As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

August 1911

13 articles

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

The article reports the 1910 death of the last known male passenger pigeon, leaving only one female at the Cincinnati zoo. It reflects on the species' former abundance, citing massive historical shipments and flocks, and laments the lack of conservation foresight.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

The Madison Daily Leader · 1 August 1911 · page 2

ONLY ONE LEFT Lut Male of the Passenger .Pigeon Species %t'. Last Year Chicago Evening Post: The editor of the Independent has this to say about the death of a biid: "One of the sad dest records of the year 1910 is tbe death of the only male pateenger pigeon Known to exist in the United States." This may seem to be drawing it a little strong. A bird dies and the death is recorded as one of the saddent events of a year. It is not a bit too strong nentimentally aor, so to speak, sab Htuntiii'ly.

See moreSee less

The passenger pigeon, commonly known as the wild pigeon, is—or must it lie written wast—one of the most beautiful of American birds. Moreover, it was of immense economic valne as an article of food. If the people of a generation ago bad given any thought to the conservation of the country's natural resources there would lie millions of wild pigeons today and we would not lie confronted with tbe piinted offer of a reward of $400 for autbeutic knowledge of a living, nestliug pair of the birds. Tbe passenger pigeons were so nu merous at one time that the atorv of the passing of a floe* composed of mil lions of individnals went unchallenged. Today, so far as is known, one female of the t-pecies in a cage in the Cincin nati zoological gardens is the only liv ing representative of the race, in 1878 from one Michigan town 12,000,000 of the birds were shipped to market in forty days. Records like this are easi ly duplicated. Tbe early voyagers in America told stories of pigeon flights which shut out the son. As late as the centennial year tbe dark clouds of the birds were sti!l passing over head in spring and fall in some parts of the middle west. Man killed tbe birds by every known device, and to day he is sorry. There are some few local records of the last appearances of the wild pigeon in and near Chicago. Two of the birdq were shot in Lake Forest about eighteen yeais ago. and somewhat later two were killed in northern Indiana. A single male pigeon was seen in Lincoln park, near North avenue, in April, 1895. Today ornithologists are on the watch all over the country in the bope that a few pigeons may have been spared. Tbe belief of the scientists is that the species is extinct. Tbe American insisted on pigeon pie. If he had not been a glutton be coold have eaten his pie and still have had it.

See the clipping

The Comet · Johnson City, Tenn.

The article states that passenger pigeons, once so numerous they darkened the sky, are now reduced to a single known survivor, a 13-year-old female in the Cincinnati zoo. It notes that large rewards have been offered for any other specimen but none have been found.

The Comet · 3 August 1911 · page 1

Johnson City. R.L.Jones, superintendent of the Murfreesboro Normal, announced the opening date as Sept, 11. The pro gram will be arranged by Mr. Jones and J. W. Brister, state superintend ent of public instruction. All mem bers of the board will be present at the opening, i neooara adjourned at 5 p m. until the meeting at Murfreesboro. WILD PIGEONS NO MORE. Wild pigeons formerly went in such flocks through this country as to dark en in their nights the very heavens. It is practically established that of these countless numbers there is but one survivor, a female bird 13 years old, in captivity in the zoo in Cincin nati.

See moreSee less

Rewards aggregating several thousand dollars have beon offered first and last for a single specimen, other than the one at Cincinnati, but there have been no takers.

See the clipping

The Dawson News · Dawson, Ga.

The article mourns the death of the last known male passenger pigeon in 1910, leaving only one aging female known to survive. It recounts the species' former overwhelming abundance, citing massive historical shipments of pigeons to market, and laments the recklessness that led to its collapse.

The Dawson News · 9 August 1911 · page 7

AUGUST 9, 1911, From the Independent. One of the saddest records of the year 1910 is the death of the only male passenger pigeon known to ex ist in the United States. One female is known to exist, now about 18 vears old. There were four in Mil wvaukee two years ago and three in Cincinnati. The former are all dead, and only one-of the latter survives. Oceasionally we hear of a flock of these pigeons in some remote corner, but it turns out to be mourning doves or something else in the pigeon line.

See the clipping

The Calumet News · Calumet, Mich.

Fred Platt of the Centennial and Allouez stamp mills reports seeing a wild pigeon in the woods along Torch Lake on several occasions. The report notes that experts had long believed the wild pigeon to be extinct, making the sighting notable.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later.

