As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

October 1900

8 articles

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

The report quotes a speaker arguing that Alaska, once dismissed as a frozen, unmanageable 'terra incognita,' is now peacefully governed with military posts and American settlers pouring in. He uses this vindication of the Alaska purchase to argue the Philippines, despite insurrection, can likewise be governed by the United States.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 14 October 1900 · page 6

burn. jya* on atomarh and bowels and every form of atumach derangement. fW ocean Intervene*; they He almost on the #hores of Asfa; It Is a far-off colony and difficult for the United States to manage But it Is not ho far off or so difficult to reach, nor is It so difficult to handle, as Alaska waa at the time of the Alaska purchase. Alaska waa then supposed to be almost a terra in cognita. It waa a froten land, fit only to he inhabited hy the Kuaa and )u rider.

See moreSee less

We. at this irate way, have felt the beneficent influence of that pur chase and the whole country felt it a few >*ara ago. We have now our mili tary poets up there, and hold that coun try In subjection. American cltisens are pouring in there. No man can say but that, after a little v.lille, unother star will flnd its way Into our flag the North Star come to huddle with the Pleiades. Th«r« i t «"• anv reason for saying the United States wa* Improperly exer cising dominion when it took Alaska un der the nag. Y»»t Alaska does not adJoin the United States. There ara I.OAO

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

A 1900 speaker defends U.S. policy in the Philippines by analogy to Alaska, noting that Seward's purchase was once mocked as 'Seward's Folly' but is now universally acknowledged as wise policy. The speech also veers into a racialized argument about civilization, religion, and the destiny of the white race.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 14 October 1900 · page 6

now acknowledged In taking possesion ' Ala«ka although it was at that time cursed and denominated Seward s folly * A Dlreet Otft. "In the verv beginning of every race. It «ems natural In » w way that they

See the clipping

The Honolulu Republican · Honolulu, T.H.

This item uses the legacy of Secretary of State William H. Seward, alongside Sumner and Reverdy Johnson, to argue for the constitutionality of acquiring new territories, contrasting them with Daniel Webster's opposition to expansion. It draws a polemical parallel between Webster's narrow views and William Jennings Bryan, framing Seward as a visionary statesman of territorial growth.

The Honolulu Republican · 20 October 1900 · page 2

WEBSTER AND SEWARD. Great is laid on a spcb of Daniel Webster, by the friend of tbe lrarnd jurist of Usiraii wbo thinks of the Sapneae Court of Hawaii are. more to be regarded a in a constirstional iu tka affecting tb rights of dtiiens of tb I'nitrd Statrs. than decisions of Unitl States rourts. in which the Mawscbu setts Senafor bcid that tht conctitntioa did not extend over newly acquired territorial of tb United States. It I well in thi connection to conidVr on the other hand the opinion and views of soch eminent men as William IL Seward,

See the clipping

The Honolulu Republican · Honolulu, T.H.

A newspaper column looks back on William H. Seward's career, crediting him with skillful handling of the Trent Affair and the purchase of Alaska, and praising his broader vision of American expansion including failed efforts to annex Santo Domingo and the Danish West Indies. The piece contrasts Seward's optimistic expansionism with Webster's caution, using this as commentary on contemporary debates over American expansion.

The Honolulu Republican · 20 October 1900 · page 2

WEBSTER AND SEWARD

William II. Seward was a master mind, broad in all thing3. The leading candidate for the nomination for the Presidency when the republican convention at Chicago in 1SG0 he was finally defeated for the nomination by Abraham Lincoln. Seward accepted the situation like the broad minded citizen that he was nnd labored earnestly for Lincoln's election, later accepting tho chief position in Lincoln's cabinet, in which position he added lustre to his fanio as n statesman uud diplomat. What n contrast between the actios ol Seward when Lincoln was nominated and the sulking of Daniel Webster when Taylor was nominated in 1S48.

