As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

November 1911

9 articles

Sequachee Valley News · Sequatchie, Tenn.

A Rockford, Illinois editorial praises a Chicago policeman who refused to shoot a stray dog, contrasting his sentiment with the heartless men who drove the passenger pigeon and prairie chicken to extinction. It closes with a Shakespeare quote on manhood.

Sequachee Valley News · 2 November 1911 · page 3

Sentiment is dying out as commercial ism advances. The world is looking for big, burly men, who have courage but no heart or sentiment. Men who from lack of sentiment have driven the passenger pigeon and the prairie chicken out of existence, and who are happy when slaying birds in flight. will look upon tbis policeman as a faint heart. But his refusal to kill a homeless friendless dog, marks him as a man worth liking aud loving. He might well say with the bard of Avon: I dare do nil that becomes a man. Who dares do more is none. Editorial

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A bird captured in Hebron and reported as a passenger pigeon is reexamined by local bird authority Frank T. Noble, who believes it was actually a mourning dove. Noble notes passenger pigeons are exceedingly rare, having seen only two live specimens in all his years in Maine woods.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Wood County Reporter, 19 October 1911, The Webster Echo, 20 October 1911, Daily Kennebec Journal, 28 October 1911.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 3 November 1911 · page 11

Almost Half a Century, j A MOURNING DOVE. Local Naturalist Does Not Think Hebron Bird Passenger Pigeon. Tinn i l nt capture at Hebron of a Dili] thought to have been either a passenger pigeon (octopistus migruto rtus) or a mourning dove (zenaUlura Oaro'ineiisls), as reported in tile Journal, was being discussed. Thurs day morning, with Frank TNoble ol tlds city, wlio is an authority on Nt w Kngland birds, and he is of the opin ion that the bird in question was a mourning dove and not a passengei pigeon, as the latter are exceedingly rare in any part of (lie United States and in New Kngland especially so.

See moreSee less

.Mr. XobJe showed a Journal report er with justifiable pride a beautiful specimen of the passenger pigeon—a male bml in brilliant plumage.—one of the gems 01 his private collection, which lie prizes very highly. It is one of the last few birds taken in the Kastern states and was shot in New York state some 17 years ago. Mr. Noble states that in all liis > i urs of experience in the Maine woods lie lias seen but two live speci men^ of the passenger pigeon. The first one he caught only a passing glimpse of, some :<o years ago, near tiie mouth of" "the Kennebec river. The other was seen on the banks of Cobbosseecontee stream, about 20 years ago. while duck shooting, and although he made a quick try for him he failed to connect owing to the rap idity of flight, -which, he jokingly de scribes as almost like a streak of lightning. The mourning dove, he says, is more often si on, but is not at all common in Maine. The specimen of the latter bird in the Noble collection came from Dexter, where it was accident ally killed by flying against a store w indow. The greatest difference between the two birds is in size, the mourning dove being less than half the size of the passenger pigeon. The passenger pigeon has much more brilliant plum age than its somber cousin, the irides cent shade being plainly shown on both sides of the neck. Tile specimen of tin: passenger pigeon in Mr. Noble's collection measures IS inches from the til) of the bill to the tip of the tail Tiie extensive collection of Mr. No ble is one of great value and is alwujs ( available for comparison or identifica tion and study. Mr. Noble believes that tincity or State should Anally possess it in order that it may W

See the clipping

The Holt County Sentinel · Oregon, Mo.

A government-backed investigation offered rewards for reports of nesting passenger pigeons, but all such claims proved false upon inspection. It is now believed that only a single female bird, eighteen years old, survives in captivity at the Cincinnati Zoological Garden.

The Holt County Sentinel · 3 November 1911 · page 3

Passenger Pigeons Exterminated.

SENSE OF GRATITUDE LOST Hobo No Longer Gets Help From Negroes by pjslng as Civil War Veteran. An old tramp, who was resting In City llntl park after a long trip on the road, Is authority for tho statement that the attitude of the negro race toward the old soldier Is not what It was. "When I began hoboing years ago," aald the man, "I could live on the fat of the land by appealing to the gratl tuda of the colored people. 'For four long years I fought to set you free,' I said to them, 'but I was unfortunate enough to get off without a wound, ao nnw the government won't help me and I am forced to beg.'

