As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

May 1886

6 articles

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A letter from the man who served as U.S. Minister to Russia during the Alaska purchase disputes later claims that Seward alone deserved credit, arguing Lincoln as chief deserves the honor. He also describes his own diplomatic achievements in Russia, including telegraph rights, coal mining leases, and fur company privileges.

The Sun · 9 May 1886 · page 5

I have lately soon It la print for the first lime tbat William II. Baward said that tho on tat of bit Ufa most to bo proud of was tho fio qalsltlon of Alaska. This, to thou who are cot Ignorant of the faota. Is a romarkablo claim. As I was Minister Plenipotentiary from tfjo United States at Bt. Petersburtr, Russia, during the time of the purchase and addition of Alaska to th Union, and Sewnrd Becretnrr of Btate howovsr, we mleht both olalm to bo the poers of Lincoln In abllltr Lincoln was our chief, nd the honor of that expansion of territory bslones to him.

See moreSee less

It Is the General-in-Chief who wears the laurels of vlatorr. howover ealI lantlr his subordinates mar havo fousht. So far than, us Soward and myself are roncernod, I Ur the fact before the world for th award of honor,

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The writer recounts his own earlier negotiations with Russian officials over telegraph rights, Sakhalin coal mines, and fur company privileges in Alaska, claiming these laid the groundwork for the eventual transfer. He asserts that Seward negotiated the actual purchase but had no more claim to credit for it than Jefferson did for some unspecified precedent.

The Sun · 9 May 1886 · page 5

with England, which then soemed Immlnont. Collins and Blbley asked not only for a right of way through Alnokn.but for land grants for the lines and stations : all of which woro freely dis cussed by mo and Russlnn officials In a private and personal way. I found the roHOureos ol Alaska to bo beyoud prlco In minerals, and

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A letter writer, C.M. Culy, claims he had been negotiating with the Russian Fur Company for transfer of Alaska rights before the U.S. government's purchase, and argues Seward deserves no more credit for the deal than Jefferson did for Louisiana. He portrays himself as having 'ripened' the project that fell into Seward's hands.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Sun · 9 May 1886 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Still, the advantages of the transfer of Alaska were so apparent that, having sounded the Russian authorities, I had formal meetings with the Russian Fur Company, and the terms were all agreed upon, when the news came that Alaska was purchased outright by the United States. Seward sent me a treaty upon "trade marks," which I signed and delivered; but he negotiated the Alaska purchase, for which he had no more reason to claim credit than for Jefferson's

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

Governor Swineford of Alaska testified before the House Committee on Territories, urging passage of a territorial government bill. He declared that the U.S. got a bonanza when it purchased Alaska, citing its coal, gold, cereals, lumber, and fish resources.

Alexandria Gazette · 12 May 1886 · page 2

FROM WASHINGTON.

Governor Swyneford, of Alaska, was be fore the House Committee on Territories thi~ morning, urging the passage of a bill giving ihat territory a territorial form of government. He said the United States got a bonanza when it bought Alaska, in

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · and 1 other paper

Writing in the New York Sun, C.M. Clay argues that credit for acquiring Alaska belongs to President Lincoln rather than Secretary of State Seward, since Lincoln was the 'chief' during the purchase negotiations. Clay, who served as U.S. minister to Russia, also recounts his own role in securing telegraph and coal concessions from the Russian government around the same period.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The Indianapolis Journal · 13 May 1886 · page 2

Alone Should Have Credit for It. C. M. Clay, In New York Sun. I have lately seen it in print for the first time that Wm. H. Seward said that the one act of his life most to be prond of was the acquisition of Alaska. This, to those who are not ignorant of the facts, is a remarkable claim. As I was min ister plenipotentiary from the United States at St. Petersburg, Russia, during the time of the purchase and addition of Alaska to the Union, and Seward Secretary of State —however, we might both claim to be the peers of Lincoln in ability—Lincoln was our chief, and the bouor of that expansion of territory belongs to him.

