As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

April 1899

12 articles

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The report cites statistics on Alaska's seal, fish, and gold revenues to argue the $7.2 million purchase was a bargain at about 2 cents an acre. It closes with Seward's own prediction that history would vindicate the deal, though it would take a generation for people to realize it.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 14 days earlier.

The Indianapolis Journal · 8 April 1899 · page 4

Alaska Was a Good Bargain

KOKOMO. Ind.. April 7. Rev. David Kirkpatrlck. of this city,, fell from a tiee in his yard and sustained dangerous in juries, lie is a large man and quite old. His recovery is not assured. He is a re tired minister and an uncle of Judge L. J. Kirkpatrick. ... Indiana Note. Winchester has closed a contract with lo cal citizens under which, by Nov. 1, the city will be supplied with a first-class system of water works and later have the right to purchase. Hon. J. W. Lovctt, of Anderson, has re cently organized a company for the build ing and equipment of an electric railway from Laporte to Michigan City.

See moreSee less

The road will be fourteen miles long, costing, when complete, from HUkv to $X),0u0. The annual expenses of the New Albany metropolitan police department have been reduced over $4,2o in the past two years. The present board of commissioners consists of Fred D. Conner, It. M. Boardman and Dr. C. I. Cook, appointed by Governor Mount Joe Whitton, who says that his home is at Columbus, is in jail at Jeffersonvllle. Whitton claimed to represent a Chicago carpet house and took orders, always col lecting $3 in advance. The carpets failed to come and he was arrested. He has worked his scheme all over the county. Sam Marshall, the man who was acquitted as one of the alleged murderers of Mrs. Stoltz, at Portlana, and who was arrested at Terre Haute two weeks ago for forging a check in Henderson, Ky.. was taken to that town yesterday, the requisition having finally been received at Terre Haute from Indianapolis, where it had been delayed some days by an oversight. Baron Hirnch'a Children. Washington Post. . A few days before the death of Baroness Hirsch last week the Emperor of Austria, in recognition of the magnificence of her charities, since the demise of her husband, conferred the title of baron upon young; Arnold and Raymond de Forest, illegitimate children of the late baron, and whom, with a generosity beyond all praise, she adopted, as her own sons, even during the lifetime of her husband. They will share the im mense fortune left by the baroness, with the latter's granddaughter. Mile. Luclenne Hirsch, now. about seventeen years of age. Luclenne. according to French law, is quite as illegitimate as the two young De Forests. She is the daughter of the lato baron's only legitimate son, Luclen. who died in 1SS7 at the age of thirty. Luclen fell in love with a girl by the name of JTemelic, who occupied a quasi-menial posi tion In the household of the baroness. Luclen went through a religious ceremony with her in France, v.hete he made hi home at the time. But his parents declined; to give their consent to the match, and consequently he . was debarred by French law fromgoing through the civil portion of the ceremony, which is absolutely necessary in order to render a matrimonial union valid in France. The child, therefore. Is. in the eyes of the French law. Illegitimate. Baron and Baroness Hirsch undertook her educa tion on the condition of her complete sep aration from her mother, now married to an Italian. Starvation In Havana. Letter In Leslie's Weekly. The crowds around the stations of relief are composed almost entirely of negroes, and their scramble for food would, in an Anglo-Saxon country, be called fighting. A delicate or refined woman stands but small chances of getting near to the door, but as a rule the ollicer ih charge looks out for such a case, and helps her over the heads of the mob. A fewr days ago, at one of the stations, we noticed a well-dressed woman being elbowed about and apparently with out enough strength to hold her own. We made way for her through the throng, and when she reached the room he sank Into a chair half fainting. She was given food enough for ten days. She was about to leave when she burn Into tears, and It was some few minutes before she could speak. She told us that It was the first time in her life that she had ever applied for charity. A few months ago her husband and fiva children had been with her on a beautiful plantation, prosperous and happy, but. to day the plantation is a waste, her husband executed by Spanish guerrillas, and her children dead of starvation. She still owns the land, and as soon as she is able to get It under cultivation will be in good circum stances. Cases of this sort aro common, and manv of