The Sun · New York, N.Y.
The report describes multiple testified sightings of passenger pigeons in Connecticut, New York, and Long Island after the species' last known individual died in 1914. It notes that past sighting reports upon investigation turned out to be mourning doves, yet presents the new testimonies as encouraging evidence the species may still exist.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Sun · 4 January 1919 · page 6
The Passenger Pigeon
displayed l;ccn IntetllRcncc In special izing In the cultivation of the soil, and by complying with certain high standards In marketing what they raise they have been able to make a name or their State that Is worth dollars tn them In every market In the world. The application of such enlightened methods to territory now Included In Mexico would unquestionably rcult In greatly lticreaslne the yield of the land. Hut the feelings of Mexico arc to be considered. Moreover, the United Stutes must proceed slowly In annex ing land. The Latin American repub lics hnvc undergone a long, thorough, Intensive campaign deslgupd to con vince their people that wc arc con stantly eeeklng to gobble them up, and the mot Innocent proposal for the extension of United Stntcs territory should bo studied not only from our viewpoint but frflm the viewpoint of continental solidarity ond good will before it Is approved.
See moreSee less
A Question Answered. Oar neighbor the World has asked editorially a question to which the answer seems obvious: "What do thcoe critics of the rrcl dent mean who Insist that ho has no mandate to spak for the United States at the peoco table?" We hac not observed that the question of the President's right to sneak for the United States "at the peace table" has yet come Into focu. The "peace table" K not quite ready for Its occupants. If nny critic of the President is questioning his man-dala-lo spenk for tho United States we suppose the doubt thus expressed concerns the preliminary public spoeches hich he has made and Is to make as "the spokesman of Amer ican opinion." And wc suppose fur ther that any such doubts as to the validity of his mandate have their origin In the President's own declara tion, in his appeal to the American voters on October So, that the fail ure to return a Democratic majority In cither houso of Congress "would be Interpretative on the other side of the water ns a repudiation of my leadership." The Tasccnger Pigeon; Are passenger pigeons returning? F. H. Mansose, vice-president of tbe Connecticut State Hoard of Fisheries aud Game, and E. L. CurtiSjS of Forestvlllo In the Nutmeg Stat1, boih testify that at Granlss Pond, Ston ington, they observed last May thri' passenger pigeon lurched on a dead tree not more than fifty feet away from them. One was a Urn? specimen of the full Hedged cock pigeon, with the markings; another was n full grown hen pigeon, and the third indi vidual wax a yearling cock, with slightly mottled breast. Hoth men being members of the Forestvllle Fishing Club they urged the other members to make further observation. G. W. WoosTr.it on June 2 observed all three bird and W. K. Parker noticed the no old birds seven das later. All the men nre over (50 years old. and In their boy hood days were familiar with the passenger pigeon. The evidence holds out hope. In Science of November 1 there appears a statement that three bird studenu saw n small flock of passenger plgeoiii between West Galwoy and Charlton, N. Y. Some of our Great South Bay oystcrmen and Daymen Insist that a few of thec bird'- may be seen mi grating every year along the southern shore of Ixmg Island. Since the death on September 1, li14. In the Zoological Garden nt Cin cinnati, of what was gpnerally be lleed to be the last surviving pas senger pigeon, there have been numei ou reports of the sighting of pas senger pigeons, but on Investigation the birds have proved to be mourn ing doves. At attempt w-as made in 3010 to find an undisturbed net of the pas senger pigeons, and although more than $3,00Qwas offered in reward, to the discoverer of one and the offer held good for several years no award was ever collected. Suite rewards of $100 were offered with the same end In view In New York. New Jersey, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Pennsyl vania, Illinois and Michigan, where the passenger pigeon once was pro lific, but Cmios, Kuseb, Uorkoughs, Kinnev, Avis, Mebshon, Thayer, Grinnkj.l and Hodge, and others In terested In the passenger pigeon, had their checks returned to them. Civilized man was the exterminator of the bird. Millions of birds were brought down by systematic "daughter for the market and the pot by the shotguns clubs and nets of the earli est American pothunters. How could a bird, even though its numbers once darkened the skies, stand mch slaugh ter as whs Involved in a dally ship ment of three carloads for forty days? The town of Hartford, 5Ilch., did that lu 1SC0. The total was estimated at 11,$80,000 bird. In two years an other Michigan town marketed 13, S40.000 birds. In 1R4S Massachusetts gravely passed a law protecting the nettow of wild pigeons. There was a flue of S10 for damaglug nete or frightening pigeons awny from them. Pigeon slaughter was n legitimate industry. In 1SC7 New York came to the con clusion that the wild pigeon needed protection, but the following year saw Its last great nesting, the last roost ing being In 1&7.". Michigan gave the birds protection in 1800 and Pennsyl vania not until 1878. Massachusetts In 1S70 gave, protection to the birds that once were sold for 12 cents a dozen. Tho millions of passenger pigeons were so suddenly exterminated that It was hard tn bellee that they were extinct. Assertions were numerous that the birds that formerly ranged from the Atlantic coast westward to the Hocky Mountains had "taken ref uge in South America or in Mexico," his stock. Alexander Wilson, the pioneer Amer ican ornithologist, onco estimated the number of passenger pigeons at 2,230. 272,000; no wonder wasteful Ameri cans regarded them as food for hogs. That the bird regarded as extinct has been seen again will make ob servers particularly watchful during the nesting time of 1910. Perhaps the American Ornithologists Union will come forward again with nn offer of rewards In the hope 'of finding n nest ing pair or colony of these birds. The Stop on Promotion Abroad. Tho stopping or promotions In the American Expeditionary Force Imme diately after the signing of tbe ar mistice is a matter which probably will be considered in Congress in due old domestic cow. time. Meanwhile tbe resentment of officers and their friends is reflected in complaints of which the letter elsewhere on this page Is typical. From a letter which appears In the Army and A'arj ,oumol and which was written by an officer In France on November 20, It is evident that the