Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Pawnee Bill, Deadwood Dick and Other Famous Old Plainsmen, at Recent Meeting Discuss This Rumor, Started by Story in a National Magazine; Heretofore Untold Incidents Come to Light
See moreSee less
ONE of the most interesting—and at the same time one of the most important—meeting of frontiersmen ever held in recent years was staged at Norfolk, Neb., a few days ago when "Deadwood Dick," "Diamond Dick," Capt. "Lute" North, Dr. W. F. Carver, once world's champion wingshot, "Pawnee Bill," and "Idaho Bill" were brought together to set history aright as regards the last stand of Gen. George A. Custer, who with all his men, was massacred by the Indians in 1876 at the Battle of the Big Horn in Montana.
Never before had there been such a meeting. And probably never again will there be another. For out of the past, reaching back half a century or more, there stepped forth into real life these six famous characters that every small boy a generation ago knew only in "Diamond Dick" and "The Boys with Buffalo Bill"—those exciting five-cent thrillers were bought on the sly and read hiding in the barn loft.
For half a century or more the battle has been refought by historians, no two of whom ever seemed to agree. Nor how could they agree as to what happened when there was none left to tell the story after the Indians slaughtered Custer and all his valiant men? Only the Indians themselves who made off into the wilderness actually could give eyewitness accounts of the fight, and their stories were at such wide variance nobody could rely upon them. But two months ago the Cosmopolitan magazine published a resume of the battle as told by an Indian, Chief Buffalo Child Long Lance, in which he stated that General Custer died by his own hand, a suicide, rather than to meet certain torture and death at the hands of the savage redskins.
Instantly the towns of the Northwest that had been on the old frontier began to buzz with controversies. How could anyone say the brave Custer died by his own hand? If there was any coward near that battle on the Little Big Horn was it not Major Reno, who failed to come to Custer's support as he had been ordered to do?
And who was this Chief Buffalo Child Long Lance, who said he had got the true story in a secret Indian conference in Canada where old leaders and chieftains told him they did not kill Custer because the general when a young man had befriended "Chief" Sitting Bull.
Was It All Fiction?
"Why, the story's all fiction," the old timers said. "Sitting Bull was never a chief, but a medicine man and philosopher for the Indian tribes."
But was it all fiction? Norfolk decided it would hear what such men as "Lute" North, "Deadwood Dick" and "Doc" Carver, all of whom had been Indian fighters and scouts at the time Custer made his fatal attack on outlawed Cheyennes and Sioux and Uncpapas, had to say about it. So one night late in June, after a parade and banquet in honor of the visiting delegates of the National Editors' association (stopping over on their way to the Black Hills), a powwow was arranged for the six pioneer plainsmen.
Behind closed doors in one of the smallest banquet rooms of the Hotel Norfolk, they sat around a big table and talked until well after midnight, while 30 leading citizens of Norfolk and a few chosen visitors listened, laughed and applauded. R. H. Beerman, secretary to Carl Gray, president of the Union Pacific railroad, took a verbatim report in shorthand of the unique hearing.
But before we go into the "powwow" with them let us see them as they rode in parade that afternoon through the streets of Norfolk.
Here they came, riding through the rain on decidedly spirited horses, while a crowd of 10,000 in that northeastern Nebraska city lined the sidewalks to cheer them and while every adjunct of the civilization for which the valiant plainsmen fought back the wilderness to advance now united to pay them homage. A big airplane soared back and forth overhead, roaring a welcome that echoed along the microphone of station WJAG, broadcasting from the roof of the Hotel Norfolk.
Now they came in sight far down the long avenue, riding two and two, while brass bands blared and the crowds cheered anew. Here were "Pawnee Bill," with his huge sombrero, and "Doc" Carver, an imposing figure on a bay charger that was almost covered by the huge buffalo coat Carver wore and which he has possessed for nearly 60 years. Next were "Idaho Bill," and "Lute" North, both riding as if they had been born in the saddle, and closely followed in train by "Deadwood Dick" and "Diamond Dick." What a sight—what a thrill—what a picture?