Wrong

The Calumet News · 10 August 1911 · page 3

FINDS WILD PIGEON. "-"'-1 - FrcV! Matt of tho Centennial and Al loiit". stamp mills claims that for sev eral ila3 past be has seen a wild pigeon in the woods along Torch Itke. Kxperts have believed for years that the wild pigeon had been extermina te d, and for this reason the discov ery is a notable one. Mr, Piatt says there is no possibility of a mistake as b( has seen the bird sever.-. 1 times and has hid an opportunity t study it.

See the clipping

Macon Beacon · Macon, Miss.

A letter writer and editorial argue for protecting birds as vital to agriculture, noting that insect populations are kept in check by birds. The piece cites the extinction of the wild pigeon as linked to subsequent overwhelming locust damage, urging conservation and education.

Macon Beacon · 18 August 1911 · page 4

It is not necessary to recapitu late the contents of the stomachs of various birds to show that they are insect eaters. Every child knows the fact. Not so well realized is the great need of pro tecting the birds. With the ex tinction of the wild pigeon the lo custs came in overwhelming numbers and in some years did millions of dollars damage. The vast flocks of blackbirds so com mon here twenty years ago have dwindled down to few flocks and they small. The number of in sects they destroyed was incalcu lable.

See moreSee less

Other birds must do their work if the balance is to be pre served and the insects kept down to reasonable numbers. The worth of birds in an agri cultural way should be taught in schools, and inculcated with a good hickorv on the minds of boys robbing bird nests. This is not sentiment but sense.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

A newspaper essay on bird conservation notes the passenger pigeon's collapse from vast flocks fifty years earlier to apparent extinction, with only one captive bird known to survive at the Cincinnati Zoological Garden. It uses the pigeon as a cautionary example alongside warnings about the hunting of robins and herons.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 14 days earlier.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 24 August 1911 · page 13

Few of us realize to what extent the slaughter of birds is carried on. some species are being actually exterminated, ror example, the passenger pigeon 50 years ago abounded in quantities that now

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A sportsman discusses hunting gray squirrels and notes the black squirrel has vanished from its old haunts just as completely as the wild pigeon has disappeared. The wild pigeon's extinction is mentioned only in passing as a point of comparison.

The Sun · 27 August 1911 · page 20

"The law doesn't permit our hunting squirrels until late autumn, and then thoy am at their best. The early morning or toward the close of dny is the best time to go out after gray squirrel, which are the only squirrels now left In this latitude worth hunting, the black squirrel seem ingly having disappeared from its old time haunts as completely as the wild pigeon has passed away. It is said that

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A Steuben County man recounts finding decades-old pigeon-netting equipment in a corn crib, prompting memories of the mass trapping of wild pigeons near Pennsylvania's beech woods. The account describes how netters used hickory poles, ropes, and stakes to trap pigeons during feeding and nesting seasons, a practice blamed by some for the bird's extinction.

The Sun · 27 August 1911 · page 20

I annually over the country, a bird now as ;";'! -",r,r h ! i"';t,!n "f letting, ropes, Makes and j poles was a pigeon net. one of the traps I to which some authorities charge the di 'appearance of that curious bird "Ihe vast lieech woods that covered western Pennsylvania nffnrded the food that attiacted the wild pigeons, and during the great flights of the birds toward that feeding ground in th spring netteis from nil ner tho country gathered there to l"vy tiiliute on the bitd The pigeons also nought nestins places n the Wcinity of the beech woods, whein they hatched their young, three Lionels a season Tho ne-tlng tint" was also a harvcM for the netters, although they lin.it In admit :l flilTerent inclli id tnHnr,

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A newspaper account of a massive grasshopper flight over Sabetha triggers old settlers' memories of past passenger pigeon migrations, when flocks were so dense they blocked the sun and broke tree branches with their weight. The writer notes that, like the buffalo, the wild pigeon is now nearly extinct.

The Topeka State Journal · 30 August 1911 · page 4

great delicacy by the Mexicans and Indians, who dig large pits, drive the grasshoppers in and roast them. The flight brings recollections of the wild pigeon to the old settlers. A com paratively few years ago the pigeons were so numerous that during their annual migrations the sun would be obscured by the immense flocks. Mr. Edgar says that back in Ohio the birds would alight on trees at night in such numbers that large branches w-ere broken off by their weight. And now, like the buffalo, the wild pigeon is al most extinct. The flight of the grass hoppers also brings recollections of the "grasshopper days" to the old timers. Sabetha Herald.

See the clipping

In the story →

Gilpin Observer · Central City, Colo. · and 5 other papers

A report claims a lone wild pigeon, possibly the last of its species, has been seen making Jackson Park in Chicago its summer home. A $500 reward is offered for any pair found, with the public urged not to kill the bird if spotted.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Gilpin Observer · 31 August 1911 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

LONELY WILD PIGEON

Only Survivor of Species Believed to Be in Chicago.

