A review of Hal G. Evarts' book 'The Passing of the Old West' describes the sequential disappearance of beaver, buffalo, wild pigeon, and other wildlife as dollar-seeking Americans overran nature. The book is framed as an indictment of this exploitation, culminating in the hunting of elk in Yellowstone Park.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 13 November 1921 · page 24
WEST. My Hal CI. Evai ts. Uttl| Brown & Co., MOKton. i In thin bool; the passing of tho oil I tVest in unfolded?the di?nppe?ianc[ jfi'st. of the beaver, then the buffn.ll then the wild pigeon, noxt the timboil
A reader writes to the Evening Public Ledger asking whether any wild creatures besides the buffalo and passenger pigeon have been exterminated in the United States. The paper responds citing naturalist Louis Agassiz Fuertes, who says about fifty species of birds and animals have been exterminated in the country, with others nearing extinction.
Evening Public Ledger · 14 November 1921 · page 13
Questions Answered Extinct Wild Animals 7"e tlie Editor e the Vvenine Public I.tdier: Plr H-vve any wild creatures besides the buffalo and passenger pigeon been exter minated in the United States? .7 .7. C.
A wildlife extermination feature mentions that the passenger pigeon, which once darkened the skies 60 years earlier, mysteriously disappeared. It frames this alongside bison and other vanishing American wildlife as examples of man's conquest over nature.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Bisbee Daily Review · 23 November 1921 · page 4
CALL OF THE WILD S your job monotonous? How would you like to quit It and become one oi 1 the wild animal hubters etmployedTiy'trVe" UnitecTStates government? In six jeara those hunters have killed, by gun and trap, 156,150 wild beasts in the werst. Poison baits snuffed out the lives of many more. Cattle now are safer. The official hunters' victims included 17,842 bobcats and lynxes. 668 mountain JionB, 133,604 coyotes and 3,636 wolves. It would be rather disheartening to meet these beasts if they could be herded together in one snarling, roaring, howling mob.
See moreSee less
But they would soon kill each other off like humans, going to war. A rat and a peaceful songbird are about the only form of wild animal life In Bisbee. Living in our intricate civilization, it Is hard to believe that wild beasts jiill infest America in the numbers killed by the government hunters. They are making their last stand. They ore all that is left of savage four-legged prowlers that once dominated our whole country, keeping primi tive man terrified. Monster dinosaurs, sable-toothed tigers, camujs and hairy mammoths these ruled America before the coming of man. Horses, brought to America by Spanish explorers, multiplied into huge numbers of wild mustangs. Burfaloes, which once roamed the western plains by tlrfe millions, now are within a few thousand of extinction. The passenger pigeon, which 60 years ago darkened the 8kies with its ast flocks, mysteriously disappeared.
Wisconsin farmers near Beetown report seeing flocks of birds they identify as the old wild pigeon of pioneer days, insisting they are not mistaking them for mourning doves. The article notes ornithologists maintain the species is extinct, framing the claims as recurring, unverified folk reports.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.
Wrong
Grant County Herald · 23 November 1921 · page 2
SEVERAL WILD PIGEONS SEEN AT BEETOWN
clare the Birds Are Real Thing. Is the wild pigeon of pioneer days extinct? Or are the stories of the species being seen nowadays a myth? Such storibs bob up with frequency ami true or not they serve to keep alive one of the most interesting forms of wild lite as the pioneer knew it. Certain it is that the famous wild pigeon of the old days whose great numbers darkened the sky in their an nual migrations lias disappeared. But why, on the other hand, do orni thologists contend so persistently that the bird is not only a rara avis but en tirely extinct?
See moreSee less
Anyhow—here’s the story: James Frankland and Thos. Lou thain, Beetown farmers, claim they have seen good sized flocks of wild pigeons on their farms in the past few weeks. Frankland says he saw a flock while he was shredding corn three of four weeks ago. The flock had about twenty birds in it. Mr. Frankland knew the wild pigeon in the early days and claims there is no doubt but what the birds he saw are of the same type. Mr. Louthain saw ten or twelve birds that he is sure are wild pigeons at numerous times. But this isn’t all—Frank Tebo, another well-known farmer, says he has seen the Beetown wild pigeons numerous times. Frank says the un learned call the birds “wild doves” but they are simply unlearned and unfamiliar with the famous species. Do wild pigeons still exist? Stories are frequently afloat that rare flocks of the bird of pioneer days are still in existence. As is well known this county in the early days was a. com mon habitat of these birds. Anyhow, Mr. Frankland. Mr. Louthain and Mr. Tebo and others living in the wooded recesses of Beetown say on their oath they have seen them. The story is an interesting one.
Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.
This Thanksgiving feature recalls the vast abundance of wild game in early colonial New England, citing accounts from settlers like William Hilton, Thomas Morton, and William Wood describing turkeys, waterfowl, and pigeons in overwhelming numbers. It notes that wild pigeons once darkened the sky in such multitudes that they broke tree branches, while also mentioning the extinction of the great auk and decline of wild turkey populations.
Shepherdstown Register · 24 November 1921 · page 7
game will be a part of the bill of fare. Before that first Pilgrim Thanksgiving the governor sent out four men j to shoot wild fowl, of which they "did take suck great store" as sufficed for the needs of the little setlement for a week. Game was plenty?how plenty can be judged from some of the early writers. jonn >mun, wno expiorea those coasts a few years before the Pilgrims landed, had found the natural food resources of the region to be very great. William Hilton, who wrote in 1622, said that "the land affords beasts of diverse sorts, and great flocks of turkeys, quail, pigeons and partridges." Thomas Morton of Merrymount fame,
Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.
The article recalls the former abundance of game birds like turkeys, great auks, and passenger pigeons in colonial New England, contrasting it with their later extinction or near-extinction. It notes a long-standing $2,000 reward for proof of a living passenger pigeon went unclaimed, and urges readers to practice moderation during Thanksgiving hunting season.
Shepherdstown Register · 24 November 1921 · page 7
* Sl.50 Gets the Register a year ty-pound gobler. The great auk nest: cd as far south as Massachusetts Bay and on islands off Newfoundland had teen slaughtered by millions to fur msn iooa ror tne nsnermcn wno naa their summer settlements on Damariscove Island long before any white foot touched Plymouth Rock. Great flocks of swan whitened the waters of all the bays along the coast, and geeso lay in masses that were well named "rafts." Wild pigeons, in spring and fall, darkened the sky and settled on trees in such numbers that they broke I the branches.
See moreSee less
The mornings were murmurous with the "talking" of the ducks and the days musical with the : piping of shore birds. But the last great auk was killed early in the nineteenth century, the last wild turkey in Massachusetts was taken on Mount Tom in 1852, and for years there stood, with no claimants, . a prize of two thousand dollars for any proof that there is one living passenger pigeon anywhere in the world. As we enjoy Thanksgiving and the hunting season, let us be a little mindful of our ancestors' mistakes as i well as of their manifold virtues, and by moderation and restraint do our bit to keep the day of feasting and prayer imm uci.uiiiiiik a uay 01 Tasting ana
This 1921 feature laments the extermination of American wild animals by government hunters and civilization, listing bobcats, wolves, buffalo, and mustangs. It briefly notes the passenger pigeon, which once darkened skies 60 years earlier, 'mysteriously disappeared.'
The passenger pigeon, which 60 years ago darkened the skies with Its vast flocks, mysteriously disappeared. It1 is the same all over the world animal life being exterminated by the cold, cruel Intellect of man. Even do mesticated animals eventually will pass out. Auto and airplane will end the horse. Laboratories, producing milk and synthetic meat, will doom cattle. Then man will be supreme, except for his battle with germs. Civilization began when men banded together against their common enemy, wild beasts. , War devices were, first invented for the conquest of animal life.
See moreSee less
Then men turned them against each other. With wild beasts exterminated, a fu ture and more perfected civilization will have no use for rifles, pistols, dag gers and traps. Those devices some day will exist only in museums where future intellec tuals will study the barbarians of 1921. The first real step in that direction Is now being taken in Washington.
A newspaper filler anecdote recounts J. L. Swadner's recollection of seeing immense flocks of wild pigeons in northern Indiana as a boy, including a story of a single shotgun blast downing eighty-two birds. The piece notes the species is now extinct.
The St. Joseph Observer · 26 November 1921 · page 8
On ono occasion ho was driving along behind another man In n wagon, when tho latter raised his hand and motion ed to Swadner to stop. Then reaching down In his wagon for his nnclent nuuzlo loading shot gun, he drew bead on a flock of wild pigeons that were ecklng at beech nuts by tho road (Ide. When the rest flow away, there icmalned behind on tho ground eighty-two wild pigeons, dead or wounded, which was surely some pot