As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

December 1918

6 articles

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A Connecticut fish and game official reports seeing several passenger pigeons near Southington in spring 1918, describing distinct males, females, and a yearling. He submitted detailed observations to game commissions, suggesting the species may not be extinct after all.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 34 days later.

Wrong

The Sun · 1 December 1918 · page 23 · transcribed from the page image

HOPE OF THEIR RETURN.

Is it possible that the passenger pigeon, which once was so numerous that it darkened the sun in its flight, is not extinct after all?

See moreSee less

F. N. Manross, vice-president of the Connecticut State Board of Fisheries and Game, is very positive that he has seen several individuals of this species within recent months, and he has furnished the game commissions of Connecticut and New York and the American Game Protective Association with a detailed account of his observations.

This reads in part as follows:

"About the middle of May while fishing with a friend at Crannis Pond in the town of Southington, Conn., near Lake Compounce, I discovered three passenger pigeons perched on a dead tree in plain view, not more than fifty feet away and almost directly overhead. There is absolutely no doubt about their identity.

"One was a fine specimen of the full fledged cock pigeon with all the markings; another was a full grown hen pigeon, and the third individual a yearling cock, with slightly mottled breast. These birds were on the property of the Forestville Fishing Club. On June 2 the three birds were observed again by a friend, and on June 9 another friend saw the two old birds.

Observer Familiar With Bird.

"I am 61 years old. My first hunting was at the age of 13 years, and the first birds I shot were passenger pigeons. My father had a 'pigeon bed,' and many times early in the morning and just at night when a small boy I have been out with him and helped catch the birds. When a lad I took two young passenger pigeons from the nest and succeeded in raising one to maturity. It was very tame and would perch on my shoulder and remain there even when I moved around.

"I mention these detailed facts so that there may be no doubt as to my ability to identify a passenger pigeon. Mourning doves, which are frequently mistaken for the passenger pigeon, are very common here and I am thoroughly familiar with their markings."

Mr. Manross and three friends who observed the birds at different times have made affidavit to the fact that they were undoubtedly passenger pigeons.

Some years since various individuals interested in the passenger pigeon offered a reward in excess of $3,000 for any one discovering the nest, undisturbed, of such a bird. This reward was withdrawn a few years ago. The last known individual of the species died in captivity in the Cincinnati zoological gardens several years ago.

Pigeon Can Be Bred.

Leo S. Crandall, assistant curator of birds at the New York zoological gardens, states that the passenger pigeons can be bred in captivity with comparative ease. If some of these birds really do exist, as many pairs as possible should be placed in charge of Mr. Crandall, in order that at least a remnant of the species may be saved.

In recent years under Mr. Crandall's supervision the mourning dove has been successfully bred in captivity in considerable numbers. This bird is frequently mistaken for the passenger pigeon.

Audubon estimated that an average flock of these pigeons contained a billion and a quarter birds, which consumed more than eight and a half million bushels of mast in a day's feeding.

William B. Mershon in his book "The Passenger Pigeon" gives April, 1906, as the last authenticated report of these pigeons having been seen in the wild. This is based on a statement by John Burroughs, the well known naturalist, to the effect that one of his friends, Charles W. Benton, saw a large flock of the pigeons near Prattsville, Greene county, New York, in April of that year.

The late Judge D. C. Beaman of Denver, Col., in an article contributed to a sportsmen's publication in 1914 stated that up to 1868 there was only a slight lessening of the numbers of the passenger pigeon and that their flights did not entirely cease until some time after 1880. As late as 1876, according to Judge Beaman, there was one nesting ground in Michigan, which was four by twenty-eight miles in area. Nestings were also reported in Michigan as late as 1886.

Pigeons Seen by Bird Students.

While the passenger pigeon was mercilessly slaughtered, its reduction in numbers during the last few years of its existence was so great that many who have studied the subject are inclined to believe that its slaughter, merciless as it was, does not wholly account for the final disappearance of the species.

Among theories advanced to account for its disappearance, are that it was wiped out by an epidemic or that a great storm drove the birds out to sea, where they perished. There seems to be no ground, however, for these or any other theories advanced.

In connection with Mr. Manross's report it is interesting to note that three men of Amsterdam, N. Y., students of birds, declared recently that they saw a small flock of passenger pigeons somewhere between West Galway and Charlton. An account of their discovery was published in Science of November 1.

Sockeye Averages 17 Miles a Day.

WASHINGTON, D. C., Nov. 30.—The Bureau of Fisheries has received a record of the capture in the upper Fraser River of a sockeye bearing on its tail a button that had been inserted in the marking experiments of Puget Sound. The fish was dipnetted by an Indian at Soda Creek Canyon, British Columbia, and assuming that the fish moved in a direct route, its average rate of travel was seventeen miles a day.

Louisiana Home of Waterfowl.

