As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

January 1919

21 articles

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The report describes multiple testified sightings of passenger pigeons in Connecticut, New York, and Long Island after the species' last known individual died in 1914. It notes that past sighting reports upon investigation turned out to be mourning doves, yet presents the new testimonies as encouraging evidence the species may still exist.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Sun · 4 January 1919 · page 6

The Passenger Pigeon

displayed l;ccn IntetllRcncc In special izing In the cultivation of the soil, and by complying with certain high standards In marketing what they raise they have been able to make a name or their State that Is worth dollars tn them In every market In the world. The application of such enlightened methods to territory now Included In Mexico would unquestionably rcult In greatly lticreaslne the yield of the land. Hut the feelings of Mexico arc to be considered. Moreover, the United Stutes must proceed slowly In annex ing land. The Latin American repub lics hnvc undergone a long, thorough, Intensive campaign deslgupd to con vince their people that wc arc con stantly eeeklng to gobble them up, and the mot Innocent proposal for the extension of United Stntcs territory should bo studied not only from our viewpoint but frflm the viewpoint of continental solidarity ond good will before it Is approved.

See moreSee less

A Question Answered. Oar neighbor the World has asked editorially a question to which the answer seems obvious: "What do thcoe critics of the rrcl dent mean who Insist that ho has no mandate to spak for the United States at the peoco table?" We hac not observed that the question of the President's right to sneak for the United States "at the peace table" has yet come Into focu. The "peace table" K not quite ready for Its occupants. If nny critic of the President is questioning his man-dala-lo spenk for tho United States we suppose the doubt thus expressed concerns the preliminary public spoeches hich he has made and Is to make as "the spokesman of Amer ican opinion." And wc suppose fur ther that any such doubts as to the validity of his mandate have their origin In the President's own declara tion, in his appeal to the American voters on October So, that the fail ure to return a Democratic majority In cither houso of Congress "would be Interpretative on the other side of the water ns a repudiation of my leadership." The Tasccnger Pigeon; Are passenger pigeons returning? F. H. Mansose, vice-president of tbe Connecticut State Hoard of Fisheries aud Game, and E. L. CurtiSjS of Forestvlllo In the Nutmeg Stat1, boih testify that at Granlss Pond, Ston ington, they observed last May thri' passenger pigeon lurched on a dead tree not more than fifty feet away from them. One was a Urn? specimen of the full Hedged cock pigeon, with the markings; another was n full grown hen pigeon, and the third indi vidual wax a yearling cock, with slightly mottled breast. Hoth men being members of the Forestvllle Fishing Club they urged the other members to make further observation. G. W. WoosTr.it on June 2 observed all three bird and W. K. Parker noticed the no old birds seven das later. All the men nre over (50 years old. and In their boy hood days were familiar with the passenger pigeon. The evidence holds out hope. In Science of November 1 there appears a statement that three bird studenu saw n small flock of passenger plgeoiii between West Galwoy and Charlton, N. Y. Some of our Great South Bay oystcrmen and Daymen Insist that a few of thec bird'- may be seen mi grating every year along the southern shore of Ixmg Island. Since the death on September 1, li14. In the Zoological Garden nt Cin cinnati, of what was gpnerally be lleed to be the last surviving pas senger pigeon, there have been numei ou reports of the sighting of pas senger pigeons, but on Investigation the birds have proved to be mourn ing doves. At attempt w-as made in 3010 to find an undisturbed net of the pas senger pigeons, and although more than $3,00Qwas offered in reward, to the discoverer of one and the offer held good for several years no award was ever collected. Suite rewards of $100 were offered with the same end In view In New York. New Jersey, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Pennsyl vania, Illinois and Michigan, where the passenger pigeon once was pro lific, but Cmios, Kuseb, Uorkoughs, Kinnev, Avis, Mebshon, Thayer, Grinnkj.l and Hodge, and others In terested In the passenger pigeon, had their checks returned to them. Civilized man was the exterminator of the bird. Millions of birds were brought down by systematic "daughter for the market and the pot by the shotguns clubs and nets of the earli est American pothunters. How could a bird, even though its numbers once darkened the skies, stand mch slaugh ter as whs Involved in a dally ship ment of three carloads for forty days? The town of Hartford, 5Ilch., did that lu 1SC0. The total was estimated at 11,$80,000 bird. In two years an other Michigan town marketed 13, S40.000 birds. In 1R4S Massachusetts gravely passed a law protecting the nettow of wild pigeons. There was a flue of S10 for damaglug nete or frightening pigeons awny from them. Pigeon slaughter was n legitimate industry. In 1SC7 New York came to the con clusion that the wild pigeon needed protection, but the following year saw Its last great nesting, the last roost ing being In 1&7.". Michigan gave the birds protection in 1800 and Pennsyl vania not until 1878. Massachusetts In 1S70 gave, protection to the birds that once were sold for 12 cents a dozen. Tho millions of passenger pigeons were so suddenly exterminated that It was hard tn bellee that they were extinct. Assertions were numerous that the birds that formerly ranged from the Atlantic coast westward to the Hocky Mountains had "taken ref uge in South America or in Mexico," his stock. Alexander Wilson, the pioneer Amer ican ornithologist, onco estimated the number of passenger pigeons at 2,230. 272,000; no wonder wasteful Ameri cans regarded them as food for hogs. That the bird regarded as extinct has been seen again will make ob servers particularly watchful during the nesting time of 1910. Perhaps the American Ornithologists Union will come forward again with nn offer of rewards In the hope 'of finding n nest ing pair or colony of these birds. The Stop on Promotion Abroad. Tho stopping or promotions In the American Expeditionary Force Imme diately after the signing of tbe ar mistice is a matter which probably will be considered in Congress in due old domestic cow. time. Meanwhile tbe resentment of officers and their friends is reflected in complaints of which the letter elsewhere on this page Is typical. From a letter which appears In the Army and A'arj ,oumol and which was written by an officer In France on November 20, It is evident that the

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The article recounts the 1914 death of the last known passenger pigeon in Cincinnati and reviews repeated unverified sighting reports since then, noting failed reward offers for finding an active nest. It also surveys the history of market slaughter and belated legal protections across several states that failed to prevent extinction.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 34 days earlier.

