The article uses the ongoing Alaska boundary commission in London as an occasion to revisit the 1867 congressional debate over purchasing Alaska from Russia. It quotes Representative N.P. Banks defending the treaty by citing Russian naval support during the Civil War, and notes Benjamin Butler's later claim that the U.S. could have gotten Alaska free.
The Chicago Citizen · 3 October 1903 · page 4
BRITISH-CAN ADI AN CUPIDITY. The commission which is now sitting In Ismdou (why not in Washington?) to ascertain the correct meaning of the treaty by which Alaska was ceded by Russia to the United States makes a
This passage recalls Civil War-era congressmen who ridiculed the Alaska purchase as worthless, including quotes from Butler, Washburn, Price, Ferriss, and Loan dismissing the territory as a frozen wasteland. It also cites James G. Blaine's later account describing Alaska's vast size and strategic value, contrasting the skeptics' scorn with the territory's eventual importance.
The Chicago Citizen · 3 October 1903 · page 4
Alaska. He declared that at any time within twenty years we could have had Alaska for the a/'.king, and added: “ *No man. except one insane enough to buy the earthquakes in St. Thomas and the ice fields of Greenland, could be found to agree to any other terms for the acquisition of Alaska.’ “Mr. Washburn, of Wisconsin, in sisted that Greenland was a better ter ritory to purchase than Alaska, which, he said, was absolutely without value. “Hiram Price, Congressman from Iowa. said: ‘Alaska is a dead loss to us anyway, aud the more exj>ense we incur the worse It is for the country and the people.* “Orange Ferriss. Congressman from Xew York, declared: 'Alaska with the
Quoting a congressman's memoir, this piece touts Alaska's vast gold, fur, and fish output as vindication of the 1867 purchase price, dismissing contemporary mockery of Seward. It also recounts how Canada only disputed the Alaska-British Columbia boundary after gold was discovered, accusing them of opportunistic territorial greed.
The Chicago Citizen · 3 October 1903 · page 4
BRITISH-CANADIAN CUPIDITY
Total.\....$ 185.218.071 Some of these figures are only brought up to 1807, and it must be rememl>ered that the output of gold is Increasing at a rate of 40 i»er cent per flutimu; great deposits of copper have just b«*en discovered and the mines, so far as known, are practically inex haustible. fo a moderate man this look* like a very fair return for an expenditure of $7,200,000. While the discussion on the Alaska purchase was in progress neither En gland nor Canada dreamt of object ing to the frontier. In 1807 the I'nited j States published a map of Alaska is
Sheriff Quinn recounts his trip to Alaska, noting that Sitka had been the capital since Secretary Seward's purchase of the territory until the capital was recently moved to Juneau. The report also describes steamship companies' high fares for travelers to and from Nome, and mentions Butte men working placer claims in the region.
The Butte Inter Mountain · 5 October 1903 · page 8
OLD BUTTE MEN IN WILDS OF ALASKA
> car. Will Hurt the Town. "Sitka is a beautiful place, butt the re moval of the capital will take away its imlllprtance and leave it without busi iVcss," said Sheriff Quinn today. ()ine of the things that the man who visits Nome in the summer and travels there by the ocean route takes notice of is the way the steamship lines hand it to Iassengers in the way of charges for transportation," contiued the sheriff. "'hey charged us $5o to take us into Name(', but made us pay $too to come 'his custom of the transportation con palies, five of which have boats on the Nome line, is explained by the sheriff with Ite statement that thle comltpanlies know that there are tmn in the country that are thte.rmined to comne out in tile fall, and Ihey regularly raise the prices and stand together onl themt in order to get all they ;ia out of the outbountd mIliners.
A New York Sun correspondent argues Alaska has returned over $150,000,000 in furs, fish, and gold since its 1867 purchase for $7,200,000, more than 20 times the cost. The article details 1903 fiscal year figures showing Alaska's merchandise, gold, and fish exports far exceeded the original purchase price.
