As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

May 1899

3 articles

Douglas Island News · Douglas City, Alaska

A newspaper correspondent recalls that opposition to the 1867 Alaska purchase mirrored current arguments against acquiring the Philippines, citing Congressman Orange Ferris's dismissal of Alaska as a worthless, God-forsaken region. The piece notes the $7,200,000 purchase price and draws a parallel between past and present imperial expansion debates.

Douglas Island News · 3 May 1899 · page 2

Washington or the Mississippi river j than the Island of Luzon is today, cost $7,200,009. Correspondent Curtis of the Chicago Record recalls that the oppo sition to the acquisition of Alaska was i identical in its reasoning processes with the present opposition to tho acquisi tion of the Philippines. It was argued then that we had enough land of our own; that Alaska was worthless, and - ? l-~ d f "v ioc% nnp It WilS it UiUt puiltj iuvi wwv vrv?i national responsibilities; that it would be uecessary to retain a large military force up there, and that the necessarj7 taxes to support it would be a great; burden upon the people.

See moreSee less

Nothing, j however, was said about the consent of the governed. In answer to an iuquiry from A. Borkaw of Litchfield, 111., says Mr. Curtis, I would say that much of this opposition came from the leaders of the dominant party in congress, as j is the case with the Philippines. Hon. Grange Ferris of New York, for exam ple, said in debate that Alaska was a "wretched, God-forsaken region, worth nothing, and a positive iujury and in cumbrance." He moved an amend ment to the annexation bill authorizing the president to pay 87,-00,000 "to any : respectable European, Asiatic or Afri can power that would take Alaska off ; our hands." Ci? r? > P anroeanf at ira OU ^UUU U Ulan ac ivcyi tovututu v j Illrarn Price, of Iowa, declared that the $7,200,000 which we paid for Alas-1 ka was "a dead loss to us and the more expense we incur the worse it will be for the country and the people." Gen. B. F. Butler said: uIf we are to ? pay her (Russia) for her friendship I desire to give her the $7,200,000 and let her keep Alaska. No man except oue insane enough to buy the earthquakes of St. Thomas or the icefields of Green laud could be found to agree to its * acquisition." Elihu B. Wasebarne, of Illinois, took the same position in regard to Alaska that Mr. Hoar takes regarding the Philippines, and he lived to realize his folly. He urged congress not to ratify the treaty; he declared that the govern ment was taking upon itself unneces sary and expensive responsibilities, and went so far as to predict that no part of Alaskan territory would ever be in habited by white men. As against the original cost of ST,- j *200,000 the Alaska seal company has paid in royalties to the United States government over 0 million dollars and still owes 81,340,000. Over 33 million dollars of sealskins have been taken from the Alaska seas and nearly twice as much more in the fisheries, while the gold product has aggregated lo millions and is increasing. Mr. Curtis quotes Seward as saying in reply to the question as to the most important act of his career: '*The purchase of Alaska, but it will take the people a generation to find it out." The same story may be told of the acquisition of Louisiana, which was to the greatness of the United States the critical event and turning point of the j early period of the nation. The expan sion program from the earliest days to

See the clipping

Douglas Island News · Douglas City, Alaska

The article recalls how congressional opponents of the 1867 Alaska purchase, including Ferris, Price, Butler, and Washburne, dismissed it as worthless and burdensome, paralleling current objections to acquiring the Philippines. It notes Alaska's purchase price of $7.2 million has since been vastly outweighed by seal, fishery, and gold revenues, vindicating Seward's prediction that history would prove the purchase wise.

Douglas Island News · 3 May 1899 · page 2

Transcript to come.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Western News-Democrat · Valentine, Neb.

The article reviews the economic returns from Alaska since its 1867 purchase for $7,200,000, citing fur, fish, and gold revenues that vastly exceeded the original cost. It quotes Seward's prediction that it would take a generation for people to recognize the purchase's importance.

Western News-Democrat · 25 May 1899 · page 2

on. men go wrong and how easy it is for li. wise men to be mistaken. The price li.th paid for Alaska was $7,200,000. The li ( area acquired was 309.529,000 acres , so ar that it was about 2 cents an acre. The es Alaska fur companies have already to

See the clipping