As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

October 1921

12 articles

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

A 'Forty Years Ago, 1881' column reprinted in 1921 recalls that wild pigeons that season equaled any in local history, with hunters bagging 111 and then 97 birds within days. The item is part of a nostalgic roundup of old local news including marriages, deaths, and fairs.

Mineral Point Tribune · 6 October 1921 · page 5

Harris by Rev. Chase. News of the death of George Mitchell, a son of our city, at his new lowa home, has been received. Mr. J. J. Ross of this place was awarded 14 first premiums out of 15 en tries of cattle at the Darlington fair. The number of wild pigeons in this section will equal that of any season in our history. Last Thursday, Henry Tyack and Sammy Harris secured 111

See the clipping

Pueblo Chieftain · Pueblo, Colo.

A reader's question-and-answer column asks whether any wild creatures besides the buffalo and passenger pigeon have been exterminated in the United States. Naturalist Louis Agassiz Fuertes is cited as saying several species have been exterminated while others are nearly extinct, though the buffalo itself survives with nearly 10,000 living.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Grant County Herald, 14 September 1921, The Weekly Times-Record, 29 September 1921.

Pueblo Chieftain · 8 October 1921 · page 9

United States government be In 1922? — H. F A. The estimated income of the United States government for 1922 Is $4,450,000,000. Q. Is there any estimate of the loss of life in Russia due to plague and famine?—O. F. A. Gorky, the Russian author, in his plea for help from the United States, said that 300,000 Russians were dying dally from epidemic disease and star vation. Q. Have any wild creatures besid s the buffalo and passenger pigeon been exterminated in the United States.’— V. T.

See the clipping

Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · Wilmington, Del.

A newspaper advice column answers reader questions on varied topics, including one asking if other wild creatures besides the buffalo and passenger pigeon have been exterminated in the US. The answer, citing naturalist Louis Agassiz Fuertes, states about 50 species have been exterminated while others are near extinction, and notes nearly 10,000 buffalo still survive.

Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · 8 October 1921 · page 4

QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS

T nl*ed States Govermr»"nt be In 1922" t H. F. ■ A, The estimated Income of the ■ United States Government for 1022 is 14,450,000,000. Q. Is there nny estimate of the Ions of lift in Russia due to plague and famine? o. F. A. Gorky, th Russian author, ln his plea for help from the United States, said that 300,000 Russians were dying dally from epidemic disease and star vation. Q, Have any wild creatures hr sides tho buffalo nnd passenger pigeon been exterminated in the United States? V. r A.

See moreSee less

Lxmf* Agassiz Fuerf.-s, the well known naturalist, says that about 50 species of blnls and animals have b»en exterminated In this country while several others are on tho vergv of extermination. The buffalo Is not extinct, there being nearly lO.OOfl liv ing buffaloes In th» United State« today. Q. What natl«)n has the largest Navy in the world and wh«»re does the United Slates Navy rank? S. U. R.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A library acquisitions list includes J.C. French's 1919 book 'The Passenger Pigeon in Pennsylvania' among natural history titles. The entry is purely bibliographic, offering no narrative detail about the species itself.

Evening Star · 16 October 1921 · page 71

Ealand. C. A. The Romance of the Microscope. MB-EaT>5r. French. J. C. The Passenger Pigeon f in Pennsylvania. 1919. PE-F>84p. Hudson. W. H. Birds of La l*TT?Ta. 2 . v. PE-HS64bl. Johnston, Sir 14. H. The Backward , People. PX-Jf?4G.

See the clipping

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

A publisher's advertisement describes a new book chronicling the disappearance of the buffalo and the wild pigeon as part of the vanishing wildlife of the Old West. It is framed as an indictment, in story form, of the toll pioneer expansion took on nature.

The New York Herald · 16 October 1921 · page 84

ntemporary fiction. Sl.90 vet. OLD WEST I"! ^mmmm na ha West is unfolded?the disappearof iffalo, then the wild pigeon, next Io\ roads made on the wild life of idictment in story form of the Plf ran over the lovers of nature and wt on

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This is a publisher's advertisement for Hal G. Evarts' book 'The Passing of the Old West,' which laments the vanishing of the buffalo and the 'wild pigeon' as emblematic losses of frontier America. It frames the passenger pigeon's disappearance as part of a broader nostalgic narrative about the closing of the West.