The Nome Nugget · 10 October 1903 · page 3
In the 36 years since its purchase we have sent merchandise to Alaska to the value of $100,000,000, on all of which we made a profit. Our merchandise to $10,000,000 yearly. The exact figures for 1903 fiscal year are #9,497,721. tn the same year Alaska sent us $10, 228.074 in merchandise and #4,719,579 in gold produced on American soil. ' In addition, Alaska acted as agent for transmission to the United Stales of $10,979,285 in gold produced in pres ent Canadian-British territory. Canned salmon to the value of more than $8,000,000, besides $750,000 worth of other fish, was sent us in 1903 fiscal year.
See moreSee less
That total value of #8,750,000 in fish would alone have covered the pur chase price of the territory, with a sur plus; and with the remaining #11,250,000 of merchandise shipments and the $4, 719,679 in gold. Alaska paid for itself more than twice over in 1903 alone. Of the #9,407,721 worth of merchan dise which we sent to Alaska in 1903 fiscal year fully #8,000,000 was of manu factured goods, directly benefiting our factories and wage earners. More than one-fourth of that #8,000,000 was for manufactures of iron and eteel, accord ing to the bureau of statistics, depart ment of commerce and labor. An item of special interest included in that one fourth was tin plate for salmon cans, of the value of #920,810, besides #420,31A of tin manufactures not so included. Provisions and breadstufTs foot up #1, 500,000. Musical instruments repre sent #10,400 and jewelry #24,504. These last two items show that Alaska is no longer to be looked upon as being out side of the bounds of civilization, par ticularly as we also sent #119,000 worth of paintings and statuary, books, maps and engravings, toys and perfumes. The rest of our shipments cover a wide
An October 1903 World's Work article is cited describing thousands of miles of railroad planned in Alaska, framing the territory as already prosperous and developed. It claims Nome has 25,000 inhabitants and cites decades of trade and revenue since the 1867 purchase as vindication of Seward's decision.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
Bismarck Daily Tribune · 13 October 1903 · page 2
THE WEEKLY TRIBUNE. Published every Friday eight pages, containing a summary of the news of the week -loeal and foreign—particular atten tion being paid to state news. Sent to any address, postage paid, for $1.00 for rue year 50 cents for six months Ho cents for three months. The Bismarck Tribune Is the oldest newspaper In the state—established June 11. 1873. It has a wide circulation and 1 a desirable advertising medium. Being published at the capital of the state It makes feature of state news, of a semi official character, aud Is therefore particu larly Interesting to all who desire to keep the run of state affairs—political, social and business.
See moreSee less
According to an article in the Worlds Work for October, there in Alaska and contiguous territory— all farther north than any now touched1 by any existing line—ten thousand miles of railroad "already under con struction or definitely projected a greater mileage than that of the Union Pacific, the Northern Pacific and the Erie systems combined." And the most marvelous thing about it is, not that these railways are to be built, but that they will in many instances find a country already "developed" and waiting for their coming. Nome, for instance, has today 25,000 inhabitants anu many important industries aside from gold mining. Portland, Ore., even so late as 1880. had only a little mor«? than 17,000 inhabitants, and had but moderate additions to the number when in 1883 the Northern Pacific was completed. When Nome shall wel come the railroad which is to connect it with Seattle and St. Paul, it will at the outset furnish an immense traffic. The products exported from Alaska and the adjoining Yukon territory in Canada, in the thirty-six years since Seward's purchase, are estimated at $.'175,000,000. The country now ab sorbs, mainly from the United States, $40,000,000 annually in manufactured goods and supplies. The United States revenues have amounted to enough, since ibe purchase, to pay th? pr^?o--i qUPnf.es he predicted, last May, that the men they see one of the greatest and mostj as large as does the entire Scandinav ian peninsula of Europe"—that is, of over 7.300,000.
All seven members of a municipal council in Pezzer, Hungary, secretly sold municipal forest land and split the proceeds among themselves. When the scheme was discovered, the councillors held a hurried meeting and killed themselves rather than face the consequences.