The Sun · 4 January 1919 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

displayed keen intelligence in specializing in the cultivation of the soil, and by complying with certain high standards in marketing what they raise they have been able to make a name for their State that is worth dollars to them in every market in the world.

The application of such enlightened methods to territory now included in Mexico would unquestionably result in greatly increasing the yield of the land. But the feelings of Mexico are to be considered. Moreover, the United States must proceed slowly in annexing land. The Latin American republics have undergone a long, thorough, intensive campaign designed to convince their people that we are constantly seeking to gobble them up, and the most innocent proposal for the extension of United States territory should be studied not only from our viewpoint but from the viewpoint of continental solidarity and good will before it is approved.

See moreSee less

A Question Answered.

Our neighbor the World has asked editorially a question to which the answer seems obvious:

"What do these critics of the President mean who insist that he has no mandate to speak for the United States at the peace table?"

We have not observed that the question of the President's right to speak for the United States "at the peace table" has yet come into focus. The "peace table" is not quite ready for its occupants. If any critic of the President is questioning his mandate to speak for the United States we suppose the doubt thus expressed concerns the preliminary public speeches which he has made and is to make as "the spokesman of American opinion." And we suppose further that any such doubts as to the validity of his mandate have their origin in the President's own declaration, in his appeal to the American voters on October 25, that the failure to return a Democratic majority in either house of Congress "would be interpretative on the other side of the water as a repudiation of my leadership."

The Passenger Pigeon.

Are passenger pigeons returning? F. H. Manrose, vice-president of the Connecticut State Board of Fisheries and Game, and E. D. Curtiss of Forestville in the Nutmeg State, both testify that at Graniss Pond, Stonington, they observed last May three passenger pigeons perched on a dead tree not more than fifty feet away from them. One was a fine specimen of the full fledged cock pigeon, with the markings; another was a full grown hen pigeon, and the third individual was a yearling cock, with slightly mottled breast.

Both men being members of the Forestville Fishing Club they urged the other members to make further observations. G. W. Wooster on June 2 observed all three birds and W. K. Parker noticed the two old birds seven days later. All the men are over 60 years old, and in their boyhood days were familiar with the passenger pigeon.

The evidence holds out hope. In Science of November 1 there appears a statement that three bird students saw a small flock of passenger pigeons between West Galway and Charlton, N. Y. Some of our Great South Bay oystermen and baymen insist that a few of these birds may be seen migrating every year along the southern shore of Long Island.

Since the death on September 1, 1914, in the Zoological Garden at Cincinnati, of what was generally believed to be the last surviving passenger pigeon, there have been numerous reports of the sighting of passenger pigeons, but on investigation the birds have proved to be mourning doves.

At attempt was made in 1910 to find an undisturbed nest of the passenger pigeons, and although more than $3,000 was offered in rewards to the discoverer of one and the offer held good for several years no award was ever collected. State rewards of $100 were offered with the same end in view in New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, Illinois and Michigan, where the passenger pigeon once was prolific, but Childs, Kuser, Burroughs, Kinney, Avis, Mershon, Thayer, Grinnell and Hodge, and others interested in the passenger pigeon, had their checks returned to them.

Civilized man was the exterminator of the bird. Millions of birds were brought down by systematic slaughter for the market and the pot by the shotguns, clubs and nets of the earliest American pothunters. How could a bird, even though its numbers once darkened the skies, stand such slaughter as was involved in a daily shipment of three carloads for forty days? The town of Hartford, Mich., did that in 1869. The total was estimated at 11,880,000 birds. In two years another Michigan town marketed 15,840,000 birds.

In 1848 Massachusetts gravely passed a law protecting the netters of wild pigeons. There was a fine of $10 for damaging nets or frightening pigeons away from them. Pigeon slaughter was a legitimate industry. In 1867 New York came to the conclusion that the wild pigeon needed protection, but the following year saw its last great nesting, the last roosting being in 1875. Michigan gave the birds protection in 1869 and Pennsylvania not until 1878. Massachusetts in 1870 gave protection to the birds that once were sold for 12 cents a dozen.

The millions of passenger pigeons were so suddenly exterminated that it was hard to believe that they were extinct. Assertions were numerous that the birds that formerly ranged from the Atlantic coast westward to the Rocky Mountains had "taken refuge in South America or in Mexico." Alexander Wilson, the pioneer American ornithologist, once estimated the number of passenger pigeons at 2,230,272,000; no wonder wasteful Americans regarded them as food for hogs.

That the bird regarded as extinct has been seen again will make observers particularly watchful during the nesting time of 1919. Perhaps the American Ornithologists Union will come forward again with an offer of rewards in the hope of finding a nesting pair or colony of these birds.

The Stop on Promotion Abroad.

The stopping of promotions in the American Expeditionary Force immediately after the signing of the armistice is a matter which probably will be considered in Congress in due time. Meanwhile the resentment of officers and their friends is reflected in complaints of which the letter elsewhere on this page is typical.

From a letter which appears in the Army and Navy Journal and which was written by an officer in France on November 20, it is evident that the

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Brattleboro Daily Reformer · Brattleboro, Vt.

