As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

July 1888

6 articles

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A Boston correspondent revives a Civil War-era story claiming the $7.2 million Alaska purchase money was actually payment for a Russian fleet that had patrolled American coasts to deter British/French intervention. The piece asserts Alaska itself was essentially a free byproduct, not something genuinely bought.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 25 days later.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 1 July 1888 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

ALASKA AS A PRESENT.

A Story that Uncle Samuel Never Really Purchased the Far-Away Land.

See moreSee less

Boston Special.

"Wilcox" contributes to this week's Congregationalist a bit of most interesting war history which has probably never before been made public. The purchase of Alaska was authorized by Congress on recommendation of Secretary Seward, and for reasons which did not seem adequate the fact seems to have been that the great sum of purchase money—$7,200,000—was not paid for Alaska at all. There was at one time imminent danger that England and France would unite in recognizing the confederacy and in raising our blockade of the Southern ports. Our navy was so small, and the demand for armed vessels along our immense coast so great and sudden, that no resort was left but chartering or purchasing abroad. Our government therefore contracted for a large and powerful Russian fleet. The vessels appeared on our coast, and for a considerable time were hovering about our northern harbors. There was much speculation as to their object. But at last they departed as mysteriously as they came. The dreaded exigency went by. It had become evident that no foreign government would side against us in the struggle for national existence. But the contract with Russia remained to be met. The expense of maintaining such a fleet in idleness was heavy. The whole bill amounted to $7,200,000. Russia wanted the money. The situation was very embarrassing. It was not safe to acknowledge to the country that so large a sum as the bill for this fleet was wanted for "a dead horse," a danger which had been feared but had passed away. The enemies of the administration would have made the land ring with their complaints at such extravagance. So the matter hung on from month to month, from year to year. The embarrassment was appreciated at St. Petersburg. It was therefore finally agreed that a bill should be urged through Congress, not to meet the bill for the fleet, but to purchase Alaska for the amount of the Russian claim. There was as much querying among Senators and members touching the odd $200,000 as there had been among the people on the Atlantic coast touching the errand of the fleet itself. Alaska, therefore, virtually was thrown in at the settlement for a debt contracted for a totally different purpose. Gen. W. T. Sherman, after the close of the war, made a considerable tour abroad. Among other cities he visited St. Petersburg, and was received and entertained with high honor. The facts as given above he received while there from some of the highest officers of the Russian government. When he expressed his surprise they were equally astonished that he was not already familiar with the whole matter.

Eggs by Weight.

New York Mail and Express.

"Isn't it strange that we buy and sell eggs by number instead of by weight?" observed a Washington Market dealer to a reporter.

"Number does not show their value; weight does. Some eggs weigh twice as much as others. What justice or business sagacity is there in paying the same price for one as for the other? Is not the farmer who sells a large egg for the same price that his neighbor sells a small one for cheated? And is not the buyer of the small one cheated? Just as well might butter be sold by rolls, the small roll bringing as much as the larger one. People do not buy or sell butter by the number of pieces or cheese by number; nor should the dealer sell eggs by number.

"If eggs were bought and sold by weight, the value of certain breeds of fowls would be changed. Now the breed that furnishes the greatest number of eggs is the most profitable; then it would be the breed that furnishes the greatest weight. Some broods are remarkable for the smallness of their eggs; such breeds would necessarily suffer in popularity, while the fowls that lay large eggs would gain. This would only work justice, however, to the fowls, as it would to their owners and consummers. Clearly, eggs should be sold by weight. When the committee of the Pure Foods Association wait on the Common Council again, as they propose to do shortly, they may be impelled to grant a corporation ordinance granting this request, which they refused in the past, no doubt because the question was not placed in a proper light and in such a manner as will show that the public at large will be the greatest gainers by the effect sought to be obtained."

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

This 1888 account claims the Russian fleet that visited American ports in 1863 was sent under a secret contract, and that the government, embarrassed to ask Congress to pay off this debt, disguised the payment as the purchase of Alaska. It cites General Sherman's later conversations with Russian officials in St. Petersburg as the source of this story.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Indianapolis Journal · 1 July 1888 · page 1

I I I I I 1 I ALASKA. AS A PRESENT. A Story that Unci Samuel Never Really Pur chased the Far-Awax Land. Boston Srecial. "Wilcox" contributes to this week's Con gregatiooalist a bit of most Interesting war his tory which has probably never before been made public Tbe purchase of Alaska was au thorized by Cod cress on recommendation of Sec retary Seward, and for reasons which did not seem adequate the fact seems to hare been that the (rreat sum of purchase money $7,200,000 was not paid for Alaska at all.

