer · 6 June 1886 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

City Marshal sat in a poker game with two of the quartette. While conning his cards, however, his hand never wandered far away from his lap, on which reposed his six shooter, and those who saw it predicted trouble at any minute. A day or two later Earp commenced war by arresting Ike Clanton for a violation of some trivial ordinance, and then open threats were made on both sides. The duel was fought in front of the O. K. corral on Fremont street, and followed closely on the heels of Ike Clanton's arrest.

See moreSee less

Billy Clanton and Frank McLowry had their horses in the corral, and went after them preparatory to starting off on some cattle business, their brothers accompanying them to see them off. Billy and Frank were leading their horses and walking by the side of Ike and Tom, when the three Earps and Halliday came upon them from Fourth street, which crosses Fremont not far from the corral. Virgil Earp's first words were an order for the

See the clipping

Hoof and Horn · Prescott, Ariz.

A newspaper reprints an Alta California account describing the Earp-Clanton-McLowry conflict as originating from a stagecoach robbery reward dispute, claiming Virgil Earp wanted the Clantons to lure robbers into an ambush. The piece frames the story as colorful 'frontier history' narrated by an anonymous source years after the fact.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 16 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 551 days earlier.

Wrong

Hoof and Horn · 10 June 1886 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

The following extract from the history of characters more or less known to many in Arizona, is interesting, as showing "how it was done" up to a year or two ago. One of the parties mentioned below now resides in Apache County. We copy from the Alta California:

Pursuing this branch of the subject the reporter induced his friend to rehearse the story of the war between the Earp brothers [a]nd the Clanton and McLowry brothers. This was probably the bloodiest and most desperate impromtu duel that has ever taken place in any border country, and a half dozen men died a violent death afterwards in consequence of it. The eight [m]en engag[e]d in the fra[y] were Tom and Frank McLowry and Ike and Billy Clanton on one side, and Wyatt, Morgan and Virgil Earp and Doc Holliday on the other. The four former were cattlemen on adjoining ranches, and up to within a short time before the feud commenced they were on the best of terms with the Earps, who held various positions in Tombstone, Virgil at the time this story opens, in 1882 being city marshal. Holliday was a gambler, and supposed to be something of a stage robber also, but he was on terms of intimacy with both parties, and only inclined the more to the Earps because of their inclination to overlook his little infractions of the law.

See moreSee less

The prime cause of the trouble, it is generally believed, was a certain stage robber, in which considerable blood was shed by the robbers. A heavy reward was offered for the robbers, dead or alive, and it lay in the power of the Clantons to inform the Earps who the robbers were. Virgil had his brothers as a posse, and he desired that the Clantons should lead the highwaymen into an air bush, where he and his party could kill them and obtain the reward without having to make a fight in affecting their arrest. Ike Clanton sat on the proposition atonce, and hard feeli[n]gs were engendered. No im-

See the clipping

Hoof and Horn · Prescott, Ariz. · and 1 other paper

The report recounts the 1881 shootout where Virgil Earp ordered the Clantons to surrender, leading to a gunfight that killed Billy Clanton and the McLaury brothers while the Earps were lightly wounded. It then describes Morgan Earp's later assassination through a glass door and the Earps' subsequent killing of suspected shooter Frank Stillwell.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

Hoof and Horn · 10 June 1886 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

McLowry were shot to death, while the Earp party had escaped lightly, Virgil having a trivial flesh wound in the leg and Morgan an equally light one in the shoulder. Of course they had their side of the story to tell, and on preliminary examination were acquitted.

