The article recalls that half a century earlier, passenger pigeons were killed in huge numbers near Lake Ontario for food, yet claims their disappearance couldn't be explained by that slaughter since there was no prior decline in numbers. It states they simply stopped appearing and their new habitats were never found.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 19 days later.
Wrong
The Sauk Centre Herald · 2 January 1908 · page 7
Wild Pigeons. There was never any great “sport” in hunting wild pigeons. Halt a cen tury ago along the shore of Lake On tario, in the town of Sodus, it was no trouble to get a wagonload simply by knocking them from their roosts in the trees at night. But their flesh was delicious, and in certain seasons con tributed in considerable degree to food supply. In those days they were slaughtered by .wholesale, but that hardly accounted for their sudden flight to parts unknown, considering that just before that event there was no apparent diminution in their num bers. They simply stopped coming, and their new haunts were never dis covered.
This 1908 magazine essay by Edwin L. Sabin, reprinted from Lippincott's Magazine, defends sentimental animal stories by arguing humans kill wantonly, citing the slaughter of buffalo and passenger pigeons as evidence of needless destruction. It argues such stories may foster compassion toward animals despite their exaggerations.
The Lee County Journal · 10 January 1908 · page 2
~ Man kills b easily, even so mechanically, with never a . thought for thé¢agomies of the victims., Man is the only an ; " mal which kill, norinally, just for the love of it. Other an . (8 imals of prey b kill to eat or in defence. But it is man who killed "thousands of buffalo bu's, when they were valueless, simply to see them stagger and fall; who slaghtered the passenger pigeons and fed them to the hogs; who catches far mor trout than he can consume, and shoots more ducks -than_he can give away.
See moreSee less
| : i Step &fflx as an average pan may into a wood merry with bird ana squirrel, and he surely must noe the sudden voices of alarm which herald his presence, the hush which atteids hig passage, the outburst again, timidly In. creasing, when he has gone. ‘or through the wood his reputation is that or a murderer, from whom no Iying thing is safe. He is Man; a “varmint” worse than bear and wolf andtiger, snake and hawk. 4 Therefore, if the animal spry, exaggerated as it undeniably is, can bring man to look with more triend{ “and compassionate eye upon his humbler cou-~ sing, and can interest, especiily, the nprising generation, it deserves a Goa speed despite its faults.—Frot Lipp’ncott’s Magazine,
The Savannah Tribune · Savannah, Ga. · and 1 other paper
An essay by Edwin L. Sabin defends sentimental animal stories, arguing humans kill wantonly and without need, citing examples like the buffalo slaughter and passenger pigeons fed to hogs. It argues such stories may foster compassion toward animals despite their exaggerations.
The Savannah Tribune · 11 January 1908 · page 2
The Animal Story
|j ■ with o’er-little? I J I Man kills so easily, even so mechanically, with never a I thought for the agonies of the victims. Man Is the only an mal which kills, normally, just for the love of it. Other an imals of prey to kill to eat or in defence. But it is man who kined thousands of buffalo bulls, when they were valueless, simply to see them stagger and fall; who slaughtered the passenger pigeons and fed them to the hogs; who catches far more trout than he can consume, and shoots more ducks than he can give away.
See moreSee less
Step softly as an average man may into a wood merry with bird and squirrel, and he surely must note the sudden voices of alarm which herald his presence, the hush which attends his passage, the outburst again, timidly in creasing, when he has gone. For through the wood his reputation is that or a murderer, from whom ro living thing is safe. He is Man; a "varmint” worse than bear and wolf and tiger, snake and hawk. Therefore, if the animal story, exaggerated as it undeniably is, can bring man to look with.more friendly and compassionate eye upon his humbler cou sins, and can interest, especially, the uprising generation, it deserves a God speed despite its faults. —From Lippincott’s Magazine.
The Port Gibson Reveille · Port Gibson, Miss. · 16 January 1908
The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.
