As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

September 1907

6 articles

Pocahontas Times · Huntersville, W. Va.

The newspaper recounts a supposed sighting of a passenger pigeon near Marlinton, prompting the editor and locals to recall the once-vast flocks that darkened the sky decades earlier. An old resident describes pigeons so numerous they nearly stripped a field of cut buckwheat, contrasting with only occasional 'stragglers' seen in recent years.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

Pocahontas Times · 5 September 1907 · page 2

POCAHONTAS TIMES.

THURSDAY, September 5, 1907 One day last week while in com pany with J.W. Curry at bis feed ■tore our attention was called to a dove-like bird which was picking up grain that had been lost upon the ground. Years ago we had seen a wild pigeon and immediate ly recognized the bird to be one of the long loBt host which in time gone by had darkened the heavess in their flight. Mr. Curry well remembered these wonderful flights and he was better able to identify the bird than we.

See moreSee less

The pigeon aeeraed tame, came quite near while hunting food, and fed around for many minutes. It finally dis appeared toward Buckley Moun tain, and has not been seen to re turn to feed again. It has beeD many years since wild pigeons were here in numbers but a few stragglers have been seen every year or so. Mostly, however, in the deep-woods of Walliams and Cranberry country they have been fonnd, usually two together. They are smaller than the com mon pigeon, about the size of tho turtle dove which they resemble somewhat in color, only they are much browner and are entirely different in form of body, wings and tail. In speaking of pigeons to an old resident, he well remem bered the immense flocks which he had seen when a boy. The very high point west of Buckeye was a roosting place, and in the evening lines of birds apparently miles long would streak the sky, coming in for the night. On his father’s place was a large Held of buckwheat which had been cut and cocked up. One morning the pigeons discovered the grain and thousands lit down upon the field. Two boys were sent there to mind off the birds until suffi cient help could be procured to flail it out. So numerous were the pigeons that in a few days they would have taken every grain in the large field. Five or six years since he had seen a pair on Cranberry, the last he had heard of in this county. In the sport ing papers every few weeks one reads of wild pigeons being seen in small numbers in different parts of the country, justifying the opin ion that a bird which was believed to be entirely extinct is gradually on the increase. Many are the suppositions as to what became of the immense flocks which so sud denly disappeared twenty or more years since. One writer in the Forest and Stream claims to have found the same identical bird in Central America in undiminish ed numbers, where they were a menace to growing grain. In the Charleston Gazette is an account of one ‘’Rev” J. H Rat liff going back to the pen for hav ing violated his parole by stealing a horse. Ratliff stole a horse in this county about ten years ago, and was sent to the penitentiary, a*.He served out his term, stole an other horse, and was sentenced to ten years more. About half of s time was out and he was pa roled last Decenber. He is now back again on the same old of feDse. Ritliff professed to be a minister, and it is said that he was really in charge of a circuit at one time, but he evidently fell from grace and has continued so todo ever since. Negroes in search of opportuni ties outside the South to do the work for which they are best fit ted are not likety to flock to Indi ana. A contractor failing to se cure 25 white men to build a big ditch in Gibson county, in that State, brought in 25 negroes. The white farmers resented this move and refused to supply the negroes with provisions. This difficulty, too, was overcome by the contrac or by shipping in provisions, and when this was discovered the far mers attacked the negroes with clubs and stones, while others stood by with guns and pistols ready to fire upon the Eegroes

See the clipping

Daily Public Ledger · Maysville, Ky.

A brief item recalls that wild pigeons once flew in such numbers they darkened the sky over the region. It states that these birds are now practically extinct.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Baltimore County Union, 6 July 1907, The Wisconsin Weekly Advocate, 18 July 1907, Pocahontas Times, 5 September 1907.

Daily Public Ledger · 11 September 1907 · page 1

I It's likely there Isn't n damson pl'um, which raseu 10 oe sucn a common iruic, now to pe s found In the country. ' ' The steady downpour of rain for several hour's yesterday did not benefit the growing to. baccp and corn crops. Wild pigeons, which years ago used to obscure the sun in passing over this section, are , .now practically extinct. Tho Knights of Pythias got a bargain in eecuring the entire front of the Cooper building, .now being razed to give place to the new Bank building, for $175.

See moreSee less

The iron front and cor- , inice is alone worth, according to competent .: judges,. $1,000. The Order is contemplating . the erection of a building on their site oppo- ,site the Opera-house in 'West Second street, -and will utilize the material in Its construction.

