As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

January 1870

6 articles

Bedford Inquirer · Bedford, Pa.

A Mexico City newspaper lauds William H. Seward's arrival in the capital as a remarkable event, marveling at the speed of his journey from New York through Alaska to Mexico. It praises him as a great American statesman who has seen all extremes of climate, peoples, and civilization.

Bedford Inquirer · 7 January 1870 · page 1

MEXICAN OPINION OF HON. Wl. H SEWARD. A City of Mexico paper, of recent date, contains the following. The arrival of Mr. Seward in this capital is the most note worthy and remarkable event of the year for Mexico. This great American diplomat has performed a mighty journey in a rela tively short time. Within the confines of the past century it would have required three years to have made this circuitous journey from New York to Mexico. Passing the legendary West of his own country, he has already contemplated all the zones of the world with their varied productions.

See moreSee less

He has been where he could treat with the five colors into which the human race is classed. He has seen the extremes of civilization and and of the temperature of the globe. Be tween New York, Alaska and Mexico there is nearly everj thing for which tbe mind may long. There are Camanches, ice, gold, M urinous, Chinese, bears, tigers, philoso phers, artists, debauchees, sugar cane, 1 quicksilver, coal, iron pearl, rabies, em ! cralds, topaz, opals, bisons; wild horses, Aztecs. Spaniards, and Mexicans, about which a book may be written full as in teresting as the Thousand and One Nights. Mr. Scwa r d will probably let tbe book re main impressed upon his groat mind only until the proper day comes for its publica tion. 11c will soon ret urn to be saluted by j and to salute his neighbors at Auburn. This trip appears to him as ordinary as though it were a holiday at Niagara. In our country there are few, we hope, who do not realize the glorious figure represented by tbis great statesman in our history, (jrand as the name of Seward stands upon the roll of the legion of honor where are embossed the names of the great actors in the United ■States' war of tbe rebellion, to us, to Mexicans all, his name stands still higher. When the darksome days of our war against the schemes of Europe hung their black mantle like a funeral pall over the cradle of liberty, Mr. Seward said to arrogant Napoleon, "Away from our continent." The crest fallen army of France rolled up itbanners and marched down the slopes of tbe Cordilleras to embark from Mexico on their ignominious retreat to sunny France,

See the clipping

Worcester Daily Spy · Worcester, Mass.

A Washington correspondent warns that figures once tied to lobbying for the Russian-American Alaska treaty—Judge O'Sullivan and a reporter named Noah, allegedly paid $1,000 in gold by the Russian minister—are now pushing for Santo Domingo annexation. The writer implies the same corrupt network profited from Alaska and hopes to profit again from Caribbean expansion.

Worcester Daily Spy · 11 January 1870 · page 1

Washington, D. C., Jan. 9, 1870. SAN DOMINGO AND ANNEXATION. “Monsieur Tonson’s come again.” Alaska is a sore subject with me, and I am not now going to reopen it. I only desire to suggest that it excites my suspicions when I see some of those who were engaged in the interests of Russia at that time, busily at work now forwarding the Samana Bay matter. That we have got to make ourselves felt in the gulf, among the islands of the Caribbean Sea, I well understand, and will favor any reasonable plan by which this may lie accomplished.

See moreSee less

But I “fear the Greeks even when they come with presents,” and am sus picious of what lies behind all movements en gineered by diplomats, lobbyists of the Judge O’Sullivan and Mr. Noah stripe. O’Sullivan was very active in support of the Alaska treaty, but declared it was only on account of his friendship for Mr. Seward. Noah was the Cali fornia reporter whom the Russian minister, with such amazing unsolicited generosity, sent SIOOO in gold, for his equally unsolicited sup port of the Alaska purchase. I am told that Judge O’Sullivan is the only banker at

See the clipping

Worcester Daily Spy · Worcester, Mass.

An 1870 editorial on proposed annexation of San Domingo cites the earlier Alaska purchase treaty as a precedent for how the House's constitutional power over appropriations was overridden by executive treaty-making. The writer warns against repeating the secretive 'pig in a poke' pattern used with Alaska, urging full public disclosure of the San Domingo deal's terms.