See moreSee less

Much has been said in the Iat.t year about the administration of William McKinley and the masterful diplomacy of his administration which has made tho United States n world power. Following the weak and vacillating foreign policv of scxeral proceeding administrations the vigorous policy of the McKinley administration has stood out ns the only one of far-reaching effect in the affairs o the world. But it is well to remember that the administration of Abraham Lincoln with William H. Seward as the Secretary of State had a mosf well flfinccl diplomatic policy and Europe vas mado to fee that the United States won to l reckoned with even if we did havo a "fight in our own houee." At the time of the Mason and Slidel affair England did "a good deal of blustering over the action of Captain Wilkes in searching the Trent and taking off the Confederate commissioners, but Mr. Seward came back and spiked the English guns with their own weapons. H con ceded the fact that Captain Wilkes had exceeded his authority and disavowed his acts on tlw part of the United States. Then he went further and placed Lord Palmerston in a hole from which tho English have never been able to crawl out. Mr. Seward declared that the United States had maintained for seventy-five years that the right of search on the high seas did not exist. He pointed out to the English minister that the war of 1S12 between England and the United States was over this very question, England maintaining that she had the right of search. And more, Mr. Seward drove the nail home and made Lord Palmerstoii, great a diplomat as he was, "acknowledge that Mr. Seward's contention was right. It was William H. Seward who" nted and carried through the Senate' the treaty for the purchase of Russian America now known as Alaska. It was Mr. Seward who negotiated the treaty with Denmark for the cession of St. Thomas nnd St. Croix, the uanish Isles of the West Indies, and which treaty was defeated in the Senate by that other Massachusetts Senator, Charles Sumner, of Sumner's bitter hatred of and animosity against President Johnson. Seward believed in the futuie destiny of

See the clipping

The News & Observer · Raleigh, N.C. · and 1 other paper

A political speaker attacks McKinley-era imperialism in the Philippines and Puerto Rico, contrasting it with earlier legitimate territorial growth like Jefferson's Louisiana Purchase and Seward's Alaska Purchase. The speech argues that true expansion should be economic (via a Nicaragua Canal) rather than colonial conquest of distant peoples.

The News & Observer · 21 October 1900 · page 11

gether and assert the sovereignty of the people in the management of public af fairs by hurling McKinley and Mark Han na's henchmen and satellites from power, this Republic is doomed for destruction. But the McKinleyites seek to cover up their sinister designs with the cry of Expansion! Expansion!! And they will ask me and you. ain't you in favor of “Expansion?” I answer yes, if it is ex pansion such as Mr Jefferson secured by the Louisiana purchase, and Mr. Seward secured by the purchase of Alaska; but

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Farmer and Mechanic · Raleigh, N.C. · 23 October 1900

Oxford Democrat · Paris, Me.

A political essay published in 1900 defends American territorial expansion against charges of "Imperialism," listing historical precedents including the Louisiana Purchase, Florida, the Gadsden Purchase, and the Alaska purchase negotiated by Andrew Johnson and William Seward. The author argues that if acquiring new territory constitutes imperialism, then the nation's entire history, including its founding, must be labeled imperialist.

Oxford Democrat · 23 October 1900 · page 2

Srcbase constitute "Imperialism* Τ «η write that word across the fame lof Thomas Jefferson, for it was he who m President of the United Statea pur chaaed I/>uUUna. Under Um Demo cratlc admlnUtratton of Monroe this republic purchased Florida In 1819. Under the Democratic admlnUtratton of Franklin Pierce we In 18M secured what U now the southern portion of Arizona by what U known as the G^daden per chase. Andrew Johnson and William H. Seward negotiated the purchase of Alaska. I· It "Imperialism" for the I nlted States to acquire territory and sov erelgnty by force of arm·, by conoueet?

See moreSee less

If It la, then our forefathers were Impe rialUts when they wrested the territory of the eolootes from KngUnd by a war and established sovereignty thereover. Did the conqueet of thU KnglUh terri tory arrest the progress of civilisation and destroy the liberty of mankind? ThU republic bad a Democratic ad mlnUtratton In 1846. James K. Polk was president and Jamee Buchanan sec retary of state. Under that administra tion, the armies of the United StatesIn vaded and conquered CallfornU and New Mexico. The conquest was effected un der a Democratic administration, and the territory was Incorporated Into the

See the clipping

Oxford Democrat · Paris, Me.

A pro-McKlinley editorial defends U.S. acquisition of the Philippines by comparing it to earlier territorial acquisitions, including the Louisiana Purchase, Florida, and Alaska, none of which required consent from inhabitants. It argues that opposing the Philippines annexation on anti-imperialist grounds is inconsistent with America's history of territorial expansion.

Oxford Democrat · 23 October 1900 · page 2

United States. After the United State· bad completed the oonquest of New Mexico and Call· fornla, and Inatltated a civil government thereto, the inhabitant· rote In lneur rectlon and exerted tbemselvee to the aUnoat endeavor to compel the United State· to withdraw therefrom. Did anybody think It neoessary to w care permluion from the Inhabitant· of Alaska before purchasing that coantry from Russia?