New-York Tribune · 16 October 1921 · page 69

THE PASSING OF THE OLD WEST

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Free Trader-Journal and Ottawa Fair Dealer · Ottawa, Ill.

A report on game bird conservation notes that bobwhite quail populations are declining in several states due to habitat loss from farming. It invokes the passenger pigeon's near-extermination as a cautionary parallel for what could happen to other game birds if not protected.

Free Trader-Journal and Ottawa Fair Dealer · 18 October 1921 · page 6

the old settlers may yet live to a return t . their tables of thai hichlv n w remembered only as a half-for-birds do take a small toll of grain or their keeping? It is little enough they destroy in their search for food tl n. provide vv nen tnev i rk that has been ai: ui i d these nrize trame r r, hl,-e the iry, have been nearly exterminated. may i s iaw d still i: birds, being niempassenger pigeons of

See the clipping

The Ocala Banner · Ocala, Fla.

This 1921 editorial reflects on a past speech by Henry Clay praising America's self-sufficiency and isolation, contrasting it with later realities. It notes that wild pigeons, once darkening the skies, had by then become entirely extinct, alongside vanishing buffalo herds, as evidence that such optimism no longer held true.

The Ocala Banner · 21 October 1921 · page 6

It is true that when Mr. Clay de livered his musical oration those then living were not troubled with the gaunt fear of want for the woods abounded in game, both large and small, but not so any longer. The most salutary laws are required to prevent their extermination. The im mense herds of buffaloes no longer exist and that animal is now seen only in captivity and the wild pigeons that formerly darkened the earth have thus early become entirely extinct. The country was so self-sufficient, Mr. Clay is quoted as saying that it would never need additional territory, yet it is possible—when that speech was delivered —the United States flag did not float over Texas and the vast domain that we acquired from Mexi co: it certainly did not float over Alaska, the Hawaiian Islands, the

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A letter to the editor warns that the prong-horn antelope, once more numerous than the buffalo, is nearing extinction due to settlement and wanton killing by sheep herders in Oregon and Nevada. It cites the passenger pigeon and buffalo as earlier examples of superabundant species that vanished before advancing civilization.

New-York Tribune · 23 October 1921 · page 27

On the Vergeof Extinction?Wan? ton Killing Reported To the Editor of The Tribune. . Sir: The prong-horn antelope is one of the^very few North American ani? mals peculiar to tho continent and without close relations anywhere in the world. It formerly ranged from near the Mississippi River west to the Pacific Ocean, and from western Canada south well into Mexico. In primitive times, and indeed within the memory of living men, it was the most abundant of the larger animals of the plains?more numerous, many of us believe, than the buffalo, whose numbers have always been so talked about. Likje many other wild crea? tures that formerly were enormously numerous?the wild pigeon and the

See the clipping

The Lakeland Evening Telegram · Lakeland, Fla.

A 1921 opinion column by Robert F. Clark argues for protecting birds like quail for pest control, noting that species such as the parakeet, prairie chicken, and passenger pigeon have vanished due to careless hunting. It warns that killing birds upsets nature's balance against insects, which could become humanity's next great struggle.

The Lakeland Evening Telegram · 24 October 1921 · page 2

OBSERVATIONS

The passenger pigeon, once very numerous, has entirely disappeared. By killing the birds 'a bal ance of nature to control insects is being upset. The expense of fighting insect pests is increasing.

See the clipping

Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo.

A correspondent shares a fifty-years-ago newspaper clipping mentioning wild pigeon shooting at Ironton, prompting the writer to recall witnessing an enormous flock darken the sky in February 1870. He claims the pigeons vanished suddenly and completely within a few years, calling it an inexplicable mystery.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 18 days later.

Wrong

Iron County Register · 27 October 1921 · page 3

before the season opens. According to government reports, quail are more plentiful this season than ever before, due to the two previous mild winters and good breeding seasons. This report says that the birds are as plentiful in other sections of the coun try as In the Ozarka. Following is the Farminoton Times' Btory of the base ball game at Farmington October 16th': "Before the game with the Arcadia Valley team began, considerable time was wasted, apparently without adequate reason. While the visitors were warming up it became apparent that the home boys would be kept busy, and it was here -they soon realized that they were in sore need of Forshee's puz zling delivery, as the visitors ex perienced no difficulty in finding Clawson, and he was really batted out of the box some time before the local manegement appeared to realize that fact.

