As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

December 1899

4 articles

Staunton Spectator and Vindicator · Staunton, Va.

A Democratic commentator reviews past U.S. territorial acquisitions, arguing Louisiana and Florida were necessary for national unity while Alaska was merely 'a caprice of Mr. Seward' with no trade value. He uses this history to argue against American imperialism in the coming 1900 election.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 28 days later.

Wrong

Staunton Spectator and Vindicator · 1 December 1899 · page 1

I Note of Waniii. IS AGAINST IMPERIALISM And Declares the Democratic Par ty Will Take a Like Stand in 1900—Reasons for the Purchase of Territory by Jefferson. Mr. George Cammack, a prominent Republican of Louisa county, writes as follows to the Baltimore Sun : Governor Roosevelt and other McKinley Republicans, who defend ex pansion abroad, appear to think that the odium of imperialism may be si lenced by a cry of Copperhead ! Trai tor ! and by the assertion that Thomas Jefferson was the first advocate of that un-American policy.

See moreSee less

Driven to the necessity of finding a precedent for territorial aggrandizement abroad, they cite the purchase of Louisiana, but withhold facts. Louisiana bordered our Union on the West. American pioneers had al ready invaded the northern part of that territory; the mouth of the Mis sissippi river was wholly under con trol of France. Mr. Jefferson saw that the growth of our western com merce, all confined at that time to riv ers, depended on the possession of the great Mississippi from its source to the Gulf. A divided ownership of that great stream would have resulted in endless confusion and strife. Mr. Jef ferson purchased adjacent territory, ' and although at that hour the Missisi sippi may not have been indispensable i to the Union, nevertheless, he saw I that in the near future it would be. Iv 1861, while Horace Greely was urging the North to let the wayward sisters (Southern States) depart in < peace, the retention of the Mississippi ' river as an outlet for Western produce ! became a powerful factor in the ar- . gument for an undivided country. Unless we had purchased Florida our Atlantic and Gulf Coast line would i have failed of connection by a thou- ' sand miles and the mouth of theChat taboochie river, the Gulf outlet for Georgia pine and cotton, have remain ed under Spanish control. Look at the map of the Union and you will see at a ; glace this is so. The purchase of Alaska was a ca price of Mr. Seward. He acquired for Uncle Sam a far-away, bleak, almost uninhabitable ice plant—a big thing in an atlas, but without trade or com merce; almost destitute of population. Even it should not be cited as a prece dent for grabbing islands of 10,000,000 people, who for 300 years have been under the guidance of Christian priests. The purchase of Alaska was ratified, too, while the carpetbaggers misrepresented the South in Congress. No doubt the expenses of Alaska

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

This short item in a newspaper's miscellaneous commentary column recalls that 'Seward's Folly' was the derisive nickname given to Alaska thirty years earlier by anti-expansionists. It implicitly contrasts this old mockery with the present, suggesting the purchase has since been vindicated.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 11 December 1899 · page 4

AFTERTHOUGHTS

V V Senator Mark Hanna says that when ha has anything to announce he wilt announce It himself. He can't fool the yellow Jour nals that way. V o°o V It may be well to recall the fact that "Seward's Folly" was the favorite name bestowed on Alaska by the prototypes of the Little Americans thirty years ago. 000 0 0 U 0 0 V

See the clipping

The Forest Republican · Tionesta, Pa.

An 1899 editorial pushes back on anti-expansionists who cite Seward's 1844 opposition to Texas annexation as evidence he opposed expansion. It argues Seward opposed Texas annexation only because it would add slave territory, not because he was anti-expansionist, pointing to his later purchase of Alaska as proof of his pro-expansion views.

The Forest Republican · 13 December 1899 · page 2

Those antis who are quoting William II. Seward, as an auti-expansionist bo cause he opposed the annexation of Tex as in the campaign of 1844, should go a little slow. Seward opposed the annex ation of Texas not because he was an anti expansionist, but because be wa against the acquisition of any more slave terri tory. The purchase of Alaska later con summated by Mr. Seward, showed his

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

The article recounts Secretary Seward's 1867 purchase of Alaska from Russia for $7,200,000, then details the vast wealth later extracted from the territory through fur seals, whaling, salmon fisheries, and royalties paid to the treasury. It concludes that Alaska's fisheries alone were valued by the U.S. Fish Commissioner at nearly $68 million, far outstripping the original purchase cost.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 28 days earlier.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 29 December 1899 · page 4

The Result of the Alaska Purchase.

ESEXCLUSIVELY IN STRAFFORD COUNTY. It is reported that a man named ‘Henry L. Millis has failed and gone into bankruptey in Chicago and that Lis liabilities are $768,891 and assets only §IO,OOO. A list of his creditors is given, among whom appear one of the Manchester, N. H., National banks to the amount of $83,000 and once ecitizen of Manchester to the amount of $22,- 850. Itrather looks as though they would not get a very large dividend out of that SIO,OOO assets of the debtor. The Result of the Alaska Purchase.

See moreSee less

Becretary Seward negotiated the treaty with Russia for the purchase of Alaska., He paid $7,200,000 for it. The fur companies have taken over $33,000,- 000 worth of seal skins; and they have paid into the treasury a total of over $6,000,000 as royalties. And there are $1,340,000 now in dispute. It is esti mated that the whale fis"eries have produced $2,000,000 a year, and a total of $20,000,000 a year since Alaska was ceded. The salmon fisheries have pro duced $30,000,000. The United States commissioner of fisheries has estimat ed the value of the Alaskan fisheries, exclusive of whales and seals, at $67,- 890,000. Pension Revelry. It 18 estimated that the bills for pén sioning introduced thus far in the pres ent Congress would swell the amount appropriated for this purpose to the ex tent of $200,000,000, thus wmore the doubling the sum of $144,000,000 now paid out by law. One bill, which re maves all limitation upon the payment of arrears of pensions, the pension of fice declares to be good for $500,000,- 000. There is a pension service bill proposed by an Ohio Democrat which calls for $100,000,000 annually. We have noted that Senator Cullum dis claims approving the bill he introduc ed to pevsion 117,000 deserters, but that bill has been offered before, and may be again. There seems to be no end to these projects, and no limit to the per sistency with which they are present ed. Besides these general measures, the stream of applicationß for private pensions runs on. There are very few members of Congress who do not par ticipate in it, and .the sources from which it comes are apparently inex haustible.—[Herald. y Labor and Imperialism. The San Francisco Argonaut isa strong Republican party paper, and promises to continue the same way, but it takes the opportunity to define itself and doesso ina way thatex presses our opinion a 3 well as its own. It also gives some other facts pertinent Just now in the following editorial tak en from its columns by the Man chester Mirror, and worthy of serious eonsideration: The Argonaut is a Republican paper, and it will loyally support the Repub lican party’s stand on the Philippines when the Republican party declares it self. If our party in congress—both houses being Republican—declares against’Philippine independence, the Argcnaut will support the party on its stand. We have opposed the forecible annpexation of the Philippines on two urely material grounds—that we be-

See the clipping