As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

October 1907

6 articles

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A literary essay reprinted from Lippincott's magazine discusses animal stories in fiction, arguing that even exaggerated humanization of animals is preferable to human indifference toward their suffering. It cites the killing of buffalo for sport and the slaughter of passenger pigeons fed to hogs as examples of wanton human cruelty.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 6 October 1907 · page 17

The Animal Story. Eclwln E, Sabin in September Lippin cott’s. Criticised though they are—these an imal stories so popular of late in fic tion—as being mawkish, supersentl rnental, unnatural, and misinforming, is it not better to invest the beast and bird creation with o’er-much Human ization rather than with c'er-little? Man kills so easily, even so mechan ically, with never a thought for the agonies of the victims. Man Is the only animal which kills, normally, just for 1 the love of It. Other animals of prey kill to eat or In defense.

See moreSee less

But it Is man who killed thousands of buffalo bulls, when they were valueless, simply to see them stagger and fall; who slaugh tered the passenger pigeons and fed them to the hogs; who catches far more trout that lie can consume, and shoots more ducks than he can give away. Step softly as an average man may Into a wood merry with bird and squir rel. and lie surely must note the sud den voices of alarm which herald his presence, the hush which attends his passage, the outburst again, timidly Increasing, when he has gone. For through the wrood his reputation is that of a murderer, from whom no living thing is safe. lie Is Man; a “varmint” worse than bear and w'olf and tiger, snake and hawk. Therefore, if the animal story, exag gerated as it undeniably is, can bring man to look with more friendly and compassionate eye upon bis humbler cousins, and can Interest, especially, the uprising generation, it deserves a God-speed despite its faults.

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

This opinion piece defends sentimental animal stories as a way to make humans more compassionate toward wildlife. It cites the wasteful killing of buffalo and passenger pigeons—fed to hogs rather than eaten—as examples of man's uniquely wanton cruelty toward animals.

The Washington Herald · 13 October 1907 · page 19

Edwin L. Sabin in September Lippincott's. Criticised though they ara-these ane {mal stories so popular of late in fiction —ms being mawkish, supersentimental, unnatural, and misinforming, is it not better to. invest the beast and bird cre. ation with o'er-much humanisation rather than with o'er-little? Man kills so easily, even sec mechan ically, with never a thought for the agon« jes of the victims, Man is the only an ima! which kills, normally, just for the love of it. Other animals of prey kill to eat or in defense. But {it is man who killed thousands of buffalo bulls, when they were valueless, simply to see them stagger and fall, who sisughtered the passenger pigeons and fed them to ths hogs.

See moreSee less

who catches far more trout than he can consume, and shoots more ducks

See the clipping

Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.

The magazine Recreation argues the passenger pigeon is not extinct, citing sightings from multiple states since 1898. It highlights John Burroughs' investigation of a flock near Livingston Manor, NY, and a letter from President Roosevelt reporting sightings near Pine Knot, Va.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Perth Amboy Evening News · 17 October 1907 · page 6

RETURN OF THE PASSENGER PIGEON, For several years past Recreation has been convinced that the passenger pigeon (Ectopistes migratorius) is not extinct, notwithstanding the generally accepted belief to the contrary. Reli able observations of the occurrence of these birds have come to this magazine from Manitoba, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Michigan. Illinois. Indiana, Ohio. Ken tucky and New York state at various times since 18y8. In June last a communication from JoJhn Burroughs, the celebrated natur alist of West Park, Ν. Y., told of his having just recently made a trip to Sul livan county.

See moreSee less

Ν. Y., to investigate a rumor of wild pigeons having bien seen there. Mr. Burroughs said he had met two persons who had seen the oigeons, one an old farmer who knew the birds as well as anyone could know them. The pigeons, a flock of several hundred, were seen on the afternoon of May 23«rd, a few miles north of Liv ingston Manor, near Beaverville, a lo cality familiar to many New York ang lers and grouse hunters. Mr. Bur roughs declared he was fully convinced that the pigeons were seen. Further more, he stated that about the same time he had receivèd a letter from President Roosevelt in which the Pres ident reported having seen a flock of wild pigeons near Pine Knot, Va. He said the President had seen the birds several times, that he had verified their idently through a friend of his living near there. Mr. Burroughs was of the opinion that there could be no doubt at all about tile President having seen the genuine passenger pigeon.— September Recreation.