the destitute have been used to much better fare, and some have been wealthy. Alnnkn Wan a Good Bar grain. Washington Special. This illustrates how frequently good men go wrong and how easy it is for wise men to be mistaken. The price paid for Alaska was $7,2y).ouo. The area acquired was wto,52y.t) acres, so that it was about 2 cents an acre. The Alaska fur companies have already taken over $33,000,000 worth of sealskins, and they have paid into the treasury owr $5.uAMi as royalties, with $1,310,S23 still un settled. The fish product of Alaska In was valued at $2,977,019. During the last fifteen years it has exceeded $..W0,0. The com mi.'sioner of fish and fisheries in a letter to , Congress estimated the value of the Alaska fisheries, excluding whales and seals, at $', SW.txjO. or nine and one-half times the cost of purchase. The gold output has exceeded $13.0J,0 already. The Treadwell mine alone up to lsy7 had paid $.fii.91" as dividends to Its stockholders, and claims to have several millions in sight. In that year alone the output of the mine was $2.4J9,0uO, ar.d in lh'.u it was nearly twice as much. When Mr. Seward was aked what he con sidered the most important event in his carter he replied: "The purchase of Alaska; but it will take the people a generation IQ find it out." Chance for "Illtc Head. Philadelphia Record. Unless young Mr. Harrison be a remark able man there will soon be a case of swelled bead developed in Cnlcago which will be amazing even In that metropolis of swelled heads. Undoubtedly his victory over his Republican opponent for the mayoralty, with Altg!d running as the in dependent Democrat, was unexpectedly brilliant, but It was clearly the re.-ult of Republican revolt and not of Mr. Harri son's puissance in hlx own party. How ever, if on the Mtrength of his present suc cess he shall be enabled to carry Illinois against Bryanbm. as he has carried Chi cago against Altgeldlsm. he will render a notable service to both his party and his country, and in that event he should not go unrewarded "Jim" Mains'. Lock. Washington Special. Young "Jim" Blaine, who returned from Manila under a cloud a few month ago. 1 said to have cleaned up $loa.fo in the stock market since he reached Washington. He does the bulk of his trading through Com modore Pateman. who was1 Armour's fa vorite broker In the great packer's famous St. Paul deal back In the eighties. He Is rarely seen in public. AVhen not at hi broker's ottioe be Is lost to view. He seems to have turned over a nw leaf. Gosrdp names Col. O. O. Stealey. Washington corie iIondent of the Louisville Courier-Journal, as being $7.V) ahead of the stock market. T View of economy. New York Commercial Advertiser. On the ground of economy, a West Phil adelphia young woman declined to let her betrothed buy her an engagement ring, but permitted him to give her the hundred dol lars he had Intended to spend for it. When they had been married rlx months she In formed him that she had Invested the money In a life membership In the Woman'a Suffrage Society. It Is evident that the cou ple differ as to what constitutes extra va sane a. Ur.Ion, has declared off the strikes at Bed key and Swayzee. Over sixty nonunion blowers from those two places have been taken Into th? union by John Roeyjer, chair man of the executive committee of the union. They wcie all made members of local branch. No. CO. at Upland. Found Deud In Her Bed. Special to the Indlanapo!! Journal. BLOOM INGTON. Ind., April 7.-Mrs. Melissa Ciendenen was found dead in her bedroom at Harrodsburg this morning. She lived alone and fupic!on was aroused. A cj'ieful investigation by the corner leads to the belief that death resulted from heart disease. She separated from her husband some tme ago and had threatened suicide. 11 a rn: I urn at Stilton. Special to the Indianapolis Journal. MILTON, Ind.. April 7. Burglars en tered .the residence of Aaron Morris and Bayard Baldwin last night. At the latter place razors and edibles are articles missed; at the former toilet articles were taken and probably other things. Efforts were made to enter other houses In the north end of town, but unsuccessfully. Acquitted for Killing? Trlbble. Special to the Indianapolia Journal. BRAZIL. Ind.. April 7. Andrew Kuhns, charged with killing Emery Tribble at Ashboro last October, was acquitted this morn ing by the Jury, after remaining out over night. Kuhns also shot Mat Clark during; the fight, inflicting a bad wound telow his left eye. but he will probably escape trial on this case. Rev. Klrkpatrlek'n Bad Fall. Special to the In.lianajxjlls Journal. KOKOMO. Ind.. April 7. Rev. David Kirkpatrlck. of this city,, fell from a tiee in his yard and sustained dangerous in juries, lie is a large man and quite old. His recovery is not assured. He is a re tired minister and an uncle of Judge L. J. Kirkpatrick. ... Indiana Note. Winchester has closed