The report cites a Connecticut game official's claim to have seen several passenger pigeons, suggesting the species may not be extinct after all. It notes a $1,500 reward once offered for an undisturbed nest went unclaimed.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Brattleboro Daily Reformer · 6 January 1919 · page 8

NOT EXTINCT AFTER ALL.

probably also made of dissolved cotton. Which is not mentioning the awful fact that her favorite movie hero never could strut across the silver screen were it not for the dissolved cotton which I. useii us me oasis or nuns. "All these women who have been winding cotton bandages for the Red , k,1,)Wl1 as ' be passenger pigeon, may be Cross are probably wholly ignorant of I a f:ut of in port a ir-t in connection the fact that the wounds which will : "vvitliour future food supply. The later be dressed with those bandages I American Game Protective association are inflicted bv cotton made into appears to credit the testimony of n smokeless powder and other forms of ammunition bv the dissolving process.

See moreSee less

"This is a funny world, sure enough. 'has seen several stecimens of this once Nobody knows what is what most evplentiful species. It is only a few years erything is something else, isn't it?" since a reward of $.1,000 was offered And he hurried away, his arms f ull f or one undisturbed nest of this bird ot various colored sateen and hair and was unclaimed. It has been brushes and the jvearls which had once been a cotton boll. AS OTHERS SEE US. NOT EXTINCT AFTER ALL. Reported the "Passenger Pigeon' i3 Cnce More in Evidence. The rejKirted return of the North American - wild commonly pigeon. snortsman. the vice president of the Connecticut State Game board, that he com monly supposed that when the last known individual of the species died in captivity in the Cincinnati Zoologi

See the clipping

The Brattleboro Daily Reformer · Brattleboro, Vt.

The report recalls that the last known passenger pigeon died in captivity at the Cincinnati Zoological Gardens on Sept. 1, and that living persons still remembered flocks so vast they darkened the sky. It cites Audubon's estimate of a single flock containing 1,250,000,000 birds consuming enormous quantities of food.

The Brattleboro Daily Reformer · 6 January 1919 · page 8

NOT EXTINCT AFTER ALL. Reported the "Passenger Pigeon' i3 Cnce More in Evidence. The rejKirted return of the North American - wild commonly pigeon. snortsman. the vice president of the Connecticut State Game board, that he com monly supposed that when the last known individual of the species died in captivity in the Cincinnati Zoologi cal Gardens on Sept. 1 the passenger pigeon had become extinct. There are persons still living who can remember the great flights of pigeons which in their time literally darkened the sun. flense column eight or ten volume , miles loner were not uncommon, and calEurope.

See moreSee less

Un onrr Audubon estimated that the avllock contained . 1,250,000,000 and that they consumed more S.500.000 bushels of mast in a day's feeding. Their habit of setting at roosting time in great bodies as big as hogsheads ,011 limbs of trees made them easy to kill and the slaughter was mioviirvi.; V.-en llils lintt'flvir rtu1il but I i imi'dlv have accounted for the complete disappearance ot the species, the last , .... j riii vn 11 r.i .tOiri cinnaj the " 1 . .v.. nvevioii :miffl i-Jineo nf which in has been set bv naturalists as April, l!0ti. One great nesting ground, four by twenty-eight miles, is reported to have existed in Michigan as late as 1S80. The complete and sudden disappear ance or a whole speciesf lormerly so prolific, gave an almost romantic, tinge to scientific speculation upon the sub ject. One theory was advanced that this was due to an epidemic; another was that n great storm had driven the birds far out to sea during a migration and that they had perished en masse These were. mere guesses, and no proof was ever adduced. v Rediscovery of the lird, therefore, possesses exceptional interest to lovers of wild game. The assistant curator of birds at tlu Xew York Zoological Gar dens is authority for the statement that it can be bred in captivity with comparative ease. There is hope that it may bp re-established on the conti-.

See the clipping

The Brattleboro Daily Reformer · Brattleboro, Vt.

This fragment discusses hunting the passenger pigeon from the market hunter's perspective, noting that while true sportsmen find little interest in it, market hunters view it differently due to the food value of the birds. It suggests the species could be re-established on the continent by protecting breeding grounds.

The Brattleboro Daily Reformer · 6 January 1919 · page 8

"Their prisons are places of pleas-1 f.enger pigeon lacks interest, but the

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

The article reports multiple claimed sightings of passenger pigeons after the species' last known individual died in captivity in 1914, including testimony from elderly Connecticut sportsmen and bird students in New York. It notes that previous sighting reports, when investigated, turned out to be misidentified mourning doves.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 8 January 1919 · page 4

From the New York Sun. ARE passenger pigeons returning? F. H. Manrose, vice president of the Connecticut state board of fisheries and game, and E. D. Curtiss of Forestville in the Nutmeg state, both testify that at Graniss Pond, Stonrng ton, they observed last May three passen ger pigeons perched on a dead tree not more than 50 feet away from them. One was a fine specimen of the full fledged cock piogeon, with the markings; an other was a full grown hen pigeon and the third individual was a yearling cock, with slightly mottled breast.

