As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

November 1910

9 articles

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This report is an obituary for Professor William H. Brewer, who died in New Haven, crediting him with convincing Secretary Seward to purchase Alaska through arguments about fishing rights, ice resources, and scenic value. It quotes Brewer's own recollections of his conversations with Seward decades after the 1867 purchase.

New-York Tribune · 3 November 1910 · page 7

URGED ALASKA PURCHASE Prof. Brewer Convinced Seward, but Found Johnson Difficult.

Combined Exploration ang Pedi gogy with Expert Knowl edee of Horses et Rf Ci ats, I —_————— —————————————_ ttssm———————————— To William H. Brewer, who died at his home in New Haven early yesterday morn ing, belongs much of the credit for the purchase of Alaska. It was he who was largely instrumental in persuading Presi | dent Johnson and Secretary Seward of the advisability of that move. 1 | “1 urged three reasons upon Seward tor buying Alaska,” said Professor Brewer re cently. * ‘First, we need it for its fishing rights,” I said to him.

See moreSee less

‘What a great thing I EE III Ti iy for America it would be if we owned the Banks of Newfoundland. See how the fish | ing industry built up the Dutch Republic. England has always fostered her fishing in dustry, and see her results! “Kecond, I said that Alaska must hecome a great source of ice for the Pacific Coast. How laughable that reason appears now! Yet it was a very scientific argument then. and the company which controls the fishing industries of Alaska was originally only an ice company, according to its charter. “Third was a very sentimental! reason, but I am inclined ;to think that it is being demonstrated bv the events of later years. 1 said that the climate and scenery of Alaska were of pecuniary value. It was and i= a land of unequalled sublimity and grandeur. The Alps have brought millions of dollars into Switzerland. The White Mountains have brought fortunes into New Hampshire. Both will in time yield to Alaska in mountain scenery. 1 can still see Seward smile as I told him that the people of the United States would. in time, want to visit Alaska for the sake of the scenery. I said I might not live to see the time. but that a nation lives longer than a man, and that the time would surely come when trips to the north regions would te commonly made for pleasure.” Seward was convinced, but Johnson | proved more difficult. A while after Pro fessor Brewer's conversation, however, the President visited New Haven, and there the advocate of Alaska met him and com

See the clipping

San Antonio Light and Gazette · San Antonio, Tex.

This report on the death of Professor William H. Brewer claims he was largely responsible for persuading President Johnson and Secretary Seward to buy Alaska. It recounts Brewer's own account of giving Seward reasons for the purchase, including fishing rights and ice resources.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

San Antonio Light and Gazette · 3 November 1910 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Associated Press. New Haven, Conn., Nov. 3.—To Prof. Wm. H. Brewer, who died at his home here yesterday, belongs much of the credit for the purchase of Alaska by the United States. Close personal friends declared today that it was he who was largely instrumental in persuading President Johnson and Secretary Seward, of the advisability of that move.

"I urged three reasons upon Seward for buying Alaska," Prof. Brewer once told a party of Yale friends. "First, we need it for its fishing rights," I said to him. "What a great thing for America it would be if we owned the banks of New Foundland. See how the fishing industry built up the duties. England has always fostered her fishing resources and see her results.

See moreSee less

"Second, I said, Alaska must become a great source of ice for the Pacific coast. How laughable that reason appears now. Yet it was a very scientific reason then and the company which controls the fishing industries

See the clipping

San Antonio Light and Gazette · San Antonio, Tex.

A reminiscence describes how Professor Brewer argued to Seward that Alaska's climate and scenery would someday draw tourists and revenue, comparing it to the Alps and White Mountains. The account recalls Seward being convinced, while President Johnson required further persuasion at New Haven.

San Antonio Light and Gazette · 3 November 1910 · page 4

Buying Country. t of Alaska was originally an ice comI pany. according to its charter. | "The third was a very sentimental i reason, but I am inclined to think that it is being demonstrated by the events of laU-r years. I said that the climate and scenery of Alaska were of pecuniary value, ft was and is a land of unequaled sublimity and grandeur. The Alps have brought I millions of dollars into Switzerland. The White mountains have brought fortunes into New Hampshire. Both will in time yield to Alaska in moun tain scenery.

