As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

September 1900

4 articles

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A partisan editorial from 1900 invokes Seward's purchase of Alaska as evidence of his foresight, claiming he foretold the Pacific Coast's splendid destiny. It uses this historical reference, along with praise of Sumner and Lincoln, to attack Democratic rival Bryan and the party's record.

The San Francisco Call · 6 September 1900 · page 4

of It! Democracy praises Lincoln and seeks to claim him as its own! Mayba they will yet indorse the emancipa tion proclamation. Maybe they will yet praise Seward,;to whom. California is largely indebted for admission into the Union ajid to whom we her children are gTateful for leauingr her into the Union fifty year* ago. "clad in the gorgeou? robes of freedom"; Seward. whoso brought about the purchase of Alaska and foretold the ppiendld destiny of the Pacific Coo st.

See the clipping

Amador Ledger · Jackson, Calif.

This 1900 article looks back at how Alaska came to be purchased from Russia in 1867 for $7,250,000, explaining it arose from fishing-rights negotiations rather than any national necessity or popular demand. It notes the purchase proceeded without consulting Alaska's 60,000 residents, though a treaty clause promised American citizenship rights to white inhabitants.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 44 days earlier.

Amador Ledger · 21 September 1900 · page 4

EXPANDED AMERICA. No. 6. The Purchase of Alaska and the Annex - r ation of Hawaii, Tntuila . .:■ and Guam." Alaska belonged to Russia by right of discovery and occupation. Our navi gators had made discoveries up that way, and there was some question as to whero our claims ended and Russia's began, which was settled by the treaty of. 1524, fixing the southern limit of Russian America at 64 deg. 40 coin. Alaska was not regarded as good for much of anything save furs' and fishes, but the treaty with Russia did not ac cord as good fishing privileges to Ameri can fishermen as the Pacific coast states thought their interests demanded, and petitions ' went to Congress from the northwest to have a more liberal treaty madu with Russia.

See moreSee less

In making over tures to Russia for an extension of fish ing privileges to the Alaskan banks it was found that the whole of Alaska might readily be bought, and it -was bought March 29, 1867. for $7,250,000. ". There was no supreme national neces sity for the buying of Alaska. There was no. clamor by American residents for. the annexation of Alaska. It was never intended that Alaska should be admitted into the Union as a state. It was . not annexed in order that there might be an extension either of slavery or of American liberty. It was simply in the market, the price was cheap enough, there were advantages enough in sight to make it worth the money, and we bought it. The consent of the 60,000 people living in Alaska was not asked for or offered.. There was a stipulation in the treaty of annexation that the white people in Alaska should have the rights of Ameri can citizens, but, as in all other cases, those rights were guaranteed by treaty stipulation and not by mere operation of the constitution.' The constitutional right to purchase was 'held to have been - established by unbroken precedent from Jefferson down.-.; :-.:■., has been anticipated from the first that Alaska would always remain a ter ritory and never become a state, and yet theConstitution has not fallen apart and free government has not perished. * * • The story of Hawaii is briefly told. American missionaries established them selves in the islands and taught the native people as much of the ways of civilization as possible. American and European capital became interested in productive enterprise, bringing prosper ity to the islands. The native govern ment did not properly safeguard the industrial interests. The representatives of the industrial interests brought the native government more and more un der their influence untilthey finally absorbed it and discarded its monarchi cal features and established a republic. The young republic sought annexation with the great republic and is now a part of it .. Congress set up a territorial govern ment * for ' Hawaii and " extended the American Constitution to tho 'islands by special enactment. By that act the citizens of Hawaii are made. citizens of the United States. . They are as free as the people of California and . as" well governed. No wrong has been inflicted upon them by annexation, but their condition has been bettered, and, thanks to a progressive Republican policy, the United States now holds the key to the trade of the Pacific. . We Americanized Hawaii and annexed it because we wanted it. It was a great national necessity that afforded the jus tification and the constitutional war rant, just as in the cases of the annexa tion of Louisiana under Jefferson and of Florida under Monroe. * * * Tutuila is one of the Sanioan group of islands in" the south seas. For many years there has been a great deal of trade in the South Sea islands, and as the Sanioan group early became impor tant for. traffic, English, German and American traders soon came into sharp competition there. The respective gov ernments above mentioned established consulates there, and oat of the mutual ity of association and of commercial in terest there arose in 1890 a tripartite agreement for the government of the islands. This tripartite agreement was not ad hered to in good faith by Germany, and friction between the powers and inter necine strife among the natives resulted. It seemed better, therefore, to dissolve the agreement and take the islands in severalty. . This has recently been done, the United States taking the Tntuila group (which,' however, had been ceded to the United States by the natives in 1878),' Germany taking the rest of the islands, and Great Britain retiring from them altogether. * • • Guam is an island in the Ladrone group directly in the track of our trans pacific commerce, and it came to us as a result of the war. with Spain. It will make jui excellent and needed harbor of refuge and naval and cable station. According to the Bryan moral philos ophy the acquisition of Hawaii, Tutuila and Guam were instances of criminal ag gression, but prudent people will see in such a*oquisitions instances of wise fore thought and common-sense action on the part ofa common-sense adminis tration. . . ■; We acquired these insular possessions because - they are important strategic points to enable us to extend our com jnerce'aud furnish needful refuges in lime' of war for our commercial and naval marine. Hawaii is at the focus of transPacific commerce. Guam has a fine harbor and will make a splendid naval or coaling station. Tutuila con tains the splendid, harbor of PangoPango, the only perfectly safe and land locked harbor in the Samoan group if not in the south seas. . " ■. There are several thousand inhabitants on these inlands whose consent to their acquisition by the United States was not asked nor ascertained by any vote of the people living on them. Our govern ment wisely concluded that the com mercial and naval interests of 75 to 80 million's of people could not be made subject to the preferences of a few thou pand half-clothed inlanders who do not known -what is for their own good. Fjor this policy there is, as we hare tedn, a century of unvarying Jeffer eonian and Democratic precedent - to warrant it. • • • • It is within the bounds of possibility, though not of probability, that Hawaii may some time become a state in the American Union, but Tutuila and Guam piver can be. Yet nothing but good will ever result to. the islanders by rea son of their . acquisition by the United States, and nothing but good will ever result by • that event to the • United States. .The islanders will be wards of the Great Republic which will not be will be very useful" adjuncts to an ex panding American commerce. A man -of --war out of coal is as helpless as a ferry-boat stranded on a sandbar, and it may be taken as a fixed principle of Republican polity to provide inde pendent and convenient naval and coal ing stations wherever on j this round hearing. ■ world such stations can be had and are likely to advantage our commerce, in dustry and naval power and efficiency. The Bryan platform professes itself " unalterably opposed to the seizing or purchasing of distant islands to be gov erned outsidethe Constitution, and whose people can never become citizens, " no matter how necessary such islands may be to our national welfare. Which party commends itself the more strongly as being patriotic and of a common sense character? The answer will be received at the ballot-box in November. the trustees. EXPANDED AMERICA.