See moreSee less

"Of course I didn't fight for them I was In short pants when tho war broke out, but tho negroes never stopped to reason out a problem In ages. After a song-and-danre of that kind the btack man of fifteen, ten or even Ave years ago would dig up coin or share his last cup of coffee and his last scrap of bacon with me. Hut the present generation has lost the sense of gratitude. Whether a man did or did not tight for their freedom mnkes no difference, nnd the tramp who ex perls the old soldier wheeze to win him an easy living from the negroes Is In danger of getting left" C.irrled Too Far. Jerome 8. McWade, the millionaire collector of Duluth, discussed, on the Nurrngnnsrtt beach, the trend of mod ern fiction. "Modern fiction Is charitable to women," he snld slowly. "Perbnpa It Is too charitable to women. Wells and Galsworthy nnd llernard Shaw are not content with letting tho worn. en go as far as the men they let them go farther than the men. "They arc as unduly charitable as Duluth chap who got himself engaged lo a notorious flirt. '"Why, Horace,' said a friend, 'you nlu't engaged to Mlnnlo Manners, aro you? "'Yes, I am,' snld Horace stoutly. "'Why, Horace, that glrl'a been engaged, off and on, to nearly every man In Duluth.' 'Well.' snld Horace, charitably, 'Duluth ain't such a big place.'" Passenger Pigeons Exterminated. Measures were taken to ascertain whether the pnBsciigcr pigeon had been completely exterminated lac cording to a government report). Un Uer tho stimulus of rewards offered aggregating altogether several thou sand dollars many reports were re ceived of nesting passenger pigeons, The Information, however, proved In correct on Investigation, nnd It Is practically established that of the vast hordes of wild pigeons that formerly Inhabited tho eastern United States there Is now but ono survivor, a fe ninte bird eighteen years old In cap. tlvlty In tho zoological garden ol Cincinnati, To Alleviate Horees' fluttering. A wnter-cnrrylng motor enr, the first of Its kind In the world, has been placed In commission In Philadelphia by the Women's Society for tho Pre vention of Cruelty to Animals as a dis penser of water to thirsty horses, "The car," says Popular Mechanics, "Its mis. slon clearly placarded on Its body, will move slowly through busy streets In the parts of Philadelphia where troughs are not available, and any driver can stop and get a bucket of water free of charge." A Peace Program. "What we want Is peace and bar mony and politeness In business," said Mr. Dustln Stax. "And there Is only one way to get It." "What Is that?" "Find some way to convince the fellow who gets the worst of It that he might ns well take bis medicine and stop kicking."

See the clipping

Ellsworth American · Ellsworth, Me.

An Audubon Society bulletin by William Dutcher recalls historical accounts of the passenger pigeon's once-vast numbers, citing Wilson, Audubon, and Lawrence on massive flocks seen in the early-to-mid 1800s. It notes that by 1911 the bird had become so rare that sighting even one was remarkable.

Ellsworth American · 8 November 1911 · page 3

The WUd Pigeon. ,gj William Dotohar. chairman protection wmmittee of the American Ornithologists Union] _ Alexander Wilton, the “Father of Amer ican Ornithology,” estimated that a Hock of wild pigeons soon by him now Frank fort, Kentucky, about 1808, contained at least 2.230,272,000 individual*. Audubon writes that in 1806 ho raw schooners at the wharves in New York olty loaded in balk ^itb wild pigeons, caught np tha Hndaon river, which wore sold at one cent each. Tbe late Ueorge N. Lawrence tella of the peat flights ol pigeona that annually passed over New York city aa late as I860.

See moreSee less

He says: “We oonld see flocks consisting cf from twenty-flT* to over a hundred pigeons come sweeping down over the tree lope, seemingly at a speed of eeventy jve miles an boar. Th* flock* followed aaob other in quick succession. On the patent site of General Grant’s tomb was an old country-scat known aa ‘Claremont.’ From tbe top of this boom, daring one of tbsae great flights of pigeons, th* owner killed a hundred or more in on* morning.” The writer, daring th* post forty years, has studied th* Mrda of th* vioinity of Haw York, and In nil that period has aeen only oue live wild pigeon. Tbe writer’s father, who iivod at Tarrytown, N. Y., in his boyhood, has often told of the enor mous flocks of pigeona he aaw there, so peel that in pnoaing overhead the sun was darkened a* by a rain-cloud and the noise of their winga was lik* thunder. To-day tbe wild pigeon la so rare that tbe observation of a single individual is considered noteworthy. The species con tinued abundant until about 1880, when, aa a result of increasing slaughter for food, It began rapidly to diminish in numbers, sod do large flock has beau recorded since 1388. Frank M. Chapman tells me that as late as juiy, looi, w mw whu pigeons usea is large number* at a trap-sh K>ting tourna ment held near New York city. The birds had been netted in tbe West and were often so helpless from their eon tenement in foul cages that they were unable to fly. William Brewster writes that in 1S7B or j 1877 there wss a pigeon-nesting near Petosky, Mich., which was twenty-eight miles long and averaged four miles in width. Tbe disappearance of so abundant a creature in so comparatively short time is a surprising Illustration of man's power In tbe animal world when, for any reason, his forces are directed toward a certain end. Wild pigeons lived in flocks st all sea sons, nesting, roasting and feeding in enormous bodies. Wilson mentions a nesting colony which was several miles in breadth and upwards of forty miles in ex tent. Tbe birds chose preferably beech woods, and as many as ninety nests have been coanted In a single tree. The flock previously mentioned, estimated to con tain over two billion Individuals, stretched from horizon to horizon, ss farts the eye could reach in every direction, and was tour hours in passing a given point. At all seasons, whether migrating, roosting or nesting, pigeons ware subject to attack by man. Their migrations were governed largely by the food supply, scorns and beech-nuts constituting their Chief fare, and when they appeared st a certain place their destruction became tbe object of the day. Many were shot, bat by far tbs larger number were netted with tbe aid of live deoevs. Wilson tells of thirty dozen birds being captured at one spring of tbe net. Audubon stales that he knew a man who, in Pennsylvania, netted 600 dozen pigeons in ono day. When roosting, pigeons were attacked by men armed with guns, poles, clubs, and even pots of snlphnr, and wagon-loads of birds were killed nightly. Similar methods of destruction were employed when tbe birds were nesting. At this sea son the squabs were especially desired J tod the tree# were shaken or felled to ob tain them. When the wants of the hunt ers had been supplied, droves ot hogs were released beneath the neeting trees to feed on the bipds remaining. At one of the last larg/ known pigeon nestings, near Petoaky, Mich., In 1878, it 1* estimated that one billion birds were killed during the season. tuu, iu ones, u ui« ow*/ •traction of the wild pigeon, whoee re markably rapid extermination ia paral leled only by that of the American bison. Daring the period ot ita abundance the wild pigeon was distributed throughout the greater part of eastern North America, from the Hudson Bay region southward to Florida, and raenally westward to Brit ish Columbia. To-day an occasional in dividual is observed at intervals in the Atlantic States, and in the middle and up per Mississippi valley they are seen more frequently. He porta ot their presence in large numbers on the Pacific coast or in various parts of the tropics prove to be based on other species of pigeons.

