As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

December 1870

3 articles

The Cambria Freeman · Ebensburg, Pa.

A political editorial denounces President Grant's advocacy for annexing Santo Domingo, comparing his rhetoric to Secretary Seward's earlier praise of Alaska as a 'great prize.' The piece mocks Alaska as 'barren, sterile and frozen' while criticizing both acquisitions as costly political schemes.

The Cambria Freeman · 15 December 1870 · page 2

It was to be expected that after the Bignal failure cf the San Domingo job last summer, at tbe hands of a Republican Senate, that corrupt scheme had been consigned to well merited oblivion. But the prize is loo tempts ing to be lightly abandoned, and Grant sur passes all his former efforts, in his advocacy of this venal project. He calls it "a great prize' just as Seward, his illustrious pred ecessor in the purchase of real estate, styled the acquisition of barren, sterile and frozen Alaska. To Grant's vision everything in

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The editorial argues Senator Sumner is being inconsistent by opposing the acquisition of Santo Domingo while having previously championed the purchase of Alaska, dismissively called an 'out-of-the-way ice-berg.' It also reports rumors that Secretary Boutwell may be forced from the Cabinet due to his association with Sumner over the Santo Domingo controversy.

Evening Star · 23 December 1870 · page 2

Domingo. A-'l be nrisf expect to enco-intet rrrr general censnre for his willingness to dis j r ipt the republican party on tht? petty issue el j t Sai> Domingo business, the more especially | at he was the zealous advocate of the purchase t <>' irozeu Alaska. Mr. Sumner is thus placed

See the clipping

The Evansville Daily Journal · Evansville, Ind.

The report criticizes Senator Sumner for attacking President Grant over the Santo Domingo annexation resolutions, suggesting his real motive was anger over the recall of Minister Motley rather than principled opposition. It points out the irony that Sumner had used his influence and eloquence to push through Seward's Alaska purchase treaty, yet now opposes a similarly expansionist measure.

The Evansville Daily Journal · 29 December 1870 · page 2

Confirmatory of this opinion is tho known fact that Senator Sumner used all his knowledge cf precedents and all his eloquence, to crowd through the Senate Mr. Seward's treaty for the purchase oZ Alaska.' There is not an iste'ligoct voter in the land that docs not know that the possession of San Domingo by this country is far more desirable than Alaska. Indeed, the latter is of no use whatever now, and is neve likely to be; wL.il ua iomiozo m3vin time become an absolute I uecssity to this country. We are opimI,.

See moreSee less

,B0r.fin .TJ.nr , : ; at present under ., the circumstances in which the question of annexation ;omes up but we think Senator Sum ner cannot, with any consistency, crit icise the motives of the President and others who do favor the project.

See the clipping