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The report announces that a flock of an estimated 10,000 wild pigeons is nesting in Sullivan County, New York, claiming this proves the species is not extinct as popularly believed. It then recounts the historic abundance of passenger pigeons in Pennsylvania and New York decades earlier, describing roosts miles long and the slaughter by hunters.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Washington Herald · 18 October 1907 · page 6

If in past years the contributions to the one. Presidential campaign funds have come from the “yellow dog accounts” of cor porations, then there will be €wapty treas uries for the national comnilttees next year. i structor of cavalry, and he was com-| mended for special efficiency by the In- | spector General of the army in 1884. Wild Pigeons Coming Back. The announcement that a flock of wild pigeons, estimated at 1,000 birds, are nest ing in Sullivan County, New York, proves

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

This article recounts the enormous historical flocks of passenger pigeons, describing roosts miles long and the massive commercial slaughter that shipped tons of birds to city markets. It closes by claiming that after near-extermination, legal protection is allowing the birds to return and that great flocks may form again if laws are enforced.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Washington Herald · 18 October 1907 · page 6

If in past years the contributions to the one. Presidential campaign funds have come from the “yellow dog accounts” of cor porations, then there will be €wapty treas uries for the national comnilttees next year. i ing in Sullivan County, New York, proves that this bird, once go numerous, is not | extinct, as has been popularly supposed. Thirty years ago, wild pigeons were to be geen by the million in Potter, Elk, War- | ren, McKean, and Cameron counties, New | York. In Potter and McKean counties was one of the largest nesting grounds in North America.

See moreSee less

Their roosts were from four to Ave miles long and from one to three miles wide, and their numbers 3 man could count. No other birds were ever known to migrate in such num bers. These pigeons swept across the sky in such masses that it is not exaggeration to say that they often obscured the sun. Hunters were permit ted to shoot and net them on their nesting grounds, so that the slaughter was ter rific. In one day in 1851 the American Ex- | press Company carried from the northern | tier of Penngylvania and the southern tier of New York, over the Erie Railway, seven tons of pigeons to the city market, and in one season the total aggregated ! fifty-six tons. Hunters shot them by the!

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Virginia Citizen · Irvington, Va.

The piece looks back thirty years to the massive passenger pigeon nesting grounds in Pennsylvania and New York, describing how hunters shipped tons of birds to market daily before protective laws came too late. It draws a parallel to the depletion of Virginia's oyster beds, urging conservation before it's too late.

Virginia Citizen · 25 October 1907 · page 2

Our child-readers will doubtle88 recall some months ?go an article in this paper from "His Nibs" on the wild-pigeon rOBBBi of McKean county, ENrBBBflvaaia. . A recent writer iu a nnrthrrn pfriodical la iu?ut8 the llaagat** of these benuti ful and toothsnne birda and shows how law, if eiiito'ed promptly, would h*ve saved ili<- billiona of wild pigeous aud left a liveiibood to those among their htunts Thirty years ago wila i.igeonrt wnf found by the tnilli.itm ia Pwcttr, Warreu, McKean aud Cameron countits, Pennsylvani*. and in Chemuug. Steuben and Alle ghauy couutiea, N*??

See moreSee less

York. In Pot Ur and McKe.su counties was one of the largestues'.ing grounds in Amer ica. The pigeon* migrated to these parts unnually ia April, legions of them. Tbeir rooets were from four to five milei long and from one to three miles wide, and their number no man could count Hunters were permittcd to shoot and net them on their ne*ting grounda. The slaugh ter of the innocents was aomething terrific In one day the American Express Company carried from the Northern Tier of Pennsylvania and B nuhem Tier of New York over the Erie railway seven tons of pigeons to the city market. In one week the total aggregated 56 tons. Tben the law came in and prohibited the trapping or slaughteriog within two miles of their "roosta" But it was too late. As with the buffalo so with the pigeon; "the stable was

See the clipping