See moreSee less

Reward of $500 Offered for Any Pair, and Public Is Warned: "Don't Kill This One If You Find It."

Chicago.—Is there a wild pigeon in Jackson Park? Is an individual bird of a species once numbered by the millions, but now supposed to be extinct, making Chicago its summer home and thereby reviving hope that somewhere there are others and that the pigeons one day may come back to their own?

The story of the reappearance of the bird has much to give it the color of truth. Most scientists are convinced that the wild pigeon, ectopistes migratorius they call it, has gone never to return. The other day, however, Charles E. Hayden, an old-time sportsman and bird student, told Ruthven Deane, president of the Illinois Audubon society, that he had seen a wild pigeon in Jackson Park and that "there was no mistake about it."

About three weeks ago a high school teacher, a man who has made ornithology a study, reported that he had seen a wild pigeon in Jackson Park. The discovery was recorded in the papers, but the scientists who had run down hundreds of reports of this kind, only to find a mistake had been made, were skeptical to the point of disbelief.

Now comes Mr. Hayden, who knew the pigeon when its tribe numbered millions, to make positive statement that a fine male bird of a supposedly extinct race was under close observation by him in Jackson Park for an hour.

It was 4:30 o'clock in the morning when Mr. Hayden went "bird studying" in Jackson Park. He was astounded when he saw the pigeon. He knew the tribe was supposed to be extinct, and that a reward of $500 had been offered for authentic knowledge of the existence of a single nesting pair. He made allowance for deceptive lights and shadows, conditions which might exaggerate the common mourning dove to the size and semblance of its bigger relative, and then was convinced that the stranger was the wild pigeon which he had known in youth.

There was another early morning stroller in Jackson Park, Attorney F. A. Pennington, and Mr. Hayden called him over to see the bird. Mr. Pennington pronounced the bird a wild pigeon. He is familiar with the bird only from description and picture, but he knows the mourning dove, the only species with which the pigeon is likely to be confused, and he knows it well. Mr. Pennington said that barring what appeared to be a motling of the feathers on the back of the neck of the bird was a wild pigeon to a dot.

See the clipping

Also printed in 5 papers
  • Parsons Advocate · Parsons, W. Va. · 31 August 1911
  • The Citizen · Frederick City, Md. · 1 September 1911
  • Jerome News · Jerome, Ariz. · 2 September 1911
  • Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis. · 6 September 1911
  • Baxter Springs News · Baxter Springs, Kan. · 7 September 1911

Gilpin Observer · Central City, Colo. · and 6 other papers

Charles E. Hayden, an experienced bird observer, reported watching a wild passenger pigeon for an hour in Jackson Park at dawn, later confirmed by attorney P.A. Pennington. Scientists remained skeptical, having debunked numerous similar reports of the supposedly extinct bird.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

Gilpin Observer · 31 August 1911 · page 7

LONELY WILD PIGEON

** country of the spread of plague from ship rats beyond the limits of a port. This Is reassuring, the more so as if there had been any such spread It would have been indicated by exces sive mortality in rats. "The evidence appears to indicate that rat plague has been present for several years in East Suffolk. Never theless. during that time only three very limited outbreaks of probable hu man plague have occurred, showring that under the conditions there exis tent human infection is an excep tional and. as It were, an accidental phenomenon.

See moreSee less

As Is well known, the possibilities of spread of plague from rats to man are much smaller in this country than in India.” Bubonic plague is spread by rat fleas. Pneumonic plague, however, can spread from human being to hu man being, especially where the do mestic conditions are uncleanly. The precaution of regarding all cases of pneumonia in a suspected district as plague, obtaining bacteriological an alysis and securing Isolation is recom mended. "A considerable outbreak of human plague might be anticipated.” Dr. Newsholme concludes, "if such fail ure to recognize early cases occurred In a district In which the conditions favored spread by direct Infection by means of fleas.” rlnced that the wild pigeon, ectoplstes mlgratqrtus they call IL has gone never to return. The other day. how ever. Charles E. Hayden, an old-time sportsman and bird student, told Ruth ven Deane, president of the Illinois Audubon society, that he had seen a

See the clipping

Also printed in 6 papers
  • The Port Gibson Reveille · Port Gibson, Miss. · 31 August 1911
  • Parsons Advocate · Parsons, W. Va. · 31 August 1911
  • The Citizen · Frederick City, Md. · 1 September 1911
  • Jerome News · Jerome, Ariz. · 2 September 1911
  • Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis. · 6 September 1911
  • Baxter Springs News · Baxter Springs, Kan. · 7 September 1911

Gilpin Observer · Central City, Colo.

