As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

September 1905

12 articles

The Wisconsin Weekly Advocate · Milwaukee, Wis. · and 2 other papers

A newspaper feature surveys vanishing bird species, citing the great auk and the passenger pigeon as examples of creatures hunted to near or total extinction. It calls for stronger Audubon Society efforts to protect remaining sea birds from the feather trade.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Wisconsin Weekly Advocate · 7 September 1905 · page 7

Others Are Threatened. No one knows better than the sailor or the shore hunter how the sea birds may be exterminated, and no one better than the Indian or the trapper of the deep woods how sometimes the wildest and most abundant land species may dis appear. The wonderful great auk, or garefow), has, within the memory of men now living, been hunted from the face of the earth, so that its skins and eggs are now worth their weight in gold. Practically the beautiful wild pigeon which once darkened the skies with its

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Watertown Republican · Watertown, Wis. · 6 September 1905
  • · · 9 September 1905

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

An article mourning the decline of the prairie chicken in Iowa recalls the passenger pigeon as an even starker example of vanished abundance, describing flocks that once blackened the sky for days. It warns that wild game birds generally are disappearing as wilderness shrinks before human encroachment.

Evening Times-Republican · 8 September 1905 · page 4

THE PASSING OF THE PRAIRIE CHICKEN

Few men under thirty have seen a passenger pigeon, and yet middle-age'l men remember the vast and uncountwont to sweep over tl\e middle west. Their numbers were incomprehensible. For days they swept' by and over, one monstrous flock reaching from horizon to horizon, following another. Perhaps millions were in sight at one time. They crushed the forest trees when they roosted. If they fell upon a newly sown field they swept It bare of every kernel in an hour. Shooting clubbing and trapping it seemed could never affect the type. But the wild pigeon has vanished utterly from the earth and of all its, multitudes that covered the earth and obscured the sun, apparently not one remains.

See moreSee less

Our winged wild game is nearing its extinction. Crowded farther and far ther to the north and west, pursued to its most secret sanctuaries, the time is short for all of our wild game birds. The hunters of the near future will be confined to the class sufficiently wealthy to support game preserves and breed half-wild, half-domesticated ma terial for field shooting. For the or dinary shooter the traps and the clay disks. There is no more wilderness and the wild game goes with the wild*

See the clipping

The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich.

The article recounts what participants believed was the final large-scale passenger pigeon nesting, noting netters caught birds by the thousands until none remained. It reflects on how such massive hunting pressure led to the species' disappearance from the United States.

The True Northerner · 8 September 1905 · page 2

Admirer. pt. . t J r..k.r Alta a nrottv so preat that a man s voice coald not be heard three feet away. Thi was ftuthor reformert which shows that the last great netting tl hi state, courtiy an(1 chlvalric Rentleman and and so far as these pigeon hunters great writer in a playful mood:

See the clipping

The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich.

The article reflects on the passenger pigeon's once-immense migratory flocks across the middle states, noting their disappearance around 1878-9 sparked much speculation about the cause. It describes the rise of commercial hunting, with birds sold at 50 cents per dozen and trapped by netters as cities grew in population.

The True Northerner · 8 September 1905 · page 2

A. V. (iUJden. The sudden disappearance of the passenger pigeon, which migrated in immense Hocks across the middle states to their northern nesting places in snrinsr and returned with their young in the fall to feed on the stub ble lands, has been the source of many surmises and much speculation as to the cause thereof. From the earliest settlement of the country up to the years 1S78 9 the passing of the pigeons heralded ap proaching spring, and every country bred man of middle age or older with in the borders of the states alluded to has stories to tell of the numbers he lias brought down at a single shot while they were feeding or alighting on the stubble fields or sitting hud dled close in the tree tops.

See moreSee less

As the cities increased in popula tion, there was" a lively market demand for the dead birds at 50 cents per dozen and trapping them with nets became a regular business for many

See the clipping

The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich.

