As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

November 1902

8 articles

The Nome Nugget · Nome, Alaska

A reminiscing speaker recalls a long-circulating legend claiming the U.S. purchased Alaska decades after the Civil War as a disguised reimbursement to Russia for the cost of sending its fleet to American waters during a crisis. He describes how the deal allegedly passed the Senate quietly but required Grant to address the House in a rare secret session to overcome opposition before it passed Alaska's purchase unanimously.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Nome Nugget · 5 November 1902 · page 3

of a Fleet, During the Mason· Slideil Incident. The following letter from I'. J. Cos top, the well-known Nome attorney, appeared in the New York Sun ol <-ct. 5, last. It is of such interest to Alas kans that THE Ncuiàkt republishes tl.e full text, as well us a letter from a for mer frieml of Mr. Costop, throwing some additional liyht upon the subject. The letter follows: "To the editor of the Sun: There nrevails a leueud in relation to tinnur ckiii>e of what is now known as the dis trict of Alaska from liussia b.v the United States which it seems to me might be cither disputed or verilieti, and 1 know of no belter way for either the one or the other than to refer it to The Sun, which shines for all regard less of latitude or longitude.

See moreSee less

To make the legend intelligible a few historical facts must he related; and by preface 1 will say that before 1 came to Alaska, early in 1000, 1 heard the whole matter related in Washington, the national capital. "The capture of Mason and Slidell is an historical fact: the demand of the English government for their immedi ate release is also an historical fact, it is said that at the time of this de mand, whether by accident or design i-· not stated, there was off Capes Charles and Henry a ltussian Meet ol seven war vessels, 1 think, and, as soonasihe commander of this alleged Heet heard the news of the demand of ι hi· English government, he caused word it) be sent to President Lincoln that the Meet was at his disposal for the purpose of enabling· him to resist the aforesaid de mand. The student of history knows that it never became necessary to use force in resisting this demand, for the reason that Lincoln took the matter in his own hands, and if 1 remember right, against the wish of a majority of his cabinet, released Mason and Slidell, thus closing that incident, to use a dip lomatic term. "Now, the legend is that some time «àner iiifse îuiiucuih, uiiu aiLtr uru. Grant became president, it was deter mined to reward Russia for her timely aid, or, rather, her good offices, «it that perilous time, and to do so it was con cluded in diplomatic circles to reim burse her for the expenses she would naturally have incurred in having and maintaining the fleet in close proximity te American waters. But it was deter mined that it would not. be the correct thing, from a diplomatic point of view, for congress to make a direct appropri ation for that purpose, for the reason that it might appear that she was an especially favored nation, which in it self might make diplomatic complica tions that, from policy, if for no stronger reason, should be avoided. So, in dip lomatic circles, it was found necessary to make some shift, and the one resort ed to was for Russia to otter to sell Alaska to the United States for the same price that would have reimbursed her for the cost of maintaining; the fleet. "That is the legend, and it goes on that so far as the senate ( which we all know has a secret session) was con cerned, this was an easy matter, as the whole scheme could there be explained and no record weuld be made of it, or any publicity given to it (always bar ring leakages); and, actually, the mat ter went through that body without any trouble. But when it got to the house, where it was open for ] ub'.ic dis cussion, it was siiown very soon that there would be an overwhelming ma· iority against passing the senate meas ure; and the majority was so pronounced and emphatic that President Grant, was ^induced to request the house to go intc secret, or executive session, for the pur· poee of receiving a communication froir the pr< sident. The legend goes on thai this was the first and only time thai euch a request had ever been made a president of the United .States to thai body; that it was agreed that the re .quest should be granted, and the house accordingly did go into executive ses sion, the president laid the whole mat ter before that body and the measur* was pa-sed· without a dissenting voice Hence our purchase of Alaska. •'Now, 1 can understand that possibly this might have been i.orie; that is thai euoh admeasure might have i>een pui t rough t'ae House in the way alleged Iran understand how, from a diplo

See the clipping

The Nome Nugget · Nome, Alaska

A correspondent recounts the oft-told legend that President Grant called a secret executive session of the House to push through the Alaska purchase treaty, framing it as diplomatic maneuvering to avoid provoking Russia. He asks the newspaper to verify whether this romantic tale has any factual basis, noting it is repeatedly used in oratory about Alaska.

The Nome Nugget · 5 November 1902 · page 3

inatic point of view, it was not good policy in make the direct κior to Uus,ja, and how, to avoid such ii measure, Iliiosia would connut to sel us Alaska for tin' price of her expense on t|jut Heel: and, also the.further fact, ' that if suelvv.as the reason and methot ; of purchase, why it wit* ::ot made pub ! lie. ''It,this story lias any foundation ir fact, it is the most, romantic piece o: diploma! :e jugglery of which I remem her lo have heard and us there ar< some point λ in it which, il true, coulc he verified, can The Sun or any of it> eorres|>ondenis enlighten us a little ot the subject?

See moreSee less

Kver.v time a fellow get up to respond to the toast of Alaska ir ! this, region we have this .legend de·

See the clipping

The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.

Judge James Wickersham of the U.S. District Court of Alaska spoke to the Seattle Chamber of Commerce about Alaska's vast resources, citing over $200 million in gold shipped mostly to Seattle in four years and praising the territory's fisheries. He also discussed Alaska's legal system, defending the license law as not excessive and advocating that government revenue collected in Alaska be spent there.

