The article summarizes a published exchange between Frederick W. Seward (son of the Secretary of State who negotiated the Alaska purchase) and Canadian official C. T. O'Hara over the Alaska-Canada boundary dispute. It argues that Russia's 1825 treaty with Britain established an unbroken coastal strip that the U.S. purchased and still claims.
New-York Tribune · 3 December 1902 · page 8
TEE ALASEA BOUXDARY. Three noteworthy contributions te the Alaska boundary discussion have recently appeared in cur ~olnmps. These were a brief state ent of the American ease by Mr. Frederick W, Seward. a reply by Mr. ¥. C. T. O'Hara and a rejoinder by Mr. Sfewerd., These letters svere weighty with authority, for Mr. Seward, the son and official aid of the Secretary of Stste who megotiated the Alaska purchase, is # past master of the American side of the controversy, while Mr. O'Hara, as secretary to 2 Canadiag Cabinet officer.
See moreSee less
may be supposed 10 be an adeguate exponent of the Canadian side. Between the two our readers will doubt less have judgeé for themselves. That the de cision of the vast majority of Americans is on Mr. Seward’s side is beyond doubt, Hairsplitting over minor details aside, the great, fupdamerpta]l fact of the case is this, that Russia owned, undisputedly. according to Great Britain's formal] and deliberate agree ment in the treaty of 1823, an unbroken strip of Alaskan coast from Mount St. Elias down to the Portland Canal. That is what Russia owned. That is what the United States pur chased. That is what the United States claims and possesses, and expects to keep forever That strip of coast is nowhere more than ten sez leagues in width. At points it may be wuch less than that, The width does not so greatly matter. The essential fact is that it is a continuous and unbroken strip. It does not run down to one side of an arm “of the sez and siop, and begin again on the other side, but it goes without a break around every such arin of the sea, the houndary line being drawn, as the treaty says, mot only parallel ‘with the coast in its genersl outline, but paral lel with “the windings thereof.” But why not arbitrate? demand our Cana dian friends, with persistent iteration, Mr. Seward suggests more than one convincing re rly. It is not an arbitrable cade. Arbitration is permissible and commendable in, for ex. ample, such a case as that of Chili and Argen tina, which has just been determined, in which both disputants laid claim to a territory which was not In actual possession of either and the ownership of which bad pever been authorita. tively declared. But in the Alaska case the conditions are altogether different. The own.
This editorial argues that Russia's title to the Alaskan coastal strip, later purchased by the United States, was formally and continuously recognized by Great Britain since 1825, making the boundary non-arbitrable. It dismisses Canadian calls for arbitration as a late, gold-motivated challenge to long-settled ownership.
New-York Tribune · 3 December 1902 · page 8
THE ALASKA BOUNDARY
But this. in time, proves a reward fer setting up unfounded claims. The hungry community has oniv to claim evervthing in sight, then clamor for arbitration, and rest, reascnably secure at least of getting something. In such a ease. then. acceptance of arbitration may merely indicate a willingness to be robbed if the other side is urgent, rather than resist. There comes a time when large nations, like large men. resent heing ssked to step into that gallery. : In the Chaili-Argentina case the disputed ter ritory has been divided between the two claim ants.
See moreSee less
In the Alaska case, were it to be arbi trated. there could be nothing of the sort. The T'nited States is making no claim for acces sions of territerr at Canada’s expense, As Mr. Seward truly says, this country would have nothing to gain in such arbitration. while it “would have to lose outright everything that Canada might gain. We deo not say, of course, that a country should refuse to enter into arbi tration just because there was danger of its los ing something and gaining nothing. But the Alaska case was thrashed out and settled between Great Britain and Russia three-quarters of a century ago. There is no more excuse for reopening it now than there is for reopening the dispute about the Maine boundary or that about the Oregon houndary. Indeed. these latter might more properly, or less improperly. be reopened, since they are of more recent settlement. But what would our Can adian friends say if the United States should again raise the ery of “54-40 or fight”?