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

The magazine Recreation reports its long-held belief that the passenger pigeon is not extinct, citing sightings from several U.S. states since 1899. It highlights naturalist John Burroughs' investigation of a flock near Livingston Manor, New York, and President Roosevelt's reported sightings of a flock near Pine Knot, Vermont.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 12 September 1907 · page 8

AVeM " the Heart til It was ns large as the Australian crane and If the wings of the insct wore etilnrgeil to maintain the propor tion they now bear to Its body. they would babout one hundred and fifty limes larger than the rrane's. It requires ?,.C2 sepia re feet of wing area per pound to float the bank swallow, but to sustain tin lawny vulture, a monstrous bird In com parison, rertilr-s nnlv .IS of a square foot of wing surface per pound of bndv. The albatross, weighing, eigh teen pounds, has a spread of wing of eleven feet and slv Inches, while the trumpeter swan.

See moreSee less

weighing twenty eoght pounds, has si spread of wing of onlv eight foot. The stork wi Igns eight pounds, hns a spread of wing of In proportion lias only half 11s much wing surface. "The Mystery of tilril 1'llght." In 'he August 'Everybody's. 1iik.ti iiv or Tin: iNi:t;i:ii rii; i:o. For several years pist Recreitton has been convinced that the p is-enu'er pigeon (Ectoplstes mlgratnrlus) is not extinct, notwithstanding the generally necepti d b lief to the contr.nry. Reliable nlis, rv.i tlons of the occurrence of tin -e b nls have enmo to this magazine from Manito ba. Minnesota, Wisconsin, Michigan, Il linois, Indiana, Ohio, Kcntuckv and Now Ymk Stale at various times since 1W, In June last a communication frcm John r.nrroughs. the celebrated natur alist of West I'nrk, N. told of his having Just recently made a trip to Sul livan County, N. Y to Investigate a rumor of wild pigeons having been seen there. Mr. Utirroughs s,t,i he had met two persons who had seen the pigeons, one an old farmer who knew the birds in well as anyone could know them. The pigeons, a Hock of sevor.il hundreds, were s-oon on the afternoon of Mav !rd, .1 ft w miles ninth of Livingston Manor, near I!eaervlllo, a lorihtv familiar to many New York anglers and ;;rotis - hunters. Mj liurroughs declaied he as fully con vlneed that the pigeons wenseen. Pur tbermore, he slated that about the same time he ha' received a letter from Presi dent Ttoievolt In which the President re. ported having seen a Hock of wild pige ons near PlnoNKnot, Vt. He s.ihl the President had been tho birds "Jver.il times, that he had verlllod their Identity through a friend of his living near there, Mr. Hurrniighs was of the iv.ri-unn that there could be no doubt at all about the President hiving seen the genuine pas tenger pigeon. September Recreation. Tin: ni'.iiocii rs i:TitiniiTv i Tut: MM'Tir. oi'i'ouTrxiTV. Tin I e has never been a better chance In our whole (Mimical history, says Hut World's Work Tor September, for a man to do a g-eat political service than then Is now for a democrat, preferably from some .southern State, to come forward nnd claim the nominationthe right kind of man on the right kind of platform. Ho must be national In thought, lie must have no sectional .self-couselousness. Ho trust leave the war nlnne-a war thar ended before he became of age. lliymust talk of something else besides the "negro problem." lie must have a program of interest and of justice to men alike In Maine and In Cn-orgla, in Minnesota and Oregon. He must not be "afraid of Ids shadow," nor of Mr. llrvan. nor of the backward southern political press, lie must speak tho language of Tllilon and of Cleveland, and this must be also his own language. The nomination of such n man ' 'ght not lead to his election next year (who Is suro that any demo crat can be elected next year?), but It would IiiIiij: tho party and the South out of the utterly hopeless death-valley of Its self-conscious sectionalism; uuil that would bo a meat gulp,,

See the clipping

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

An opinion piece defends anthropomorphic animal stories in fiction, arguing humans kill wantonly unlike other predators. It cites the passenger pigeons being slaughtered and fed to hogs as an example of man's needless destruction of wildlife, alongside buffalo and overfishing.

The Butler Weekly Times · 19 September 1907 · page 4

Plea For the Animal Story. Edwin L. Sibln, In Llpplnoott' . Criticised though they are, these animal stories so popular of late In fiction as being mawkish, eupersentlmental, unnatural misinforming Is it not better to Invest the beast and bird creation with o'er-much humanlzatlon rather than with o'er little? Man kills so easily, even so mechan ically, with never a thought for the agonies of the victims. Man Is the only animal which kills, normally. justfor the love oflt. Other animals of prey kill to eat or in defense. But it Is man who killed thousands of buSilo bulls, when they were value less, simply to see them stagger and fall; who slaughtered the passenger pigeons and fed them to the hogs; who catehes far more trout than he can consume, and shoots more ducks than he can give away.