NEW ORLEANS, La., Nov. 30.—M. L. Alexander, Conservation Commissioner of Louisiana, estimates that 75 per cent of the wild waterfowl of the United States and Canada make their home in this State. This is partly due, it is said, to the destruction of their former wintering grounds in other parts of the country.

Fine Work of a Royal Coachman.

BUTTE, Mont., Nov. 30.—The prize for the largest rainbow trout given annually

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This 1918 report reviews historical sightings and population estimates of the passenger pigeon, citing Audubon, John Burroughs, and Judge Beaman on the species' decline through the 1870s-1900s. It discusses competing theories for the bird's sudden disappearance beyond mere slaughter, including epidemic disease or storms driving flocks out to sea, while noting no solid evidence supports these theories.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 36 days earlier.

The Sun · 1 December 1918 · page 23

HOPE OF THEIIl RETURN, Js it Mo that the passenger pigeon, which onto was W' numerous thai, It darkened the sun In, Ha lllght, Is. not, ex tinct after rI17 - . . - 1", N. Matiross, vIcc-preBlilcjnV-oftlio Connecticut State Board of KUherlpjiml Quae, Is very positive thnt he liai..een several Individuals of this) epeclC3:Ulth" Is recent mouths, ntul ho lias furuUhed the game commissions, of Connecticut ami New Yorl; and tho American Oaf no Protective, Association witha detailed account of his observations. This reads In part as follows: ' "About Hie middle of May while fish ing with a friend at Crannls Pood In trie town of JSouUiIngton, Conn, near Lnke Compounce, I discovered three paB lenxer pigeons perched on n dead tree In plain view, not moro than fifty feet awny and almost directly overhead.

See moreSee less

There Is absolutely no doubt about their Identity. ( "One was a lino specimen of tho full Seised cock" pigeon with nil the mark ings; another was a full crown, hen pic eon, and the third Individual a yearling cock, with slightly mottled breast.- These birds wcro on the property of tho jyorest llle Fishing Club. On Juno 2 the three birds were obsorvod again by a friend, and on June 0 another friend saw the two old blrda. Obsrncr Familiar With Bird. "I am 61 years old. "My first hunting was at the age of 13 years, and the first birds I shot were passenger pigeons. My father had a 'pigeon bed and rnnny times early In tho morning and Just at eight when a small boy I havo been out with him and helped catch tho birds. When a lad I took two youngpassenger pigeons from the nest and succeeded in railing one to maturity. It was very tame and would perch on my shoulder and remain there even when I moved around. "I mention these detailed facts eo that there may be no doubt as to my ability to Identify a passenger pigeon. Mourn ing doves, which tre frequently mistaken for the passenger pigeon, are very com mon here and I am thoroughly familiar with their markings." Mr. Manross and three friends who observed the birds at different times have made affidavit to the fact that they, were undoubtedly passenger plseona. Some years since various Individuals interested In the passenger pigeon cftered a reward In excess of $3,000 for' any one discovering the nest, undis turbed, of 6uch a bird. This reward was withdrain a few years ago. The hist known Individual of the species died In captivity In the Cincinnati zoological gardens several years ago. Pigeon Can lie Bred. Lee S. Crandall, assistant curator of birds at the New Ytfifc zoological gar dens, states that tho passenger pigeons can be bred In captivity with compara-' tlvs met. If some of these birds really do exist, asmany pairs as possible should be placed in charge of Mr. Cran dall, In order that at least a remnant of tho species may be saved. In recent years under Mr. Crandall's rjpervlslon the mourning dove has been s-jocttufully bred in captivity In con siderable numbers. This bird, is fre quently mistaken for the passenger Sigeon. Audubon estimated that an .average (lock of these p!fons contained a billion and a quarter birds, which consumed mora than eight and a half million bushels of mast in a day's feeding. Wl.:,am B. Merahon In his book "The Passenger rigcon" gives April, 190G, as the last authenticated report of these plfons hnving been aeen in the wild. This la based on a statement by John Burroughs, the well known naturalist, to he efre t that one of his friends, Charles W. Benton, raw a large ft"-'- of the rlgtor.s near Pratt-- vounty. New Vr k. In April of that ear. The lue Judge V. C lleaman of Den- , 1n an nrticlo contributed to a 'PTtsn.iii's publication In 1014 Etatcd that up to there was only a slight iHsemng of the numbers of tho passen ger pl?eon and that their Mights did not entirely cease until come time after As late as 1S76, according to Judje Beaman, there was one nesting tround n Michigan, which was four by tnty-e.gl.t mile.i In area. Nestings ere a'o reported In Michigan as lato Pigeons Seen by Bird Stndrnta. While the passenger pigeon was mor '"essly ii'auglitcreJ, Its reduction In nuT rs d.irir.g the last few years of Its 'licit; r. was po groat that many who havo studied the subject are Inclined to Mkeve that Its slaughter, merciless ns it ii -a not wholly account for the Sr..i! d. ippearance of tho species. An iig theories ndvanced to account its 'llsappearance, are that H wa9 '""PM o-.t by an epidemic or that a R-pat 'o. ti drovo the birds out to sea, where they perished. There eeems to be ro pn ir, i, however, for these or any t,vpt- ""in-, advanced. In r -non with Mr. Manross's re Pr' I' 'i.terostlng to noto that three rr'"i 'f Amsterdam, N. V., students of ! ''to d. lirnj recently that they saw a srr i; n it f passenger pigeons sotne ere I. 'ween West Gahvay and Cliarl ' :i amount of their discovery was .'tolled in Science of November 1, ' SocLeye, Aiirnget 17 Miles a Dny. w,, ;:..r,T,,Vi n c Nov jo.The i if Fisheries ha:j received a rec r i 1 .j upturn jn the upper Frascr '; ' of .i Mu'Ueyo bearing on Its tall a ihit had been Inserted In tho i.Tkng (xpr:monts of Puget Sound. ('" !'-1 wu dliiiettej by an Indian at '''-ilt (.".inyon, HrltlBli Columbia,' " " i.ng thnt the llsh moved In n "''-' r..i',-, u average rate of travel a . . . ttn nilles a day. I.onl.lHtui IIoiiir of Waterfowl, On. i aks, La., Npv. 30. M. I,. " r .nsorvatlon Commissioner " l. ' -..mi, i;ftlmatcB that 73 per 'f n.u wild waterfowl of tho 1 and Canada make their i i ".is State. This 1h partly due, i to the dontructlon of their r entering grounds in other parts l. j i try. , l'ln lru f n Hiij-nl Cnnohmnn. H' t i Mont . Nov. 30. The prize for