The into the hotel to rest awhile and have dinner with the editors, where it becomes opportune to introduce the famous frontiersmen.
Meeting "Deadwood Dick"
First, because he seemed to be one of the most lovable and picturesque of the pioneers, we will present in close-up "Deadwood Dick," whose legal name is Robert W. Clark. His home is at Deadwood, S. D., where he has lived since the wild and wooly days of the Black Hills country, a famous frontiersman, scout, guide, pony express rider and Indian fighter. Now 79 years old, he still remembers vividly the stirring days when the Indians, gamblers and hard-riding, quick shooting road agents constantly helped the Wild West to live up to its name.
Of course, the boys of a generation ago will remember that "Deadwood Dick" used to rage back and forth in the covers of "Beadle's Dime Library." And Edward L. Wheeler was the author who made him rage. Thirty or forty years ago nearly all the boys in America knew "Deadwood Dick" as a hero always on the side of the weak protecting it against the strong with a pistol that sent every shot unerringly to its mark. But most of the valiant deeds, as was this dare-devil character of Wheeler, were creatures of fiction. "Dick" Clark, in real life, was known to be quick on the draw and as good a shot as "Wild Bill" Hickok, "Calamity Jane," and others of the gold rush days in the Black Hills, but he never was in any sense a desperado. He could give a good account of himself in battle, but his fights were with Indians and bandits and road agents who used to try to hold up the stage-coaches he guarded with their treasures for the express companies. He saw "Wild Bill" killed by the cowardly "Jack" McCall as Hickok sat in a saloon in Deadwood with his back toward the door playing poker. He knew General Custer and his associates well and fed the ragged and starving troops of General Crook after they had been routed by the Indians in the campaign after the Battle of Little Big Horn and driven back to Deadwood.
But the wild days finally passed and "Deadwood Dick" seemed to pass out of the picture with them. The dime novels of Wheeler faded and were forgotten and every now and then came the report that "Dick" was dead. But he has been living on a ranch near Deadwood, after having retired from his peace-time job as watchman at the railroad station, and never asking for a pension from the government he served so well as an Indian scout on what finally became the munificent pay of $16.50 a month.
A lovable, genuine, picturesque character is "Deadwood Dick," with piercing black eyes and long dark hair, barely graying, held back from a high, classic forehead, by an improvished bandeau of buckskin on a head that is handsomely chiseled as that of Paderewski, whom "Dick" with his hat off closely resembles. His figure is erect and lithe and slenderly masculine ac thae.mcnww, and slenderly muscular; his face is powder scarred; his hands are twisted and gnarled like pine knots and his right index figure is missing—lost in a gun fight, but just when and how "Dick" will not say. One likes "Deadwood Dick" instantly. His disposition reminded us of the portrayal of "Jim Bridger" that we saw in the movie called "The Covered Wagon;" for "Dick's" bright eyes frequently send off glints of humor.
And Here is Dr. Carver
Now we are meeting Dr. W. F. Carver, 87 years old, but recalling the days when he was the champion rifle and pistol shot of the world as vividly as if they were yesterday. Carver was the first partner of Buffalo Bill, organizing First a Wild West show in 1883, while Col. W. F. Cody was appearing on the stage and then getting Cody to join him in that soon was to become the famous "Carver & Cody's Wild West." But longer before that "Doc" Carver had been an Indian fighter and killed not fewer than 30,000 buffalo on the plains. So deadly was his aim that the Indians called him "the Evil Spirit of the Plains." As a wingshot he knew no equal; being the greatest rifle shot from the back of a running horse he soon became known also throughout the world as the man who with either rifle or pistol could penetrate with a single shot any silver coin tossed in the air.
After defeating all the crack shots in America when shooting was shooting to boast of, he appeared in public exhibitions in 1879, and subsequently before the crowded heads of Europe, and today treasures royal gifts from the late Edward VII of England, ex-Kaiser Wilhelm and the late Franz Joseph, emperor of Austria.