Some weeks later Morgan Earp received his quietus at the hand of a friend of the dead brothers, but as to just who that friend was, there is considerable dispute. His surviving brothers claimed to have certain knowledge of his identity, and they afterwards killed Frank Stillwell for the deed, but the latter's innocence is claimed by many to this day. Earp was playing billiards in Hatch's saloon one evening, and was shot from a rear window or door. The glass of the window or door was frosted, with the exception of one pane, which had recently been put in, and this clean pane afforded the avenger his safe opportunity. The murderer poked a forty-five caliber revolver through this bit of glass and dropped his man at the first shot. Wyatt Earp arrived before his brother died, and in time to ask the single question, "who did it?" The dying man whispered a name in his ear, and expired almost immediately. Nothing was to be found of the murderer in the city, but the beat of a horse's hoofs immediately following the shot showed that he had laid his plans carefully. The next morning Frank Stillwell the man suspected by the Earps, ate his breakfast in Tucson, ninety miles away, but such a feat of horsemanship would have been little to an average plainsman if he could secure a change of horses, and the Earps pointed this out when they accused him of the murder. Their vengeance on Stillwell was prompt and terrible. Just two days after the occurrence they rode into Tucson in pursuit, and their man was found at the depot just at the train time. With Wyatt Earp were McMasters, Johnson, Texas Jack and Holliday, and when Stillwell's body was found it was so riddled with bullets that it would have made a good sieve. A fortnight prior to this Virgil Earp received a close call and warning in the shape of a bullet, which rendered his right arm useless for all time to come. He received the compliment between 1 and 2 o'clock in the morning, as he was leaving a saloon on Fifth street and it never was discovered where it came from.

See moreSee less

These warning were too much for the Earps, and after spending about all the money they had in getting clear of the law, they left the country. Virgil ran a faro game here in San Francisco for a little while and then retired to his father's ranch in San Bernardino county. Wyatt is over in Montana, rustling as usual, and Doc Holliday is in Colorado. He left Tombstone between two days, and in considerable of a hurry. Ike Clanton and another brother straightened up after the big fight, and are now running a cattle ranch in Graham county, A. T."

"I guess that's about enough for to-day," concluded the narrator as he located the actors in the tragedy. "Next time I will tell you about the different fates of the stage robbers that caused the original dispute between the Earps and Clantons. I don't think there is but one of them living, and the fate of one of the dead ones would form a chapter of itself.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • · · 6 June 1886

New York Dispatch · New York, N.Y.

A traveler named Colonel Conway reminisces about notorious Western figures he encountered, claiming they were all blondes, including Bat Masterson, Doc Holliday, and the Earp brothers. He repeats the exaggerated claim that Masterson had killed twenty-seven men by age twenty-seven.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 231 days later.

Wrong

New York Dispatch · 20 June 1886 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

THE NOTED DESPERADOES.—Colonel Conway, who has been for twelve years in Arizona, Colorado, Wyoming and New Mexico, says that all the noted desperadoes that he saw were blondes. He says: "Masterson, the famous sheriff of Dodge, who had killed twenty-seven men when he was twenty-seven years old, has light hair and blue eyes. So has Doc. Holliday, exiled from Arizona or trying to kill off all of Tombstone in one day. The Erp brothers could join a Lydia Thompson troupe, if yellow curls

See the clipping

Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · Butte, Mont. · and 1 other paper

This account, published years after the 1881 shootout, claims the feud stemmed from a stage robbery and a reward dispute in which the Clantons refused to help the Earps ambush the robbers. It then narrates the buildup and the gunfight itself near the O.K. Corral, including Ike Clanton's unarmed flight.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · 26 June 1886 · page 3

THE PRIME CAUSE OF THE TROUBLE, it is generally believed, was a certain stage robbery, in which considerable "blood was shed by the robbers. A heavy reward-was offered for the robbers dead or alive, and it lay in the power of the Clantons to inform the Earps who .the robbers were. Virgil Earp had hie brothers as a posse, and hè de sired that the Clantons should lead the highwaymen into an ambush where he and his party could kill them, and ob tain the reward without having to make a fight in effectingtheir _ arrest.

