As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

October 1905

12 articles

The Citizen · Berea, Ky.

A Kistler's Valley correspondent reports that wild pigeons, long thought nearly extinct, are supposedly returning in numbers alongside huntable turtle doves. The piece recalls the area's past as a massive passenger pigeon roosting ground and the wasteful mass slaughter that once occurred there.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Citizen · 5 October 1905 · page 4

WILD PIGEONS RETURNING / Pennsylvanians Are Now Looking For Them In the Wake of Turtle Doves

were ground groundWild Wild pigeons formed tho staple mea food tnr hundreds of families through out the wtnter They were killed am I salted down One could buy tw < down pigeons for five ante or Ion la spite of the Immense slaughter It hail no npprtclabln effect In redueln their number Each spring the peopl would hear a peculiar booming whirring sound and on looking up they would leo cloud after cloud of pI eons swooping up from the souther hortwn and seeking their old roost Ing pinto For miles around the new would speed nearly as fait as the flocks that the pigeons are coming and preparaltnm fer the staHgbte would be made One year tho people looked In rat for their annual food supply of pI goons They never came again and although over halt a century bas come and gone this tragic mystery In the feathered kingdom has never beer solved To this day no one know what swept away In one MMon mil lions of wild pigeons In this connection a curlou prophecy Is remembered Years ag an old manMid When once anal the wtM tattle dove Is shot IB 1111111 eaunty look for the return of tke wile pigeons bat net beta It to a strain commentary upon tlte above that within tits past year awn than one huutor has reported stria null locks of wild plgeeus In Ihl county but so swift ou u wing sa so sky were they that no shot could be nude effective That tbe turtle dove Is the arse t courier of the wild pigeon Is behev < by many an old hooter

See the clipping

The Mirror and Farmer · Manchester, N.H.

A Pennsylvania writer recalls the vast pigeon roosts of Kistler's Valley decades ago, describing the wasteful slaughter of countless birds despite no apparent reduction in their numbers. The piece claims that one year the pigeons simply never returned, calling their disappearance an unsolved mystery to this day.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Mirror and Farmer · 5 October 1905 · page 8

A firstclass fox dag; one that will fol low no other kind of game; one that has had numerous foxes shot ahead of him; one that will not follow a back track; one that will not dig at hole after having run a fox in; one that has a good voice; one that never quits a good trail until dark; one that has good hard feet, that are not prone to get sore. Address with particu lars Fox Hound, MIRROR Office, Manches ter, N. H. _ ing $2200. ^ # For the first time in many years the shooting of wild turtle doves is allowed in the state of Pennsylvania, and this bird, once thought to be almost extinct, i s now so plentiful that big bags are being se cured by hunters.

See moreSee less

Kistler's Valley (Penn.) years ago was famous as the roosting and breeding place of thousands of wild pigeons, and there are still some of the older people left, says a Pennsylvania writer, who can tell stirring tales of the countless thou sands of wild pigeons that obscured the sun in their flight, and when they alight ed in a forest crash upon crash was heard as branches broke under their weight. The slaughter was proportionate to the density of the roost. There was no sport connected with it; it was simply slaugh ter. One could knock them over by the hundreds by merely using a pole. Many killed for the sake of wanton killing, and thousands of the birds were left to rot on the ground. Wild pigeons formed the staple meat food for hundreds of families throughout the winter. They were killed and salted down. One could buy two dozen pigeons for five cents or less. In spite of the im mense slaughter it had no appreciable ef fect in reducing their number. Each spring the people would hear a peculiar booming, whirring sound, and on looking up they would see cloud after cloud of pigeons sweeping up from the southern horizon and seeking their old roosting place. For miles around the news would speed, nearly as fast as the flocks, that "the pigeons are coming," and prepara tions for the slaughter would be made. One year the people looked in vain for their annual food supply of pigeons. They never came again, and, although over half a century has come and gone, this tragic mystery in the feathered kingdom has never been solved. To this day no one knows what swept away in one season millions of wild pigeons. In this connection a curious prophecy is remembered. Years ago an old man said: "When once again the wild turtle dove is shot in Lehigh county then look for the return of the wild pigeons, but not before." It is a strange commentary upon the above that within the past year more than one hunter has reported seeing small flocks of wild pigeons in this coun ty, but so swift on the wing and so shy were they that no shots could be made effective. That the turtle dove is the avant cou rier of the wild pigeon is believed by many an old hunter.