The report describes the massive commercial hunting operation at Shelby, Oceana County in 1874, where pigeons were caught, plucked, and shipped by the carload to Boston, New York, and Chicago for weeks at a time. It concludes that this mass exploitation, followed by extermination of scattered flocks by local hunters, explains why the passenger pigeon vanished.

The True Northerner · 8 September 1905 · page 2

ers pulled out and the wings chopped oiY with a hatchet accumulated around w . ,,.. wcic iMv,rr' t.' .. - n - - -. the station to such an extent that thd followed the guide. To her surprise teamsters who brought in the pigeons and gratification, he led her up to the In a twinkling the stool and easel nxnlait urt onrl the firtlat pncprlv

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A Pennsylvania correspondent reports that wild turtle doves have become plentiful again in Kistler Valley, allowing hunting for the first time in years. The article recalls that the same valley was once a famous roosting and breeding ground for countless wild pigeons, with old residents still telling tales of flocks so dense they darkened the sun and broke tree branches with their weight.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 20 days later.

Wrong

The Sun · 10 September 1905 · page 29

RETURN OF THE WILD PIGEONS

It It ia ithey they get away aWIY with everything evorhlnthais that1 that1loose loose looseThe lO looseThe The Te little Hto old unpainted structure srctur with its is sharp fhar pointed pintd door and window frame frameon fres freson fraxeson on the hillside hlilde above abve the Alcott house hous Is i ieadly a asadly asadly sadly neglected n gleted reminder rminder of the school Ihool o ophilosophy of ofphiosophy ofphilosophy philosophy phiosophy Tho last It use uo to which th thbuilding the thebuiding thebuilding building buiding was wa put one on of tho residents rldents o oConcord 01 01Cncr ofConcord Concord Cncr said sd was was a storehouse storhous for onions onionsItETUlty onion onionRETURN onionsRETURV RETURN OF TIlE WILD PIGEONS PIOKOXExpected PIGEONSEpecte PIGEONSEXpeeted Expected Epecte by Peniuyivanlanf PenlIanlanl Now Thai ThaiWild Tat Tatld ThatWild Wild ld Turtle Doves Have ave Conic ConicKiiiltr ome omeKialtr onieXailer Kiiiltr Kialtr Valley taltj correspondence corrtapondtnc ot olPIUadrl olPIUadrlpMa Philadel Philadelphia Phaadclphia ¬ phia Rtcord Rtcordfor Rrcordior RccordVor for ior the first Irlt time tme In many years elrs thoshootlnc thoshootlncof the shootn shootnot shooting shootingof of wild wid turtle turte doves Is allowed aloed and this thisbird thisbird thisbird bird onoe thought to b6 b almost extinct extnot Is Isnow Isnow isnow now so plentiful plentul that big bans bais are lre re being belnusecured beln belnsecured beingsecured secured by t hunters huntersKistlers huntersK1ters huntersKistiers Kistlers K1ters Valleyyenrs ago was wa famous as asthe the roosting roostn and breeding place of thousands thousandsof of wild wid pigeons pleens and there are arestltl si sti 111 some eme of ofthe the older people pcple left who can tell tel stirring strrne tales tale of the countless countess thousands of wild wildpigeons wid widpleeons wildpigeons pigeons that obscured the sun In 1 their flight flightand flght flghtand flightand and when whr hl they alighted alghted In a forest crash crashupon crashupon crashupon upon crash crl was M heard as branches broke brokeunder brokeunder brokeunder under their weight weightThe weightThe weightThe The slaughter was wa proportionate proportonate to the thedensity density densiy of the roost There was no sport sportconnected sportconnecled sportconnected connected with It I It was simply Ilmp slaughter slaughterOne slauehterOne slaughterOne One could knock them over by b the hundreds hundredsby by merely using a polo poll Many killrd 1 < lld for the thnsake thl thesake sake sae of wanton killing kiing and thousands th of the theblrd theblrd8 thebirds birds were left to rot on the ground groundVtllu groundWid groundWild Wild Wid pigeons pllens formed romed the staple meat meatfood meRttood meatfood food for hundreds hundres of families rnmiies throughout lliroughoutthe the winter They hl were killed kiled and tailed taileddown faied down One could buy bu two so dozen pigeons pigeonsfor for or s I cents or less Il8 In J spite Ipl of the Immense Immenseslaughter IIens immenseslaughter