See the clipping

Red Lodge Picket · Red Lodge, Mont. · and 2 other papers

A political speech supporting McKinley's re-election cites Seward's purchase of Alaska as a precedent for American expansionism. The speaker claims the $7,200,000 price included $200,000 paid to Britain for coal consumed by their fleet during the Trent Affair.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

Red Lodge Picket · 26 October 1900 · page 8

Examine Our Prices on Alls has marked wonders. the country wvest of the Mississippi was only fit for the home df the cactus and the jack rabbit will make little over this new propositiop. But, my friends, within the last three years every bushel of surplus wheat in Cali fornia, in Oregon, in Montana, has been going west instead of east. Going where? Going into the hungry mouths of the mighty hordes of the Orient. And if every acre of irrigable land were cultivated to its utmost, if every drop of water that runs waste were stored and utilized during the irriga tion season, you would still be unable to produce a bushel tor the acre of wheat in all the country for every family in the Orient that may become our customers.

See moreSee less

As my friend, Colonel Guild of Massachusetts, says, they have quit eating bird's nest soup over there and are getting after our flour. They are getting after our canned beef; they are using our cotton. Let me state to you a fact that the transportation men here assembled will verify. Cotton has been going at better prices for the last few years. Why? Be cause the cotton of Texas and Louisiana and Mississippi is being shipped to China and Japan instead of the overflooded market of England. This is the material side of this proposition. but let no ma , howsoever enthusiastic in behalf of civilization and the Christian religioi , underesti mate the value of the commercial world as a civilizing forced. Now, my friends, why have these things come about? We need something in addi tlon to what we have in order to gather in the full fruit of this harvest. We need more ships upon the ocean and these ships must fly the American flag (applause) and the republican party stands for American shipping. (Applause.) We want your state, Colonel Guild, toparticipate in this com mercial feast also and therefore we want the Nicaragua canal built and the republican party believes in that. (Applause.) American Rights Upheld. More important than ships and canals, we want it understood that wherever an American merchant makes a contract, wherever an American shipowner enters into an agreement, that agreenment will beE carried out, whether it be with Chinese or Japanese or Koreans or any other peoples of the earth. One of the difficulties heretofore encountered by our American merchants abroad has been that more or less contempt existed in so far as our government was concerned. Everywhere, let us admit it, let us blush with each other in shame--times without number all around this globe American sailors, American merchants and American travelers have been compelled to pass by the American consul and go to a British, a German, a Russian or a French consul to get ordinary justice in the courts. You can not deny that under the administration of President McKinley the word of the American consul is received with the same prompt consideration and profound respect as is shown the consuls of any other country. (Applause.) What Expansion Means. But people will say that there is expansion and imperialism. My dear friends, let me say to you that in my humble judgment, the victorious, en terprising, conquering spirit of the American people cannot le confined to a reservation. You cannot make Chinamen or a band of Indi ns out of the average American. (Applause.) We will not stop upon the shore of any sea, but we will insist that the young, aggressive, progressive, intelligent, industrious American boy shall have as good a chance anywhere on this earth as is afforded to anyone else. That is all that expansion means. If you want to herd the people into a reservation, if you want to stand shak ing upon the western shore and say, "We have gone far enough; we may get hurt if we go farther," all you have to do is to throw your vote away and leave for the next generation the work from which you shrink, because some generation will do it. We may be subject to censure and blame by the men who do the work. Let us do the work ourselves. (Applause.) During McKinley's administration we have gone far to supplement what William H. Seward did. Seward got hold of Alaska, bought it for 87,200,000. The $200.000 was added to the purchase price for the purpose of paying for coal that had been consumed by the British fleet in coming over into New York harbor at the time when the British were about to at tack us when Mason and Slidell were seized. The purchase price was $7, 000,000. That carried with it Alaska and the Aleutian islands. The Hawaiian islands take in the center of the Pacific; the Philippine islands the southwest. Thus, we have within a single administration secured physical control of the Pacific ocean. If we re-elect McKinley, as we will, the close of the next administration will witness the complete commercial conquest of the Pacific and I propose three cheers for McKinley, Roosevelt and prosperity. (Great applause.) after March 30, 1901. Best sheep and A WOMAN TO BE PRETTY and cattle ranch in Montana; frame

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Dupuyer Acantha · Dupuyer, Mont. · 18 October 1900
  • The Neihart Herald · Neihart, Mont. · 3 November 1900