As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

December 1907

8 articles

The Columbian · Bloomsburg, Pa.

A Benton, Pa. correspondent reminisces about his youth, describing abundant fish and vast flocks of wild pigeons that darkened the skies. He recalls expert pigeon catchers taking hundreds of dozens in a good season, as part of a nostalgic letter about rural life.

The Columbian · 12 December 1907 · page 5

of 4CCCMA est of the family, my experience in early life was that of rough and tumble, over stumps" and stones. Father's farm, in common with neighboring farms, was very stony. But then there was lots of fun aud sport. I think I enjoyed life in youth, in spite of all drawbacks, as well as the youth enjoy life in this late day. I told you last week what some people told me about the shad. In my youth our streams had an abundance of fish, suckers most prolific, and many a good catch did I enjoy.

See moreSee less

But, Oh, could you see the vast flocks of wild pigeons that I have seen, even the heavens spread over with them, it seems to me that the river full of shad would be uo circumstance to the pigeons. Some expert pigeon catchers caught as many as a hun dred dozens in a season of good pigeon flight Yes, excitement, spoit and game were not lacking in my young days. My motive for improving this golden opportunity was to have a little chat with all you Bloomsburg pjople 011 topics most of you do not remember, aud to give you as much ruralistic and antiquarian informa tion as possible. John C. Wbnnkr,

See the clipping

Ladysmith News-Budget · Ladysmith, Wis.

A swarm of about 5,000 wild pigeons settled over a section of West Virginia, the first such sighting in twenty-five years. Farmers and citizens killed hundreds of the birds for food as the flock foraged and broke tree limbs with their weight.

Ladysmith News-Budget · 12 December 1907 · page 6

Swarms of Wild Pigeons. A swarm of 5,000 wild pigeons set tled over this section yesterday, and before they were driven off hundreds of them had been killed by farmers and other citizens attracted by the un usual spectacle —one that has not been witnessed in West Virginia before for twenty-five years. The pigeons were flying low and were evidently foraging. Settling on the limbs of trees in iarge numbers in many instances their weight broke te limbs. One tree, a big fellow, w r as literally stripped of its branches, all that remained being the trunk and here and here a broken ranch.

See moreSee less

Several attacks were made by the citizens on the birds, pigeon pie be ing considered a delectable dish in this section, and hundreds of the feathered invaders were killed.

See the clipping

The Sisseton Weekly Standard · Sisseton, S.D.

A report describes 5,000 wild pigeons descending on a West Virginia area, with many killed by farmers and residents who considered pigeon pie a delicacy. The birds reportedly broke tree limbs with their weight, in a spectacle not seen in the region for twenty-five years.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Sisseton Weekly Standard · 13 December 1907 · page 2

8warms of Wild Pigeons. A swarm of 5,000 wild pigeons set 'led over this section yesterday, and efore they were driven off hundreds if them had been killed by farmers ind other citizens attracted by the un isual spectacle—one that has not been witnessed in West Virginia before for wenty-flve years. The pigeons were flying low and were evidently foraging. Settling on the limbs of trees in large numbers "n many instances their weight broke ,e limbs. One tree, a big fellow, was iteraliy stripped of its branches, all ".hat remained being the trunk and here and here a broken ranch. Several attacks were made by the citizens on the birds, pigeon pie be ng considered a delectable dish In this section, and hundreds of tlu feathered invaders were killed.

See the clipping

The Webster Echo · Addison, W. Va.

Edward A. Preble of the U.S. Bureau of Biological Survey visited Webster Springs to investigate an earlier report of about 500 wild pigeons seen on October 26. The original local story had been distorted by other papers into something ridiculous, even though wild pigeons were believed extinct and a witness recalled massive flocks decades earlier.

CorrectionThis set right 4 earlier articles: Catoctin Clarion, 14 November 1907, The Moorefield Examiner, 14 November 1907, Bisbee Daily Review, 16 November 1907, The West Virginia News, 16 November 1907.

The Webster Echo · 13 December 1907 · page 2

In /estigating the Pigeons. Edward A. Preble, of the bu reau of biological survey of the United States Department of Ag riculture, at Washington, D. C., was here last Thursday night to secure information in regard to the wild pigeons seen near Web ster Springs on Saturday, Octo ber 26, last. This paper, in its issue of Nov ember 1st, mentioned the seeing of this flock of pigeons, estimated to number ( about five hundred, but other papers soon distorted the story and made it appear ridic ulous, resulting in the .whole be ing branded as untrue.