See the clipping

Sharp County Record · Evening Shade, Ark.

A settler's reminiscence describes passenger pigeons as the most numerous birds in early Arkansas, with roosts half to three-fourths of a mile wide and nearly two miles long. He recounts how locals harvested pigeons at night by hand or with sticks, and how their collective noise was so loud it drowned out normal conversation.

Sharp County Record · 6 October 1905 · page 1

EARLY HISTORY. jp- (Gon-Uni! Fd Tro m last week.) There were a great many birds ] here in the early days; the wild j pigeon, quail or partridge, the prairie chicken, the dove, snow bird, redbird, blackbird, crow,; wild ducks, geese, and other, birds of various kinds. The wild pigeon was the most numerous. In the falls and win- ; ters of 1847, ’4B and ’49, they ■ were here by the millions. They : roosted on the ridge or little hill 1 north of the John S. Medley mill ; and creek.

See moreSee less

Their roost was from ■, a half to three-fourths of r. mile ]; wide and near two miles long, ; and every part of the trees, limbs ; and bushes would be loaded as ’ ] thickly as could be with pigeons.] ] At night one could hear the trees j,

See the clipping

Sharp County Record · Evening Shade, Ark.

A first-person recollection describes how men and boys once harvested passenger pigeons by hand, stick, and torchlight at a massive roosting site, with birds so numerous they darkened the sky for nearly an hour as they left each morning. The account recalls the noise, heat, and chaos within the roost, and the practice of selling or eating the fat birds that fed on acorns in fall and winter.

Sharp County Record · 6 October 1905 · page 1

pick up as many as he could car- : ry home. They were generally pretty fat; were good to eat, and , furnished meat for tho people here for two or three months in the late fall and early part of the winter. Men and boys would > come ten and fifteen miles, on horseback and in wagons, and] get all the pigeons they wanted, j Our campfires would bo built j outside the roost and generally on some elevation, so if our torchlights went out we could see where to go, for it was intensely dark in the roost, and we fre quently lost our lights by the pigeons rising by the thousands to fly and fanning out our lights, and our hats from our heads.

See moreSee less

In tho roost was a very unpleasant j

See the clipping

Sharp County Record · Evening Shade, Ark.

An elderly resident reminisces about massive passenger pigeon flocks that once roosted and nested near Rose Pond north of Evening Shade, describing their daily migration patterns and how locals harvested squabs for pigeon pies. He notes the pigeons disappeared from the area in 1850 and never returned, with their fate unknown to local residents.

Sharp County Record · 6 October 1905 · page 1

EARLY HISTORY. jpplace in' he dark, as the air was warm a >. night. I suppose the heat; from th Girds kept the air warm. ] They v. ..ild come in here in the; fall, abi 11 the time acorns began to matu.p and fall from the trees, for aeon s were what they lived! on prim tally at that season of the year. When they would leave i their roo t in the morning and go; north, tn y would darken the sun I and line-he elements for nearly an hour i i passing.

See moreSee less

You could see nothing but pigeons in every direction. They would leave their roost bc-inning about sunrise and the t ar guard would leave about an tour later. They would begin re -.ruing about an hour before s-ndown and continue] coming i.-.io roost*until 8 or 91 o’clock a s night. I have said they rang d northward. After they got ver Strawberry river ’ they had vast and extended territory which to hunt for acorns, fc there were but few people li' ■ q between Strawberry and the M souri state line. The pigeons u.-’- ally remained here until sprln’,then they would find a good , oak grove in which to build th jP nests and raise the young bird, They raised their young onr , )ring on the ridge at and aroun \ the Rose Pond, on the^3'»’_A!/.Lp;<t,Ur il!1 .'’ five > pics north of Evening Shade. And what fine and delicious eating we people had from the “sqaubs” when they were about three weeks old. Until they could fly we w'ould go with baskets and sacks, climb the trees and get all the “squabs” we wanted, and we did have sure-enough “pigeon pies.” The pigeons left herein

See the clipping

The Holt County Sentinel · Oregon, Mo. · and 3 other papers

A Pennsylvania correspondent reports that wild turtle doves are now plentiful after being thought nearly extinct, and recalls Kistler's Valley's former fame as a massive passenger pigeon roosting ground. The piece implies pigeons may be coming back, mixing nostalgic memories of the old slaughter with current turtle dove sightings.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The News-Herald, 28 September 1905, The Pacific Commercial Advertiser, 30 September 1905, The Citizen, 5 October 1905.