Bismarck Daily Tribune · 13 October 1903 · page 2
MUNICIPAL COUNCIL WIPED OUT
Alaska," and that Alaska "within thej^ay because they could not produce as large as does the entire Scandinav ian peninsula of Europe"—that is, of ing placed the requisite papers before the federal authorities. The police
This 1903 article recalls how in 1867-68 many congressmen denounced Seward's $7.2 million purchase of Alaska as a worthless, wasteful deal, quoting several who called the territory a frozen wasteland. It notes that decades later, the annual Alaskan salmon catch alone was worth more than the original purchase price, vindicating the decision.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 15 October 1903 · page 5
BAD BARGAIN, SO THOUGHT CONGRESSMEN OF PURCHASE OF ALASKA.
We Paid for the Territory. In 1867, when Secretary of State William H. Seward negotiated with Russia for the pur chase of Alaska, agreeing to pay 67,200,000 for the great territory, a majority of the peo ple regarded the transaction as a shameful waste of money. At any rate, they Insisted that the price agreed upon. 2 cents an acre, was altogether too high, says The Chicago Chronicle. General B. F. Butler of Massachusetts pro posed in Congress on July 7. 1868. to pay Russia the $7,200,000 for her friendship, and ask her to keep Alaska.
See moreSee less
He declared that at any time within twenty years we could have had .Alaska for the asking, and added: "No man, except one insane enough to buy the earthquakes in St. Thomas and the Icefields of Greenland, could be fohnd to agree to any other terms for the acquisition of Alaska.” Mr. Washburn of Wisconsin Insisted that Greenland was a better territory to pur chase than Alaska, which, he said, was abso lutely without value. Hiram Price. Congressman from Iowa, said:
The article quotes 1867-era congressmen who derided Alaska as worthless, inhospitable, and a waste of money. It then contrasts their predictions with decades of gold, fishery, and fur revenues far exceeding the $7.2 million purchase price, declaring Seward's policy vindicated.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 15 October 1903 · page 5
PURCHASE OF ALASKA.
lutely without value. Hiram Price. Congressman from Iowa, said: "Alaska Is a dead loss to us. anyway, and the more expense we incur the worse it is for the country and the people." Orange Ferrlss. Congressman from New York, declared: "Alaska, with the Aleutian islands, is an inhospitable, wretched and God-forsaken region, worth nothing, but a positive Injury and Incumbrance as a colony in the United States.” Benjamin F. I.oan of Missouri said: "The acquisition of this inhospitable waste would never add one dollar to the wealth of our country.” The Alaskan salmon catch of 1002 alone was worth $7,200,000.
See moreSee less
the price paid for the ter ritory. In five years the Alaskan mines have sent to Seattle alone $14,000 000 in gold dust and bullion, nearly twice the purchase price of the territory. In 1902 the total output of gold In Alaska was $18,870,075 and In 1901 It was $14, 675.675. or for two years. $33.545.000—more than four times the amount paid to Russia In 1867 Previous to 1897 we had taken $15,000,000 gold from Alaska—also more than twice the purchase price. From 1868 to 1897 the Alas kan fishery products brought us $08,000,000. The fur sale for twenty yearn after 1870 amounted to $33,000,000 The fur companies paid into the United States Treasury $7-460. 000. Thus one Item of cash In the treasury was more than the price paid for the terri tory. Meantime the gold mines are increasing their output annually at a rate of 40 per cent., the copper mines are being develojied. railways are being built and a naval station on the Aleutian islands bids fair to become a great commercial center. Alaska has paid for itself many times over. It is doing so now almost every year. It has more than justified the expectations of Mr Seward. Kow sagacious today appears hl» policy in comparison with the puny wisdom of anti-expansion Congressmen! In talking up the new town the Blllvllle agent said' An' the best of all Is—railroad's cornin’ our way, an’ w’ll have all sorts of improve ments soon as we git an opportunity to sue It fer damagM’"—Atlanta Constitution.
Senator Perkins describes his visit to the Alaska-Canada boundary commissioners in London, noting that documentary evidence confirms the existing boundary lines match those held by Russia before the Alaska purchase. He suggests the dispute would never have arisen were it not for the Klondike gold discovery, and expresses hope that Lord Alverstone will rule justly.
