An old timer reminisces about a hunting trip roughly 30 years earlier near Tulpahock, where hundreds of wild pigeons flew up from a field along with squirrels, pheasants, and quail. He laments that game is now scarce compared to those plentiful days.
The Mahoning Dispatch · 1 December 1911 · page 5
others went to Tulpahock to hunt We came to an open field and hund reds of wild pigeons flow up They had been feeding In the field and we got a big bunch of them Continuing our hunt we came to a broken tree in a woods and from that tree wo got a score of gray squirrels We saw at least 200 pheasants and bagged a num ber of them also quail Were game as plentiful now the average hunter would get buck fever and couldnt shoot a little bit
A 1911 report from Roswell, N.M. notes that turtle doves are vanishing just as the wild pigeon did a few years earlier, having become open game for hunters once the pigeon disappeared. It notes Oklahoma passed a protective law, though many doves have still been killed since.
Albuquerque Evening Herald · 5 December 1911 · page 6
TURTLE DOVE IS BEING WIPED OUT
Ago Were Plentiful. itonwt'll. X. M., Dec. G. According to Home of tho local nlmrodn, tho tur He dove In nboiit to folluw in tho nl;c of Hi coualii, tbo wild pigeon,
A government report describes efforts to determine if the passenger pigeon was completely extinct, offering rewards that prompted many claimed sightings of nesting birds. All such reports proved false upon investigation, leaving only one known survivor: an 18-year-old female in captivity at a zoological garden.
Wausau Pilot · 5 December 1911 · page 10
Passenger Pigeons Exterminated. Measures were taken to ascertain whether the passenger pigeon had been completely exterminated (ac cording to a government report). Un der the stimulus of rewards ofTered
This sporting article about dove hunting digresses to recall the passenger pigeon's traditional reputation for extraordinary speed, citing estimates of 80-90 miles per hour. It compares the dove favorably to the passenger pigeon, teal, and other fast game birds as a hunting challenge.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Hattiesburg News · 7 December 1911 · page 3
THE MORE GUNS THE BIRDS FLY FAST AND ARE HARD TO HIT. BETTER FOR THEN THE QUARRY IS KEPT ON THE MOVE.
winter seasons. The mating season I I is gone, the young have been reared, the birds are flocking in great droves in search of food, and then it is that the sportsman of the grain country learns to know the real dove. The flight of the passenger pigeon is traditional for its unerring speed and swiftness. Its speed has been es timated at as high as eighty and nine ty miles an hour. A close relative of the passenger pigeon is the dove, and it is doubtful if the passenger pigeon, the blue wing teal, t.he jack snipe or the quail have anything on an old dove, a last year's one, wise and full
A New York Mail article reports the Department of Agriculture's biological survey announcement that the wild pigeon, once America's most abundant bird, is now extinct. It recalls the species' former vast flocks and calls its disappearance an unsolved natural history mystery, noting that while hunting killed many, some believe other causes contributed.
Evening Star · 9 December 1911 · page 17
I* The announcement of the biological sur% vey of the Department of Agriculture that f the wild pigeon, once so common in the f' i'nited States, has become extinct, recalls one of the strangest mysteries in Amerj. ican natural history. It is a puzzle which lias baffled scientists and which probably t* never will be solved. Thirty years ago wild pigeons were S abundant in PennsvlvaTiiu ohtn tnHisna f Kentucky and all tiie states of the middle ?* west. In their migrations they traveled i* in flocks numbering tens of thousands, 1, and it sometimes look a single flock the 4 t, better part of an hour to pass a given point. * Vast numbers of the pigeons were & killed every year by gunners, but many
Professor C.F. Hodge of Clark University reports that his investigation and reward offers (up to $1,500) for proof of nesting wild passenger pigeons produced no results during the past season. He notes the last known roost and nesting occurred at Petoskey, Michigan in 1878, as documented in Mershon's book on the passenger pigeon.
NO WILD PIGEONS FOUND. Not . Trace of the Bird. Despite the Big Rewards. S.ininaw. Mich., Dec. I, till flag 1 1 ('. K ll.alge of t'lark I m ei sll , Wot center, Mass . has Issued a pamphlet anowlng that bla lnveetlgaNogb or re ports of paaoengefi plaona during the (mat sea eon have been fruitless. Pro fessor limine has In en In ehwrge of prizes aggrtKatin several thousand dollars with maud prize .,f $l,iM)i) PW the lirst Rnd f,,r two seasons, to he kmc, i for i I' !