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.

An item from Our Dumb Animals reports that the upland plover has been hunted toward extinction much like the passenger pigeon before it, despite many bird-lovers still finding the pigeon's disappearance hard to believe. It notes hope remains if federal migratory bird law closes hunting season on the plover year-round.

New Britain Herald · 7 December 1918 · page 6

The Vanishing Plover. (Our Dumb Animals) The upland plover, one of the most beneficial birds of all the winged host that once abounded in North America, has been hunted and shot to the Acrg, of extermination. With the passing ot the passenger pigeons, which even

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Frank H. Stewart of the Ocean City Fishing Club discusses the disappearance of wild life in New Jersey, noting species like wolf, beaver, and swan now survive only in zoos. He recalls his father clubbing a mess of wild pigeons decades earlier, but says a $1,500 reward has produced no proof that a single wild pigeon still lives.

The Sun · 15 December 1918 · page 23

WILD LIFE PROTECTION.

Jersey and are only to be found In Its Zoological Gardens. "If pportsmen do not organize, protect and help propagate game and fish, the next generation will look with wonder ment at a mounted mallard duck, sim ilar to ours, while gazxlng at a stuffed wild pigeon. "When my father was a boy wild pig cons wero so plentiful In New Jersey that he killed a mess one evening by throwing clubs Into an Immense flock as It settled to roost Now, seventy five years afterward, a reward of 15,000, brings no proof that a single wild pigeon Is now alive."

See the clipping

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis. · and 3 other papers

A short filler piece comparing the abundance of Alaska caribou to the long-gone days when wild pigeons were so numerous they blotted out the sun. It frames the passenger pigeon's former abundance as a nostalgic memory of 'the good old days.'

Iowa County Democrat · 19 December 1918 · page 6

Mountain Tea be your internal cleanser, then your organs will be pure and clean, your health good, your system right. Start tonight. Tea or Tablets 35c. Ivey’s Pharmacy. Caribou. Those Alaska caribou, so numerous that they make river navigation diffi cult, are a reminder of the days in the West when one couldn’t see the sun for the flights of wild pigeons that ob scured the sky. Those were the good old days. —Oregoniaji.

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • Decorah Public Opinion · Decorah, Iowa · 22 January 1919
  • The Chickasha Daily Express · Chickasha, Indian Territory Okla. · 13 February 1919
  • The St. Mary Banner · Franklin, La. · 29 March 1919

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

A McDonough County report of a flock resembling wild pigeons flying south revives hope the species survived, despite the belief that the last one died in a Cincinnati garden years earlier. The piece ends by questioning the sighting's credibility, suggesting a correspondent may have been fooled.

Evening Times-Republican · 27 December 1918 · page 4

Iowa Newspapers WILD piWRONS? I l'.urlin«ton HawUej e.J McDonough county reports that a tlo?k of olrda reaombllng wild piteons flew over that county recently, south ward hound. It has been held that tlie last surviving wild pigeon, of the kind that were counted by I he billions here leaa than fifty yfears agu, died in a public garden at Cincinnati a few yeurs ago. tt in not impossible t'lat there were flocks oif these bird# that survived tho terrible slaughter, and that earn pen the pot hunters, ftnd that after all the wild pigeon, that ha* been mourned by many, Is not extinct. And then some one in McDonough county mny have "sprung something" on a correspondent who was looking for a

See the clipping