Someone at Norfolk the other day asked "Doc" Carver's secretary, Charles R. Nordin of Omaha, how many notches Carver had in his gun. "He hasn't any," was the quick reply, "for he only notched 'em when he missed—and he never missed." "Doc" Carver still is a dominant figure in any assembly. He is 6 feet 2 inches in height and weighs 240 pounds. He says he was born in 1840, but one would easily mistake him for a man of 65.
If "Doc" Carver was Buffalo Bill's first partner, "Pawnee Bill" (Maj. Gordon W. Lillie) of Pawnee, Okla., was his last. The reunion between Carver and "Pawnee Bill" was happy indeed. "Gordon was just a rosy cheeked boy of 16 when Cody and I got him into our show," Carver said. "Now he is still rosy cheeked and boyish, even with some gray hairs from six raised with a wondrous $400 French siren horn. He borrowed for his driver the mayor of Pawnee, O. O. Mentzer. Major Lillie's story is well known. Retiring from the show business a few years ago, he established a large ranch in Oklahoma and keeps a herd of buffalo there.
Captain "Lute" North
Comes now—and really one of the most important figures in this unique conference—Capt. "Lute" North of Columbus, Neb. Almost everybody in the state knows Captain "Lute," and those who are familiar with the history of the West since the '60's should recall him instantly. Like "Deadwood Dick," Capt. Luther H. North was a veteran Indian fighter. He was a captain in the Pawnee Indian scouts, which he organized in 1864 to help put down the depredations of the warlike Sioux and Cheyennes. Later his company became a part of the battalion of four companies under his brother, the late Maj. Frank North. These men knew Cody long before he was "Buffalo Bill," and when he, too, was a leader of Pawnee scouts and helped fight the Indians.
"Lute" North knew General Terry and Custer and Crook. Also he lived among the Indians and became well acquainted with their language and knew intimately such chiefs as Gall, Crazy Horse and Rain-in-the-Face, and the medicine man, Sitting Bull. Captain North is 81 years old now, but, he, too, has the appearance and keen recollection of a man of 60.
"Idaho Bill" and "Diamond Dick"
"Idaho Bill," whose real name is Col. B. R. Pearson, was born in 1868 on the Oregon trail, either in Nebraska or Wyoming. His father was a railroad construction foreman. Nute Kay Pearson, who homesteaded in Adams county, Nebraska, in 1872, where "Idaho Bill's" sister, Mrs. H. E. Van Boening, still lives near the town of Hastings. In his younger days "Idaho Bill" was a scout and trapper of wild animals, and in 1908 roped wolves and took them to Chicago for an exhibition. He owns a large ranch in the Snake river valley of Idaho, where he has raised many hundreds of horses. At one time 1,500 head of horses ran on his ranges and today there still remain about 900. He acquired a competence selling horses to the British army during the Boer War, and before that time was a noted buffalo hunter.
Theodore Roosevelt visited Pearson's ranch of 20,000 acres near Weiser, Idaho, while president and there made his famous bear hunt. One of "Idaho Bill's" best tricks is to catch mountain lions and wolves alive by lassoing them. He is as picturesque as his photograph and still wears his hair long, almost to his waist, and a slender goatee that he says is nothing more than a wisp of mane.
"Diamond Dick," who in private life is Dr. Richard J. Tanner, is Norfolk's local celebrity. Dr. Tanner freely admits there were other men known as "Diamond Dick," but says he has used the name since he was 16 years old, at which time he adopted it and went into a show as a crack shot and rider. His chief claim to fame came with his ride on his horse, Gyp, covering 5,500 miles in nine months—from March 15 to November 19, 1893. He came to Norfolk unassumingly more than a dozen years ago after getting his degree in a medical college and has been a practicing physician here under his real name since.
The "Powwow" Begins
The six famous frontiersmen sat around a large table. C. E. Burnham, president of the Norfolk National Bank, became chairman of the informal meeting and announced its purpose. To set aright some disputed history concerning what happened at the Battle of the Little Big Horn. Was General Custer a suicide, as a recent magazine article had stated? There follows a word-for-word report of the "powwow."
Mr. Burnham—In our discussion of the Custer fight yesterday I asked if you gentlemen had read the article in the Cosmopolitan stating that Custer had committed suicide, and before I got the words out of my mouth Deadwood Dick said, "That's a damn lie."