See moreSee less

Both men being members of the For e: tville Fishing club they urged the other members to make further observations. G. VV. Wooster on June 2 observed all three birds and W. K. Parker noticed the two old birds Seven days later. All the mer. are over 60 years old, and in their beyhood days were familiar with the pas senger pigeon. The evidence holds out hope. In Science of November 1, there appears a statement that three bird students saw a small, fleck of passenger pigeons between West Galway and Charlton, N. Y. Some of our Great South Bay oystermen and bay men insist that a few of these birds may be seen migrating every year along the southern shore of I -ong Island. Since the death on September 1, 1914, in the Zoological Garden at Cnicinnatl, of what was generally believed to be the last surviving passenger pigeon, there have been numerous reports of the sighting of passenger pigeons, but on investigation the birds have proved to be mourning doves. An attempt was made in 1910 to find an undisturbed nest of the passenger pigeons, and although more than $3000 was offered in rewards to the discoverer of one and the offer held good for sev eral years no award was ever collected. State rewards of $1000 were offered with the same end in view in New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, Connecti cut, Pennsylvania, Illinois and Mich igan, Wtjjere the passenger pigeon once was prolific, but Childs, Kuser, Bor

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

The article recounts the history of passenger pigeon hunting, protective laws, and massive population estimates before the species' sudden extinction. It notes unconfirmed claims the bird had been seen again, fueling hope among ornithologists for a surviving nesting colony.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 8 January 1919 · page 4

THE PASSENGER PIGEON F. H. Manrose, vice president of the Connecticut state board of , roughs, Kinney, Avis, Mershon, Thayer Grinnel and Hodge and others inter ested in the passenger pigeon, had their checks returned to them. Civilized man was the exterminator of the bird. Millions of the birds were brought down by systematic slaughter for the market and the pot by the shot guns, clubs and ' nets of the earliest American pothunters. How could a bird, even though its numbers once darkened the skies, stand such slaugh ter as was involved in a daily ship ment of three carloads for 40 days?

See moreSee less

The town of Hartford, Mich., did that in 1869. The total was estimated at 11,880,000 birds. In two years an other Michigan town marketed 15,840, 000 birds. In 1848 Massachusetts gravely passed a law protecting the netters of wild pig eons. There was a fine of $10 for dam aging nets or frightening pigeons away from them. Pigeon slaughter was a le gitimate industry. In 1S67 New York came to the conclusion that the wild pigeon needed protection, but the follow ing year .saw its last great nesting, the last roosting being in 1875. Michigan gave the birds protection in 1S69 and Pennsyl vania not until 1878. Massachusetts in 1870 gave protection to the birds that once were sold for 12 cents a dozen. The millions of passenger pigeons were so suddenly exterminated that it was hard to believe that they were extinct. Assertions were numerous that the birds that formerly ranged from' the Atlantic coast westward to the Rocky mountains had “taken refuge in Soutl^America or in Mexico." Alexander Wilson, the pio neer American ornithologist, once esti mated the, number of passenger pigeons at 2,280,272,000; no wonder wasteful Amer icans regarded them as food for hogs. That the bird regarded as extinct has been seen again will make observers par ticularly watchful during the nesting time of 1919. Perhaps the American Or- • nithologists’ union will come forward again with an offer of rewards in the hope of finding a nesting pair or colony of these birds.

See the clipping

Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo.

The report recounts a claim that a member of the Connecticut Game Commission had seen several passenger pigeons, a species believed by most to be gone from North America. It notes the skepticism this claim provoked, recalling Audubon's accounts of the bird's former overwhelming abundance.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Iron County Register · 9 January 1919 · page 4

lady friends, and I take this opporT1 .... ri n iirria nhi h .m ii i - tnnitvtntein.hm thnir H.ii . . oi iur. ana Mrs. 6vuu-nm ia Krpnnna rlia tA. v.u,'.i.:.i . ..j. ...... . -f-ui luuuBDza, iiiuuiui6utiw!eui, uoupiess tnemi Thnp....J..J ,. . If I were the arbiter of their destinies, "h J ZZZ.T a'n'8 nome ,a9t haoninesB wonld attnrl thi iiot, i w 'u,unue was about through "this vale f . " " y.?ar" 0f age aDd le68 widowed w . mnino. : l . "w "UD B'iBr, tnree orothersand is tne old-time "wild pigeon" going a nosc or friends to monrn his death f K n !1U n .

See moreSee less

f, mi. ... 1 lUwa fl ! U TT, , . . iu ud wiwi ua BKiur ine lOilowing ulu Jvans died at her hnmn at is taken from the Christian Science Courtois of influenza, She was 60 Monitor of December 28th: years old, and was resDected hv n When they hear the currpnt rnnnrt. who knew her. that-a member of the Connecticut husband, one daughter and tnm n. State Game Commission has seen sevShe had been 1 h! i u eral passenger pigeons, persons who h d be" e-long Christian know the story of bird life in N7,rth ana belonged to the Baptist church. America are almost as surprised as if chasPayne of Viburnum died last he had said he had seen specimens of week of pneumonia. He was abnnt ffi o: 35 rs oldand U surviedatfe Less than a century ago it was th aDli two small children. ' most plentiful game bird on the con0tis Henslee, aged 22 years, died at tinent, and flocks of passenger his home, near Vih . . - . i .-wm. .iuiu. jaoL rr I mv of pneumonia. A urifA on4 f... nun ... nyu-v oarbeneath the sun. This seems likely OId aaQghter mcurn him. enough, when one recalls Audubon's Tne remains of Mrs. Jasper Anderance would be a true return of the na7 r bnnaL Tne 'emains were tive, and would be widely welcomed. accomPanied by the husband, her son It was considerably less than a r-n. lgar, ner daughter. Marv. anri .T n tury ago that they were with us in NewmanThe deceased lived here a ir.aof T,i,Wtl a T .1 , . fpp naff f U 1 - r . uuuiucio, iu ine eariy spring , u "Kr '"esne was a ot 1870, while on a horseback journey memDer or the Christian church, and between Eminence and Thomasville, her life had Deen such that she was one afternoon, I saw a flock of these loVed and respected by all who knew birds which fairly darkened the sun k'1 8ne 18 survived by an aged husband, four sons and two daughters. and required over an hour in passing. oan yotn. L. W. s ineir suaaen and apparently comnlAr.o rliaannnaminnA a . . . " r .fl;iiuwi a iow years later Huzzah Items. was inexplicable, and truly everybody will rejoice if they return to us. It is real" wif&r weather at lam Christmas passed off ouietlv onri HEHEareafew excerpts from the New Year is here. Anti-Tobacco handbook: Two of our bovs. ami,. n . "One million four hundred and flf'tv thousand acres of good, productive BaiIor and WiIlis Freeman, a marine .lilth'9.,y?ar be W88ted 1,1 K'owwere home on' furloughs Christmas ing tobacco unless von nrvnt t have returned. "The land could supply every erain Mrs. A. W. Schwieder flnri little , " unuu aim ng allies. The Ti u- ..... . . .., wuor uomu supply every labor short uovo returned rrom a week's age in America." visit with the former's parents "Tobacco lessens mental efficiency Mr. Wilbur Dodson has returned to by over 10 per cent." "It causes deafness, blindness, can oaiem, scnool havingr re-opened af cer, tuberculosis, insanity, aponlexv ter tne nouuayg. dyspepsia, hardening of the arteries HT IT . x.0. tioury cay u nere on busi and heart disease." '

