As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · The full archive

March 1893

7 articles

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The piece hopes the Julia Force case won't drag on like the Lizzie Borden case in Fall River, Mass. It notes both accused are women suspected of insanity, but warns against prolonging proceedings for notoriety.

The Morning News · 10 March 1893 · page 4

It it to be hoped that tbe Julia Force case will not be suffered to drag along after the manner of the Lizzie Borden case at Fall River, Mass. There is little similarity in the cases except that the accused ore women, and eaoh is suspected of insanity. But they may tie made more alike should there be blundering in tbe Force case, aud a pro longing of the inquisition for the Bako of notoriety. Under the circumstances the Fulton county court should be able to dis pose of the case in short order.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A Memphis newspaper editorial complains that Lizzie Borden has been held in jail without bail for over six months on what it characterizes as mere suspicion. It argues the only evidence against her is that police have found no other suspect to blame.

The Morning News · 12 March 1893 · page 4

The Lizzie Borden Case. From the Memphis Appeal-Avalanche (Dem.). Lizzie Borden has been in jail for more than six months on a suspicion of murder. The tes timony on which she has been held amounts to this: The police have not been able to tlnd any body else on whom to saddle the crime. And eo Massachusetts jus:ice authorizes the incarcer ation without bail of a young woman against whom only a suspicion Is entertained. “.aklnir Time.”

See the clipping

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · St. Johnsbury, Vt.

A Fall River correspondent reports visiting Taunton jail and finding Lizzie Borden cheerful, comfortable, and allowed small privileges like flowers and a lamp in her cell. The report also notes her few visitors, including her sister Emma and two clergymen, and identifies the mysterious 'veiled lady' as Elizabeth A. Stockwell of Worcester.

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 16 March 1893 · page 4

Newt in thin Iuterealing Cane. From our Special Correpondcnt.) I was at Taunton jail last evening, and learned some things not generally known in regard to Lizzie A. Borden, her case, and the probabilities of its being tried this spring. I found, first of all, that Miss Borden was ns well as ever, cheer

See the clipping

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · St. Johnsbury, Vt.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's relatively comfortable life in the Taunton jail, her visitors, and the gentle treatment by the sheriff's wife. It also debunks rumors about a fixed trial date, noting none of the legal parties have been informed of one, while describing widespread public speculation about her guilt or innocence.

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 16 March 1893 · page 4

LIZZIE BORDEN AT TAUNTON.

Meanwhile there is widespread specu lation both about the identity of the murderer and the manner of the murders. The number in Fall River who cling to the theory of Lizzie A. Borden's innocence, even though they have no clearly defined theory of the sort of per son who committed the murders, is of respectable size; but the great body of those both here and in Taunton who talk with any intelligence on the subject are on the other side. When detectives and other men familiar with criminal characters tell you what they think, they come to the same conclusion that the 21 men came to, who found Lizzie A.

See moreSee less

Borden guilty and brought in a true bill against Tier. It is clear to such that she murdered or procured the murder of her parents. Deputy Sheriff Falvcy, of Taunton traces her course throughout that his toric 4-th of August, and finds a perfect chain of conviction in the nets and words of Miss Borden on that day. In the very act of standing at the door after her alleged discovery, on returning from the barn, that her father was killed, instead of rushing into the street and alarming evervbody with theghnstly an nouncement, lie finds a convicting cir cumstance; for, he says, she was prob ably so far overcome by her crime that she had to go to the door to get air. ! She was neither blood-spattered nor ' frantic to inform the world of what had ! ha opened. He thinks she wore a gossamer water proof, and put it in the fire as soon as she killed her father. He takes its signifi cant Lizzie A. Borden's differing versions of why she went to the barn, her speedy intimation to Adelaide B. Churchill that perhaps Mrs. Borden, too, had been kill ed, and her inability to show an alibi against the accusation of Eli Benee nnd his associates in the drug store that she applied to him for prussic acid the day before the murders. There is a theory that the old people were murdered by a Chinaman, the manner in which their heads were hack ed being like the manner of the Chinese in cutting human beings, Some who cannot conceive how Lizzie A. Borden could have had the strength to kill two persons in that way hold that she employed a Chinaman to commit the deeds, and that the weapon and stained clothes, if there were any such clothes, were spirited away in the ample time which passed before the house was searched nnd guarded, nnd the China man quietly passed out on the street in the crowd while the crowd surged back wards and forwards. This theory is strengthened by the fact that Lizzie Borden had had something to do with Chinese pupils of the Central church Sun day school. But a Chinaman, if seen in such a crowd, would have been remem bered by some one. There is no support for the theory of insanity in the ease. Lizzie A. Borden shows as much insanity today as ever, ami no one, seeing her at this hour! would forecast her residence in an asylum. The whole tragedy is ns nuuli a mystery to millions, probably, as ever, for the public has obtained surprisingly little of what was presented to the grand jury; but the prosecution is 1.3 sure of its ease as ever, and no delay in bringing its evidence before thecourt will occur alter the recovery of Attornev lieneral I'illsbury. " i;, r, C-"

See the clipping

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · St. Johnsbury, Vt.

This report denies rumors about a set trial date, noting that none of the legal parties have been consulted or notified by the court. It then surveys widespread public speculation about the murders, including detectives' theories implicating Lizzie Borden and a rival theory blaming a Chinaman.

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 16 March 1893 · page 4

LIZZIE BORDEN AT TAUNTON.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The Fall River Bar Association met to consider serious corruption charges against Judge Blaisdell, who presided over Lizzie Borden's preliminary proceedings, after Special Justice Lincoln alleged corruption on the District Court bench. The matter was referred to the association's board of counselors, and the report notes the elderly judge has suffered greatly since the case.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 27 days later.

Wrong

The Morning Call · 17 March 1893 · page 8

CHARGED WITH CORRUPTION. The Judge Who Tried Lizzie Borden in Serious Trouble. Fall River, Mas-., March 16.— The Fall River Bar Association held a special meet ing this afternoon ami considered the grave charges preferred against Judge Blaisdcl, who presided at the Borden trial, by Special Justice Lincoln. In brief, these were that he (Lincoln) had been led to think that there was corruption o.i the bench of the District Court. It was finally voted to refer Hie matter to the board counselors of the association. The Judge is an elderly man and during and since the Harden trial he has undergone much mental suffering, but lias borne up as few men of his years could.

See moreSee less

James \V. Hyatt Buried. NOBWAXK, Conn., March 10.— Tne funeral services over the remains of Hon. James W. Hyatt, ex-United States Treasurer, were held from Ins late residence and from the Korwalk Methodist Church this after noon. The obieuuias wero held With Ma sonic honors. No Hope for a Murderer.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A report claiming Lizzie Borden will be arraigned for trial in Fall River on April 10th is said not to be believed in Taunton. The dispatch casts doubt on the rumored court date without confirming any official schedule.

The Providence News · 25 March 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE. Report that She Will Be Arraigned in Fall River April 10, TAUNTON., Mass, March 25.-<The re port that Lizzie Borden will be arraigned

See the clipping