The San Francisco Call · 15 October 1903 · page 3
going on in England, AMEBICA'S ADVANTAGES. ff Our climate, our resources, give us a great advantage over other* countries. ¦ We do not realize what a Messed country we have here. It only takes a trip abroad to make one more In love with his home country. Why In France, the famed place for the raising' of grapes. I'll venture to say that their vines do not bear by one-tenth the amount of fruit that the vineyards of Fresno In this State produce, and I think that our wines are as good as any made there.
See moreSee less
While in London I visited the commission ers who were fixing the boundary dispute be tween Canada and the Unltii States. All of the documentary evidence shows that the pres ent existing lines are the same as those held by Russia prior to the purchase of Alaska by us. I do not believe, were It not for the dls- ( covery of -gold in the Klondike, that any dls- . pute would have ever arisen.- Our only hope is in Lord Alverstone. England's Chief Justice, who is on the commission, and who, I believe, is an able Jurist and an honorable man. With out him the commissioners would merely come to a tie vote. I think that he will look at It from a purely legal standpoint and his decision will be Just. • Senator Perkins was accompanied on his trip by his daughter Pansy, whom he left visiting relatives In Maine when he re turned to California. He will remain here about two weeks and then depart for the East to attend the next session of Con gress on November 9.
The report states that Alaska, purchased in 1867 for $7.2 million, has yielded $150,000,000 in fish and gold over thirty-six years, far exceeding its purchase price. It contrasts this profitable investment with the Philippines, where military costs allegedly exceed commercial returns and foreign ships carry most trade.
The Intermountain Catholic · 17 October 1903 · page 1
Western Watchman T I Alaska Vs Philippines In 1SG7 for the sum of 7200000 we purchased Alaska In fish and gold Alaska has yielded in the thirtysix years we have possessed it 150000 000 or about 50 per cent annually oil our invest ment During the same period we have sold for use in Alaska 100000000 worth of our products At the present rate we are selling 10000000 worth of our gooos to Alaska annually Our Alaskan exports and imports arc almost exclusively car ried by ships flying the American flag Tn the fiscal year just closed we have received in fish alone S7K000 from Alaska or more than the original purchase price of the territory I It is also interesting to note that the country produced during the las year 4710570 in gold and S250000 in other merchandise More than half the revenue of the country is produced by the fishing industry while the total value of all products in the last year amounted to more than twice the price we paid for Alaska in 1867 In the fiscal year of 19015 only onesixth of our commerce with the Philippines was carried in American ships All nations share in the com merce of the islands Our cost of maintaining an army and navy to maintain our power far ex ceeds the total commerce derived from the islands r and there is no immediate prospect of the ex pense being reduced Bloodshed tyranny and a very unenviable reputation has been our chief harvest in the Philippines Dries imperialism pay 1 Catholic Light Scranton 1
The report explains that the Alaska boundary tribunal mainly confirmed existing American claims rather than adding territory, with the U.S. conceding the Portland Canal as a compromise. It traces the dispute's origins to the 1825 Russo-British treaty, the 1867 purchase referencing that treaty, and the post-Klondike gold rush revival of boundary claims by Canada.
The Savannah Morning News · 20 October 1903 · page 4
Britain and Russia, made in 1825, in which treaty the boundaries of Alaska were set forth. When the United States purchased Alaska from Russia in 1867 reference was made in the deeds of cession to the boundary marks and measurements contained in the treaty of 1825. Thus all of the Alaskan terri tory recognized by Great Britan as Russian in 1825 became American terri tory by purchase in 1867. During the thirty-one years following the transfer of Alaska, up to the time of the dis
An international commission arbitrating the Alaska-Canada boundary dispute has ruled in favor of the United States, with British commissioner Lord Alverstone siding with the American representatives. The disputed strip of coastline, unimportant until the Klondike gold rush, determined control over key passes to the goldfields.
Yorkville Enquirer · 23 October 1903 · page 2
The territory in dispute was a narrow strip, about fifty miles wide, extending from the southernmost limit of Alaska proper at the 60th parallel of latitude down the coast of British Columbia to the 55th parallel of latitude. Although the strip has been in dispute ever since the purchase of Alaska from Russia, it