See moreSee less

Ike Clanton sat on the proposition at oùce, and hard feeling was engendered. No immediate trouble grew out of the refusal, however, and the same night it was made the cheerful City Marshal sat in a pc game with two of the quartette. While conning his cards, however, his hand never wandered far away from his lap, on which reposed his six-shooter, and those who saw it predicted trouble at any minute. A day or two later Earp commenced war by ar resting Ike Clanton for a violation of some trivial ordinance, and then open threats were made on both sides. The duel was fought in front of the 0 K corral on Fre mont street, and followed closely on the heels of IkeClanton's arrest. Hilly Clanton and Frank McLowry had their hom in the corral, and went after them prepara tory to starting off on some cattle busi ness, their brothers accompanying them to see them off. Billy and Frank were leading their horses and walking by the side of Ike and Tom, when the three Earps and Halliday came upon them from Fourth street, which crosses Fr°mont not far from the corral. Virgil Earp's first woid was an order for the brothers to THROW UP THEIR HANDS.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Hoof and Horn · Prescott, Ariz. · 10 June 1886

Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · Butte, Mont.

A San Francisco reporter relays an Arizona traveler's secondhand account of the Earp brothers' 1882 feud with the Clantons and McLaurys, including Doc Holliday's role and a stage robbery as the alleged root cause. The story claims Virgil Earp proposed the Clantons lure robbers into an ambush, a refusal that supposedly sparked the deadly conflict.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · 26 June 1886 · page 3

THE BLOODY BORDER. The Gory Reminiscences of a Resident of Arizona. A few days ago a San Francisco reporter met a gentleman juBt from "Arizona, and in the casual chat that followed the exchange of greetings, the former asked what civiliz ing influence had fallen on the Territory" to stop the constant slaughter of man by his fellow, that was so common a very f w years back. This led out a strong flood of reminiscences, ai.d some of them wet* of interest to a great many Butteites who knew "Doc."

See moreSee less

HaHiday, the gambler who fled the city last Spring while under indict ment by the Grand Jury. The Arizona man rehearsed the story of the war be tween the Earp brothers and the Clanton and McLowry brothers. . This was proba bly the bloodiest and most desperate im promptu duel that ev.r took place in any border country; and half a dozen men died violent deaths afterwards in consequence of it. The eight men engaged in the fray were Tom and Frank McLowry, and Ike and Billy Clanton on one side, and Wyatt, Morgan and Virgil Earp -and "Doc." Hahday on the other. The four former were cattlemen on adjoining ranches, and up to a short time before the feud com menced they were on the best of terms with the Earps, who held various positions in Tombstone, Virgil at the time this story opens, in 1882, being City Marshal. Halli day Was a gambler, and supposed to be something of a stage robber also, bat he was on terms of intimacy with both parties, and only inclined the more to the Eferps because of their inclination to overlook his little infractions of the law. THE PRIME CAUSE OF THE TROUBLE,

See the clipping

Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · Butte, Mont.

This 1886 account recaps the 1881 gunfight near the OK Corral, describing Virgil Earp's order to surrender, the deaths of Billy Clanton and the McLowry brothers, and the Earps' acquittal. It then describes Morgan Earp's 1882 assassination while playing billiards, the dying man's whispered identification of his killer, and the Earps' subsequent killing of suspect Frank Stilwell.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 16 days earlier.

Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · 26 June 1886 · page 3

THROW UP THEIR HANDS. It is only certain that Ike obeyed, and he did so because he was unarmed. What move was made by the others no person outside of the Earps and Halliday knows, but the firing commenced immediately. For five minutes the bullets flew in a perfect hailstorm in the vicinity, and scarcely a shot was thrown aivay. It was give and take, and seven cf the party stood and pumped lead from their weapons as long as they had a shot left. The other member, Ike Clanton, was unarmed, and consequently wad forced to be a non-combatant.

See moreSee less

He saw he could do nothing, and fled through the corral and a photograph gallery back of it, and es caped unhurt, although pursued by shower of balls and buckshot. An im mense crowd collected on either side of the street before the shooting was over, but it would have been suicide to attempt to in terfere, and the battle went on to the deadly end. When the smoke cleared away Billy Clanton and Frank and Tom Mc Lowry were shot to death, while the Earp party had escaped lightly, Viigil having a trivial flesh wound in the leg, and Morgan an equally light ODe in the shoulder. Of course they had their side of the story t\. tell, and on preliminary examination w ere acquitted. MORGAN EARP'S DEATH.

See the clipping