Wrong

The Holt County Sentinel · 6 October 1905 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

WILD PIGEONS RETURNING.

Pennsylvanians Are Now Looking for Them in the Wake of Turtle Doves.

See moreSee less

For the first time in many years the shooting of wild turtle doves is allowed, and this bird, once thought to be almost extinct, is now so plentiful that big bags are being secured by hunters, says a Kistler's Valley correspondent of the Philadelphia Record.

Kistler's Valley years ago was famous as the roosting and breeding place of thousands of wild pigeons, and there are still some of the older people left who can tell stirring tales of the countless thousands of wild pigeons that obscured the sun in their flight, and when they alighted in a forest crash upon crash was heard as branches broke under their weight.

The slaughter was proportionate to the density of the roost. There was no sport connected with it; it was simply slaughter. One could knock them over by the hundreds by merely using a pole. Many killed for the sake of wanton killing, and thousands of the birds were left to rot on the ground.

Wild pigeons formed the staple meat food for hundreds of families throughout the winter. They were killed and salted down. One could buy two dozen pigeons for five cents or less. In spite of the immense slaughter, it had no appreciable effect in reducing their number. Each spring the people would hear a peculiar booming, whirring sound, and on looking up they would see cloud after cloud of pigeons sweeping up from the southern horizon and seeking their old roosting place. For miles around the news would speed, nearly as fast as the flocks, that "the pigeons are coming," and preparations for the slaughter would be made.

One year the people looked in vain for their annual food supply of pigeons. They never came again, and, although over half a century has come and gone, this tragic mystery in the feathered kingdom has never been solved. To this day no one knows what swept away in one season millions of wild pigeons.

In this connection a curious prophecy is remembered. Years ago an old man said: "When once again the wild turtle dove is shot in Lehigh county look for the return of the wild pigeons, but not before."

It is a strange commentary upon the above that within the past year more than one hunter has reported seeing small flocks of wild pigeons in this county, but so swift on the wing and so shy were they that no shots could be made effective.

That the turtle dove is the avant courier of the wild pigeon is believed by many an old hunter.

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The News-Herald · Hillsboro, Ohio · 28 September 1905
  • Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · 10 October 1905
  • Devils Lake Inter-Ocean and Devils Lake Free Press · Devils Lake, N.D. · 8 December 1905

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A general article on American hunting conditions lists the passenger pigeon among vanished wildlife, alongside bison herds and elk bands, while touting abundant modern game statistics across states. It focuses mainly on current hunting yields of deer, moose, elk, and waterfowl, using the pigeon's disappearance as a passing historical marker.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Evening Star · 8 October 1905 · page 13

Some of Our Game. It is true that there are no more herds of bison, no more enormo-us elk bands, no more caribou herds, covering more ground than the eye can span, no more sky-hiding flocks of wild pigeons. But there are still enough animals and birds to furnish shooting to every Amer ican hunter. In lfHXI so many quaU and grouse were shipped to the Chicago mar ket from Minnesota and Wisconsin that the prices were forced down by the over supply. In Michigan careful estimates made by the game wardens were that at least 1*?<XW grouse were carried annually over the roads of the state.

See moreSee less

During the last duck-shooting season in one sound of North Carolina alone?Cur rituck sound?the market hunters shot duck enougn to net them $100,000 in the markets. M une's deer and moose-shooting season last autumn netted more than 300 moose and 5.000 deer. The game sent out of that state over the railroads amounted to 222 moose and 3.55* deer. In New York state more than 2.000 deer

See the clipping

Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis.

This item is a miscellany column discussing various topics, including a warning from conservation societies about terns and gulls facing extermination similar to the fate of the wild pigeon and buffalo. It references the passenger pigeon's extinction as an established fact to argue for protecting other bird species from egg and plume hunters.