See the clipping

The Yale Expositor · Yale, Mich.

The item reprints a daily paper's note that only one wild passenger pigeon remains, a 19-year-old female at the Cincinnati zoo whose mate died two years earlier. It states her death would make the species extinct, since naturalists have found no others despite diligent searching.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Yale Expositor · 16 November 1911 · page 12

It stated that only one wild pigeon now remained on the American contineut where not many years ago they were so numerous as to obscure the sky while Hying in huge nocks. This one pigeon s now in the zoo at Cincinnati. It is a female bird l'J years old. Its mate died two years ago. Its demise makes the species extinct as naturalists have been unable to Imd any more alter a diligent search. Many old settlers can relate remarkable stories about their abund ance when beech nuts were ripe. Then they would get so fat and lazy that they were knocked down by hundreds with sticks.

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

This prairie dog article digresses to reference the already-extinct wild pigeon as a warning example, noting it once was shot freely and might have eaten harmful insects. It laments that scientists only discover an animal's ecological value after it has been exterminated, drawing a parallel to the prairie dog's fate.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 22 November 1911 · page 4

Convince us we are living. PAUL COOK* aro occasionally broken in "dog 1/oles” when a village is encountered by ij. gal loping horseman. Farmers charge him with eating a great deal of valnd ,r-i grass. So far as lho investigation has goi/e noth ing lias been said in behalf of tit > prairie dog save that he amuses the pussenge-s upon trains. Scientists have u way of finding out the value of an animal or bird after mistaken agriculti trists -have exterminated it or erring stages have al lowed it to he exterminator'/. The wild pigeon was once game for anyone's gun and no questions asked. Nowadays it is said that the wild pigeon would eat up

See the clipping

The Caucasian · Shreveport, La.

This general article on bird protection discusses the economic and ecological value of birds, citing Audubon Society and Department of Agriculture reports on declining bird populations across the U.S. It specifically mentions that the passenger pigeon, prairie chicken, Carolina paroquet, and bluebird have "almost disappeared from the land," as part of a broader argument for conservation efforts.

The Caucasian · 26 November 1911 · page 8

bird life has d'creased about i6 per 'edn. iallinaeearu hirds. such as the grouse. quail and wild turkey have heei'n most afleteid. Wihlt ducks and shore birds have also noticeahly de 'reased, while ith passenger pigeon. prairie chicken. Carolina paroquet and blue bird have almost, disap peared from the land. But something is being done by states and associa tions to protect the bird world. It is good to read that reserves are be ing established here and there where birds are encouraged to dwell, by feeding in winter from little nesting

See the clipping

El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.

This article about dove hunting technique in the South mentions the passenger pigeon only in passing, citing its legendary flight speed of 80-90 mph as a point of comparison for the dove's swiftness. The piece treats the passenger pigeon's speed as established lore rather than reporting on the bird itself.

El Paso Herald · 28 November 1911 · page 6

learns to know the real dove,' Is Close Relative ef Pigeon. Tbe flight of the passenger pigeon is traditional for its unerring speed and swiftness. Its speed has been esti mated at as high as 80 and 90 mtyes an hour. A close relative of the passenger pigeon is the dove, and it is doubtful if the passenger pigeon, the blue wing teal, the jack snipe 4t the quail, have

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A 1911 Thanksgiving article describes historical customs, including how wild pigeons were once trapped using a decoy duck and a spring net, then fattened before being made into pigeon-pie for the holiday table. It notes this dish, popular in the early nineteenth century, had become rare by 1911.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Topeka State Journal · 30 November 1911 · page 4

The turkey is still king of the Thanksgiving feast and as an addi tion the good things of the field and vineyard have been added. The famous plgeon-plo, which was a popular Thanksgiving dish of the early part of the nineteenth century. Is rarely seen. In those days the wild pigeons which lighted In great num bers on the buckwheat fields were

See the clipping