slaughter It had no 10 appreciably npPfclaull effect In Inreducing Inreducnl inreducing reducing reducnl their number numbl Each spring 5prlnl the thepeople thepeple thepeople people peple would hear a peculiar pecular booming boomingwhirring boom boomingwhirring In Inwhlrrn whirring sound and on 01 looking 10okhl1 tip Ut l > they thoywould theywoulrl theywould would see cloud after cloud coud of pigeons plgronl sweep sleop ¬ ing up U from the southern horizon horl1ol and seeking seekingtheir seeklnetheir seekingtheir their old roosting place For mllrs mlrs around aroundthe aroundthe aroundthe the newn ntwn would speed nearly ncnrl ns fast ns nl Ihe Ihelocks IhefockB itieflocks locks fockB that tho pigeons are all comine comII nnd nndpreparations nndprepnratols andpreparations preparations prepnratols for the slaughter slaughttr would otild bo bomade bomade bemade made madeOne madeOne madeOne One year Hal the people plople loolied loollr In il vain nln for fortheir rortheir fortheir their annual alnual aiinuatjood Jood supply suppl of pigeons They Theynever The Thenever Theynever never came again ngail and although alhough over half halfa a 1 century has hnl conic and cone pon < this tragic tragicmystery tragic1stery tragicmystery mystery 1stery In II the th feathered rlnthfld kingdom kllldon has never neverbeen nHerben neverbeen been ben solved To 0 this day da no oie knows what whatswept whatawept whatswept swept pigeons pigeonsIn away a wa In one season 8raSOl millions 1lllon > of wild wildpigeons wid widpigeons wildpigeons In n tills thl connection onllclon n 1 curious curloll prophecy prophecyIs prophlc prophlcIs Is remembered rememberld Years Yenrl ago nlO an ni old man Inl said saidWhen salr saidhen When Whel hen once OICO again tho wild wie turtle turtt dove is isshot Isshot isshot shot in Iehlgh count COUl county then look for the Ihl tie re return retur return ¬ turn tur of the th wild wid pigeons pigeoll but hit not Infore InforeIt ICorlI It I Is a strange strule commentary upon UpOI the above abovethat aboethat abovethat that within wlhll the past p t year Inr more than one onehunter ol onehunter hunter has reported seeing seilg small 8111 flocks of ofwild orwid ofwild wild wid pigeons plgeole In II this county but so swift on ontho ontho onthe tho wing and so shy 111 were they that no shots shotscould ahotscould shotscould could bo b made effective effectiveThat efect effectiveThat 1 That the thl turtle turte dove do Is the thE ovnnt oont vnnt courier courierof of the wild wid i2i pigeon Is believed beleer by many on onold nnold anold old hunter hunterWO hunter11W I II Inw I WO KETLCK 1TlCIO ItErTIlr ItErTIlrUs mPTlE mPTlEIl Us Il Trail Trai ficctt feel Cncp Cnll More Iorl on a Ilanlln IlanllnCounty larlln larllnDUUI IlarilinCounty County DUUI Hoatl HoatlEliiabdhtovn noadEIobclhlw ItoadEtizabclhora Eliiabdhtovn EIobclhlw rorrfspomcnrr rorr oldcncr of tht t louhriHe louhriHeCourierJournal Iolisrilt IolisriltCourirrJolflol ousrie ousrieCourierJournal CourierJournal CourierJournalThe CourirrJolflol CourirrJolflolThe The giant Iaut snake which Is supposed SUPPOlpr lo live liveIn Ih IhIn livein In the cliffs dlfs of Southwestern HOlthwlsllr Hnrdiii Inrdli county countyhas rOllty rOlltyhas colilityhas has scam asaln made itn In appearance appearllr A few CIW days dayssince da dayssince 1 1slnc since It I crossed the th Ilardin lardln Springs Sprlnls road near nearPole nrarPole nearPole Pole Bridge Brldle Church Chuch leaving lealnl a 1 huge hUI wriggling wrigglingtrail wrlllng wrlllngtrai wrigglingtrail trail trai In the dust two and onehalf on half Inches Inch deep deepand dlp dlpand deepand and eleven ellln Inches InrhlR wide wideThis wldpThl wideThis This enormous reptile rrptle made madl Its Is first fr t advent adventIn In that bection fifteen and andfince andslne becton some 10mI ffleen years pnrs ago SIO anr pine that time timE has crossed rosRN the public publc high highway highway ¬ way 1 near he Fame point twice twlcl every ever r year yearonce yeMonce yearonce once In the th sprlns sprlnl and ald again alaln in the thl early earlyautumn rarhIltumn eariyautumn autumn Iltumn During thU time It I has hal been sighted sightedby ellhied ellhiedb sightedby by b a 1 number numbtr of different dlrent persons prr5M among amongthem amongthtm amongthem them thtm som of the thE most reputable rrputnblt citizens cltztnA of ofHsrdln ofHadin ofIlardin Hsrdln Hadin