See the clipping

The Manitowoc Pilot · Manitowoc, Wis.

A short item notes that Alaska's caribou are so numerous they hinder river navigation, likened to the old days when wild pigeons were so thick they blotted out the sun. It wistfully calls those pigeon-darkened skies 'the good old days.'

The Manitowoc Pilot · 9 January 1919 · page 5

Caribou. Those Alaska caribou, bo numerous Unit they make river navigation dlffl cult, are a reminder of the days In the West when one couldn’t see the sun fur the flights of wild pigeons that ob scured (lie sky. Those were the good old days.—Oregonian.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A letter writer recalls seeing massive passenger pigeon flocks in Pennsylvania and Vermont decades earlier, and responds to an editorial by arguing that human hunting alone seems insufficient to explain their total extinction given the vast, sparsely settled range they occupied. The writer suggests disease or some other factor may have contributed alongside overhunting.

The Sun · 12 January 1919 · page 10

THE PASSENGER PIGEONS. Was Their Sudden Extinction the Work of Man or of an Epidemic?

. ' ... . . . . , They were probnbly most abundant In the middle West, but ns late as the '60s were frequently seen In New England, where It was no unusual thing for squirrel hunters to bring In n dozen of thorn with tholr other gome. As a very small boy I once saw In Pennsylvania t large a flock of theso pigeons thnt It looked like a great cloud and absolutely darkened tho sky, nnd up ft about 1870 I occasionally shot them In Vermont.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A reader writes to the editor dismissing hunting as the sole cause of the passenger pigeon's extinction, arguing instead that some virulent disease, spread rapidly due to their gregarious habits, wiped them out. He also expresses skepticism about reported sightings of surviving pigeons, citing frequent cases of mistaken identity.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Sun · 12 January 1919 · page 10

From Ike Wamn Ttiori. Bam Oberman waa a visitor here tho flrat of the week, and had a mix with a watrhdoc who mlitook him for another psrty. have been more widely discussed than the comparatively sudden extinction of the passenger pigeons, and. while It Is prob nbly true that their extinction was largely due to the wholesale slaughter wrought by so-called sportsmen and market hunters, I have, never been able to con vince myself that a speclee so widely distributed nnd existing In such count less hordes, could have been effaced si siddenly and eo thoroughly from that cause alone.

See moreSee less

Much of the country' where they nested was unsettled and compar athely wild at the time they ceased to exist, nnd It would ibe unreasonable to supposo that hunters and farmers could have seen and killed all of them. Several theories have been offered to account for their extinction ; that some terrible worm destroyed both the old and the young on their nesting grounds or blew them out to sea during their migra tions : that they souglit a safer sanctuary In South or Central America, or that 'the food supply absolutely failed them. But Is It not much moro probable that they were smitten by some dls-easo that would be more virulent and deadly because of their gresrarloiM habits and that thus they met their doom? It Is a well known fact that such dis eases do affect bird and animal life, even when tho species are widely scattered in pairs or small groups. If I am cor nctly Informed, the northern hares were completely wiped out a few years ago throughout a wide section of Canada by nrma disease that attacked them. Is this not the rational solution of the pas senger pigeon probleim? It la Indeed encouraging to hear that there probably remaJns a Temnant of this beautiful and Interesting species; but so mcny cases of mistaken identity have occurred that the most convincing proof would have to be offered to sustain the supposition. Abtiicr F. Rice. New York, January 11. London Bencher -Honor to Mr. Reck nnd Mr. Crnvath. To tub Kditor or The Sun Sir; - A few days ago The St'N made a com plimentary reference to a great honor that Gray's Inn had dbne me during my stay In London. It should be added that simultaneously Gray's Inn alo elected Paul D. Cravath, Esq., of the New York bar an Honorary Bencher. This give me an opportunity to testify to Mr. Cravath's great service to the cause of the Allies In the last year or more, leaving behind hlni one of the most lucrative law practices In America Mr. Cravath went to London and became counsel for the Interallied Commission, nnd while In I5ndon I heard many favorable comments upon the skill and tact with which he reconciled at times seemingly divergent Interests. In his case the recognition of this venerable Inn Is richly deserved. James M. Beck. New York, January 11.