See moreSee less

Unfortunately, a controversy arose oyer a decision, and consider able more daylight was "burned" be fore play was resumed. In the ninth inning it became apparent that some of that wasted daylight would be very essential in finishing the . game as the shades of night draw down very quickly at this season of the year. At the end of the seventh in ning it was decided to "call it a day," owing to the darkness, with a score 10 to 6 in favor of Arcadia Valley. But In the brief period Forshee operat ed in this game a tightening of the line b was noticeable throughout the local line-up, which came with added confidence in the boxman's ability to deliver, and bad daylight lasted awhile longer there is good reason to believe Farrmngton would have over come the visitors' lead. But, while that is a very good alibi, it has no bearing on the actual result of the game." The Annual Agriculture and Stock Show hele in Farmington last Friday and Saturday, while not so elaborate as the county fairs formerly held in St. Francois county, was a decided success and reflected much; credit up on the citizens of Farmington and vi cinity. The writer "laid off" Friday and in company with several other Irontonians motored to Farmington and took in the show in its entirety The exhibits were all very fine, full of interest and calculated to build up and improve conditions in thatcommuni ty; they also furnished valuable in formation and suggestions to visitors, especially to those engaged in agri cultural and kindred pursuits. Farm ington has long been celebrated for its hospitality and its reputation was fully sustained on this occasion, every citizen, evidently, constituting him self a committee of -one to make things pleasant for "the stranger. within her gates." After spending the greater portion of the day in Farm ington we motordd out to the farm of Mr. Maurice Highley, who lives on the Farmington-Flat River road.three and a half miles north of Farmington, to sea his flock of beautiful thorough bred Angora goats, headed by a genu ine South African buck. No single feature of the stock show was more interesting than this. Mr. Highley is vice-president of the American An gora Goat Breeders' Association, or ganized in 1900, which maintains the only record of pure bred Angora goats in America. This information is giv en here so that our readers who mayl be interested in goat raising may know where to obtain thoroughbred stock at reasonable figures. Under date of October 13, my young friend, Mr. Kelton E. White, St Louis, writes me: "My dear Mr Ake The enclosed item may interest you. and recall to your memory the early days in Ironton. I am wonder ing what the next fifty years will bring forth, and where our quail, song birds and sqnirrels will be. I am afraid the ruthless hunter with the automatic and pump gun will an nihilate them, the same as he has the wild pigeon and the fast disappear ing deer and wild turkey." Enclosed with the foregoing was a clipping from a city paper under the beading "Fifty Years Ago Today." One of the items in the clipping reads: "Wild pigeon shooting is the pastime at Ironton, Mo." It does indeed recall a condition thai is but a memory. The wild pigqon has gone from us forever, leaving not a trace to mark his departing way. Before that -time their numbar might have been al most likened to the sands upon the seashore. They were known to every locality in this broad dominion north, east, south and west and so common as to give little zest to the sportsmen. One afternoon in Febru ary, 1870, whIe traveling between Eminence and Alton, the sun brightly shining, my attention was arrested by a sudden darkening of the air. Looking upward I beheld an appar ently solid mass of pigeons winging the way to their evening "roost." Fully ten minutes elapBed before the feathery cloud had passed. Evident ly the . flock numbered millions. A few years later not a wild pigeon re mained. The disappearance of game has been gradual with the advance of settlement and civilization, but the wild pigeons all disappeared in a single night: for forty years not one has been seen or heard of. A reniarkable, inexplicable circumstance, before the season opens. According to government reports, quail are more plentiful this season than ever last Thursday. before, due to the two previous mild winters and good breeding seasons. City last week. This report says that the birds are as plentiful in other sections of the coun caller Saturday. try as In the Ozarka. Following is the Farminoton Times' Btory of the base ball game at Farmington October 16th': "Before the game with the Arcadia Valley team began, considerable time was wasted, apparently without adequate reason. While the visitors were warming up it became apparent that the home boys would be kept busy, and it was here -they soon realized that they were in sore need of Forshee's puz zling delivery, as the visitors ex Pilot Knob. perienced no difficulty in finding Clawson, and he was really batted out of the box some time before the