See moreSee less

It is the general-in-chief who wears the laurels of victory, however gallantly his subor dinates may have fought. So far then, as Sew ard and myself are concerned, I lay the facts before the world for the award of honor. Collins, having explored the route from Amer ica, through Alaska, the Aleutian isles, and Si beria to St. Petersburg, united with Sibley, the president of the Western Union Telegraph Com pany, to extend their line to the Russian capital. They placed this project in my hands, and I got a very favorable charter from the Russian gov ernment, one clause of which was the privilege of a “rebate," or gratuity, in com mon phrase, for all words transmitted from the Pacific to St. Petersburg on Russian lines. Another project of mine was to secure to Ameri can citizens the perpetual lease of the splendid coal mines on the island of Saghalien, on the eastern coast of Russia. A third was the grant of the Russian Fur Company’s pfrivileges— for an equivalent—to an American company, in tbe vast regions of Alaska. Heretofore the Russian Pacific coast was not open even to foreign con sulships. but an American consulship was now allowed. These projects of mine were all coguate. The telegraph would free us from dependence on the enemies of the Union by lines in onr own possession. The coal mines of Saghalien were almost a necessity of our commerce with China, Japan and tbe Corea. And our acquisitions in Alaska would offer a combined force of Ameri cans and Russians against a war with England, which then seemed imminent. Collins and Sibley asked not only for a right of way through Alaska, but for land grants for tho lines and stations, all of which were freely dis cussed by mo and Russian officials in a private and personal way. I found tbe resources of Alaska to be beyond price in minerals, and fish eries, and forests, and furs, and commercial promise I wrote to Gov. John A. Andrew, of Massachusetts* and other distinguished citizens and capitalists, about these projects. A com pany was formed in San Francisco, and I was engaged to contract with the Russian Fur Com pany for a transfer of its chartered rights to the Americans. Everything was favorable, when Seward opened np his unfortunate Perkins claim aod completely disgusted the Russian autocrat and Gortchakoff with American projects. The Sag halieu enterprise was cut 6hort. The telegraph line was refused the “rebate" and dropped out, notwithstanding Collins, Sibley and I did all we could to have tbe terms confirmed which had been made by the Minister of Telegraphs, Count Tolstoi Still, the advantages of the transfer of Alaska were so apparent that, having sounded tho Rus sian authorities, I had formal meetings with the Russian Fur Compauy, and the terms were all agroed upon, when the news came that Alaska was purchased outright by the United States. Seward sent me a treaty upon “trademarks." which I signed and delivered; but he negotiated the Alaska purchase, for whioh he - had no more reason to claim credit than for Jefferson’s acqui sition of Louisiana. Taere was no American so odious to the Russians as Seward, and I had worked up the project and cultured the troe un til tbe fruit was ripe and fell, by the necessity of the case, into his basket.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Wessington Springs Herald · Wessington Springs, S.D. · 6 August 1886

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A writer recounts his own prior negotiations with Russian officials and the Russian Fur Company over Alaska's resources, claiming he had already secured favorable terms before Seward completed the purchase. He argues Seward deserves no more credit for the acquisition than Jefferson did for Louisiana, implying the groundwork was his own.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 128 days later.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 13 May 1886 · page 2

Alone Should Have Credit for It. C. M. Clay, In New York Sun. I have lately seen it in print for the first time that Wm. H. Seward said that the one act of his life most to be prond of was the acquisition of Alaska. This, to those who are not ignorant of the facts, is a remarkable claim. As I was min ister plenipotentiary from the United States at St. Petersburg, Russia, during the time of the purchase and addition of Alaska to the Union, and Seward Secretary of State —however, we might both claim to be the peers of Lincoln in ability—Lincoln was our chief, and the bouor of that expansion of territory belongs to him.

See moreSee less

It is the general-in-chief who wears the laurels of victory, however gallantly his subor dinates may have fought. So far then, as Sew ard and myself are concerned, I lay the facts before the world for the award of honor. Collins, having explored the route from Amer ica, through Alaska, the Aleutian isles, and Si beria to St. Petersburg, united with Sibley, the president of the Western Union Telegraph Com pany, to extend their line to the Russian capital. They placed this project in my hands, and I got a very favorable charter from the Russian gov ernment, one clause of which was the privilege of a “rebate," or gratuity, in com mon phrase, for all words transmitted from the Pacific to St. Petersburg on Russian lines. Another project of mine was to secure to Ameri can citizens the perpetual lease of the splendid coal mines on the island of Saghalien, on the eastern coast of Russia. A third was the grant of the Russian Fur Company’s pfrivileges— for an equivalent—to an American company, in tbe vast regions of Alaska. Heretofore the Russian Pacific coast was not open even to foreign con sulships. but an American consulship was now allowed. These projects of mine were all coguate. The telegraph would free us from dependence on the enemies of the Union by lines in onr own possession. The coal mines of Saghalien were almost a necessity of our commerce with China, Japan and tbe Corea. And our acquisitions in Alaska would offer a combined force of Ameri cans and Russians against a war with England, which then seemed imminent. Collins and Sibley asked not only for a right of way through Alaska, but for land grants for tho lines and stations, all of which were freely dis cussed by mo and Russian officials in a private and personal way. I found tbe resources of Alaska to be beyond price in minerals, and fish eries, and forests, and furs, and commercial promise I wrote to Gov. John A. Andrew, of Massachusetts* and other distinguished citizens and capitalists, about these projects. A com pany was formed in San Francisco, and I was engaged to contract with the Russian Fur Com pany for a transfer of its chartered rights to the Americans. Everything was favorable, when Seward opened np his unfortunate Perkins claim aod completely disgusted the Russian autocrat and Gortchakoff with American projects. The Sag halieu enterprise was cut 6hort. The telegraph line was refused the “rebate" and dropped out, notwithstanding Collins, Sibley and I did all we could to have tbe terms confirmed which had been made by the Minister of Telegraphs, Count Tolstoi Still, the advantages of the transfer of Alaska were so apparent that, having sounded tho Rus sian authorities, I had formal meetings with the Russian Fur Compauy, and the terms were all agroed upon, when the news came that Alaska was purchased outright by the United States. Seward sent me a treaty upon “trademarks." which I signed and delivered; but he negotiated the Alaska purchase, for whioh he - had no more reason to claim credit than for Jefferson’s acqui sition of Louisiana. Taere was no American so odious to the Russians as Seward, and I had worked up the project and cultured the troe un til tbe fruit was ripe and fell, by the necessity of the case, into his basket.

See the clipping