a contract with lo cal citizens under which, by Nov. 1, the city will be supplied with a first-class system of water works and later have the right to purchase. Hon. J. W. Lovctt, of Anderson, has re cently organized a company for the build ing and equipment of an electric railway from Laporte to Michigan City. The road will be fourteen miles long, costing, when complete, from HUkv to $X),0u0. The annual expenses of the New Albany metropolitan police department have been reduced over $4,2o in the past two years. The present board of commissioners consists of Fred D. Conner, It. M. Boardman and Dr. C. I. Cook, appointed by Governor Mount Joe Whitton, who says that his home is at Columbus, is in jail at Jeffersonvllle. Whitton claimed to represent a Chicago carpet house and took orders, always col lecting $3 in advance. The carpets failed to come and he was arrested. He has worked his scheme all over the county. Sam Marshall, the man who was acquitted as one of the alleged murderers of Mrs. Stoltz, at Portlana, and who was arrested at Terre Haute two weeks ago for forging a check in Henderson, Ky.. was taken to that town yesterday, the requisition having finally been received at Terre Haute from Indianapolis, where it had been delayed some days by an oversight. Baron Hirnch'a Children. Washington Post. . A few days before the death of Baroness Hirsch last week the Emperor of Austria, in recognition of the magnificence of her charities, since the demise of her husband, conferred the title of baron upon young; Arnold and Raymond de Forest, illegitimate children of the late baron, and whom, with a generosity beyond all praise, she adopted, as her own sons, even during the lifetime of her husband. They will share the im mense fortune left by the baroness, with the latter's granddaughter. Mile. Luclenne Hirsch, now. about seventeen years of age. Luclenne. according to French law, is quite as illegitimate as the two young De Forests. She is the daughter of the lato baron's only legitimate son, Luclen. who died in 1SS7 at the age of thirty. Luclen fell in love with a girl by the name of JTemelic, who occupied a quasi-menial posi tion In the household of the baroness. Luclen went through a religious ceremony with her in France, v.hete he made hi home at the time. But his parents declined; to give their consent to the match, and consequently he . was debarred by French law fromgoing through the civil portion of the ceremony, which is absolutely necessary in order to render a matrimonial union valid in France. The child, therefore. Is. in the eyes of the French law. Illegitimate. Baron and Baroness Hirsch undertook her educa tion on the condition of her complete sep aration from her mother, now married to an Italian. Starvation In Havana. Letter In Leslie's Weekly. The crowds around the stations of relief are composed almost entirely of negroes, and their scramble for food would, in an Anglo-Saxon country, be called fighting. A delicate or refined woman stands but small chances of getting near to the door, but as a rule the ollicer ih charge looks out for such a case, and helps her over the heads of the mob. A fewr days ago, at one of the stations, we noticed a well-dressed woman being elbowed about and apparently with out enough strength to hold her own. We made way for her through the throng, and when she reached the room he sank Into a chair half fainting. She was given food enough for ten days. She was about to leave when she burn Into tears, and It was some few minutes before she could speak. She told us that It was the first time in her life that she had ever applied for charity. A few months ago her husband and fiva children had been with her on a beautiful plantation, prosperous and happy, but. to day the plantation is a waste, her husband executed by Spanish guerrillas, and her children dead of starvation. She still owns the land, and as soon as she is able to get It under cultivation will be in good circum stances. Cases of this sort aro common, and manv of the destitute have been used to much better fare, and some have been wealthy. Alnnkn Wan a Good Bar grain. Washington Special. This illustrates how frequently good men go wrong and how easy it is for wise men to be mistaken. The price paid for Alaska was $7,2y).ouo. The area acquired was wto,52y.t) acres, so that it was about 2 cents an acre. The Alaska fur companies have already taken over $33,000,000 worth of sealskins, and they have paid into the treasury owr $5.uAMi as royalties, with $1,310,S23 still un settled. The fish product of Alaska In was valued at $2,977,019. During the last fifteen years it has exceeded $..W0,0. The com mi.'sioner of fish and fisheries in a letter to , Congress estimated the value of the Alaska fisheries, excluding whales and seals, at $', SW.txjO. or nine and one-half times the cost of purchase. The gold output has exceeded $13.0J,0