See moreSee less

Wild pigeons were sujiposed to be ex tinct, and the announcement that these had been seen created a fu rore among ornithologists. A writer in Forest and Stream says: “The country about Webster and east thereof, including what used to be known as Hoy’s Wilder ness, was at one time a great roosting place and nesting ground for wild pigebns, and I have seen quite large tracts of timber in the above mentioned districts in which a great many trees had the limbs broken off from the weight of the pigeons alighting on them. I think, without any exaggeration, that during one hunt in the fall of 1878 in Hoy’s Wilderness 1 saw Hocks of wild pigeons that num bered hundreds of thousands. On taking flight the roar of their wings was like thunder, and the whole country seemed alive with them. I killed my last pigeon in 1883 along the foot of the Chest nut Kidge, Fayette county. Pa., and in 1882 killed quite a number from scattered flocks in the same district. It was during the fall, and they were feeding on pin oak acorns. But they are gone, just as the bison has gone, and from all indications, never to return.” Mr. Wm. B. Mershon, of Sag inaw, Mich., has also sent a copy of this yarn, and says: This is another of the sea ser pent stories that so regularly have appeared. The flight must have been tremendous to crush down the forest growth in this way. I think instead of using the birds for potpie, the farmers could have more profitably disposed of them for scientific specimens. I know I would be very glad to pay 1 a good many dollars for a good ' fresh specimen of the passenger pigeon. All of the birds that Prof. Whitman, of Chicago, had ! in confinement are now dead. There are two males still left of the Whittaker flock in St. Louis, and I hear there are a few live birds in the Cincinnati Zoological Gardens, but I am not certain.” Awful Mine Disaster. At Monongah on Friday last there occurred the most disastrous mine explosion in all the mining history of this country, the dead numbering, according to the latest estimate, three hundred and seven ty-one. In mines Nos. 6 and 8 explo sions occurred simultaneously, and the horrors which followed are beyond description. What caused the explosion will probably never be known. To add to the consternation, one of of the mines has twice caught fire. Harrowing scenes have attended the efforts to rescue the bodies of the men entombed beneath num berless tons of stone, earth and debris. There is scarcely a heme in the town which has not lost one or more of its members, and sleepless and hungry widows and orphans have walked tho streets day and night in awful agony. The rescue work proceeds slow ly, and up to V/ednesday morning less than two hundred bodies had been removed from tho mines. Caught Pheasant Alive. On last Friday, during the storm, Mrs. Willis Hamrick went out to her hen-coop to look after her chickens, and 1<> her surprise found a wild pheasant in the coop. It had evidently sought refuge there from from 9otne sportsmen who were hunting at that time near the home. Mrs. Hamrick immediately closed the door and caught the bird, beeping it alive and in captivity uutil the following Wednesday, when Mr. Hamrick brought it to town and sold it to our merchant, A. R Crouch, for 50 cents _ The advance of the prohibition wave is also noted with glee by the men who are in the business of installing water-supply systems in cities large and small. In /estigating the Pigeons. Edward A. Preble, of the bu reau of biological survey of the United States Department of Ag riculture, at Washington, D. C., was here last Thursday night to secure information in regard to the wild pigeons seen near Web ster Springs on Saturday, Octo ber 26, last. This paper, in its issue of Nov ember 1st, mentioned the seeing of this flock of pigeons, estimated to number ( about five hundred, but other papers soon distorted farm. the story and made it appear ridic ulous, resulting in the .whole be ing branded as untrue. Wild pigeons were sujiposed to be ex tinct, and the announcement that these had been seen created a fu rore among ornithologists. A writer in Forest and Stream says: “The country about Webster and east thereof, including what used to be known as Hoy’s Wilder ness, was at one time a great roosting place and nesting ground dren. for wild pigebns, and I have seen quite large tracts of timber in the above mentioned districts in which a great many trees had the limbs broken off from the weight of the pigeons alighting on them. I think, without any exaggeration, that during one hunt in the fall of 1878 in Hoy’s Wilderness 1 saw king. Hocks of wild pigeons that num bered hundreds of thousands. On taking flight the roar of their wings was like thunder, and the whole country seemed alive with them. I killed my last pigeon in 1883 along the foot of the Chest nut Kidge, Fayette county. Pa., and in 1882 killed quite a number from scattered flocks in the same district. It was during the fall, and they were feeding on pin oak acorns. But they are gone, just as the bison has gone, and from all indications, never to return.” Mr. Wm. B. Mershon, of Sag inaw, Mich., has also sent a copy of this yarn, and says: This is another of the sea ser pent stories that so regularly have appeared. The flight must have been tremendous to crush down the forest growth in this way. I think instead of using the birds for potpie, the farmers could have more profitably disposed of them for scientific specimens. I know I would be very glad to pay 1 a good many dollars for a good ' fresh specimen of the passenger pigeon. All of the birds that Prof. Whitman, of Chicago, had ! in confinement are now dead. There are two males still left of the Whittaker flock in St. Louis, and I hear there are a few live birds in the Cincinnati Zoological Gardens, but I am not certain.” Awful Mine Disaster. At Monongah on Friday last there occurred the most disastrous mine explosion in all the mining history of this country, the dead numbering, according to the latest estimate, three hundred and seven ty-one. In mines Nos. 6 and 8 explo sions occurred simultaneously, and the horrors which followed are beyond description. What caused the explosion will probably never be known. To add to the consternation, one of of the mines has twice caught fire. Harrowing scenes have attended the efforts to rescue the bodies of the men entombed beneath num berless tons of stone, earth and debris. There is scarcely a heme in the town which has not lost one or more of its members, and sleepless and hungry widows and orphans have walked tho streets day and night in awful agony. The rescue work proceeds slow cause. ly, and up to V/ednesday morning less than two hundred bodies had been removed from tho mines. Caught Pheasant Alive. On last Friday, during the storm, Mrs. Willis Hamrick went out to her hen-coop to look after her chickens, and 1<> her surprise found a wild pheasant in the coop. It had evidently sought refuge there from from 9otne sportsmen who were hunting at that time near the home. Mrs. Hamrick immediately closed the door and caught the bird, beeping it alive and in captivity uutil the following Wednesday, when Mr. Hamrick brought it to town and sold it to our merchant, A. R Crouch, for 50 cents _ The advance of the prohibition wave is also noted with glee by the men who are in the business of installing water-supply systems in cities large and small.