county clunl who ho uniformly InlCorm describe It Itits ItlS itas its lS n monster reptile reptlp with Ith its is great Ipal body bod si simost atmoet almost most as large lorgf as n rynns nn waist aIFI checkered checkeredover hlkErpd hlkErpdopr heckeredover over with wih spots of blnck and gray IrA and esti estimated est estimated ¬ mated at twelve 111 or fourteen rourtell feet in In length lengthAt IrnglhH lengthAt At no time has ha It I ever pr shown fight nlht or ap appeared npfeare appeared ¬ peared feare to so 8 s much mich as a notice notc the presence Iresrnc of ofthose ottbose atthose those who Iho have hs seen 51In It i except except on one onl occasion occasionseveral occasione occasionseveral several e eral years ago alO when whI being helnl suddenly suddenlyencountered elddenlncuntNed suddenlyencountered encountered ncuntNed by h some Iom hunters hlntfrs In the thick thickunderbrush thickunderbrush thickunderbrush underbrush near the Ihl roadside the thE serpent serpentshook srpenlshook serpentshook shook Its il mammoth brad hld wlh wih lth expanded expandedjaws exptndedjaws xplndld xplndldJawl jaws over the tops of the Ih hushes and the thepanic thepanic thepanic panic stricken strlckln hunters hunlem rrnmpercd away awaySome awa awaSomE swaySome Some SomE years eaTS since Rlnc It i WI wea seen on one onl of its itssemiannual il ilemlannunl itssemIannual semiannual prowls powls hy S F Faber of ofVertrees oC1ertres ofVertrees Vertrees 1ertres one of the thE prominent fanners lArlrrs of ofthe otte ofthe the te county when whln it i crossed the thE road just justIn JustIn justin In front of his hl four COlI horse team Iam and became becameentangled bcameentaneled becameentangled entangled In a rickety rick old olt f Cpn fence nre floundering flounderingoff tolnd rln rlnor off or several rails rlll In Us ls efforts ortR to disengage disengageItself dlsnlagp dlsnlagpIaelr disengageitself Itself Iaelr It I has been bpll noticed nollccr that his great greatserpent greatserpent rfnt rfntserpent serpent crosses rross the th country olnlr road roar to west westward westward vestward ¬ ward every autumn and It Is supposed RIPPORI to tohave 10hae tohave have its le habitation habiaton In some of Ihe numerous numerouslarge n11erOlS n11erOlSlare numerouslarge large rugged rueled and cleft rf riven r pn cliffs cltl or 01 deep deepcaverns deepcaera deepcaverns caverns caera that abound In Ihe region rCllon of Hills HillsMill HIa HIaMi 11111sMlii Mill Mi on Rough Creek n perhaps hiberiratlng hiberiratlngIn hihlrltng hihlrltngIn In some covert abode whence hen1 it I issues IFSlfA forth forthat rorthat forthat at certain periods according to Its I serpentine serpentinehabits flrpntlll serpentinehabits habits habl Pope Pope Plus X In Ills Third Tird Tear Vearfrom TearFrom cu cuFrom from thi Ih Tablet TabletThe TablrlThe TablelThe The second anniversary annhcr8r of the coronation coronationof corolaton corolatonot of Pius X was aa celebrated last Wednesday Wednesdayby Wene da dab by b a solemn slemn function in the Sistine Chapel ChapelSpecial ChapelSp ChapelSpecial Special Sp clal tribunes were ere reserved reservP for the Dlplo Diplomatic Dlplomato Dlplomatte ¬ matte mato Corps accredited accreite to thn Holy Hol See HI the theRoman theRoman theRoman Roman patriciate palrlcate and Ind nobility nobll the Knights Knightsof of Malta Mala and the Holy 1011 Fathers sister and andniece andniece andniece niece U I was Wil almost II I when vhn hi his Holiness Holinesstook lolnlss lolnlsstook holinesstook took his stand at the altar alnr and recited rcie the theIntrnit theIntroll theIntroit Introit Introll with lh the celebrant Cardinal Merry Merrydel Merrydel Ierr del Val VI his his first frst creature The choir was waiHis wasInnlr wastinder Innlr tinder t the h e directon direction of Iero IeroHi Icroei IcroeiHis His Hi Holiness HolnEls seemed o to bn in excellent excellenthealth excelent excelenthealth excellenthealth health He has seeme grown n shade fhade stouter and andpales andpaler andpaIe pales paler during the two years enrs of his hl pontificate pontificatea pontfcate pontfcatea a natural consequence cnlQU eo of his confinement confinementwithin confncment confncmentwihin confincinentwithin within the Vatican Vatrln He continues contnues to be n nvery nver avery very wihin early riser risr rIserhis his attendant ntendat Silll Hit finds fnds him himwhen himwhen himwhen

