As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

March 1915

41 articles

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

This retrospective article profiles John M. Carnahan, the Western Union telegraph operator in Bismarck who transmitted the first news of the Custer massacre in 1876, now retiring after over fifty years of service. It recounts how he rode partway with Custer's expedition before turning back with the last dispatches, and how news finally reached Bismarck via the steamboat Far West.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 2 March 1915 · page 6

Telegrapher Who Flashed News of Massacre Just Retired

Words In Two Shifts. Missoula. Mont.—The news of the Custer massacre was first told to the world '4^|?f''by John M. Carnahan, then mftfiftger and operator in the Western, Y&$jA 'office in Bismarck, NWth xwkota. Aftet an active service of more than fifty years Mr. Carnahan has just been jfttired on a pension. Mr. Carnahan "began his career as a telegrapher in' 18G1. In the fall of 1872 the Northern Pa ciflc railway line had been completed as far wist as Bismarck, N. D. Mr. Carnahan-was asked to go to Bismarck and manage that office, and In the spring or 1873 he went there and the big chapter In the story of his event­ ful life began.

See moreSee less

For it was while he was-at Bismarck that he sent to the world the account of the Custer mas­ sacre en"1 the Little Big Horn .in July, 1876. Fprt Abraham Lincoln, the post of the6evefi.tK dkvalry and the headquar­ ters of Brigadier General Custer, was at Bismarck. Mr. Carnahan wpn Brigadier General Custer's friendship and lie became the personal friend of the offi&ffii at Lincoln. And so it was that he and the post surgeon rode out from the bid, garrison with the Custer it impossible expedition when it started in June, tie fence an' 1876, to punish the Sioux. The surgeon and the operator made the first twelve miles with the Seventh cavalry. Then they turned back with the last dis­ patches which Brigndier General Cus­ ter sent. No word came back to Bismarck from the Seventh cavalry and its com­ mander. But that occasioned no sur­ prise. Expeditions of that sort' were a common occurrence in those days.' It was on the night of July 5 'when the steamboat Far West came down the river to Bismarck.! The Far West tb« brought the wounded of Reno's ^com­ mand and the official dispatches which told of the complete annihilation of the Custer command.

See the clipping

Randolph Enterprise · Beverly, W. Va.

The report is an obituary for journalist James Creelman, detailing his career including a trip to the Little Big Horn to interview Sitting Bull and other Indian chiefs about the Custer massacre. It also covers his other famous assignments like the Hatfield-McCoy feud and war reporting.

Randolph Enterprise · 4 March 1915 · page 1

Ha:field-McCoy feud. He was shot a1. s-‘Vt ral times and had to hide and sleep out in the words for rlavs and nights. His next adventure was up on the Little Big Horn to interview Old Sitting Bull and other Indian chiefs about the Custer masaaere.

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

Model school pupils preparing a dramatization from 'Boots and Saddles' received a telegram from Captain Grant Marsh, who may attend their performance. Marsh was noted as the man present at the mouth of the Little Bighorn River when an Indian courier brought news of the Custer massacre.

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 9 March 1915 · page 7

tion of a dramatization taken from Boots and Saddles, Tuesday evening. Captain Marsh, it will be remembered, was at the mouth of the Llttls Big Horn river In the western part of th^* state, when the Indian courier brought the news of the Custer massacre. Cap tain Marsh is a well known character

See the clipping

The Public Ledger · Maysville, Ky.

A movie theater advertisement promotes the film 'Custer's Last Scout,' starring Marie Walcamp and William Clifford, described as being narrated by Alfred Chapman, billed as 'the Only Survivor of Custer's Massacre.' This is entertainment programming decades after the actual 1876 battle, packaged as dramatic spectacle for paying audiences.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Public Ledger · 10 March 1915 · page 4

TONIGHT "The Secret of In 3 Parts. A Thrilling Tragedy of Marie Walcamp and William Clifford in "Custer's Last Scout" the Sea the Sea

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

Captain Marsh of Bismarck, reputedly the first white man to learn of the Custer massacre in 1876, was a guest at the State Normal School in Valley City. The brief mention appears amid a roundup of local North Dakota news items in 1915.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 11 March 1915 · page 4

Captain Marsh of Bismarck, said to be the first white man to know of the Custer massacre in 1876, was a guest at the State Normal school at Valley City early this week. A

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

John M. Carnahan, who transmitted one of the biggest stories ever from Bismarck—the news of the Custer massacre at Little Big Horn in July 1876—has retired on pension after over fifty years as a telegraph operator. He worked seventeen years in Bismarck before moving to Missoula, Montana for twenty-four years, and now plans to return to La Crosse.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 11 March 1915 · page 8

PENSION FOR OLD OPERATOR

Is Retired. La Crosse,*Wis., March 10.—John M. Carnahan, who sent »ut from Bis­ marck, N. D„ one of the biggest stor­ ies the world ever knew—the story of the Custer massacre on the Little Big