See moreSee less
I it d i jtlt nt ,. of nest ing wlhl piKcor,s. il,. ajiyi there la but spark Of hop. ,n tbal these birds lie not absolutely extinct - several re ports of H ks ha ,n Im i ii seen may he gathei t d and plot It , in a map. trace the rouree of Hocks ami ptmcllcalty I'rove that a few bMg, nesting In the tar northern arliderneea, sun exist On ly tins will induce HiHSc who have of fered the rewards to n new them Um another season. The last Igpga pigeon rooal and ne.tlng ooearrad at PiatoaMey, Mich., in 17 and has hem lull tlesoribed in W. BL Mershon's wdume. "The Paaaan ger Pigeon." Profeaaor Hodaw describes visit he teuenjfl) made to ig etd "pi geoner" at Brookjleld. Mass.. win, hiiii has his nest that he formerly used In taking ggjpjogg tot the market. Mr. Mcishon recentb bouulti these nests and has them in his gafflftew ctdlwtloa prabnnl) th onfy onea In exist ence.
The article describes the last known living passenger pigeon, housed in the Cincinnati Zoological Gardens, whose body is promised to the National Museum for preservation in alcohol after death. It recalls that a single flock seen in Frankfort, Kentucky a century earlier was estimated at an enormous, improbable number of birds.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later.
Wrong
El Paso Herald · 12 December 1911 · page 6
NATIONAL MUSEUM COLLECTION BY FREDERIC J. HASKIH " years ago, is destined to be preserved in the National museum. This sole surviving passenger 'pigeon Is now in the Cincinnati aoologlcal gardens. Its body has been promised to the National museum when it dies, and it is the in tention of the museum to preserve it in alcohol for the purpose of keeping it in the best possible condition tor study. This pigeon is about 15 years old, and nbe last of a nice which once was so numerous that a single flock seen in Frankfort Kentucky, 100 yeara ago, was estimated to contain not less than 250,000,000,000 birds.
See moreSee less
Seme Other Birds. If space permitted one might tell of the rhinocerous bird, which 'rides on the back of the rhinocerous and has lately learned to make wounds in the backs of horses and cattle for the pur oose of eating fresh meat and blood; of the bee eaters of Africa, which ride on the back of a larger bird known as tne bustard: of the curious little honey birds of Africa, which have learned that man likes honey as well as it likes the larvae of bees, and It always trying to persuade the hunter to follow It to a deposit of honey, just as a dog might beg its master to go to the hunting field. One might also tell of the oven bird, which builds an ovenlike nest of mua, using horse hairs to reinforce It as the builder uses iron and steel in reinforc ing concrete construction. Then there is the bower bird, which builds a large playhouse, and gathers flowersand oth er ornament for it A whole flock of the birds use the bower as a trysting place. There are Hhe great auks which have become extinct within the memory of man, the 580 species and sub-species of humming birds, the sociable weaver birds, which select a tree difficult for a predatory animal to climb and then covers the whole tree with cartloads of grass in such a way as to make it a ml nature haystack, and in which the whole flock do their nesting. There are also the cuckoos and their relatives which Insist on imposing the duties of motherhood on other birds, always lay ing their eggs in the nests of such birds wn they are absent. But it would take volumes to mention even the names of the birds in the National museum. Tomorrow Reptiles, Toads and Frogs.
The American Humane Association's president writes to a Georgia newspaper condemning hunters who killed 5,000 doves in hours, invoking the near-extinction of the passenger pigeon as a warning. He notes several states have banned using pigeons as live shooting targets and argues such killing is needless cruelty rather than sport.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Omaha Daily Bee · 16 December 1911 · page 23
tm' : (in, ,( Animals is Diseased. KliKIt AVILCOX. Imwn In Georgia a party of huntem (growii men, mind you), Kliied 6.0W doves. In a few hours. Mr. W. O. Htlllman. president of the i American Humane association, wrote the following letter to the Atlanta Constltu- ; tlon In regard to this matter: "I see by reports that Georgia Is mak Ing Itself Infamous by an alleged slaugh ter of B.OUO harmless doves by 1D0 hogs, railed hunters. It really seems too bad that so greut and humane a state as Georgia should allow practices of this -kind to go on.