See the clipping

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

The article reports supposedly authentic claims that passenger pigeons, long believed extinct, have been seen in flight or roosting. It reflects on the species' destruction as a historical folly and speculates whimsically that survivors may have been breeding secretly all along.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

South Bend News-Times · 13 January 1919 · page 4

JANUARY 13, 1919. PASSENGER PIGEONS AGAIN. Apparently authentic reports are roMing to public i.otlcc that passenger plprons hav? lfcn sfn recently in flight, or roosting sufficiently near for the olser ts to deternilno without question that they won! peohnentt, of what Ion? has hrcn mounifil as a van l.hetl race. Tho annihilation of the nassen r piuon is one f he blots upon our history. It ranks with the destruc tion of our whit? pine forests in the early lumbering t'ay.s as one of the colos.al blunders roptcd in ignorance find fostered by creed, with which the history of new 1.

See moreSee less

iiuls i.i too oftn stained. The folly of their de truction was recognized too late for the tardy game laws to do any good. Attempts were then made to breed the birds in captivity, but they are ensentially children of the open and perished al most fts swiftly vender man's nurture as under his i?un lire, rhe last known pair dyinsr in 1014. Kewaxds ofTered since then for the discovery of pas senger pigeons have tjone unearned, and until this latest news revived it, hope that they still existed had been abandoned. Perhaps they have indeed been breeding in some teeret haunt, as has heen claimed, and now are ven turing forth, temptfd by whispers of world disarma ment or stirred by jealousy lest man with his new found wines shall wrest from them their records for lonp and peedy tlik'ht. Perhaps the laws destined for their protection were not in vain after all, and con tinued safety has J, red returning confidence. In any event their reappearance will be hailed with delight by a. nation coming, though slowly, to an appreciation of the value of its bird citizens, and their protection now will be as great a . matter of public concern as their former destruction was of public neglect.

See the clipping

Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · Wilmington, Del.

The article recounts the sudden, mysterious disappearance of the passenger pigeon, noting theories of epidemic or storm-driven death at sea that were never proven. It then claims the bird has been rediscovered and quotes a New York Zoological Garden curator saying it could be bred in captivity to re-establish the species.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · 14 January 1919 · page 17

j I | and Wednesday afternoon. . pi w m r,f b pi ? f n um r( ■ iMOOLil'lLII I lülün UnUnfj i III ni. Til il n F r\/ l 11 PT VunLli NN I r 1 ' I N I I VnnlL I I 11 U I LA f II U I Several Refiorte«! to Hove Been 1 Seen Recently; Formerly Flock j rd in Millions. The reporte«! return of t - \-.rth Amerirsn wild pigeon, eommonh Lpown as the passenger fdgeon, may I . fact of importance in etmneetjon with our future food supply The American f dune j J'roteetive Ass*» i.-.Eion - ppear« » redit I the testimony of sporoimati.

See moreSee less

tl - • ire ! president of the t « nnreticut !* 1 *■ irr» ■ , Board, that he In - r-«-n peel r\i It plerilif. I » • metis of this on.« 1« ■> > < y. !.. <| of few year« silt« ! i« only a •ii' - • uft»e. l f.'f.OOO «s« offere«! for « x.< 1 nest of this bird -ind »-runel imed It has been commonly -.pp«'cd that 1 when the las. known .nd.-.-'uH -f th« «penes died m captivity in H» < mem . nati Znologie.nl Hardens on .* • j»t I. th» passenger pig.on ha«i I,«cok< exfinet j There are persons still living who m remember th»- great fight «»{ pigeon« « which in their time htcr-ilh, 'irk'ned j the sun Dense columns eig! or 'cn : mile* long were not iinrotr-.n «,n. .n<! , calculations made by caret ul . T-«eryers 1 agreed that m some of their -o , i«>n the column, ft mile wide, wa :.*(» rr tie* k.ng Audulion estirnate«! H t the ;.« er*gc flock cr.ntnined 1,25O,0fK)/fit) f.ird« and that, they consumed n-.rc than S.500,000 bushels of ms«t :n » day* ft ding Their habit of »effing ■' mg time in grea» lg*djes big « c hog:- heads on Itmls of trees made them easy j to kill and the slaughter was enormous ! Even this, however, could hardly have | accounted for the complete disappear ance of the species, the las» previous appearance of which in the wild -tat.« has been set by naturalists ns April, IffW. On<- great nesting ground four hv f wenty-etg!.* n.ilew, is nsport«! to have existed in Michigan as Ute «« JSSfi. Th»- complete and sudden flixappear ance of a whole species, formerly -o pro hfir, gave an almost romantic tinge to «eientifie, «pc illation upon the subject tine theory ■ a* advanced »hat. this ws* due to an epidemic; another was that. . storm had driven the bird* far out to '«ea during a migration anti that, they had perished en masse These were mere guesses, and no proof xm ever adduced. i Rediscovery of the bird, therefore, possessea ex.^ptional interest to lovers of wild c.i-th*. The assistant • urator of birds at the New York Zoological ^ Garden* w authority for the statement [ that it can be bred in captivity with com parauve eaec Thenis hope that it may be rc-establish.xl on th«* continent by I setting no» ly raise»! specimenfree and protecting their breeding grounds. From the ;*»nt of view of the true sportsman, luuning the passenger pigeon lacks in

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Letters to the editor present competing theories on why passenger pigeons vanished, with one reader recalling an old account of mass slaughter at a roosting site using clubs and sticks, and another referencing a theory of disease. The piece notes a separate letter is about to recount millions of dead pigeons seen floating at sea in 1875.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

The Sun · 15 January 1919 · page 6

MYSTERY OF THE BIRDS.

the wor." Just before this significant utter ance by Lord DxvoitroBT, the chair man of the famous Peninsular and Oriental Steamship Line to India, beavers, It Is r.ot Impossible to believe dhe"ru:SnTth2ons.agent ta Many years ttS, when a boy, I read . In what was then an old book an aci count of the slaughter at a pigeon roost at night I think it waa written by John James Audubon. It was stated that the pigeons were roosting In thou sands In a grove of trees and that in somo Instances so many of them were huddled together on a email limb that It broke under their weight.