A correspondent writing to the National Tribune in 1908 recalls witnessing a massive pigeon slaughter near Mantorville, Minnesota in 1873 or 1874, where trappers caught and shipped thousands of birds. He describes learning of a secretive 'United States Pigeon Association' whose members notified each other of roost locations, and later heard that the last roost near Los Angeles was destroyed when a storm drove the survivors out to sea.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The National Tribune · 16 January 1908 · page 3
Slaughter of the Wild Pigeons
SCIENCE AND INVENTION Creating known of his methods The matter is still in the experimental stage with physicians generally waiting further de velopments with Interest The instances in which it has been used are entirely too few to more than hint at its use for that purpose We shall have to wait some time for further information on the subject Editor National Tribune Science XotrM The Marquis do Nadaillac gives mans range of endurance of temperature as equivalent to at least 132 degrees cen tigrade or 236 degrees Fahrenheit His i ia tiitit estimate is based on the recorded facts of 65 degiees centigrade or 85 de grees Fahrenheit observed in the Kara Sea and 677 degrees centigrade or 1518 degrees Fahrenheit in the coun try of the Tuaricks in Central Africa Dr Andries having calculated that accidents from lightning have increased by from three to fivefold during the last 50 years finds that the causes which have been assigned for the phe nomena do not account for all He re gards the main cause as lying in the enormous increase in manufactories lo comotives etc which fill the air with smoke steam and particles of dust of all kinds while the increased popula tions contribute their share to the im purity of the atmosphere His own experiments and those of others have shown that all the electrical phenome na of the air increase in intensity with the increase of dust in it In a military test at Caux on the Lake of Geneva a searchlight with a reflector of 324 feet has thrown its rays 73 miles showing objects distinct ly at 65 miles A generator of 24 horsepower gave a light of 1000000 candles but 40 horsepower is expected to yield 12000000 Slaughter of the Wild PlgeonM Editor National Tribune Upon read ing your article on Wild Pigeons in The National Tribune of June 20 it occurred to me that perhaps some of your readers might be pleased to learn just by what means they were so nearly exterminated In the Summer of 73 or 74 there was a pigeon roost near Mantorville Minn During its presence there I had occasion to visit the place and was astonished to see the thousands of dozens of birds alive In crates and dressed and packed in ice awaiting shipment to various parts of the coun try mostly to Eastern cities I ascer tained by Inquiry that some scores of trappers and hunters had been there many days catching and shooting the old birds and robbing the nests of squabs The sight shocked me as so unsportsmanlike and wasteful While the matter was fresh in my mind I was entertained at the home of one of my parishioners and related to him what I had seen He then confessed that he was a member of The United States Pigeon Association I think that was the name and said that all the mem bers thereof were under obligation whenever either of them knew of a roost to notify every other member of the association whercunon such as de sired so to do set out for the locality wun traps nets guns etc and began their slaughter Ten or 12 years later when some years had elapsed since I had seen a pigeon I met another mem ber of the association and asked him where all the pigeons had cone He said that the last roost had been in the vicinity or Ios Angeles Cal and that nearly all the Dleeons remaining after the usual slaughter had been driven out to sea by a fierce off land gale Since that time I have not seen a pigeon but once heard a cock calling in the woods as I was driving by I am glad to learn by your article that some are still left and hope Congress may take huch steps us win permit mem to increase once more Henry G Bilbie Owatonna Mich Young Soldlem Comrade Wm A Robinson Co E 29th Ohio and Co C 2d Ohio H A Box 17 R F D 29 Wellston Mo states that about the most juvenile rebel killer he knows of is Comrade Nick Karr of F P Clair Post G A R in St Louis who at 11 years of age en listed Aug 7 1862 and served till Jan 23 1864 Comrade Robinson has a hardtack that he drew as part of a ra tion at Chattanooga also a ration of coffee issued to him at Camp Chase O Jan 5 18C2 and he will have to be shown to convince him that any com rade now lias an older ration of coffee Comrade John Amrv rv n itivi Illd HlllfhOH Sriritlrr T v ilnna nvf desire to state as a positive fact that no was uie youngest volunteer In the army but he will maintain that he was one of the youngsters Ho was born Jan 16 1849 enlisted in November ist3 in the 13th Ind Cav but his rather took him out of the service In January 18C4 which did not end it as the comrade