Deadwood Dick—And I still say it.
Mr. Burnham—Doctor Carver, you were familiar with the circumstances there, the orders that were given to Reno, and the fact that he did not obey them. I think Lute disagrees with you on Reno not obeying orders.
Deadwood Dick—I disagree with him.
Mr. Burnham—Dr. Carver says that Reno absolutely disobeyed orders.
Dr. Carver—What do you boys want to know?
Mr. Burnham—They want the real story of the Custer fight. What happened from beginning to end.
Dr. Carver—The white men killed the buffalo off for five years to get the Indians on the reservations. Crazy Horse was one of the bravest Indians that ever lived. When they took the Black Hills away from him it broke his heart. He met a white man in a field one day, armed with a Winchester. Crazy Horse had only a quirt, but instead of running away, Crazy Horse, who didn't know what fear was, faced the man and the Winchester and chased that man clear in to Deadwood.
The Indians used to go into battle with no means of transportation and they whipped the white men with their bows and arrows. Terry, Gibbon and Godfrey couldn't whip the Indians. I am an Indian at heart, and have no love for palefaces. The whites rode into the camps and chased them out, the Ogallalas, Uncpapas, Brules and Cheyennes—they never whipped the Sioux in their lives. The Sioux have never been whipped.
How the Indians Whipped Crook
Now they go out with all the great generals—they had it all fixed and were going to eat the Indians up. General Crook was the best friend I ever had. He was going to fix the Indians, but when they woke up the Indians were scrapping and they stopped him, whipped him right. Crook hung around like a whipped pup, and then he went into Deadwood, ragged, dirty, and hungry. All they had to eat was the horses they killed. Crook was supposed to follow the Indians and they cut off his supply trains. Then they whipped him, the best soldiers, best cavalry that ever was.
After the Indians whipped Crook, comes Custer with a lot of soldiers with the old Sharp's carbine, that you can't shoot with, because they kick up. Shooting on horseback they had to hold the reins with one hand and shoot with the other, and you can't hit anything. Down came Custer, down the bluff alongside of the Indian village. Reno was going down and come in behind them and drive them up this way, and they'd clean them up.
Dear old Reno—it took them three minutes to give him a trimming—he mounted and dismounted his men three times—and then told them, "Every man for himself and get into the bluffs." Reno got up on the bluffs, dug some holes there and a lot of kids and squaws kept him there.
Custer came down off the bluff and there was a ravine—he dismounted his soldiers and started down the side of the bluff. Here were the Indians on the other side of the ravine—he got 100 feet, threw out a skirmish line and in three minutes the skirmish line was gone and in the next ten minutes all of his men would have been dead.
Deadwood Dick Speaks
Deadwood Dick—When Custer was called to Washington, he was called in on the Kansas City, Kan., deal and any man that served in the service knows that the articles of war read that a deserter in the front of the enemy is to be killed. When they surrounded Antelope's band in Kansas, there were two men in that company who, instead of staying with the colors, just turned their horses and left the fight. After the scrap was over, they were to tell him that if he burned any more settlements they would clean them out. They followed the deserters. Here is where the call to Washington came in. The men were brought back—they couldn't go from here to there and they were caught and they had to shoot them. There was a court-martial held and Custer wasn't in it. They pick the court like a jury. They were the men who condemned them to death. The men were shot. After a little while Custer was called in on that very question.
That was when they cut us (scout's pay) from $125 to $16.50 and we quit in a body at Fort Totten—the 21st infantry—we quit in a body and we came down. Word came if the white men won't, the Indians will. They did. The expedition started in the spring—the Indian agent said there were only about 1,500 off the reservation. There were close on to 15,000 Indians.
Dr. Carver—Those Indians had fought all their lives with muzzle loaders and bows and arrows and I traded a lot of weapons for them. When Custer came up against 1,000 Winchesters—that amounts to 16,000 Indians with muzzle loaders—Custer's men were killed before they knew what happened.
Thompson is one of the fellows that claims he got lost from the command and hid in the hills and got out—the only man that got out of the fight was Curley and he was on a bluff watching it. Comanche is the only living thing that came out of that fight; he died at Riley later. A horse.