A Nome city attorney praises President Roosevelt's message to Congress as the first sign of legislative interest in Alaska, noting the territory's vast size and population rivaling two U.S. states despite having no formal territorial status since its 1867 purchase from Russia. He contrasts this neglect with Canada's more attractive inducements for settlers in its Northwest Territory.
Evening Star · 4 December 1902 · page 17
WHAT ALASKA WANTS IS A HOMESTEAD LAW THAT WILL ATTRACT SETTLERS
Northwest Territory. to "I am very much pleased with President Ow Roosevelt's reference to Alaska in his mes Its, sage to Congress," said V. T. Hoggett of or Nome today to a representative of The Star the at the Riggs. Mr. Hoggett Is city attorney ow of Nome, Alaska, and is a member of the ess committee appointed to promote the wel 'ys, fare of Alaska, consisting of Capt. J. J. to Healy of Eagle City, Yukon; Robert Blel, las Copper River valley, and A. J. McNear and vnG. M. Esterly of Valdez. It was this com to mitte6 that presented to President Roose nts veit the mammoth antlers which now adorn ver the White House dining room.
A spokesman identified as Mr. Hoggett argues to Congress that Alaska, despite its 'ice-box' reputation, is fertile and populous enough to deserve territorial status and better homestead laws. He compares Alaska's population and resources favorably to U.S. states and to Canada's more generous land offers for settlers.
Evening Star · 4 December 1902 · page 17
ATTRACT SETTLERS.
aind side the rilwa-patt jais=iunmmfO schb to bed and soon teli a.p I IMs ver the White House dining room. ore Population Equals That of Two States. 7as "The President's message to Congress," for said Mr. Hoggett, "is the first evidence of as the awaking interest in legislation for Alas id-; ka, which embraces an area equal to all of lng the United States east of the Mississippi Lek ina river. It is a great country. Her great ueriver, the Yukon, discharges into the Pa ion cific ocean one-third more water than the :rs, Mississippi river discharges into the Gulf to of Mexico.
See moreSee less
Alaska has a population of per 65,000 souls, yet since her purchase of Rus per sia in 1867 has not risen to the dignity of a :h; territory. The popul.ation is equal to the ge, combined population of the states of Ne to vada and Idaho, represented in Congress 4s, by f6ur United States senators and two lei' representatives. There is a prevalent be inlief that Alaska is a land of snow and ice. he When the purchase was under discussion p_ one member proposed to call the new pos d sessions 'Zero,' while another named it i. 'Seward's ice-box.' I have lived in the )i most northerly part of Alaska, on the shore of the Bering sea, and there is no more up suffering from the cold there than there is ter in any of the cities on the great lakes of the United States. The government reports ids show that at Sitka it does not get cold elenough to freeze ice sufficient for summer to use.
A speaker argues Alaska needs generous homestead laws like Oregon's to attract settlers, contrasting the meager 80-acre allowance with Canada's 640 acres. He cites testimonials about Alaska's fertile soil, favorable climate, and growing trade to support claims the territory could support 50,000 new settlers within a year.
Evening Star · 4 December 1902 · page 17
ATTRACT SETTLERS.
ir; Alaska, that the fertile lands may be occu Gc. pied and cultivated. We do not want any railroad subsidies, but we do want land on. laws which will encourage agriculture, ad, laws such as were given Oregon when that ?ts rich country was developed. The Canadian Led government offers inducements to the his American farmers, and thousands of them mare going to the British northwest to get the section of land, 640 acres, offered to nt, every man who will enter upon it and im tpprove it. The United States has not given 1,rf Alaska one law calculated to promote Im ng migration to that country, though the land ew is every bit as desirable for agricultural nd purposes as the British northwest.
See moreSee less
The on settler in Alaska under the present home St. stead laws is allowed only eighty. acres of tre land, whereas he can get 1W in the states, near a railroad, and 640 agres in Canada. No one will go to Alaska under these cont ditions. With laws such as Oregon had, I : ng predict that 50.000 persons will settle in ] dr. Alaska in the rich valleys of the Yukon, I 'he Tanana and Copper rivers within a year. , :he . Fertility of Alaska. led "Regarding the crops of these. valleys, grass grows as high as a man's head, and nt there are millions of acres of it. All the a hay wanted for winter use can be cured. Hogs can be raised and fattened at little r on cost. It is one of the best stock countries < ier I ever saw. There are 25,000 squar : miles j
A monograph from the Treasury Bureau of Statistics titled 'Commercial Alaska' states that Alaska, purchased from Russia for $7,200,000, has produced about $150,000,000 in furs, fish, and gold, roughly equally divided among the three. It also notes that U.S. capital investment in Alaska is probably around $25,000,000.
