As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

January 1871

3 articles

Wyandot County Republican · Upper Sandusky, Ohio

The Washington Star criticizes Senator Sumner for opposing the acquisition of Santo Domingo while noting the inconsistency of his earlier support for the Alaska purchase, which it derides as paying gold for a worthless frozen iceberg. The editorial contrasts Alaska unfavorably with the supposedly valuable, fertile island of Santo Domingo.

Wyandot County Republican · 5 January 1871 · page 3

The Washington Star, which has never been suspected of a lack of independence by the most virtuous of correspondence, has the following on Senator Sumner: We doubt if Mr. Sumner oa review ing his positiou finds it exactly sat isfactory. Usually when he has taken a step in advance of his party it has been to plaut himself upon some broad principle, where he was quite sure to be followed sooner or later. But he can expect no consid erable following on the narrow little plank ot opposition to the acquisi tion of San Pomingo.

See moreSee less

And he must expect to encounter very gen Tal ctnsure lor his willingness to disrupt the Republican party on this petty issue of the San Domingo business, the more especially cs he was the zealous advocate of the purchase of frozen Alaska, Mr. Sum ht is thus placed iu the illogical position of aiding in paying millioi s in gold for the purchase of an out-of-the-way ice berg in "Nova Z.'ir bla or the Lord knows where," and opposing with passionate violence the acquisition of a valuable fertile island affording U3 a footholt in the Gulf, necessary for the protection of our national interests Mr. Sumner will find, we take it, that not cvtn his name and abilities will not en. able him to give dignity to his in. consistent raid upon a measure of administrative policy proposing to extend the national domain in a manner gratifying to the pride snd sen respect or tuo American peo ple.

See the clipping

The Workingman's Advocate · Chicago, Ill.

This 1871 article advocates for creating a National Park, addressing cost concerns by referencing the Cleveland Leader's point that the U.S. managed to purchase Alaska for seven million dollars even while deeply in debt from war. The piece argues a Park would be a profitable investment, potentially saving money currently spent by Americans traveling to Europe.

The Workingman's Advocate · 21 January 1871 · page 2

Yankee fashion by referring to the purchase of Alaska at a cost of se ven millions of dollars in gold, and at a time when we were heavily in debt and

See the clipping

Memphis Daily Appeal · Memphis, Tenn.

An advertisement for J. S. Davis's jewelry invokes the mocked Seward purchase of Alaska, claiming a newly discovered 'Alaska Diamond' quartz stone proves the land's value by rivaling genuine Brazilian diamonds in beauty and brilliance. It promotes the stones, mounted in 18-carat gold, as affordable luxury items available only briefly in Memphis.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Memphis Daily Appeal · 29 January 1871 · page 4

JOSEPH COLL, 7 Main street. Ths Dailt Appkal can be had on the day ofite issue of S. A. Wells, News Agmt, at all points between Memphis snd Little Rock, for 11.50 per month. Fins French corsets, odd sizes to close, at SI 60, worth $3, So. When William H. Seward negotiated for the purchase of Alaska it was little thought that it would be of any benefit to the Called States, but it has turned out differently, for in ths discovery oi the Alaska Diamond there has been tonnu a stone, which in beauty, durability and brilliancy is unexcelled by the Brazilian Diamond.

See moreSee less

It is cut from Alaska quartz, and when polished to the highest degree is conceded to be tbe only rival of the gen¬ uine diamond, pos sensing all tha hard ness, lustre and brilliancy ot that stonex J, S. Davis has lately introduced these Syria la this city, and whoever has seen them hav 4 pronounced them equal to the finest diamond in brilliancy. The Alaska diamond is mounted in 18 carat gold, by the finest diamond workmen. In the most stylish and elaborate manner, and the cost is less than one-sixteenth thst of the Brazilian diamond, bringing the prices within the reach of all. J. 9. Davis. 317 Main street, is the sole agent for them goexls, and as his stsy in Memphis i lim¬ ited von ahonld make your purchases. You may never have tbe opportunity again. In short, to bo appreciated the el¬ egant novelties shonld be seen.

See the clipping