"Lute" North's Version
Captain North—Reno had just 112 men when he went into the fight. Suppose Reno came in on the flank—he lost 30 men before he was in there two minutes.
Dr. Carver—He had 29 men killed when he crossed the creek.
Deadwood Dick—Before we go any further with Reno. Plem, nothing but a buck private—they wanted water, they didn't have any and Plem took canteens—16 of them—and went down the bluff, filled them and came back. When he came back Reno was going to have him court-martialed.
Dr. Carver—That man came back without being hit—you might go through a hail storm and not get hit.
Deadwood Dick—That is what he did. Reno was going to have him court-martialed for disobeying orders. When the thing was all over—Reno got a little bronze medal—Reno didn't. When Plem was discharged from Ft. Meade—before he started riding with the Northwestern Stage company, we named a butte for him—Plem Butte, which was a stage station. The day Plem got his discharge, Plem turned around and asked if he was again a citizen—he could say what he pleased and he said "Reno, you are a dirty, cowardly son of a dog"—and Reno stood it. Right there is what Plem done and Reno ducked his head and walked to his quarters. I can prove every word I am saying. Plem got a bronze cross, what we fight for. Reno was cashiered on half pay and Plem got the medal.
Dr. Carver—One man went for water and got shot in the leg—they had to cut his leg off and before they did it they gave him a drink of whisky.
Deadwood Dick—And he said to give another drink and cut the other one off!
Captain North—I am just as much a friend of Custer as either of you. I think Custer was one of the very best men that ever went out as an Indian fighter. He wasn't afraid of anything. He had the right idea of fighting Indians, go to them when you can find them; don't wait. Custer was that kind of a man, and I am a friend of his as much as you are. I am going back years before this. You probably know,—will remembered about the Belknap scandal in the Grant cabinet. Custer knew about that and he knew what was being done. He knew that these tradershipts were being traded in through politics and knew that the forage and rations that went out to the different posts weren't up to standard at all. He went to Washington voluntarily to go before the senate investigating committee that investigated Belknap. There was where he got in bad. Sherman was at the head of the army—Phil Sherman was in command of the department—he would do anything they told him to do. I was with Custer in '74 when Custer went into the Black Hills. After that he went before the testimony, and after he gave his testimony, whatever it was, he didn't come back to his regiment. His regiment was at Ft. Abe. Lincoln. Custer was sent home ostensibly on furlough, but he was just sent there. He was home a year, wasn't even in charge of the regiment, let alone the division. He didn't come back until '76. When the expedition was outfitted in '76, Custer was brought back and given command of the regiment. They put Terry in charge of the expedition.
Dr. Carver—Custer was sent on the expedition with only an hour's time—no chance to arrange things.
"Custer Wanted All the Glory"
Captain North—Custer started out with his regiment to locate the Indians. He didn't go five miles before he drew up the men in a line and told them that if they located the Indians the 7th cavalry was to have all the glory. He said then that he would disobey orders.
He divided his regiment into three columns. He gave Reno—and Reno may be a coward—he gave him three companies and he took the five companies himself. In the last order that Custer gave in his life, he said "Go to the river and when you find the village attack it." Reno did, with 112 men he attacked the village of 4,000 warriors. He was licked in two minutes, lost 29 men. He lost his head, the soldiers lost their heads and the Indians say when the men turned they staggered across the river; they seemed drunk; the Indians knocked them off their horses with the butts of their guns. Reno took his men onto the ridge. Reno was to attack the upper end of the village. Benteen was to come in further down. Custer turned back of the ridge, I guess, and rode down—this is guess work—Custer rode down there to head them off.
Dr. Carver—Custer went to the lower end of the village—the Cheyennes were there—White Shield, Spread Nose, Yellow Belly, Bobbed Tailed Horse, they were in the village when Custer got there and the Indians didn't know he was there till he was down the hill.
Captain North—You said they were all killed in a short distance. Some of them went clean down to the river. Bobbed Tailed Horse told me so.
Dr. Carver—Bobbed Tailed Horse is another.