See moreSee less

There was at one time imminent dancer that England ani France would unite in recognizing the confederacy and in raisin four blockade of the; Southern ports. Our navy was so small, and the demand for armed vessels along our immense coast so great and sudden, that no resort was left but chartering cr purchasing abroad. Oar government therefore contracted for a large and powerful Russian fleet. The vessels appeared on our eoast, and for a considerable time were hovering about our northern harbors. There was much specula tion as to their object But at last they depart ed as mysteriously as they came. The dreaded exigency went by. It had become evident that no foreign government would side against us in tbe struggle for national existence. But tbe contract with Russia remained to be met The expense of maintaining such a fleet in idleness was heavy. The whole bill amounted to $7, 200,000. Russia wanted tho money. Tbe situ ation was very embarrassing. It was not safe to acknowledge to the country that so largo a sum as the bill for this fleet was wanted for "a dead horse." a danger which had been feared but had passed away. Tbe enemies of the adminis tration would have made tbe land ring with their complaints at such extravagance. So tbe matter hung on from month to month, from year to year. The embarrass ment was appreciated at St Petersburg. It was therefore finally agreed that a bill should be urged through Congress, not to meet the bill for the fleet but to purchase Alaska for the amount of the Russian claim. There was as much querying amonc Senators and members touching the odd $200,000 as thero had been among the people en the Atlantic eoast touching the errand of the feet itself. Alaska, therefore, virtually was thrown in "at the settlement for a debt contracted for a totally different purpose. Gen. "W. T. S Herman, atter the close of the war, made a considerable tour abroad. Among other citieA he visited St. Petersburg, and was re ceived and entertaned with high honor. Tbe facts as given above he received while there from some of the highest officers of tho Russian government. When he expressed his surprise they were equally astonished that he was not al ready familiar with tho whole matter. Eggs by Weight. New York Mail ami Express. "If n't it strange that we buy and sell egss by number instead of by weight! "observed a Wash ington Market dealer to a reporter. "Number does not show their value; weight does. Somo eggs weigh twice as much as others. What justice or business sagacity is there in paying the same price for one as for tho otberl Is not tbe farmer who sells a large egg for the same price that his neighbor sells a small one for cheated! Ana is not the buyer of the small one cheated! Just as well misht butter be sold by rolls, the small roll bringing as much as the larger one. People do not buy or sell butter by tbe number of pieces or cheese by number; nor should tbe dealer sell eggs by number. "If egea were bought and sold by weight the value cf certain breeds of fowls would be chanced. Now the breed that furnishes the greatest number of eges is the most profitable: then it would be toe breed that f urnishes the greatest weight Some broods are remarkable for the ema'.lness of their eggs; such breeds would necessarily suffer in popularity, while the fowl that lay large eggs would gain. This I would only work justice, however, to the fowls, as it would to their owners and consummers. Clearly, eggs should be sold by weight. When the committee of the Pure Foods Association wait on the Common Council again, as they propose to do shortly, they may b impelled to grant a corporation ordinance granting this re quest which they refused in the past, no doubt because the question was not placed in a proper light and in such a manner aa will show that the public at largo will be the greatest gainers by the effect sought to be obtained.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont.

A Boston correspondent relays a claim, sourced to Wilcox in the Congregationalist, that the $7.2 million paid to Russia was not really for Alaska but was a disguised settlement for a Russian fleet secretly chartered to deter British/French recognition of the Confederacy. The story claims the Alaska purchase was invented as a face-saving way to pay off this embarrassing wartime debt.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The New North-West · 6 July 1888 · page 2

A BIT OF INTERESTING WAR HISTORY. How "Uncle Sam" Came to Get Hold of Alaska.

tio BosToN, June 28.-[Special.] - Wilcox set contributes to this week's Congregationalist we a bit of most interesting war history 'which no probably has never before been made public. Tb The purchase of Alaska was authorized by He Congress on the recommendation of Secrethe tary Seward,iand for reasons which did not to seem adequate. The fact seems to have nac been that the great sum of. purchase money, qu $7,200,000, was not paid for Alaska at all. if There was at one time imminent danger that At England and France would unite in recogfur nizing the Confederacy, and in raising our del blockade of the Southern ports.