See moreSee less

Step softly as average man may Into a wood merry with bird and squirrel, and he surely must note the sudden voices of alarm which herald his presence, the hush which attends his passage, the outburst again, timidly increasing, when he has gone. For through the wood his reputation is that of a murderer, from whom no living thing Is safe. He Is Man; a varmint" worse than bear and wolf and tiger, snake and hawk. Therefore, if the animal story, ex aggerated as It undeniably Is, can bring man to look with mors friend ly and compassionate eye upon his humbler cousins, and can Interest, especially, the uprising generatlon.it deserves a godspeed, desDite Its faults.

See the clipping

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · St. Johnsbury, Vt.

A 1907 piece on wild geese and ducks digresses to note the passenger pigeon's disappearance from the area, quoting Audubon's famous 1813 description of mile-wide flocks darkening the sky over Kentucky. It cites his calculations estimating over a billion pigeons in a single flock and the enormous food they consumed daily.

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 25 September 1907 · page 2

in excess of what they are now, for the gunners, each seastfn, cut into their numbers tremendously. It is not so many years ago that we had the wild Pigeon with us in this locality. We have them no ' more. To show how numerous these were at one time, let me quote from Audubon. "In the autumn of 1813, I left my hotfse at Henderson, on the banks of the Ohio, on my way to Louisville. I observed the Pigeons flying from north east to southwest in great numbers. I traveled on, and still met more the farther I proceeded.

See moreSee less

The air was literally filled with Pigeons. The light of the noonday was obscured as by an eclipse. Before sunset I reached Louisville, dis tant from where I first saw the Pigeons 4-5 miles. The Pigeons were still passing in undiminished numbers, and continued to do so for three days in succession. The people were all in arms. The banks of the Ohio were crowded with men and boys, incessantly shooting at the pil grims, which flew lower as they passed the river. Multitudes were thus des troyed. For a week or more, the popu lation fed on no other flesh than that of Pigeons." In estimating the number of these mighty flocks, and the food con sumed by them daily, he adds: "Let us take a column of one mile in breadth, which is far below the average size, and suppose it passing over us at the rate of one mile a minute. This will give us a parallelogram of 180 miles by one, covering 180 square miles; and allowing two Pigeons to the square yard, we have one billion one hundred and fifteen millions one hundred and thirty six thousand Pigeons in one flock; and as every Pigeon consumes daily fully half a pint, the quantity required to feed such a flock, must be eight millions seven hundred and twelve thousand bushels per day." I am indebted to a member of the club referred to for these statements concern ing the wild geese. C. H. Horton.

See the clipping

Canton Weekly Register · Canton, Ill.

G. T. Baylor, a longtime county resident, recounts memories of massive passenger pigeon flocks that once darkened the sky and broke tree branches when roosting. He describes his father's method of using live decoy pigeons tied to strings to lure wild flocks into nets, which he says gave rise to the term 'stool pigeon.'

Canton Weekly Register · 26 September 1907 · page 5

master at the East Cuba mine. —Mrs. Lee Cobb and children and her mother. Mrs. Jacobs, moved here from Good Hope Friday. —Word received here by his par ents from Glen Smith, who is attend ing the university at Champaign', is that he passed the entrance examin ation and entered the course with colors flying. —Miss Fenna Beeler of North Platte. Neb., who has been here visit ing her sister, Mrs. M. E. Scott, and ^Mher relatives, left Saturday morn ing for Chicago to fake a scientific course at the Northwestern university.

See moreSee less

—G. T. Baylor, who has been a res ident of the county for nearly 00 years, was telling Friday of the im mense llo<fks of wild pigeons that Swarmed across the land when he was a boy, and the means that were taken to capture them in nets. They would My so thick as to obscure the sun like a thick cloud, and settling down on trees for the night, would break off branches with their weight. While resting at night they had the habit, like bees, of keeping their wings flut tering slightly, which made'a -noise tiiat could b« heard a long distance. The “Rich woods,” asNthe country be tween Canton and Lewistown was called, was a great feeding and roost ing gr mnd for them, and below the then villagd^of Canton was where Mr. Baylor lived. His father had a large pigeon net which he would stretch on sticks in a manner that he could, by pulling H>ng strings, throw the net over quite a large space of ground. But pigeons were shy birds, and "to get then in the net one or more would be caught and a long string tied to their feet and when a flock of wild ones was seen flying past, they would bo allowed to fly td the end of the string, and then by pulling them slow ly back they would look as though settling down to feed. This would ut traet the attention of the other and as there •/as corn, buckwheat or some other grain for bait on the ground, they would quickly settle down to eat. Then tin* trapper would throw his net, and hundreds of them were his vie iiiiib. i i«'iu imsr jM&e'Mis uuii nni used to trap their mates comes the expression of “stool pigeon,” used ;i slur on any one who will assist in

See the clipping