Grant County Herald · 14 October 1905 · page 2

Remembering the fate of the wild pigeon and the buffalo, Interested so cieties are again warning America of the danger of extermination which they say besets terns and gulls along

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

A man named Hewitt reported seeing a flock of old-fashioned wild pigeons flying over Wethersfield on Sunday, a variety not seen in the area for 20 years. Local sportsmen were excited and wondered if the pigeons, once plentiful decades earlier, might be returning after their long absence.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Laramie Republican · 17 October 1905 · page 1

• ail th.* more int. i. sting I Rant II Hewitt of Welherslleld saw ■lying over the town Sunday a thick of H old lashiolied wild pigeons This variety has not lw eti seen in this 3ec tion before for 20 years. Thirty or , forty years ago they were very plenti fill hereabouts Sportsmen who heard 1 Mr. Hewitt tell about the flock are con sldeiably F.tirrcd up and wonder If the I pigeons will return here alter an ab sence of so many years. -Hartford t'ourant. Why not get all the news when iv <8 newy by reading The Republican?

See the clipping

Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis.

A 1905 article on vanishing sea birds and other species notes that the once-abundant wild pigeon has been hunted to near extinction, though it speculates small colonies might still survive in remote areas. It calls for expanded Audubon Society efforts to protect remaining bird populations from the millinery trade.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

Vernon County Censor · 18 October 1905 · page 6

SEA BIRDS DISAPPEARING. Many Species Have Become Extinct and Others are Threatened. New York Mail. —No one knows bet ter thkta the Ballot* •or shore hunter bow the sea birds may be exterminat e i and no one better than the Indian or trapper of the deep wool Is how' sometimes the wildest and most abundant land species may disappear. The wonderful great auk, or garefowl, has within the memory of men now living, been hunted from the face of the earth so that its skins and eggs are now worth their weight in gold. Practical y the beautiful wild pigeon,

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The article reports that since wild turtle doves have reappeared in numbers after being thought nearly extinct, some Pennsylvanians expect wild pigeons to return as well. It recounts nostalgic memories of the once-vast pigeon flocks and the wasteful slaughter that occurred at roosting sites like Kistler's Valley.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 21 days later.

Wrong

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 19 October 1905 · page 5

Wild Turtle Doves Have Come. For tibe firsMlme in many years the shooting of wild turtle doves is al lowed, and this bird, once thought to be almost extinct, is now so plentiful that big bags are Ibeing secured by hunters. JKistler's Valley years ago was fa mous as the roosting and breeding place of thousands of wild pigeons, and there are still some of the older jPeople left who can tell stirring tales of the countless thousands of wild pigeons that obscured the sun in their flight and when they alighted in a forest crash upon crash was heard as branches broke under their weight.

See moreSee less

The slaughter was proportionate to the density of the -roost. There was no sport connected with it; it was sim ply slaughter. One could knrfck them over by the hundreds by merely using a pole. Many killed for the sake of wanton killing, and thousands of the birds ware left to rot on the ground. Wild pigeons formed the staple meat food for hundreds of families through out the winter. They were killed and salted down. One could buy two dozen pigeons for 5 cents or less. In spite of the immense slaughter, it had no appreciable effect in reducing their-

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The article recalls how passenger pigeons once arrived each spring in vast flocks until one year they failed to return, calling their disappearance an unsolved mystery. It repeats a folk prophecy linking the return of the turtle dove to the pigeons' return, and notes recent unconfirmed sightings of small flocks.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 19 October 1905 · page 5

RETURN OF THE WILD PIGEONS.

Three Day Bargain Event number. Each spring the people would hear a peculiar booming, whir ring sound, ana on loklng up they would see cloud after cloud of pigeons sweeping up from the southern hori zon and seeking their old roosting place. For miles around the news would spread, nearly as fast as the flocks, that "the pigeous are coming," and preparations for the slaughter would be made. , One year the people Iooekd in vain for the annual food supply of pigeons. They never came again, and although over half a century has come and gone, this tragic mystry in the feath ered kingdom tfias .never been solved.; To this -day no one knows what owept away in one season millions of wild pigeons.

See moreSee less

In this connection a curious proph ecy is remembered. Tears ago an old man said: "When once again the wild, turtle dove is shot in Lehigh County then look for the return of the wild pigeons, Sbut not before." It is a strange commentary upon the above that within the past year more than one hunter has reported seeing small flocks of wild pigeons in this country, but so "swifit on the wing and so shy were they that no shots could be made effective. That the turtle dove is the avant courier of the wild pigeon is believed by many an old hunter. Kistler's Yal Record. . : ..-

See the clipping