See moreSee less
"There are two Important facts to which I'l'V-) I would respectfully call tho attention of the cltlsens of Georgia. The first of these. Is that - the relentless and merciless. slaughter of wild pigeons has nearly an AM lilhllated that beautiful species of birds . be- - commonly called "the passenger dove.' It used to exist In enormous flocks, but now is so Hourly exterminated that In most parts of the United Htales It Is never seen. "The second point to which I would' like to call your attention Is that a niim ber of states, Including, I am proud to say, my own state of New York, have -passed laws forbidding the employment of 1 pigeons as live targets for gunners. "Tho opposition to this practice, which" , has long existed, of slaughtering vast quantities of pigeons In tho name of 'sport' is not a piece of maudlin sent I- ; ment on the part of a few scatter-brained, humanitarians. Thero are aspects of cru elty connected with It which would causa . an Apacho Indian to blush with shame. It Is nut the practice of either Indians or wild beasts to merely slaughter for the ' fun of killing wild animals or birds. They kill In order to sustain life. In the case , of pigeon shooting, vast numbers are shot down lurgely for the suke of demonstrat ing dexterity In shooting and also In order , to satisfy that savage Instinct for killing something which still finds lodgment In half-civilized members of the human race. "Large numbers of theso birds are slaughtered from puro wantonness. They . are allowed to rot and quantities are not used for food. The worst aspect of the whole thing Is that a great many of thum are wounded in field shooting and escape to die a, lingering death or eke out a miserable existence of suffering for days . or weeks. 1 feel sure that the majority ' of the chivalrous people of Georgia will not call this bloody pastime 'manly sport.' It Is quite on a par with the practice of heedless und brutal children of pulling oft the wings und legs of file). One is OS much a 'manly sport as the other. ' "I appeal to the humarltarlans of Guor git to have a law passed by your IcgWIu turu which shall place It upon the Men standard adopted by several stutes ot stopping this bloodthirsty, cruel and In excusable practice, which Is followed at ' tho expense of onu of the most harmless and beautiful creatures which God ha creuled. ltelylng on the sense of honor and humanity of your splend.d southern people, I am sure that this will be done buore very long." To the minds that are not dwarfed ami . Impoverished by wrong thought?, anit ' luck ot ideals, life Is ablazo with wonder- : ful opportunities for enjoyment. There aro Innumerable avenue for poo-
The Santa Cruz News describes two hunters using a homemade double eight-gauge shotgun device mounted on a tripod to massacre a large flock of 'wild pigeons' flying over the Santa Cruz mountains near Boulder Creek, killing and maiming huge numbers at once. Local shooters were horrified by the carnage, and the writer notes the county game warden's office had been hollowed out by political interference.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.
Wrong
The San Francisco Call · 24 December 1911 · page 41
PIGEON SLAUGHTER 7 -Recently there has been s a big flight --of wild pigeons ■-: in'V the Santa - Cruz - mountains about f Bq,ulder t Creek : and : ?- the"* Santa Cruz News -tells -this strange tale of;-slaughter :. 7 A couple of -young/sportsmen (?) brought over, with • them 'from* the valley ■: one ofZ those ■ duckgun•:: contriv • ances made by firmly fastening together 1 two eight 7 gauge, double barreled shotguns, mounted on a tripod; a looking glass at the butt end that showed when the birds were in line, it was an easy matter to bag a y few.
See moreSee less
Loaded with six drams of smokeless powder and * fistful of chilled shot 4), the execution^waVsom thing terrible. One close flying flock came sailing over, about 300 feet high, and this instrument of death spoke. It resembled T somewhat the expiring gasp; of a broadside from the Oregon, the . tall trees'; bent y their tops-,to the fiery blast and what appeared to tbe two pairs of dough nut rings } appeared in that** flock of pigeons, and?as the echo reverberated back and forth through the hills, it .7 fairly rained dead, mangled, crippled and i tortured birds. ?■ Z 7 The frightful havoc wrought by this instrument of death and destruction appalled /local' shooters arid-after wit * nessing a couple of samples of its fearful work, it was - dismounted and,--with its owners, headed back to the . valley. What -has ' become of ? the vSan-; Cruz U game warden?y Some 'timeago-''this * office, 1 was ; made the football, of • " politics .'and ? it' may be /that the; supervisors ? have not; yet : slept-off. the effects.'--—--- j- " .- *> • '■*•- ; V
The article groups the passenger pigeon's disappearance with other odd bird phenomena like a prairie chicken influx, a Michigan wild turkey exodus, and an owl invasion in British Columbia. It states that unlike the turkeys, which were later found in west Michigan, no word has ever been heard as to where the wild pigeons went.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
Wrong
Evening Star · 27 December 1911 · page 8
STRANGE MIGRATION OF BIRDS.