See moreSee less

Men had gone to tho roost In wagons from the surrounding country, taking dogs, clubs and lanterns and Improvising long poles to knock the birds from the roost Possibly firearms were mentioned, but that X do not recall. It the story was true. It does not appear that It would b necessary to waste ammunition, ex pensive at that time, when the birds could b killed with sticks and stones. The writer gave a graphic description of th slaughter, told of the wagons being loaded with dead birds and concluded by saying that "th hogs and dogs were left to? feast on the remainder." A. P. Faclkjixr. Kmr Tore, January 14. Mtllloni of Bead Pigeons Passed at Sea In 1875. To ths Editor or The 8um Sir; In reply to the tetter of Mr. Bice on the disappearance of the passenger pigeon, I will quote my friend, Charles II. Eldon, of III West Fourth street Willlameport Pa., naturalist and taxidermist, and probably the most noted authority on ths passenger pigeon In this country: 'tin 187S Inbound vessels reported passlcg through great chools of dead pigeon off the Atlantic coast which had evidently lost their way In a fog. A friend of mine coming1 from Europe was a passenger on one venel which took three days to pass through these masses of dead pigeons. There were millions of them." Mr. Eldon watched one flo:k near hla home in Gettysburg, Pa., which took seven hours to pass. Several years aj;o he saw thirteen passenger pigeons. He follows up every clue he hears of. In the hope of securing some of the bird.'? for the State of Pennsylvania. IIxmrt C Corn. Jbrset Citt, January 14.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Two letters to the editor recount passenger pigeon lore: one describes a roost where huge flocks were clubbed to death by local men with dogs and lanterns, and another cites a naturalist's account of ships passing through millions of dead pigeons floating off the Atlantic coast in 1875. Both are offered as explanations for the species' mysterious disappearance.

The Sun · 15 January 1919 · page 6

MYSTERY OF THE BIRDS

A. P. Faclkjixr. Kmr Tore, January 14. Mtllloni of Bead Pigeons Passed at Sea In 1875. To ths Editor or The 8um Sir; In reply to the tetter of Mr. Bice on the

See the clipping

The Broad Ax · Salt Lake City, Utah

A filler note compares the dense herds of Alaska caribou obstructing river navigation to the once-vast flights of wild passenger pigeons that used to darken the sky in the West. It wistfully calls those earlier days 'the good old days,' treating the pigeons as a vanished natural wonder.

The Broad Ax · 18 January 1919 · page 8

Caribou. Those Alaska caribou. 0 numerous that they make river navlpitlon diffi cult, are u reminder of the days in the AVest when one couldn't see the sun for the flights of wild pigeons that ob scured the sky. Tho.e were the good old days. Oregonian.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A letter to the editor recounts the writer's childhood in 1860s Chillicothe, Ohio, when passenger pigeons were so abundant their flocks darkened the sky and roosted thickly in beech trees. The writer describes easily killing pigeons by throwing sticks or knocking them from branches, and his mother making pigeon pot pies for their family of five boys.

The Sun · 18 January 1919 · page 6

skies as tho larger groups flew past. The pigeons could always be relied upon to roost at tho samo places. AboutChllllcothe were several largo, beecn groves. Tho beech trees were ot ab normal size, the branches spreading In either direction from tho treo trunks as much as forty feet. It would seem that tho pigeons as they roosted among tho limbs of the beoch trees were almost as thick as tho leaves themselves. My older brothers and myself would go to tho beech woods tho woods were not a quarter of a mile from our coun try house.

See moreSee less

After a very short stay there wo would return with a bushel corn basket filled with pigeons. The pigeons had been easily killed by simply throw ing sticks Into the trees or by actually knocking the pigeons off tho limbs by striking them. Thero Is no better pot pto In the world than pigeon pie. In making such pies my mother would use what might be called the ordinary kitchen dlshpan. A new one would bo selected for he pur pose. Tho pot pie would be mado In the usual way and Dlled with pigeons. Our family Included five growing boys. Of course one would never forget such boyhood meals and recollections. Few who havo heard of tho wild pigeon reallie the enormous speed attained In Us flight. As an evidence In support of tho distance they could cover In an ab normally short space of time, pigeons wero often found with a specimen of rice In their craw supposed only to bo found In southern Louisiana. This would Indicate that the distance In flight from such points had been cov ered In time not to exceed twenty-four hours; otherwise the rlco food would certainly have been digested. Jostrit C. Bonner.

See the clipping

The Watchman and Southron · Sumter, S.C.

The article discusses claims that passenger pigeons, long believed extinct since the last known pair died in 1914, have been spotted again in flight or roosting. It reflects on the tragedy of their extinction while speculating hopefully that the reports might be true.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The Watchman and Southron · 18 January 1919 · page 4

If you have cotton to sell, see us, it will pay you. 9 West Liberty Street ? history. It ranks wich the destruc | tion of our white pine forest in the j early lumbering days as one of the ! colossal blunders rooted in ignorance and fostered by greed, with which the history of new lands is too often ! stained. The folly of their destruction was recognized too late for the tardy game laws to do any good. Attempts were i then made to breed the birds in cap tivity, bv.