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A New York Mail feature on declining sea bird populations compares their fate to extinct and near-extinct species, including the great auk and the passenger pigeon. It claims the once-abundant wild pigeon has largely vanished but speculates small colonies may still survive in remote areas.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union, 30 August 1905, The Wisconsin Weekly Advocate, 7 September 1905.

Evening Star · 11 September 1905 · page 15

SXA BIBBS OETTINO SCARCE. M*aj Spsdss Htn Become Extinct and Others Are Threatened. from the N>* York Mail. No one know* better then the sailor or the "horn hunt** how the sea birds may b? exterminated, and no one better than t&? Indian or trapper of the deep woods how sometimes the wildest and most abundant land species may disappear. The wonder *reet auk. or fsrefowl, has. within tke memory of men now Urine, been hunted tr*P 'ace of the earth, so that Its skins ?njl eggs aro now worth their weight in (old.

See moreSee less

Practically the beautirul wild pigeon which once darkened the skies wttn Its rest and cloudlike Right, has met the same fate, though small colonies of It tn remote spots undoubtedly still exist. The eastern pln grouse is also practically extinct. In the Chatham Islands alone. In the Pacific, seventeen species of birds have become ex tinct. On all the Islands of the see snd ell the shore spots to whloh sea birds resort the r? s'au*ht*r u b?'ng carried on quite relentlessly. Largely for purely humane reasons, and Incidentally in the Interest of science, the National Association of Audu Don Societies Is engaged In the work of trying to save the sea birds from ex term! U?. ,1" ?*veral species are being system atically destroyed for their feathers. Kash

See the clipping

Aberdeen Herald · Aberdeen, W.T. · and 2 other papers

The article warns that many sea bird species are being exterminated for feathers and sport, citing the great auk and the passenger pigeon as prior examples of total or near-total extinction. It notes that small remnant colonies of wild pigeons may still exist and calls for expanded Audubon Society wardens to protect remaining sea bird colonies.