See moreSee less

I can still see Seward smile as I told him that the people of the United States would in time want to visit Alaska for the sake of the scenery. I said I might not live to see the time, but that a nation lives longer than a man and that the time would surely come when trips to the north region would be commonly made for pleasure." Seward was convinced, but Johnson proved more difficult. A while after Prof. Brewer's conversation, the pres* I ident visited New Haven and there the I advocate of Alaska met him and com 'pleted his work.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A 1910 death notice for Yale professor William Henry Brewer credits him with persuading President Johnson and Secretary Seward to buy Alaska. The claim appears in his obituary among other notable deaths of the week.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 20 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

Wrong

New-York Tribune · 6 November 1910 · page 60

THE DEATH ROLL. “Any persons of importance die?” asked Busy Man. “Prince Francis Hatzfeldt-Wildenburg died in London. His marriage to Clara Elizabeth Huntington, adopted daughter of | Collis P, Huntington, of this city, took place in 1889. Mr. Huntington gave $500,000 to pay the prince's debts and settled $3, 400,000 on the bride. Judge George R. Gray, of the New Jersey Court of Errors and Ap peals, died at his home, No. 30 Franklin street, Newark. He was sixty-nine years old. General Charles Cleveland Dodge died | in this city from pneumonia.

See moreSee less

He was the president of the New York and Boston Cape Cod Canal Company. | “The Duke of Veragua, a descendant of Christopher Columbus and former Minister of Marine in Spain, died in Madrid. He visited the United States in 1893 on the oc casion of the Columbus celebration. Henri | Dunant, founder of the International ed | Cross, died at Halden, a health resort in Switzerland. Sir Willlam Agnew, chair man of Bradbury, Agnew & Co., publishers of ‘Punch,’ died in London. John Adams Acton, sculptor, died in London. Melton Frior, war correspcndent and artist, who saw some twenty-four campaigns and revo lutions, died in London. Professor Wiil iam Henry Brewer, of Yale, died in New Haven, at the age of eighty-two. He was one of the most prominent American ex plorers of the Arctic region and of the Northwest. To him belongs much of the credit for the purchase of Alaska. It was he who was largely instrumental in per sunading President Johnson and Becretary Seward of the advisability of that move. General James Jourdan, president of the Brooklyn Union Gas Company, died at the age of seventy-nine at his home, No. 174 Washington Park, Brooklyn. He was a conspicuous figure in military eircles and the political life of the old city of Brooklyn after the Civil War. IIugh J. Grant, twice elected by Tammany to be Mayor of New York City, and twice defeated for that of fice, died suddenly 2t his home, No. 20 Bast 724 street. Manlove Hayes, for fifty years secretary and treasurer of Dela~

See the clipping

The Newport Miner · Newport, WA

The Seattle assay office reported over $9.3 million in Alaskan gold received in the first ten months of 1910, with the year's total output estimated at $16,000,000. This pushed the total gold yield from Alaska since its 1867 purchase from Russia up to roughly $125,000,000-$150,000,000.

The Newport Miner · 10 November 1910 · page 2

Alaskan gold to the amount of $9,- 353,145.77 has been received at the Seattle branch of the United States assay office during the first ten months of the present year. This fig ure is exclusive of an enormous con signment of gold from the north brought down by the Northwestern, but too late to be classified with the October receipts. The coming of gold to the value of almost $1,000,000 from the newly found Iditarod and Squirrel river districts more than made up for the deficiency in the Fairbanks yield due to an excessively dry season and scarcity of labor following the rush to the Iditarod gold fields.

See moreSee less

Conserva tive mining men estimate this year's eutput of gold from Alaska at $16,- 000,000, which will bring the total yield of gold from the northland since its purchase by the United States from Russia up to |125,000,000 to »1M,000.600.

See the clipping

The Hawaiian Star · Honolulu Oahu

A newspaper feature on mountain climbing destinations compares peaks in Switzerland, the Andes, and the Himalayas to those in the American West, Alaska, and Hawaii. It mentions that the U.S. need not rely on 'Seward's Folly' (Alaska) for tall mountains, since Washington, California, Oregon, and Hawaii also offer impressive peaks for climbers.

The Hawaiian Star · 12 November 1910 · page 4

SOME MOUNTAINS HERE TOO. An exchange commenting on the report that an engineer . had dis- , i ii... i. :..i. !,.,,. Mmnil Mi.U'iiilnv vlifMi :i 1 1 1 covered a suuimu in viuhku mnui uum .uuuui ,........ .y, - tude is given as 20,404 feet, proceeds to discuss American resource r ,,.n..,.hiin i.iiinliimr ri'iueation. "It is not necesary," the pape Bays, "for the mountain climber who wants to hunt big orographic game to go to Switzerland, the Andes, the Caucasus or the Hima layas." It quotes a saying of Edward Whymper that there are in British Columbia "lifteen Switzerlands rolled into one," and speaks of the three big snow'-crowned volcanoes, of around 1S,0U0 feet in height, which Mexico possesses.