See the clipping

Albuquerque Daily Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.

The report recaps the original $7.2 million price paid for Alaska and its vast acreage, then details the fortune since extracted from sealskin royalties, fisheries, and especially gold mining. It frames the purchase, once mocked, as a spectacularly profitable investment decades later.

Albuquerque Daily Citizen · 10 April 1899 · page 2

A V ALU A MLB nailUAHl, The price paid for Alaska was 17.200,' 000. " The area acquired was 3M,&29.eoo acres, so that It was about 2 vents an acre. The Alaska fur oomp.nle have already taken over 133.000,000 worth of sealskins, and they have paid Into the treasury over $0,000,000 as royalties, with 11.340,033 atill unsettled. The Dab prod net of Alaska In 181)7 was valued at 2,H77.01'J. During the last fifteen years it has exceeded kiO.000,000. Tbe commissioner of fish and fisheries in a letter to congress estimated the value of the Alaska fisheries, excluding whales and seals, at t7.Hl.iO,ooO, or ulue and one-halt limes the cost of purchase.

See moreSee less

The gold output has exceeded tl&.ooo, 000 alrealy. The Treadwell mine alone np to 18U7 bad paid ,o25,lMu as divl dends to lis stock-holders, and claims to have several million In sight. In that year alone the outpnt of the mine was 2.43tf,00O, and in 18U7 it was uearly twice aa much. When Mr. Howard was asked what he eousidered the most lmportaut event In his career he replied: "The purchase of Alaska; but It will take the people a generation to and it out." !

See the clipping

The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.

The report recounts the $7.2 million price paid for Alaska and tallies the fortunes since reaped from seals, fish, and gold, showing returns many times the purchase cost. It closes by quoting Seward predicting it would take a generation for people to recognize the deal's true value.

The Seattle Star · 12 April 1899 · page 2

THE PRODUCTS OF ALASKA WABIIINOTON. April 11 -This Illustrates how frequently good men go wrong ana how easy It Is for wis* men to be mistaken.. The price paid for Alaska was 17,200.(100. The area

See the clipping

The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

The article recalls that anti-expansionists used the same arguments against buying Alaska in 1867 that they now use against keeping the Philippines. It details Alaska's purchase price and the vast profits since reaped from furs, fish, and gold, quoting Seward's prediction that history would vindicate the purchase.

The Oskaloosa Herald · 13 April 1899 · page 2

CONCERNING EXPANSION Thirty years ago the anti expan sionists used the same arguments against the purchase of Alaska that are being used by them now against the retention of the Philippines. It was argued then that we had enough land of our own; that Alaska was worthless, and that it was bad policy to increase our national respon sibilities; that it would be necessary to retain a large military force up there, and that the necessary taxes to support it would be a great burden upon the people. The price paid for Alaska was 97,- 900,000.