enlisted In the 17th on March 10 and served until Aug 7 1863 He was with Ills company all the time carried a rifle and used it too in defense of the Union in a regiment that was In it often and deep so far as hard service and brisk fighting were concerned Comrade Floyd Harris writes from Oneonta X Y that he is not the junior kid of the war but one of the juniors and says I was born Feb 15 1849 I joined Co K 185th X Y with school friends older than myself mustered In Sept 20 1864 arrived at Fortress Mon roe Sept 29 embarked on boats up the James arrived at City Point Sept 30 awakened by heavy firing at the front near Poplar Grove Church we were rushed to the front arrived there about daylight The tight being all over we were left to stand all day in a heavy rain Later In the afternoon we were assigned to the First Brigade First DI vision Fifth Corps and from that time took an active part until the close of the war Henry V Work Ihe Souk Writer Horace W Bailey Rutland Vt wants more Information in regard to Henry c Work the song writer than lln 1ms ltopn tliln tt mm1 t about Walter KIttredge the author of on mo urn camp Ground All that we can say about Mr Work la ihnt tin Wfis linrn In 7VTllIstiin Conn in 1832 and apprenticed to a printer tie nau a taste ror music studied its science and composed songs Among ills popular songs are Lily Dale Wo Are Coming Sister Mary Wake NIcodcmus Marching Hhru Georgia Babelon Is Fallen and A Song or a Thousand Years He wrote a number of temperance songs the most popular of which was Father Dear Father Come Homo With Me Now He went to Europe in 1865 and on his return settled on a farm in Xew Jersey Ho seems to have wearied of song writing and turned his atten tion to invention A knitting machine a walking doll and a rotary engine were among his achievements In this field His accomplished wife became insane and died in an asylum in 18S3 and her husband survived her only one year dying of heart disease June 8 1884 at Hartford He was buried at Spring Grove Cemetery and every year his grave is decorated by the G A It Wo know nothing a to Walter KItt redge Editor National Xrlbune
An elderly Fulton County settler reminisces about frontier farm life, homespun clothing, and primitive mills. He recalls hunting passenger pigeons at roosts at night, killing enough to fill a two-bushel sack.
Canton Weekly Register · 16 January 1908 · page 8
RAMBLER'S NOTES
and other wild game were plentiful, Including many wolves. I used to hunt some and have killed quail, wild pigeons, prairie chickens and wild turkeys, but I never killed a deer. I used to visit the wild pigeon roosts at night with a shotgun and kill hun
An opinion piece on animal stories in fiction argues humans kill wastefully and cruelly, citing the passenger pigeons as having been slaughtered and fed to hogs. It frames this alongside buffalo slaughter as evidence of man's gratuitous violence toward animals.
Tensas Gazette · 17 January 1908 · page 2
with o'er-little? Man kills so easily, even so mechanically, with never a thought for the agonies of the victims Man is the only as mal which kills, normally, j)ust for the love of it. Othme an imals of prey to kill to eat or in defence. But t(l man who eg ooAsands of buffalo bulls, when they were valueless, stmpaly to see them ptagger and fall; who slaughtered the passenger pigeons sad 4d them to the hogs; who catches far more trout than he can consume, and shoots more ducks than he can give away.
A Kennebec Journal item reports a rumor that wild pigeons have reappeared in eastern Maine, prompting reminiscences from an old pigeon-catcher about the era when they were so abundant that dozens sold for 12 to 50 cents. The piece doubts the pigeons could ever again be plentiful and recalls netting methods and a Natural History Society meeting discussion of a supposed recent sighting.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.
Wrong
Evening Star · 19 January 1908 · page 53
Maine's Wild Pigeons.
Bavk row, left to risbtI*, B. Blair, R. C. Fowler, F. H. Joiu>*. C. K. B?vkp?t <phr*i<-al ?lirevlor?. J. Smitb. Flout row?S. J. Mar, C. C. Willi?ni8 |csp(ttio>, ff. M. NaighU for dressed poultry. Duck.s can he quickly | fattened into palatable food at almost any j age: if taken quite thin in flesh and fed ; on ric!.. fattening foods they will fill up with juicy, palatable meat in a few weeks and make fairly good market fowls. Maine's Wild Pigeons. From tho Kennebec Journal. An item has been going the rounds of the Maine papers to the effect that wild pigeons have reappeared in small num bers in the eastern part of the state, and it will undoubtedly be of interest i to many people to know that these birds j
A former pigeon dealer reminisces about the days when passenger pigeons were so abundant they could be netted by the thousands and given away by the bushel. He discusses a recent report that the pigeons have returned, expressing doubt they will ever be plentiful again, while recalling tales of flocks so vast they blotted out the sun.