local ville, Illinois. manegement appeared to realize that fact. Unfortunately, a controversy arose oyer a decision, and consider Columbia, Mo. able more daylight was "burned" be fore play was resumed. In the ninth inning it became apparent that some Louis Sunday. of that wasted daylight would be very essential in finishing the . game as the shades of night draw down Hogan Saturday. very quickly at this season of the year. At the end of the seventh in ning it was decided to "call it a day," owing to the darkness, with a score 10 to 6 in favor of Arcadia Valley. But In the brief period Forshee operat ed in this game a tightening of the line b was noticeable throughout the ing. . ' local line-up, which came with added confidence in the boxman's ability to deliver, and bad daylight lasted awhile longer there is good reason to believe Farrmngton would have over brother Harold. come the visitors' lead. But, while that is a very good alibi, it has no bearing on the actual result of the game." The Annual Agriculture and Stock Show hele in Farmington last Friday and Saturday, while not so elaborate as the county fairs formerly held in St. Francois county, was a decided Lard, 12c a lb. success and reflected much; credit up on the citizens of Farmington and vi cinity. The writer "laid off" Friday and in company with several other Irontonians motored to Farmington and took in the show in its entirety The exhibits were all very fine, full of interest and calculated to build up and improve conditions in thatcommuni ty; they also furnished valuable in formation and suggestions to visitors, especially to those engaged in agri cultural and kindred pursuits. Farm ington has long been celebrated for its hospitality and its reputation was fully sustained on this occasion, every citizen, evidently, constituting him self a committee of -one to make things pleasant for "the stranger. within her gates." After spending the greater portion of the day in Farm ington we motordd out to the farm of Mr. Maurice Highley, who lives on the Farmington-Flat River road.three and a half miles north of Farmington, to sea his flock of beautiful thorough bred Angora goats, headed by a genu ine South African buck. No single feature of the stock show was more interesting than this. Mr. Highley is vice-president of the American An gora Goat Breeders' Association, or ganized in 1900, which maintains the only record of pure bred Angora goats in America. This information is giv en here so that our readers who mayl be interested in goat raising may know where to obtain thoroughbred stock at reasonable figures. Under date of October 13, my young friend, Mr. Kelton E. White, St Louis, writes me: "My dear Mr Ake The enclosed item may interest you. and recall to your memory the early days in Ironton. I am wonder ing what the next fifty years will bring forth, and where our quail, song burdened hearts. birds and sqnirrels will be. I am afraid the ruthless hunter with the automatic and pump gun will an nihilate them, the same as he has the wild pigeon and the fast disappear ing deer and wild turkey." Enclosed with the foregoing was a clipping from a city paper under the beading "Fifty Years Ago Today." One of the items in the clipping reads: "Wild pigeon shooting is the pastime at Ironton, Mo." It does indeed recall a condition thai is but a memory. The wild pigqon has gone from us forever, leaving not a trace to mark his departing way. Before that -time their numbar might have been al most likened to the sands upon the seashore. They were known to every locality in this broad dominion north, east, south and west and so common as to give little zest to the sportsmen. One afternoon in Febru ary, 1870, whIe traveling between Eminence and Alton, the sun brightly shining, my attention was arrested by a sudden darkening of the air. Looking upward I beheld an appar the convention. ently solid mass of pigeons winging the way to their evening "roost." Fully ten minutes elapBed before the feathery cloud had passed. Evident ly the . flock numbered millions. A few years later not a wild pigeon re mained. The disappearance of game has been gradual with the advance of settlement and civilization, but the wild pigeons all disappeared in a single night: for forty years not one has been seen or heard of. A reniarkable, inexplicable circumstance,

See the clipping

Evening Public Ledger · Philadelphia, Pa.

A publisher's advertisement promotes Hal G. Evarts' book 'The Passing of the Old West,' which chronicles the disappearance of beaver, buffalo, the wild pigeon, and timberlands. The passage is a literary review/ad rather than direct reporting on the pigeon's extinction itself.

Evening Public Ledger · 29 October 1921 · page 19

By HAL G. EVARTS This is the story of hew the priceless possessions of the great West vanished first the beaver, then the buffalo, then the wild pigeon, next the timberlands nnd finally of hew the wild life of the Yellow stone Park is being gradunlly exterminated. ROOSEVELT : THE HAPPY WARRIOR

See the clipping