See moreSee less

Our navy of was so small and the demand for armed vesGr sels along our immense coast so great and oth sudden that no resort was left but chartering Th or purchasing abroad. Our government the therefore contracted for a large and powerful in I Russian fleet. we: The vessels appeared on our coast and for of I a considerable time hovered around our hot Northern harbors. There was much specuical lation as to their object but at last they dew, parted as mysteriously as they came. The whi dreaded exigency went by. It had become At evident there would be no foreign struggle for of ] existence but the contract with Russia reute malined to be met. The expense of mainme taining such a fleet in idleness was heavy. tiic The whole bill amounted to $7,200,000. Russia wanted the money. The situation was embarassing. It was not safe to ac knowledge to the country that so large a sum as the bill for this fleet was wanted for a "dead horse." A danger had been feared L but it had passed away. ay The enemies of the adminisatration would the

See the clipping

The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont.

The article recounts how a Russian fleet visited US ports during a tense period and Russia later wanted payment for its upkeep; rather than admit this cost to Congress, the purchase of Alaska was arranged to cover the debt, with the extra $200,000 added in. The source is attributed to Gen. Sherman, who heard it from Russian officials in St. Petersburg.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The New North-West · 6 July 1888 · page 2

A BIT OF INTERESTING WAR HISTORY.

WASHINGTON, Speclal.-A very notable programme has been arranged for the re ception of Mr. Blaine upon his arrival in this country about the last July. One who onght to know says the programme has been determined upon as follows: Excursions are to be arranged from all parts of the country to New York. A grand flotilla of ality, 7,407. steamers will meet the incoming steamer off Sandy Hook. A great number of Harrison and Morton clubs will escort him to the Fifth Avenue hotel, and there will be a re ception at the Union League club in the evening.

See moreSee less

At that time he will make a speech. He will then go to Augusts, where he will remain two weeks, and while there he will make an opening speech of the can tribal laws. vass. After that he will visit Boston, Phil adelphia, Pittsburg and Eastern cities, speaking frequently. From t;hicago a tour of the Northwestern states and territories has been planned to Oregon, returning by California, Colorado, Kansas, Indiana and Ohio. through Congress not to meet the bill for of the fleet but to purchase Alaska for the valu amount of the Russian claim. There was as much querying among the Senators and aba Members touching the odd $200,000 as there had been among the people on the Atlantic terd

See the clipping

The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

A travel correspondent describes the Aleut people's way of life on the Aleutian and Seal Islands, noting their reliance on the sea despite living on land. He also explains that the name 'Alaska' derives from a mispronunciation of the Aleut word 'Aliaska'.

The Oskaloosa Herald · 19 July 1888 · page 8

Niue persons out of teu whom I hear pro nounce the name of this race of Alaskan sat ages do so as if it were composed of but two syllables, A-looU being the most common version. On the islands them selves and throughout that general jiortion of Alaska the pronunciation is always in three syllables (and I, therefore, assume it to be correct), or, as If given phonetically, Ah-lee-oots, the accent on tho first syllable. A most interesting fact connected with this wrung pronunciation, more interesting, indeed, than the name of this particular tribe, is that the word “Alaska” itself is a mispronunciation of an Aleut word of more syllables, Alia ska; or It might be said, more politely, it is an Anglicizing of tho word, as the English and Americans inevitably murder a native word or phrase in some way in transferring it to their language.

See moreSee less

Alaska, as such, was not known to the

See the clipping

The Washington Critic · Washington, D.C.

A New York Mail and Express item reprinted in the Washington Critic recalls that Alaska's $7.2 million purchase from Russia was once derided as 'Seward's folly' but has since proven to be sound statesmanship. It cites fur, fishery, gold, and lumber revenues, plus fur-seal lease income, to argue the territory now generates far more value than its original cost.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 25 days earlier.

The Washington Critic · 26 July 1888 · page 3

nfit-M nt dentluution o ynlldato them for lie rttnni tnj). turn until Monday, Incliuiyo. the sum of $7,200,000 was at ono tlmo called "Seward's folly," lint (hulnpso of a little more thali two decades has proved that it was tin act of far-seeing statesmanship. Tho Alaska Commer cial Company pays to tho Govern

See the clipping