Aberdeen Herald · 18 September 1905 · page 3

SEA BIRDS ARE DISAPPEARING

Many Species Have Become Kxtinct and Othera Are Threatened. No one knows bettor than the sailor or the shore hunter how the sen birds may be exterminated and no one better than the Indian or the trapper of the deep woods how sometimes the wild est and most abundant land species uiay disappear. The wonderful great auk, or garefowl, has, within the mem ory of men now living, been hunted from the face of the earth so that Its skins and eggs are now worth their weight in gold. Practically the beauti ful wild pigeon, which once darkened

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The San Juan Islander · Friday Harbor, Wash. · 23 September 1905
  • The Crook County Monitor · Sundance, Wyo. · 13 October 1905

The Alliance Herald · Alliance, Neb.

A resident of Wethersfield reported seeing a flock of fourteen wild pigeons flying over the town, a bird not seen in the area for twenty years. Local sportsmen were excited and wondered if the pigeons might be returning after decades of absence.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Alliance Herald · 21 September 1905 · page 8

Wild Pigeons Excite Comment

Happiness. Happlnosa Is ho end of every man'a philosophy, whether ho bo a phlllso phcr ot tho schools or a philosopher of tho fields and shops. But tho ques tion la, "What Is happiness?" "What constitutes it?" Most of what wo thought wok happiness had tho bitter ot selfishness, but when our happi ness consists In making others happy nnd helping them In their hour ot need, thcro aro no dregs in tho cup wo drink. And If thoro wero, wo would novor know it, for this cup of joy Is always full, and further, as long ns wo llvo thero will bo those who need our help, nnd consequently wo ennnot exhaust tho contents qf this cup.

See moreSee less

Wild 'Pigeons Excite Comment. Rant H. Howltt of Wothorsflcld saw flying over tho. town Sunday a flock ot fourteen old-fashioned wild pig conB. This variety has not been seen In this section beforo for twonty years. Thirty or forty years ago thoy wcro very plentiful hereabouts. Sportsmen who heard Mr. Howltt tell about tho ' flock aro considerably stirred up and wonder If tho pigeons will roturn here after nn absenco of bo many years. Hartford Courant.

See the clipping

New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

William Dutcher, writing for the National Audubon Society, compares the extermination of the buffalo and the passenger pigeon to the ongoing threats facing sea birds from plume hunters and egg collectors. He frames the pigeon's disappearance as a cautionary tale of unchecked exploitation and calls on the public to protect remaining wildlife like gulls and terns.

New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · 27 September 1905 · page 3

William Dutcher, President of the Na tional Audubon Society. Scarcely more than a generation ago the buffalo ranged the western plains in countless herds, their numbers soO great that no written estimate can be consid ered an exaggeration. Those who were fortunate enough to see one of these great hosts surging over the prairies little thought that in a few short years the buffalo would simply be a part of his tory. This noble beast was exterminat ed by man with a butchery so ignoble that it is sickening to dwell upon.

See moreSee less

The few dollars received for the hide was the incentive for this national disgrace. Al most at the same hour that the buffalo were vanishing another of the wonders of this continent was also heing ruthless ly and recklessly destroyed. Karly writ ers tell of flocks of wild pigeons so large that the account of their numbers verges

See the clipping

The News-Herald · Hillsboro, Ohio

A Pennsylvania correspondent reports that turtle doves are now plentiful again after being nearly extinct, prompting hunters to look for the return of the once-abundant wild pigeon. The piece recalls the old days when passenger pigeons darkened the sky and were slaughtered wantonly, implying a hopeful connection to their possible comeback.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

The News-Herald · 28 September 1905 · page 6

WIID PIGEONS RETURNING. Pennsylvanlnns Are Now Looking for Them in the Wake of Turtle Dove. For the first time in many years the shooting of wild turtle doves is al lowed, ami this bird, once thought to be almost extinct, is now bo plentiful that big bags are being secured by hunters, s.iys a Klstler's Valley corre spondent of tho Philadelphia Record, Klstler's Valley years ago was fa mous ns the roosting and breeding place of thousands of wild pigeons, ind there are still some of the older jcoplo left who can tall stirring talcs of the countiesthousands of wild pigeon that obscured tho sun In their flight, and when they alighted in a forest crash upon crash was heard as branches broko under tholr weight.