1 cent per. tried to catch some for their j own use one day and so many got into i the net that they had no; only all they I wanted, but gave away heaps of 'cm, one old man b'-eing the recipient of a bushel basketful." Think of that, you who pay good prices for squabs. If this recent [ report that the pigeons have come back be true, it is extremely doubtful if they ever are plentiful again, and no one will have the pleasure of catching them in nets, which was the principal method of obtaining them.
See moreSee less
So many years have elapsed since they disappeared that one seldom hears them mentioned, and I lie ; man whose net has held thousands told a good deal about the manner in which they were enticed to the "beds" and final ly trupppd. Not long since at a meet ing of the Natural History Society Maj. John M. Gould o' Portland, in some de lightful reminiscences of the early days of the organization, said that a man re po ted at one of the meetings having seen a flock of pigeons so large that It cast a shadow on the landscape. The one time dealer, when this was mentioned to him. said he co.tld not recall that, but lie remembered that when a boy of hear ing his mother declare that site had ee?n so many together that they hid the sun. Parsee Girls. , From tbe Bombay (Snzette. < The l'ars?e girls know the delights now of a game of badminton, the healthful glow that follows a set at tennis. Mayj hap at times, across the joy that comes, ' as the quick-moving bat darts to catch the elusive ball, may flash the wisli that ' her timid Hindu acquaintance or the hidden Moslem girl could share such 1 sports with her. ^ Sunday Dining. From the l.ondoo Bratander. I A feature of modern social life which 1 has come with rapid strides to the fore1 front of fashion during the last few j years is that of dining in public rcstauj I rants, on Sunday nights in particular. During the Victorian era Sunday night dining in restaurants was a privilege reI served exclusively for members of the i dramatic profession. < ?
Vermont Fish and Game Commissioner H. G. Thomas attributes the scarcity of ruffed grouse to overhunting rather than weather or foxes, dismissing cold springs and fox predation as causes. He warns that without strict protection laws, the grouse will become extinct just as the passenger pigeon did.
The Bennington Evening Banner · 20 January 1908 · page 1
RUFFED GROUSE SCARCE Greedy Hunters the Cause, Says Commissioner Thomas
scarce. It Is man, Mr. Thomas says, who Is the worst enemy of the partridge and the pot hunter, who after his spaniel dog has treed the birds kills the last one of a covey, Is responsible for the scarcity. He predicted that unless very stringent protection Is enforced at once, the grouse will become extinct as sure as the passenger pigeon has. He recommended a $25 license for res ident aliens anda law prohibiting them carrying a gun during the closed season. Mr. Thomas said that the fact that 440 more deer were killed in 1907 than during the previous year did not indl; cate a big Increase of deer in Ver mont for there were twice as many hunters in the woods.
See moreSee less
A record like that recently reported, 300 deer illeg ally killed, besides those legally slaugh tered since June 30, 1906, will soon exterminate the deer in this little state. When the farmers begin to re alize the importance of fish and game preservation and to report every vio lation of the laws then public sentim ent will be turned In the right direc tion and not until then will Vermont see proper enforcement of the fish and game laws.
Vermont's Fish and Game Commissioner, Mr. Thomas, warned that ruffed grouse could become extinct like the passenger pigeon unless stricter hunting laws are enforced. He blamed overhunting and "pot hunters" rather than weather or foxes for the grouse's decline, and cited similar deer poaching statistics as further evidence of inadequate enforcement.
Ho predicted that uuless very stringent protection is enforced at once, the. grouse will become extinct as sure as the pas senger pigeon has. lie has recommended license for resident aliens and a law prohibiting their carrying a gun during the closed season. Mr. Thomas said that th fact that 410 more deer were killed iu 1!07 than during the previous year did. not indicate bier increase oi deer in Vermont, tor there were twice as many hunters in the woods. A record like that recently reported, 3fi0 deer illegally killed, be side those legally slaughtered, since June :t(l, HMiO, will soon exterminate the deer in this little state.