See the clipping

The Mathews Journal · Mathews Court House

An essay on animal stories in fiction argues that humans kill wantonly, unlike predatory animals who kill only to eat or for defense. It cites the mass slaughter of buffalo and passenger pigeons—fed to hogs—as evidence of humanity's capacity for needless destruction.

The Mathews Journal · 19 December 1907 · page 1

Man kills so easily, even so mechanically, with never a thought for the agonies of the victims. Man is the only. ar mal which kille, normally, just for the love of it. Other ar fmals »f prey to kill to eat or in defence. But it is man wh Kllled thousands of buffalo bulls, when they were valueless, simply to see them stagger and fall; who slaughtered the passenger pigeons and fed them to the hogs; who catches far more trout than he can consume, and shoots more ducks than he can give away.

See the clipping

Pocahontas Times · Huntersville, W. Va.

A flock of about 500 passenger pigeons was reportedly seen near Addison, with newspaper accounts multiplying the number, prompting skepticism. A Department of Agriculture specialist visited Webster to investigate, and the actual sighting was clarified as a single wild pigeon seen feeding near a warehouse.

Pocahontas Times · 19 December 1907 · page 3

A letter has been received from the cbitf b*«<1 man at (hi State University in r'gerd to wild or, o >r« e irrsetlr, p^»,enger pigeons Some mantle si o a flock of aoino fi7e hundred pigeons were reported in ihe Webster Echtf to have been seen noaV Addisop. Me'ropolitan pergnpbeis multi plied/- tho number a hundred fol<H'r.id thrn eve ry body thought it was a lio. Last week a special ist frrm liie Department of agri r^tar* visited Webtdcr to inves-. Viga'e the truth cf the report and if < ' possible secure specimen or eve® feathers and wirgs.

See moreSee less

Our reply to the irqniry from rhr State -^Diversify was ib*t A few months *go J' \Vr. Crirry and .this writer had seen and observed for some a sagla wild pigeon that time feeding on grains scattered around Mr, Hurry’a ware rooms. Much interest is manifested by natural i»ri in the passenger pigeon which

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

A circulating item in Maine papers claims wild passenger pigeons have reappeared in the eastern part of the state. The report recalls days when the birds were so abundant they sold for a few cents a dozen and were given away by the basketful.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Washington Herald · 22 December 1907 · page 16

Old North Carolina Corn Whisky. MAINE'S WILD PIGEONS. Once Plentiful Game Said te Be Re turning to Granite State, from Te IN An item has been going the rounds of the Maine papers to the effect that wild pigeons have reappeared in small num bers in the eastern part of the State, and it will undoubtedly bg of interest to many people to know that these birds were once so plentiful hereabouts that the price was 5 cents a dozen, while a man who formerly made a business of catching them every year told a Portland reporter that he had known them to be as low as 12 cents a dozen.

See moreSee less

“When they were at that figure,” he remarked, “some neighe bors of mine who didn’t care to take the troubie to pick them for 1 cent per, tried to catch some {or their own use one day, and $0 many got into the net that they had not orly ail they wanted, but gave away heaps of em, one old man being the

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

A 1907 article recounts reminiscences from Portland locals about when passenger pigeons were so plentiful they sold for 12 cents a dozen, with one man recalling catching so many in nets that he gave away bushel baskets of surplus birds. The piece includes a Natural History Society meeting anecdote about flocks so vast they cast shadows and blocked the sun, alongside skepticism about recent reports of the birds' return.

The Washington Herald · 22 December 1907 · page 16

MAINE'S WILD PIGEONS Once...

"Phone M. 761. recipient of a bushel basketful” Think ‘of that, you who pay good prices for Squabs.. If this recent report that the pigeons have come back be true, it is extremely doubtful if they ever are plenti ful again, and no one will have the peas ure of catching them in nets, which was the principal method of obtaining them. 8¢ many years have elapsed since they disappeared that one seldom hears them mentioned, and the man whose net has held thousands told a good deal about the manner in which they were enticed to the “beds” and finally trapped.

See moreSee less

Not long since at a meeting of the Natural History Society Maj. John M. Gould, of Portland, in some delightful reminiscences of the early days of the organization, said that 4 man reported at one of the meetings having seen a flock of pigeons so large that it cast a shadow on the landscape. The one-time dealer, when this was men tioned to him, said he remembered that when a boy he heard his mother declare that she had seen so many together that they hid the sun.

See the clipping