See moreSee less

The area acquired was 369,- 629, 600 acres, so that it was about 2 cents an acre. The Alaska fur com panies have already taken over 933,- 000,000 worth of sealskins, and they have paid into the treasury over 96,- 000,000 as royalties, with 91,340,633 still unsettled. The fish product of Alaska in 1897 was valued at *2,977,019. During the last fifteen years it has exceeded 8,30,- 000,000. The commissioner of fish and fisheries in a letter to congress estimated the value of the Alaska fisheries, excluding whales and seals, at *67,890,000, or nine and one-half times the cost of purchase. The gold output has exceeded *15,- 000,000 already. The Treadwell mine alone up to 1897 had paid *6,625,945 as dividends to its stockholders, and claims to have several millions in sight. In that year alone the output of the mine was 82,439,000, and in 1897 it was nearly twice as much. When Mr. Seward was asked what he considered the most important event in his career he replied: “The purchase of. Alaska: but it will take the people a generation to find it out.”

See the clipping

The Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

The report compares the upcoming $20,000,000 U.S. payment to Spain under the Treaty of Paris with past major transactions, including Seward's $7,200,000 purchase of Alaska. It notes Alaska and other historical land deals to show the Spain payment is the largest international cash transaction in U.S. history.

The Age-Herald · 20 April 1899 · page 4

Uncle Sam's Land Deal. Uncle Sam’s largest cash transaction will consist In the payment of *20,000,000 to Spain. Secretary Seward’s purchase of Alaska cost *7,200,000, and the Gadsden pur

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

The article recounts the original $7.2 million price of Alaska and calculates profits from furs, fish, and gold mining that have since dwarfed the purchase cost. It also quotes Secretary Seward predicting it would take a generation for people to recognize the purchase's importance.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 20 April 1899 · page 4

Profits From the Purchase of Alaska. The price which the United States paid Russia for Alaska was $7,200,000, The area acquired was 369,529,600 acres, go that It was about 2 cente an acre. ‘The Alaska fur companies have already . taken over $33,000,000 worth of seal skins, and they bave paid into the treas iury over $6,000,000 as royalties, with $1,340,533 still unsettied, The fish. product of Alaska in 1807 was valued at $2,977,019, During the last 15 years it has exceeded $30,000,- 000. The commissioner of fish and fisheries in a letter to congress estimat ed the value of the Alaska fisheries ex cluding whales and seals, at $67,800,- 000, or nine and one-half times the cost of purchase.

See moreSee less

The gold output has exoceaded $15,- 000,000 already. The Treadwell mine alone up to 1897 had paid $6,625,943, as dividends to its stockholders, and claims to have several millions in sight, In that year alone the output of the mine was $2,439.000, and in 1897 it was nearly twice as much. When Mr, Seward was asked what he copsidered the most important event in his career he replied: ‘‘The purchase of Alaska; but ic will take the peopls a ' generation to find it out.”

See the clipping

The Superior Times · Superior, Wis.

The report recounts the $7.2 million purchase price of Alaska at about 2 cents per acre, then details the vast wealth since extracted in furs, fish, and gold, including the Treadwell mine's enormous dividends. It closes with Seward's prediction that it would take a generation for people to recognize the purchase's importance.

The Superior Times · 22 April 1899 · page 1

Cnn is cei A 1s -v 1 The price paid for Alaska was ST.'Jon. • mm*. Thearea ac-cpitred wa> .’’ar.i..V_’!i.c;i hi acres, so that it was about 2 cents an acre. The Alaska fur companies have already taken over S.TD nh,inn worth of sealskin-, and they have paid into the treasury over .•*(’>.< hhi,(m mi royalties, with SI." pt.oob still unsettled. The tish prodm t of Alaska in is;*! vva* valued at s!i.!*77.olJ* During the last tifteeii years it lias c-xceedecl $;.( ,l N M l.t Mn . The commissioner of tish ami fisheries in a letter to Congress estimated the value of rh Alaska fisheries, excluding whale s and seals, at S(7,B!KMJ(Kt.