See moreSee less
When the farmers begin to realize the importance of fish and game preservation and to report ev ery violation of the laws, then public sentiment will be turned in the right direction and not until then will Ver mont see proper enforcement of the fish and game laws. !.
A New Jersey sportsmen's association president warns that unchecked hunting will doom remaining game species just as it doomed the buffalo and wild pigeon, which he states are now gone forever. He calls for strict hunting laws, licenses, and bans on game sales to prevent further extinctions like that of the nearly-vanished heath hen.
yet to come. If the latter road is to be taken, and its happy consummation real ised, it is necessary that selfish and short-sighted considerations be put aside and facts and conditions fairly met. The people who were respon sible for the wasteful deforestation of the country did not realize that exhaustion of this great wealth of nature was possible until too late; when the countless herds of buffalo roamed the western plains, and great stretches of forest were cover ed with incredible numbers of wild pigeons, poeple believed that waste ful destruction could never deplete these great stores, until, too late, they discovered that beast and bird were gone forever.
See moreSee less
The case of the pitiful remnant of the once numerous and well distrib uted heath hen, now reduced to a few pairs on the island of Martha's Vineyard, where an earnest but al most hopeless effort 1b being made to avert complete extermination, is a present day reminder of the effects of unrestricted shooting. If the other game in the United States la not be brought to the con dition of the heath hen, the buffalo Eind the wild pigeon, sportsmen must awaken immediately and take a de
Vermont fish and game commissioner Henry G. Thomas blames overhunting, not weather or predators, for the ruffed grouse's scarcity. He warns that without strict protection, the grouse will go extinct just as the passenger pigeon did.
The Mirror and Farmer · 30 January 1908 · page 6
tridges. "It is man," Mr. Thomas says, "who is the worst enemy of the game bird, and the pot hunter, who, after his spaniel dog has treed the partridges, kills the last one of the covey, is responsible for the scarcity." Mr. Thomas predicted that unless very stringent protection is enforced and that speedily, the ruffed grouse will become extinct as sure as the passenger pigeon has. He recommends a $25 licensed for resident aliens and a law prohibiting their carrying a gun during the close season.
This is a printed game law statute listing hunting seasons and restrictions for various animals and birds. It specifies that it is unlawful to hunt or capture any passenger pigeon at any time of year.
The Guthrie Daily Leader · 30 January 1908 · page 3
CLOSE SEASON
1 to December If or any passenger Pigeon ot any time. And It shall he unOOnUniMKl On yM .ft Tfrt J"tagAVt JAjMUfrffl THE LgAPEP aUTHftlE. OHLA, 5vT" miftfiifmt-CKij
The Black Hills Union and Western Stock Review · Rapid City, S.D.
This 1908 article is primarily about Muir Woods becoming a National Monument through a gift from William Kent. In a tangential passage criticizing human cruelty to animals, it references the slaughter of passenger pigeons being fed to hogs as an example of senseless killing.
The Black Hills Union and Western Stock Review · 31 January 1908 · page 2
1" prey kill to eat or in dei'eas". it is a man who killed thr.:: v: 'if buffalo bulls, when they werevalu less. simply to see them staggi .• and fall: who slaughtered the passenger pigeons and fed them to the hogs: who cat 'lies far more trout than he can consume, and shoots more ducks tep softiv as an average man may into a wood, merry with bird and squirrel, and he surely must the sudden voices of alarm which hi raid his presence, the hush which attends his passage, the outburts f.gin timidly increasing, when he has gone.
See moreSee less
For through the wood his reputation is that of a murderer, from whom no living thing is safe, lie. is .Man: "varmint" worse than bear and wolf and tiger. s: ake and hawk. Therefore, if the animal story, ex aggerated as it undeniably is. can 111:111 bring to look with more friendiy and compassionate eye upon his hum bler cousins, and can interest, espe cially, the uprising generation, it de serves a God-speed despite its faults.