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Alaskan · Skagway, Alaska

A news brief notes the season's first snow at Skagway, mockingly referencing Alaska's nickname as 'Seward's ice box,' and touts record cannery output worth $60,000 in federal taxes as evidence Alaska can support territorial government. The item frames Alaska's economic growth as answering old jokes about the purchase.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 39 days earlier.

The Daily Morning Alaskan · 23 September 1900 · page 2

THE SALOON PROTEST. The law which provides that there shill be no saloon license issued for a business within 400 feet of a church or a school should be repealed, or the churches and the schools removed from the business center of the city A well known Skagwav pas tor truly said the question of prohibition does not enter into the case. If the churches are to place Iheir buildings on the main thoroughfares of the dtv they must expect to conduct their worship within less than four hundred feet of a saloon.

See moreSee less

It Is a ridiculons proposition it a few churches in the business blocks of the city are to crowd the saloons out Into the residence portion of the town. Then there is something in the conten tion that the saloons have contributed a large support to the churches and schools themselves. To cause the saloon people unnecessary expense is a poor wav to show gratitude. Amongst the saloon men affected by this protest are citizens who have done and are doing much to promote the welfare and business interests of the city. The pro prietors of the Reception saloon for in stance, have invested 840,000 in a first class brewery and have one of the largest ■..a.. baIIh nf nn.i innf i tl itlnn in kl/Qiril’ atr The same in a slightly lesser degree can be said for Fred Ronkendorf of the Senate and Herman Grimm of the Seattle. The easiest and reasonable way out of the difficulty would be a withdrawal of the protest. While the plains of the Dakotas were covered two weeks ago with a white man tle of "the beautiful” two inches deep, the first new snow visible from Skagway, the metropolis of “Seward’s ice box,” tor this year has just made its appearance and that at an altitude of more than 5000 feet. Is it a wonder that Alaskans are prone to boast of their climate? It is now estimated by Seattle transpor tation men that the output of Alaskan can neries for this year will reach 1.5000,00c cases. This will mean a tax to Jhe federal government of $60,000, not one cent ol which will be retained in Alaska, except one half of that paid bv the cannery at Ketchikan. This is pretty good evidence that Alaska is prepared to maintain a ter ritorial form of government. The action of the Porcupine miners in refusing to recognize the royal commiss ion now in session In that district presents another [side to a novel situation. What the result will be makes a fie. i for Interest ing conjecture. _'

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

A reader writes to correct Governor Roosevelt's claim that the Philippines, Hawaii, New Mexico, and Alaska were all annexed in the same manner. The writer argues Alaska was a peaceable purchase from Russia, unlike the Mexican War or the Philippines annexation.

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 26 September 1900 · page 4

Annexation. To the Editor of the Journal nnd Courier: In your quotation from Governor Roosevelt's speceh in Detroit he is made to say: "We have annexed the Philippines, exactly as we have annex ed Hawaii, New Mexico and Alaska." If he had said New Mexico and left out the others there would have been no disputing him, for every foot of land taken from . Mexico In that unrighteous war was a robbery of our sister State in the interests of that "sum of all villainies," American slavery. But the purchase cf Alaska was a peaceable commercial transaction.

See moreSee less

Russia wanted the money and Secretary Seward thought we wanted the territory, in which thinking he proved himself a far seeing statesman. The only war con nected with that annexation was a war of words on the part of those who op posed the purchase with those who favored it. For many years there was no question as to the boundary line, but since the discovery of gold in paying quantities both Canada and C.'eit Brit ain would willingly push ua into the Arctic and Pacific oceans and destroy nil cur Interests In Alaska as ruthless ly as they destroye dour seals with their piratical pelagic operations in Behring sea. Hawaii was annexed by treaty with the republic of Hawaii, a govern ment which was acknowledged by all the great powers and which was and had been in peaceable, undisputed pos session of every foot of Hawaiian ter rllory and had far five years maintain ed a government which in honesty and ability In all Its branches, whether Ju dicial or executive, would not suffer by comparison with ary state In this coun tryNew York state with Mr. Roose velt at Its head not excepted. Now for the contrast. By the treaty of Paris we bought from Spain for a trifle of twenty millions of dollars a large num-

See the clipping