See moreSee less

The slaughter wns proportionate to the density of the roost. There was no sport connected with it; it was simply slaughter. One could knock then) over by the hundreds by merely using n polo. Many killed for the sake of wanton killing, and thousands of the birds were left to rot on the ground. Wild pigeons formed the staple meat food for hundreds of families through out the winter They were killed and hjltnd down. Oun could buy two locn pigeons for five cents or lo3B. In spile of the Immense slaughter, It bad no appreciable ofi'ect In reducing their number. Hach spring the people would hear n pecullnr booming, chirring sound and on looking up they aouIiI sec cloud nftcr cloud of pi geons sweeping up from tho southern 'orlon and seeking their old roost ing plnrp For miles around tho nows ould niecd. nearly ns faU as the .'locks, that "the pigeons are coming," ind preparations for tho slaughter would lo mncle. Ono year the people looked In vain for their annual food supply of pi geons. They never camo again, and, although over half a century has come and gone, this tragic mystery In tho feathered kingdom has never been solved. To this day no one knows what swept away In ono season mil lions of wild pigeons. In this connection a curious prophecy is remembered. Years ago an old man said: "When once again the wild turtle dove Is shot In Lehigh county look for tho return of the wild pigeons, but not beforo." It Is a strange commentary upon the above that within the past year more than one hunter has reported seeing small flocks of wild pigeons in tMs county, but so swift on the wing and so shy were thoy that no shots could be made effective. That the turtle dove is the avant courier of the wild pigeon is believed by many an old hunter.

See the clipping

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands

The article reminisces about Kistler's Valley, once a famous roosting ground where countless wild pigeons darkened the sky and were slaughtered wastefully for cheap meat. It then notes that one year the pigeons failed to appear, hinting at their mysterious disappearance, while confusingly suggesting the bird is still plentiful by conflating it with the turtle dove.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 20 days earlier.

Wrong

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 30 September 1905 · page 7

The Wild Pigeon. For the first time in many years the shooting of wild turtle doves .in the states is allowed, and this bird, once thought to be almost extinct, is now so Dlentif ul that big bags are being secured by hunters. Kistler's Valley years ago was fa mous as the roosting and breeding place of thousands of wild pigeons, and there are still some of the older people left who can tell stirring tales of the count less thousands of wild pigeons that ob scured the sun in their flight, and when they alighted In a forest crash upon crash was heard as branches broke under their weight.

See moreSee less

v , The slaughter was proportionate to the density of the roost. There was no sport connected with it; It was simply slaughter. One could Knock them over by the hundreds by merely using a nole. Manv killed for the sake of wantorlkilling, and thousands of the birds were left to rot on the ground. Wild .pigeons formed the staple meat food for hundreds of families through out the winter. They were killed and salted down. One could buy two dozen pigeons for 3 cent's or less. In spite of the Immense slaughter, it had no ap preciable effect in reducing their num ber. Each spring the people would hear a peculiar booming, whirring sound, and on looking up they would see cloud after cloud of pigeons sweep ing up from the southern horizon and seeking .their old roosting place. For miles around the' news would speed, nearly as fast as the flocks, that "the pigeons are coming," nd preparations for the -slaughter would be made. One year the people looked In vain for their annual food supply of pigeons. They never came again, and, although over half a century has come and gone, this tragic mystery in the feathered kingdom has never been solved. To this day no one knows what swept away in one .season millions of wild pigeons. In this connection a curious prophecy s remembered. Years ago an old man said: "When once again the wild turtie dove Is shot in Lehigh county then

See the clipping