The Nome Nugget · 13 December 1902 · page 2
WHAT ALASKA HAS PRODUCED
NOME,· ALASKA. Fifa'tiMItKU U l!H>2. (Yank G. Kappe'.man is the onlv authorized collector in Nome for the Nom κ NrcuKT. The Nome Nugget hereby guarantees a circulation double \
A Treasury Bureau of Statistics monograph reports that Alaska, purchased for $7,200,000, has produced about $150,000,000 in furs, fish, and gold combined. It also notes rising population, merchandise shipments, and investment figures, concluding that despite this productivity Alaska remains neglected as 'the step-child of Uncle Sam.'
The Nome Nugget · 13 December 1902 · page 2
WHAT ALASKA HAS PRODUCED.
* · - I estimated 30,0()0 at the date of the purchase to 32,052 j in 1890, 63,592 in 1900 and an estimated 85,000 at the present time. The number of fur geais taken on the I'ribilof inlands i¥om 1S70 to 1901 is 2,187, 3i7, whose value ie estimated at $35,000,000, and the value of the seal and other furs taken·since the purchase of Alaska by Vhe United States i* estimated at about $50,000,000. The fur seal industry, which has declined in the past tew veare, was succeeded by the fishingindustry, Alaska now supplying about one half of the salmon : of the country.
See moreSee less
The value of the salmon pack last! year is estimated at about $7,000,000 and the total Vûiûe of the fish taken in Alaska since the purchase about $50;u00,000, while the value of gold »nd silver mined since the purchflic is also about $50,000,000. And still Alaska continues to be the step-child of
This informational piece corrects popular misconceptions about Alaska, emphasizing its vast size, rich natural resources, and valuable fisheries. It notes the territory's modest $7.2 million purchase price compared to the millions already earned from salmon packing and company royalties.
The Scranton Tribune · 23 December 1902 · page 11
INFORMATION ABOUT ALASKA
700 miles from Its mouth. With Its trib utaries 2,ti00 miles. It discharges one third more water than the Mississippi. Alaska has an area oC :iV"2!t,000 acres; 272,000,000 nuiTH lie within tho temper ate zone. In 1SG7 the Knltecl States go crnment paid far this area .$7,200,000. One Alaskan company alone has paid
The article argues against popular misconceptions that Alaska is a frozen wasteland, describing lush vegetation, successful crop cultivation, and vast untapped fishing resources. It cites economic figures showing the territory's value far exceeds the original $7.2 million purchase price through salmon packing and company royalties alone.
The Scranton Tribune · 23 December 1902 · page 11
NEGLECTED TERRITORY
of the Arctic circle, except on the coast of Bering Sea. Fine potntoes, cnuli llower, cabbage, p.ilp peas, lettuce and radishes have been grown nt the ex perimental stations at Sitka und Kenal. At Dawson the Chamber of Commerce rooms of that town display fine samples
The report describes Alaska's abundant agricultural, fishing, and mineral resources, claiming it could support millions of settlers and vast industries. It blames restrictive and costly land-title procedures for the territory's slow settlement, citing a congressman's view that Americans remain ignorant of Alaska's true potential.
The Scranton Tribune · 23 December 1902 · page 11
NEGLECTED TERRITORY.
development of agriculture -would re duce the cost of living, make labor more plentiful and give rise to better trans portation facilities. When the fishing Industry of Alaska is developed It will engage the labors of hundreds of thousands of people who must be fed In a large measure from the farms. The salmon Is as yet the only fish that has attracted attention. There nre thousands of square miles of cod banks: the enormous halibut grounds have not been touched, and tho myriad shoals of herring go by unheeded. An