As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

February 1870

3 articles

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands

Ex-Secretary Seward toured Alaska, the territory he helped acquire from Russia, and was publicly received by the people of Sitka on the 12th of last month, giving a speech praising its prospects. The report notes his enthusiasm might seem overstated for a younger man, but suggests the territory may prove even more valuable than the purchase's supporters originally believed.

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 19 February 1870 · page 4

I WJial Mr. SrwnrJ thinka fit. j Ex-Sccretary Seward has been upon a visit to the country which he was instrumental inacquir i in; from lusia for our (iovernment. On the J 12th of last month he was publicly received by i the people of Sitka and made them a speech, in which he gave his impressions of Alaska in lan ; guage which, coming from a younger man, might J be suspected of being rather too highly wrought ! for the truth. He has, however, undoubtedly spoken a good deal of troth in regard to our ter ritory ; and the years to come may prove it to be much more valuable than even the friends of the purchase puppofcI. In reading Mr. Seward's

See the clipping

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands

The report quotes extensively from a speech by Seward praising Alaska's climate, comparing it favorably to New York and Washington, and claiming its coastline exceeds 20,000 miles. The paper notes this coastline figure should be taken with some skepticism.

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 19 February 1870 · page 4

of its more nnnortant passages. lie makes the statement that the coast line of Alaska, including wrinkled foreheads. If we coul l only the islands adjacent, is 20,000 miles in extent, more than double that of all the rest of the United States. It will do to take this statement with some grains of allowance. Alluding to the reports of the sterility of the escapement we have carried so long beneath our ! W1S? get at them, as we lie on our pillows and count the j dead beats of thought after thought and image ! after image jarring through the over-tired organ ! j Will nobody block thoe wheels, uncouple that !

See the clipping

West-Jersey Pioneer · Bridgeton, N.J.

The article mocks Secretary Seward for buying Alaska from Russia for seven million dollars, citing a government agent's report that the territory is economically worthless. It claims Alaska lacks valuable furs, usable coal, good fisheries, timber, ice, and any crops, predicting it will cost $38 million over 25 years with no return.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 64 days later.

Wrong

West-Jersey Pioneer · 25 February 1870 · page 2

There are a few seal skins, but not enough to be of account—there is some coal but it is only good for gas, and it is hardly worth while to light Alaska as yet with that ma

See the clipping