See moreSee less

or uim one-half times the cost of purchase. The gold output has exceeded s ’ A. 000 already. The Treadwell mine alone up to iv *7 had paid b.' l 15 as and dends to its stockholders, and • laiitis to have several millions in sight. In that year alone the output of the mine was s.’.i:l!and ni 18517 it was t w ice a s mm h. When Mr. Sr-ward was asked what he considered the most imi*ortant event in his career he replied; "The purchase of Alaska: but it will taktiepeople a generation to find it out." Chicago 11-- ord.

See the clipping

The Hawaiian Star · Honolulu Oahu

A Washington correspondent compares 1899 arguments against American expansion (the Philippines) to those used against purchasing Alaska in 1867. It quotes congressmen like Orange Ferris, Hiram Price, Benjamin Butler, and Elihu Washburne who mocked the Alaska deal as worthless and burdensome.

The Hawaiian Star · 28 April 1899 · page 3

snn.noo "to anv respectable European. Asialic or African power that would take Alaska off our hands." So L'ood a man as lieprescntative lllrani Trice, of Iowa declared that the $7,200,000 which we paid for Alaska was "a dead loss to us, and the more viiiuki we incur the worse it will be for the country mid the people.' Gen. 11. F. Butler said: "If we are (o pay her (Russia) for her friend ship, I desire to give her the $7,200, 000 and let her keep Alaska. No man except one insane enough to buy the earthquakes of St.

See moreSee less

Thomas and the icefields of Greenland could be found fn nfrren to its nenuisition. Elihu it. Wushhurne of Illinois took the same position in regard to Alaska that Mr. Hoar takes regard ing the Philippines, and lie lived to realize his folly. He urged congress not to ratifv the treaty; he declared that the government was taking up on itself unnecessary and expensive responsibilities, and went so far as to predict that no part of Alaskan territory would ever be inhabited by white men. This illustrates how frequently L'ood men iro wrong and how easy is for wise men to be mistaken. The price paid for Alaska was $7,200,000. The area acouired was :i(9,520,G00 acres, so that it was about 2 cents an acre. The Aiasua iur companies inn is nlriMiilv taken over SIW.OOO.OHO worth of sealskins, and they have paid into the treasury over $G,000,000 as royal ties, with $l,:?40,r,3:t still unsettled. The ilsli product of Alaska in 1897 was valued at $2,977,019. Earing the last fifteen years it has exceeded $30,000,000. The commissioner of fish and fisheries in a letter to con gress estimated the value of the Alas ka fisheries, excluding whales and seals, at $07,890,000, or nine and one half times the cost of purclinse. The gold output lias exceeded $15, 000,000 already. The Treadwell mine alone up to 1897 had paid $0,025,94.' as dividends to its stockholders, and claims to have several millions in sight. In that year alone the output of the mine was $2,439,000, and in 1S97 it was nearly twice as much. When Mr. Seward was asked what he considered the most important event in his career he replied: "The purchase of Alaska; but it will take the people a generation to find it out."

See the clipping

The Hawaiian Star · Honolulu Oahu

The article recalls 1867 congressional critics who mocked the Alaska purchase as worthless, quoting their predictions of failure. It then contrasts those claims with later data showing massive returns from sealskins, fisheries, and gold mining, far exceeding the original $7.2 million price.

The Hawaiian Star · 28 April 1899 · page 3

Transcript to come.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Chicago Eagle · Chicago, Ill.

The article recounts the $7.2 million Alaska purchase price and details enormous returns since then, including over $33 million in seal skins, $67 million in estimated fisheries, and over $15 million in gold output. It closes by quoting Seward's prediction that it would take a generation for people to recognize the purchase's significance.