the course of time wild turkeys were reported as more than plentiful in the disj tricts of west Michigan, where they had been rarely seen before. The mysterious disappearance of the passenger' pigeon, of which there were millions in this country one day and not oqe to be seen anywhere the next, had not as fortunate a sequel as that of the Michigan wild turkeys, for no word has ever been heard as to where the wild pigeons went. An. unaccountable appearance of birds
A Pennsylvania man recounts finding decades-old pigeon netting equipment in a corn crib, prompting memories of wild pigeon hunting. The article describes how netters used large fish-net traps near beech woods to capture pigeons during migration and nesting seasons, a practice some blame for the species' extinction.
The Mirror and Farmer · 28 December 1911 · page 6
6 66T HE days when we hunted wild I pigeons w^fe recalled to me I not long ago," said a Steuben county, Pennsylvania, man, '"by the removal of a jumble of fish net ting, ropes, stakes and poles from a corn crib lelft on a farm on the Pennsyl vania border, where the stuff had lain for more than 30 years undisturbed. "The netting was cut up into bits to make small fish traps, and thus was de stroyed the last relic of the days when the wild pigeon winged in countless flocks annually over the country, a bird now as utterly extinct as the great auk.
See moreSee less
That jumble of netting, rope's, stakes and poles was a pigeon net, one of the traps to which some authorities charge the disap pearance Os that curious bird. "The vast beech woods that covered western Pennsylvania afforded the food that attracted the wild pigeons, and dur ing the great flights of the birds toward that feeding ground in the spring net tors from all over the country gathered there to levy tribute on the birds. The pigeons also sought nesting places in the vicinity of the beech woods, where they hatched their young, three b'roods of a season. The nesting time was also a harvest for the netters, although they had ito adopt a different method of luring the birds to their nets. * * * "Netting pigeons was a simple and ef fective method of capturing the birds by wholesale. A pigeon net was a section of ordinary small mesh fish netting, made
The report describes in technical detail how pigeon netters constructed spring-net traps using bent hickory poles, ropes, and notched stakes, baited with salt and buckwheat to attract flocks. It also explains the use of trained stool pigeons, including the cruel practice of sewing their eyelids shut, to lure wild flocks to their capture during nesting season.
The Mirror and Farmer · 28 December 1911 · page 6
tered thickly with buckwheat or salt. Wild pigeons were curiously fond of salt, and buckwheat was another irresistible attraction to them. "If a netter was operating before the birds had settled down to their nesting (he had a nigeon with a long string tied to one of its legs. This he took with him to his bough house, from which he would (release it now and then. It would fly upward, only to be stopped, by the string and to flutter back to the ground. This movement of the captive pigeon would attract the attention of flocks of pigeons flying over, and they>would circle around and come down near the spot.
See moreSee less
Once on the ground they wold not be long in dis covering the baited spot, and then they would crowd on the spot until every inch of it would be blue with pigeons. "Then came the netter's opportunity. A pull at the rope in bis hand would re lease the net rope from the notches in the stakes. The hickory poles would fly back, taking the net with them, which would shoot out over the ground covered with pigeons so quickly that there would be no escape for any within its reach. Some times hundreds of the birds would be caught. As many as 1100 pigeons have (been taken at one springing of a net. *** , "During nesting time a trained stool pigeon was used to lure the flocks to the snare. A cruel bit of work was necessary to make it do its part. Long experience (had demonstrated that if the bird could 'see the flocks it was to decoy it would in variably warn them in some way of their danger. Blinding of the stool pigeon was therefore adopted. This was accomplished by sewing its eyelids together. [ "The sightless bird would be secured to 1 n perch in the rear of the net, near the ground. The perch was manipulated by a string in the hands of the netter conIcealed in the bough house, and the pigeon would respond to the manipulation by a ifluttering as if just alighting. [ "This would attract the attention of passing flocks and they would change I their course and settle in trees around and watch the fluttering of the decoy bird in the silent, cautious way they had. By and by a pigeon or two from some flock would venture to go down and make Ia closer inspection of the matter.