See moreSee less

they are essentially chil dren of tite open and perished almost as swiftly under man's nature as un der his gun fire, the last known pair dying in 1914. Rewards offered since then for the discovery of passenger pigeons have gone unearned, and until this latest news revived it. hope that they still existed had been abandoned. Perhaps they have indeed been breeding in some secret haunt, as

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A letter writer to The Sun claims to have seen passenger pigeons intermittently over the past twenty years near Rochester, NY, including as recently as 1918, describing close observation through field glasses. He recounts childhood familiarity with the species from trap-shooting clubs in Minnesota decades earlier.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Sun · 20 January 1919 · page 6

STRAY PASSENGER PIGEONS.

to the utmost of her ability. Ho Nationwide prohibition will have ono bases this demand upon the losses effect that will please evorylsTdy. In a shown." bone dry country there will be no room which his country hns suffered tmtl for tho man who doesn't like whiskey J ti I ion tbc fact that in clothing nnd but takes It for his health. equipping her Iroops Austrullii has spent ?l,u00,O00,O0O. Tills war tlebt to No g.ur rule which deprived the a new nation of only 5,000,000 Inhabi world of tho eloquent nnd amiable ad tants he considers a serious handicap dresses delivered at the openlns of tho Congress of Paris could have been ' to future progress ami development.

See moreSee less

defendod even by tho most hidebound . He llkewlo Insists that Australia advocate of wecret diplomacy. shall retain the Islands of New Gui nea, which the Australians took from Enthusiasm for demobilization Is al Germany early In tho war. most ns great as was enthusiasm for ' In this demand die Premier states mobilization when the need was urgent. , tho policy which Austrnlln nnd New Zealand will undoubtedly declare. The marines need men cap.xblo of tip. holding their glorious fighting tradi This K)lIey Includes the adoption tion. To them a world war Is only an of n doctrine similar to the Monroe Incident, and a pcaco conference In Doctrlno for tho East. Tho Islands terferes In no way with their prepara of New Guinea aro lew than 100 tions for the future. If they aro not nillcs from tho northern coast of needed In Franco they may be In Australia; they present possibilities another place; nnd wherever they aro needed they appenr with refreshing for naval bases and for submarine promptness. boat stations, and In the hands of an unfriendly Power they would consti Cost of eating rose In 1918. .Veto tute ii menace to Australia. New paper headline. Zealand will make the same claims If It continue!, to rhe In 1919 wo regarding the Pacific Islnnds which can take comfort in the offset to bo her troops occupied. The luslstenco gained through tho reduced cost ot drinking after Juno 30. with which both of these demnnds lmve been made nnd tho evident de Can tho fact that the sessions of the termination of Australia and New pence congress aro held In the great Zealand to rid themselves of German Clock Hall be related to Premier Influences in tho Pacific form grounds Clkmenckau's vigorous dlsllko for long for tho recent British statement that and drawn out bpceches? Surely tho the fate of tho German colonies rests chairman's gazo steadily fixed on the glrla. great timepiece which adorns the hall not with Great Britain, but with her would I significant to tho oratorical oversea dominions. offender. In declaring for a "whlto Austra lia" Premier Hughes refers to a mat Whllo world penco Is prepared at ter which has long concerned Allii Versailles domestic tranquillity can bo trallu. With the exception of certain Insured by a folder of blue, W. S. S, r wll, get to a vote this week on th, proMiuiiiuii 1.1UJK.1111111. ine iirys intend to rorce matters In order to ret the legislators on record lor passing a bill creating machinery for enforcing the prohibition act ns well ns for tho sake of lining up New York an one of the States ratifying tho prohibition amend ment. STRAY PASSENGER PIGEONS. Exported by n Itocheiter Observer Familiar With the Illrds. To the KniTon op The Scn Sir: I hwe seen paroenger pigeons more or lean frequently for tho last Hfteen years In tho vicinity of Uochester. I am famlHar with the passenger pigeon; In tho town where as n boy I used to spend my tum mertt, Winona, Minn., there was a" shoot ing club that ued to shoot pigeon.- from traps nnd the pigeons used were wild plgeonn The shooting stand was In front of a ."mall grand stand on tho lorn men track, and the entire space underneath . the. Ktanrt .iivi.ir. , .., Dy jams and was niled with wild pigeons, which were trapped. Wo boys with our gunti used to po.n ourselves around the outskirts of the race track, and any pigeon that escaped the trap, shootcra was pretty sure to get his. 1 pnot them as a boy aa they wero roosting on telegraph wires In the street that ran by my uncle's residence nn,i had many of them aa pets und tried to ralso them and breed tlu-m. Thus I nm very familiar with the birds. So Is my wife. This summer I saw four, one nvnis?

See the clipping

The Broad Ax · Salt Lake City, Utah

The upland plover has been hunted to the brink of extinction much as the passenger pigeon was, with many still skeptical that such widespread species could vanish. A federal law may save the plover if a year-round closed season is enacted, since it is already classified as a migratory insectivorous bird.

The Broad Ax · 25 January 1919 · page 3

BIRD IS WORTH PRESERVING

The apland plover, one of the most beneficial 'birds of all the winged host that once abounded In North America, has been htraled and sct to the verge -of extermination, says Dasab Animals. with the passing of the passenger! pigeons which even nowo many

See the clipping

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

A hunting Q&A column about jacksnipe and trapshooting notes that new treaty protections against spring shooting are needed because the Wilson snipe was 'rapidly following the passenger pigeon into the realm of extinction.' The passenger pigeon is referenced only briefly as an established example of a species already lost.

South Bend News-Times · 26 January 1919 · page 10

While this act stops spring shoot ing, it may be the means of rescu ing the perishing, as the Wilson snipe was very rapidly following the passenger pigeon Into the realm of extinction. They are indigenous to all sections cf the United States, Canada, Great Britain, Scotland, In dia, Burmah and Ceylon, in con junction with many other sections. It is well that the spring killing of jacksnlpes has been stopped by fed eral agreement with Canada, as state laws seldom conform with each other. Question. Is there much interest in trapshootlng abroad. What will be the war effect on this line of

See the clipping