See moreSee less

Dwelling a little on the statement that most of the big mountains of the United States are in Alaska, the article proceeds to remark: Hut we need not traverse the magnificent distances of "Seward's Folly" to find mountains worthy of comparison

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A financial stocks column reports this year's Alaska gold yield at about $10,000,000, pushing total gold output since the U.S. purchased Alaska from Russia to roughly $128-129 million. It breaks down figures for Nome placer gold and auriferous vein mining, citing dredge installations for gains.

The San Francisco Call · 13 November 1910 · page 62

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Camas Prairie Chronicle · Cottonwood, Idaho

An editorial argues Alaska's natural resources and trade value exceed California's at statehood, pushing for Alaska to become the 49th state. It cites gold, copper, coal, and fish production figures alongside trade statistics with the U.S. to prove Alaska's worth.

Camas Prairie Chronicle · 25 November 1910 · page 7

The Forty-ninth Star. Nothing less than the dissolu*, tion of the nation, says Collier's Weekly, will prevent the organi zation of the State of Alaska. In 1850, when California was ad mitted into the Union, she had no lines of railway, telegraph, trades, or business connecting her with the other states, and was thought to be valuable only for placer gold. Her agriculture and trade, her railroads and present grandeur, have all grown since her admission. Alaska is a greater country and richer in all its natural re sources than California was in 1850.

See moreSee less

Alaska has more gold than California and Colorado; more copper than Montana and Ari zona; more coal than Pennsyl vania, West Virginia and Ohio; and more fish than all other American waters combined. Her output of gold and fish for last year amounted to nearly $32,000,000, and had increased from $15,000,000 in 1900. Her total cash trade with the rest of the United States for 1909 a mounted to more than $52,000, 000, while that between China and the United States amounted to only $48,000,000. She is a better customer of the merchants of the United States than Hawaii, Porto Rico, or the Philippines. The trade value of every white man, woman and child In Alaska with the United States for 1909 amounted to $1, 302.75, while that of every in habitant in Hawaii amounted to only $277.65, Porto Rico to $48.51, and the Philippines to $3.30. $3.30. Alaska has a better climate and greater agricultural capacity than Norway, Sweden and Fin land combined. Her rich and fertile valleys are capable of supporting a much larger popu lation than that of the three countries named, without men tioning the population which will be supported by her mines and other natural resources. Alaska is a great possession. Seward's Folly," as it was call ed after the secretary of state had bought it for $7,200,000, has become the pride of the United States. It is an empire in extent. Its coast line would girdle the globe. Its broad acres would cover all the states east of the Mississippi and north of Georgia and North Carolina. The Yukon is the Amazon of North America. The southern coast has an annual temperature equal to that of Kentucky. It is an empire in richness. Before long even our own coun try, with its supposedly inex haustible forests, will be com pelled to look to the vast wood lands of Alaska, where great pines, cedars, spruces and other valuable trees await the uses of men. Fur in great abundance and beauty is to be obtained from the denizens of the forests. The waters swarm with salmon. The seals are famous. The cod fish is a coming source of enor mous wealth. Coal, copper and marble are abundant, in addition to the gold that draws the throngs of miners. The first year's output of Cape Nome, that rich goldfield, was equal to the entire cost of Alaska, and more. All this wealth renders certain a large population in the distant to future.

See the clipping

Daily Independent · Elko, Nev.

This report revisits Seward's 1867 purchase of Alaska, arguing it was not merely repayment to Russia for Civil War-era friendship as commonly believed. It claims Seward's real goal was securing the entire Pacific coastline up to the Canadian border, anticipating future development comparable to the Atlantic coast.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 20 days earlier.

Daily Independent · 26 November 1910 · page 3

RESULT OF CENSUS ON PACIFIC COAST Recent statistics from the Pacific coast furnish a strong hint which pionts impressively to th e indup trial and agricultural develop ment of that part of the United States west of the Rocky mountains. William H. . Seward, when sec retary of state, bought Alaska from Russia for a little over $7,000,000. Tnat purchase was not madi to re pay Russia in money for the friendship she had shown to the United States at the time of the civil war, although it was the common impression at the time of the transfer of the property that this was Secretary Seward's sole reason.

See moreSee less

Instead, he desired for the Unted States the whole coast line from Lower CHlifornia, with which Mexico would not part, to the far north. He always believed that we made a mistake in the treaty with Great Britain by which we abandoned our claim to that part of the Pacific coast which British North America defines. Seward was certain that the devlopment of California north* ward to the Canadian line before many years had passed would be comparable to tne development *of the Atlantic coast. The recent figures from the census bureau from the comptroller of the curiency and from the

See the clipping