The Seattle Star · 6 November 1902 · page 2

ITS AFFAIRS _ c The Prattle amber of Commerce at It* regular meeting yesterday af ternoon heard an interesting and In* strut.lll o address on Alaska, deity. ered by Judg* James Wlekersiißm, of Hie United .-Halts distil. court of Alaska. Jii.ltlt vVlckeraharu Introduced his remark* by a compliment to Beat lie on Hie Interest this illy lose taken In iliv welfare ot Alaska. 11* then told at Hie st. area and the *normou* undeveloped resources ut lb* terri tory In tit* fur mirth. ll* delate! that, lb* llsheile* alone justified the purchase of Alaska, but stated thai that Indus, liv was Just a part of what the dls. trict had to boast of. He cstlnuiie.l that Cei..ie>ei'**> IB gold had been .lug from th* earth In Alaska and ship

See the clipping

The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.

Judge Wickersham spoke on Alaska's existing laws, defending the license fee system as not excessive compared to state taxes. He also discussed gold mining revenue shipped mostly to Seattle and urged that government funds collected in Alaska be spent within the territory.

The Seattle Star · 6 November 1902 · page 2

ITS AFFAIRS

state I eve* were collected. However. be was In favor of th* paaaag* of an act making It obliga tory on th* government ta spend all the money collect, -> in Alaska with. In the bounds ot thst territory. Judge Wlrke—the—l ce*etc!u-I*.l by

See the clipping

Times-Promoter · Hernando, Miss.

The report states that Alaska has produced $18,000,000 in gold output this season, calling it clear proof of the wisdom of William H. Seward's decision to purchase the territory. It frames the mineral wealth as vindication of a purchase once ridiculed.

Times-Promoter · 14 November 1902 · page 2

HERNANDO. : : MISSISSIPPI. Alaska shows up this season with a gold output of $18,000,000. Certainly a very clear exemplification of the .wisdom of William II. Seward in the

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Alaskan · Skagway, Alaska

The Seattle Daily Times editorial argues Alaska deserves congressional representation, citing its large population, land area, and immense gold production since the 1867 purchase. It claims Alaska has already returned over 400% on the $7.2 million the U.S. paid, with much greater mineral wealth expected in years to come.

The Daily Morning Alaskan · 23 November 1902 · page 2

Say. Hip Seatt'e Dully Times of recent date cont lined (he following editorial which It gave a two column spacr : ?'That Alaska h->s pnveo herself worth v of recognition bv the general government cannot be denied. A nation which would admit Nevada into the sisterhood cf states omrht not t > hesitate about tfl vlrg Alaska congressional representation. ' Nevad.t has been a atate since 11(64 and today has a puliation if 42,ooo-about the sl;e of Spokane. "Alask t has a population of 75,^0 ?. "Al iska has a territorial are 1 of j <2,000 square miles.

See moreSee less

"Ther-fore when judged from the otand polnt of populatl m and area, Alank 1 Is at least entitled to a terrltorl >1 government. "While the people of Alaska know this t<> be true, thev do not ask tor territorial government now. "On the contrary, they ask for delegate representation in the congress In order that their requirements may be properly pre sented in that body. "Alask 1 has pr >ven to be a most profit able acqulstlon to the nition. "Since her purchase In 1867?15 vears ago? Alaska has produced *J'V)OO.OOJ ol gold "As Uncle Sim paid only #7.150.001 for the whole business, he his received In re turn 4 >0 per cent, on his Investment. "But whit Alaska has yielded It the last years. Is a bagatelle In comparison with what she will yield in the next 15. "Even Cape Nome his produced *10, ? ho, coo in three years? and It will take 2s vears to begin to exnaust her gold nepos n> "But when 5foo.ooo.ooo In gold shall h ivr been tiicen out of A'askj that country will hive produced double that sum In copper anj other ores. "To put it broadlv, ill the territorial possessions of Unci* Sam. scattered throughout the nation and throughout the oceans, are partlcallv Insltinificant In value when compared to Alaska alone! "Now the Inhabitants ot this vast ter ritory? hardv, Intelligent, brave and ro bust? simply a-k recognition at the hands or Congress bv permitting deleg ite r? prt sentation therein. "Ex-Colle."tor J. W. Ivev h s been authorized bv the ere it body of Alask ms to represent them at the N itlonal Oipitil, "His chltf mission Is to obtain delegate representation at this session of congr-ess which opens the first Monday of Decem ber. "It Is the duty of every member of con gress from the Pacific Northwest? whether senator or representative? to help J. W. Ivev to gut what he his gone after!"

See the clipping

Ottumwa Semi-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa

The article reviews historical U.S. territorial purchases and their costs per acre, noting Alaska was bought for about 1.19 cents an acre. It reflects on how Seward's much-mocked purchase has since been vindicated as valuable to the nation.

Ottumwa Semi-Weekly Courier · 25 November 1902 · page 10

The Star of the Empire. "Mr. Seward said that his reputation in history would mainly rest on this act of statesmanship aud for many years his expected honor remained in cold storage in that inhospitable land. But time has vindicated the wisdom of Mr. Seward and Alaska is no longer the least prized or our possessions,

See the clipping

The Baltimore County Union · Towsontown, Md.

The report recalls that Seward's 1867 purchase of Alaska was mocked at the time, but credits his foresight now that Alaska pays for itself twice over yearly through gold, minerals, lumber and fish. It also notes experimental successes growing cabbages, garden vegetables, and food grains, proving the territory's agricultural potential.

The Baltimore County Union · 29 November 1902 · page 2

When William H. Seward closed his po litical career as Secretary of State by purchas ing Alaska from Russia, some laughed, some were amazed and the opposition derided. But Seward had one essential quality of a great statesman-imagination. He could see ahead and estimate correctly. Now we find Alaska paying for herself twice over every year in gold and other minerals, in lumber and fish. More than this, we are gradually learning the agri cultural possibilities of Alaska through the

See the clipping