Chicago Eagle · 29 April 1899 · page 4

This Illustrates how frequently good men go wrong nnd how ensy It Is for wlso men to bo mistaken. Tho price paid for Alaska wns $7,200,000. The men acquired was 300,020,000 ncrcs, so that It was about 2 cents nn ncre. The Alaska fur companies have already taken over $33,000,000 worth of seal sklus, nud they havo paid Into the treasury over $0,000,000 ns royalties, with $1,340,533 still unsettled. Tho fish product of Alaska In 1807 was valued at $2,077,010. During the Inst fifteen years It has exceeded $30,000,000. Tho Commissioner of Fish nud Fisheries lu n letter to Congress estimated the value of tho Alaska fisheries, excluding whales and seals, at $07,800,000, or nine and ouc-half times tho cost of purchase.

See moreSee less

Tho gold output hns exceeded $15,000, 000 nlrendy, Tho Trcndwcll mine nlono up to 1807 had paid $0,025,045 as divi dends to Its stockholders, nnd claims to havo several millions In sight, lu thnt year nlono the output of the mine wns $2,430,000, nnd lu 1807 It wns near ly twice as much. When Mr. Seward was asked what he considered the most Important ovent In his career he re plied: "Tho purchnso of Alaska; but It

See the clipping

Western Kansas World · Wakeeney, Kan.

This article, written 30 years after the Alaska purchase, draws parallels between the historical opposition to buying Alaska and contemporary opposition to acquiring the Philippines. It quotes several congressmen who had dismissed Alaska as worthless and a financial burden, showing their predictions were wrong.

Western Kansas World · 29 April 1899 · page 2

HISTORY REPEATING ITSELF.

A. IJorkaw of Litchfield, 111., says Mr. Curtis, I would say that much of this opposition came from the leaders of the dominant party in congress, as jn the case with the Philippines. Hon. Orange Ferris of jNTew Vork, for ex ample, said in debate that Alaska was a "wretclied, God-forsaken region, worth nothing, and a positive injury and incumbrance." He moved an amendment to the annexation bill authorizing the president to pay $7,200,000 -'to any respectable Euro pean, Asiatic or African power that would take Alaska oil our hands." So good a man as Kepresentati ve Hiram Price, of Iowa, declared that the $7,200,000 which we paid for Alas ka was a "dead loss to us, and th more expense we incur the worse it will be for the country and the peo ple."

See moreSee less

General B. F. Butler said: "If we are to pay her (Russia) for her friend ship I desire to give her the $7,200,000 and let her keep Alaska. No man ex cept one insane enough to buy the earthquakes of St. Thomas or the ice fields of Greenland could be found to agree to its acquisition." Klihu B Washburne of Illinois took the same position in regard to Alaska that Mr. Hoar takes regarding the Philippines, and he lived to realize his folly. He urged congress not to ratify the treaty; he declared that the government was taking upon it self unnecessary and and expensive responsibilities, and went so far as to predict tlia-t-no part of Alaskan terri tory would ever be inhabited by white men. As against the original cost of $7, 200,000 the Alaska Seal company has paid in royalties to the United States government over six' million dollars and still owes $1,340,000. Over 33 million dollars of seal skins have been taken from the Alaska seas and near ly twice as much more inthe lisher ies,'while the gold product has aggre gated fifteen millions and increasing. Mr. Curtis quotes Seward as saying in reply to the question as to the most important act of his career: "The purchase of Alaska ; but it will take a generation to find it out." The same story may be told of the acquisition of Louisiana, which was to the greatness of the United States the critical event and turning point of the early period of the nation. The expansion program from the earliest days to the present lias not only met opposition and the sameopposition at each successive step, but has trium phantly downed it and gone on its way working out the greatness or the Union. Topeka Capital. v

See the clipping

Western Kansas World · Wakeeney, Kan.

The article quotes 19th-century congressional opponents of the Alaska purchase who called it worthless and a financial burden, then contrasts their predictions with the actual revenues generated from seal royalties, fisheries, and gold. It draws a parallel to contemporary debates over Philippine annexation, suggesting history is repeating itself with expansionist policy.

Western Kansas World · 29 April 1899 · page 2

HISTORY REPEATING ITSELF.

Transcript to come.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page