The Silver State · Unionville, Nev.
A dispute between attorney Harry Jones and Justice of the Peace James Reilly escalated into a physical altercation in Tombstone court, with Reilly grabbing Jones by the throat and Jones striking him in the eye. Deputy Sheriff Wyatt Earp separated the two men and arrested both Jones and, later, Reilly himself.
The Silver State · 3 September 1880 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
AN ARIZONA COURT.
How a Disciple of Blackstone Pasted His Honor in the Eye.
See moreSee less
[From the Arizona Star of August 19th.]
This is the way they keep the judicial pot a boiling in Tombstone : Owing to some private difficulty between Mr. Harry B. Jones, counselor-at-law, and Justice of the Peace James Reilly, the latter ordered the former out of Court unless he apologized to him when he came to take his seat as counsel for Perrine, who is charged with murder. Mr. Jones took no notice and sat down beside his client. This incensed Judge Reilly to such a degree that he came from behind his judicial desk, grasped Jones by the throat and attempted to throw him out. Jones then hit His Honor in the eye. Deputy Sheriff Earp, who was in another part of the Court, as soon as possible separated them and arrested Jones, telling the Justice to consider himself also under arrest. Jones was taken before Justice Gray, and his case was to come up for examination yesterday, as also Justice Reilly's, for whose arrest Deputy Sheriff Earp had in the meantime procured a warrant. As soon as Mr. Jones reappeared in Justice Reilly's Court His Honor fined him $25 and one day's imprisonment. He was brought down Tuesday night from Tombstone in charge of Earp, and came up on a writ of habeas corpus before Probate Judge Woods yesterday at one o'clock. The order of commitment proving defective, and the punishment imposed for the contempt greater than a Justice can inflict, the prisoner was at once discharged from custody on motion of the District Attorney. To-day they'll go at it again.