Captain North—They were divided into seven units, the Indians said, instead of five troops. Two of them must have been divided, for there were seven units. The Indians fighting Reno jumped off their horses, ran up the ravine, and this fight that we imagine was fought on horseback was nearly all fought on foot, Indians and soldiers. Bobbed Tailed Horse told me he was crawling up this gully. Every fourth man was holding the horses—the horses broke loose and ran over toward the Indians. The saddlebags were full of ammunition. He had a gun that Crazy Horse captured on the Rosebud, and this ammunition fitted these guns. "If we hadn't got this ammunition out of the saddlebags we couldn't have killed them so quick," he told me. It was over while you could light a pipe.
Custer's Last Message
Deadwood Dick—Major Reno was in command of the right wing. French and Benteen were under Reno—they had to do what he said with their troops. What he said went—he was in command. They had to take their men up where Reno was. The men were lost crossing the river. Reno was in command, and he would not let a man out of that place. Gibbon couldn't get there; he had infantry. Terry could have come, but he didn't. The Far West came up the Yellowstone, and he stayed there at the mouth of the Big Horn. I have talked with Green Grass, and I talked with Crazy Thunder—last Seventy-six celebration day we were talking about this thing. Crazy Grass told me if they had waited another two hours the trumpeter that carried Custer's last dispatch, that was torn out of a—a leaf out of his book, reading, "Send me reinforcements—hurry"—and Reno didn't send the reinforcements, and that is the last man that saw Custer alive.
Dr. Carver—General Custer had 205 men when he went into the fight. Charley Reynolds—Hamilton was his name, he shot a sentry down in Lexington, Ky., before he came out here. The Indians called him Charley the Fox, and they said he shot 30 Indians fighting in front of Custer.
Deadwood Dick—There were three Custers killed in the fight, George, Tom and Boston.
Captain North—The first question that Reno asked of Terry and Gibbon was where Custer was. He thought he had gone back to Terry.
Dr. Carver—They whipped Crook, cleaned out Custer, and now comes Terry. They pulled down their tepees. Sitting Bull took his Uncpapas into Canada and the rest of them marched right around between Reno and Terry and went to their reservation.
Mr. Burnham—The Cosmopolitan story about Custer committing suicide—is it fact or fiction?
A Hung Jury
Captain North—The story is fiction, pure and simple.
Dr. Carver—Part of it is fiction and part is very true.
Deadwood Dick—It is fiction, the whole thing right through, all the way through.
And so it went far into the night, refighting the renowned fight on the Little Big Horn. Yet each of these three old Indian fighters is positive his own version is the true one—just as the Indians related it. Still the three, Carver, "Deadwood Dick," and "Lute" North, cannot agree. Carver believes Custer was a suicide. North believes he was foolhardy and allowed himself to be ambushed and that Reno used wisdom in not taking his command into certain death. While "Deadwood Dick" believes that Custer died fighting and that Reno was a coward. There you have it—a hung jury.
While the argument became heated at times it was generally agreed that the Indians were poor witnesses and that their testimony could not be entirely depended upon, so there was an occasional outburst of good natured laughter.
So it was not all stern fighting that the old plainsmen recounted. Finally when the ends of their cigars had begun to burn low, like the embers of a dying campfire, they said goodnight, and goodby, perhaps with just a little pathos after holding each rough hand, for now there was separating the men who never before had met together and perhaps never would meet again. For true men are these; something more than a band of boisterous gun-fighters with vainglorious tales of outlawry. Rather they must be regarded sturdy heroes and onetime soldiers who went forth valiantly to ride, to shoot and if need be to die to push back the Wild West before our advancing civilization.
MAJOR MARCUS A. RENO, who was cashiered from the army because he did not send a handful of men against thousands of well armed Indian warriors.
CURLEY. Crow scout, who witnessed part of the Custer fight and got away.
GENERAL GEORGE A. CUSTER, most famous figure of our Indian wars, who, according to a recent magazine article, committed suicide, when his command was decimated and a wave of red warriors was sweeping over him. Old Indian fighters say the story is without foundation of fact.