Worcester Daily Spy · 11 January 1870 · page 1

SAN DOMINGO AND ANNEXATION.

has the right to originate appropriations. Gen. Banks declared when he urged the passage of the Alaska appropriation bill, that treaties in volving the expenditure of money ought to be first approved by the house, i. e. in some way its approval must be obtained before a treaty

See the clipping

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

This 1870 editorial argues that U.S. territorial acquisitions since 1803, including California, Texas, and other western lands, have yielded immense economic returns despite initial costs. It defends Seward's purchase of Alaska against mockery, predicting it will yield at least ten million dollars in furs, seal oil, and fish within a decade, while also discussing proposed annexations of St. Thomas and Dominica.

The New York Herald · 15 January 1870 · page 7

On the other hand, with all these territorial acquisitions and expansions since 1803 tho area of the United States (excluding Alaska, itself a great empire in extent,) has been more than doubled, and we have a population of forty millions, and universal liberty and equality under the law are fixed in "the supreme Law of the land." Putting all the costs in money, to the North and South, in one bill, of the terrible struggle which extin guished American slavery at ten thousand mil lions of dollars, we are still richer to-day.

See moreSee less

South and North, than we were on the momentous opening of the rebel fire on Fort Sumter. But what would have been the end of a war with slavery had our national boundaries remained as in 1 803 ? It would have been the end of tho United StateB. Perhaps, howovor, the "gentleman from Ver mont" has been cured of the annexation policy by Mr. Seward's purchase of the icebergs of /Alaska for $7,200,000, and his treaty for the earthquake island of St. Thomas, calling for $7,500,000 moro. St. Thomas, we grant, if purchased, would be a sell. Alaska, on the other hand, will probably within ten yeare yield us at least ten millions of money in furs, Beal oil, codfish and salmon. And what of the I direct question of the annexation of Dominica, on the basis of the assumption of the <Jcbt of

See the clipping

Cedar Falls Gazette · Cedar Falls, Iowa

A short satirical item ridicules former Secretary of State William Seward for dancing 'jigs' with Mexican officials, calling it the silliest act he's done since the Alaska purchase. The piece uses the Alaska purchase as an established example of Seward's foolishness to mock his current conduct.

Cedar Falls Gazette · 21 January 1870 · page 3

RAILING.

Van Saun, Wilson A Co. BAIXINO.—About the silliest ca par, Bill Seward has cut since ll is Alaska purchase, is his dancing "Jigs" with the barbarians of Mexi CO. We expect boys and some old jn9U to be fooling away their time in «aeh a way, but for a statesman, gen tleman, scholar and Real Estate Bro iler to be dancing with a lot of quad foms of the Mexican persuasion is allly in the extreme. FESTIVAL.—The Ladies of tho 'Jfrpsbyterian Church and Society, will hold a Levee and Oyster Supper,

See the clipping

Chicago Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

The piece discusses two pending Senate treaties to acquire Caribbean territory: Seward's plan to buy St. Thomas from Denmark for $7.5 million, and Admiral Porter's scheme to annex Santo Domingo. It references Alaska's purchase price as a comparison point, calling it 'ice-bound Alaska' under Seward's 'vaunted American policy.'

Chicago Tribune · 31 January 1870 · page 2

SAN DOMINGO AND ST. THOMAS.

MONDAY, 3ANCABY 31,11870. fiAff DOMINGO ASD 81. THOMAS. Two treaties, looking to the Acquisition of territory in the >7651 Indies, are pending before the Senate. One is a legacy from the Secretary of State, to whose Taunted American policy we owe the annex* ation of ioe-bonnd Alaska; the other is a gift—that is, the idea, not the money to cany it Into execution—from Admiral Porter to the nation. Mr. Seward's treaty ' contemplates the purchase, from Denmark, for $7,500,000 —about the cost of Alaska— of St. Thomas, an island twenty-three

See the clipping