Mr. Hayden reports observing what he believed was a passenger pigeon for an hour in Jackson Park at dawn, despite the species being presumed extinct and a $1500 reward offered for proof. A second witness, Attorney Pennington, who knew the similar mourning dove well, also judged the bird to be a wild pigeon, though noting some unusual neck feather mottling.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Gilpin Observer · 31 August 1911 · page 7

ven Deane, president of the Illinois Audubon society, that he had seen a wild pigeon In Jackson Park and that “there was no mistake about IL” About three weeks ago a high school teacher, a man who has made oral tbology a study, reported that be had seen a wild pigeon In Jackson Park. The discovery was recorded In the pa pers, but the scientists who had run down hundreds of reports of this kind, only to find a mistake had been made, were skeptical to the point ot disbelief. Now comes Mr.

See moreSee less

Hayden, who knew the pigeon when Its tribe numbered millions, to make positive statement that a fine male bird of a supposedly extinct race was under cloße observa tlon by him In Jackson Park for an hour. It waa 4:30 o’clock In the morning when Mr. Hayden went “bird study tng" In Jackson Park He was as founded when he saw the pigeon. He knew the tribe was supposed to be extinct, and that a reward or I&00 had been offered for authentic knowledge of the existence of a single nesting pair He made allowance for decep tlve lights and shadows, conditions which might exaggerate the common mourning dove to the size and sem blanee of Ita bigger relative, and then was convinced that the stranger was the wild pigeon which he had known In youth. There was another early morning stroller In Jackson Park, Attorney P A Pennington, and Mr. Hayden called him over to see the bird. Mr. Pen nlngton pronounced the bird a wild pigeon. He Is familiar with the bird only from description and picture, but he know* the mourning dove, the only species with which the pigeon Is likely to be confused, and be knows It well. Mr. Pennington said that barring what appeared to be a mot ling of the feathers on the back o( the neck of the bird was a wild pigeon to a doL "Rat” Saves Girl. Frankfort. Ky—Miss Nannie Dun can. a school teacher, was kicked In the head by a horse the other day, but her life waa aavod by her 'vat'" of valuable ore. pany. ver ton. 400 level. a month. ** country of the spread of plague from ship rats beyond the limits of a port. This Is reassuring, the more so as if there had been any such spread It would have been indicated by exces sive mortality in rats. "The evidence appears to indicate that rat plague has been present for several years in East Suffolk. Never theless. during that time only three very limited outbreaks of probable hu man plague have occurred, showring that under the conditions there exis tent human infection is an excep tional and. as It were, an accidental phenomenon. As Is well known, the possibilities of spread of plague from rats to man are much smaller in this country than in India.” Bubonic plague is spread by rat fleas. Pneumonic plague, however, can spread from human being to hu man being, especially where the do mestic conditions are uncleanly. The precaution of regarding all cases of well. pneumonia in a suspected district as plague, obtaining bacteriological an alysis and securing Isolation is recom mended. "A considerable outbreak of human plague might be anticipated.” Dr. Newsholme concludes, "if such fail ure to recognize early cases occurred In a district In which the conditions favored spread by direct Infection by means of fleas.”

See the clipping

The Port Gibson Reveille · Port Gibson, Miss.

A newspaper reports that a wild pigeon believed to be the last of its species may be living in Chicago's Jackson Park, sparking hope the species isn't truly extinct. A $500 reward is offered for any pair found, with the public urged not to kill the lone bird if seen.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

The Port Gibson Reveille · 31 August 1911 · page 5

were obtaia ed, and of these about half were of a kind that does not bite The other kind readily: bites man. and wat t found in many cases to man The test was made in be infected. November, an d it is not certain wheth the compa rative freedom of the er English rat fnom fleas holds good in the summer. The probable' channel by which plague was introduced was infected rats, imported with foreign grain. But it is pointed out that no other in stance, with the po&sibite exception of has heed Itnown in this Glasgow, LONELY WILD PIGEON ueas.

See moreSee less

call spread from human be fng^ to hu being, especially whei/e the do man mestic conditions are undean'Jy. The precaution of regarding a) ^ cases of pneumonia in a suspected district as plague, obtaining bacteri* jloglcal an alysis and securing isolati* in is reeom> mended. A considerable outbrer (k of human 'plague might beanticipated," Dr. Newsholme concludes, " If such fail to recognize early cs sea occurred Tire in a district in which tlie conditions favored spread by <flr ect infection -> by means of fleas. vfneed that the wild pigeon, ectopistes,

See the clipping