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

The article recounts how telegraph operator Carnahan was persuaded to take charge of the troubled Bismarck office in 1873, where he remained far longer than promised. It describes his marathon transmission of 80,000 words detailing Custer's annihilation after the steamer Far West arrived with dispatches in July 1876.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 11 March 1915 · page 8

Went to the Bismarck Office. The telegraph management laid the situation before the operator. It ap­ pealed' to his loyalty. All it asked was .that he put the ismarBck office to rights. If Carnahan would do that it would send him relief in a few weeks and he might return here. Carnahan yielded. He went to Bismarck in 1873. It did send him relief, but not until i890. The Bissiarck garrison, including many friends of Carnahan, was in the Custer expedition. The operator and the post surgeon rode out from the post with the expedition and' when't started in June, 1876, to punish the Sioux.

See moreSee less

They went twelve miles with the .Seventh cavalry. Then they turn­ ed back with the last dispatch Custer ever sent. On the night of July 5 the steamer Far West came down the river ana tied up at Bismarck, when most people were in bed. The 'Far West brought the wounded of Reno's command and the official dispatches which .told of the complete annihilation of Custer's

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

This 1915 article profiles veteran telegraph operator Carnahan, who in 1876 transmitted the first news reports of the Little Bighorn battle from Bismarck to eastern newspapers, charging $1,320 for a 22,000-word dispatch. It also notes, without confirming, the rumor that Custer's recklessness stemmed from resentment over correspondence with President Grant that Carnahan had handled.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 11 March 1915 · page 8

Big Horn expedition and "which has al­ ways been supposed to have caused .the resentment whichdrove Custer to recklessness on the fatal ride. But that is a story Carnahan has never told. During the fifty-three years at a telegraph key many thrilling stories have passed .through his hands, espe­ cially during the early years of his ca­ reer, when he was on the border be­ tween the north and the south in the civil war. "1 suppose I shall miss the click of the Instruments" says Mr. Carnahan, "but I have some hens at home which make a noise that sounds good to me, and I am going tc settle down where I can take care of them.

See moreSee less

The pension will keep a little flour in the bin and some bacon on the shelf. If the hens do right I'll have a good breakfast every day—that's sure."

See the clipping

The Weekly Times-Record · Valley City, N.D.

Captain Grant Marsh, reputedly the first white man to learn of the 1876 Custer massacre, attended a Model school entertainment dramatizing early Dakota history including the Custer campaign. The program listed cast members for scenes depicting Custer's regiment, Fort Lincoln garrison life, and a Sioux visit before the battle.

The Weekly Times-Record · 11 March 1915 · page 1

He First Told the World Grant Prince Marsh, captain of the steamer "Far West," who has been called "an actor in events of great his toric moment covering almost the en tire period of the conquest of the up per Missouri river valley, the subjuga tion of the Sioux Indians and the op ening to civilization of the vast terri tory which they had occupied," Tues day was the guest of the Model school at the State Normal school. Capt Marsh, who is said to be the first white man to know of the Custer mas sacre in 1876, came all the way from Bismarck to witness the annual Model school entertainment Tuesday evening, which is a dramatization of the events of early Dakota history in which he figures so largely.

See moreSee less

The author of "The Conquest of the Missouri" says of Capt. Marsh, "tall, broad shouldered and powerful of frame, clear-eyed and gentle of voice, this veteran navigator of the Missouri has lived and worked, shoulder to shoulder, with many men famous in history, and passed through as many strange and rugged experiences as would stock the biography of an ad venturer of the Spanish main." tion gone by. city. took part:

See the clipping

The Weekly Times-Record · Valley City, N.D.

A 1915 newspaper piece profiles Captain Marsh, now 80 years old, credited with first telling the world of the Custer Massacre. The article frames him as a historic figure, appearing alongside a school pageant commemorating the Custer campaign.

The Weekly Times-Record · 11 March 1915 · page 1

Scene I. General and Mrs. Custer with 7th Cavalry Regiment on their way to Fort Rice, make a halt and are overtaken by a blizzard.

See the clipping

The Weekly Times-Record · Valley City, N.D.

Captain Grant Marsh, pilot of the steamer Far West, visited a Valley City school and recounted his early experiences, including receiving news of the Custer massacre and returning to Bismarck. The event also featured a student dramatization with scenes depicting Fort Lincoln, the 7th Cavalry's departure, and the arrival of massacre news at the Little Big Horn River.

The Weekly Times-Record · 11 March 1915 · page 1

Far West, commanded by Capt. Marsh. Dramatis Personae Gen. George A. Custer Richard White Mrs. Custer.. .Catherine McMullen Tom Custer Ralph Ferguson Mary, Negro servant Pauline McFarland Ham, Negro servant Nathanael Finney Surgeon Abraham Gill Adjutant Gordon Corby Jorgen Bonhus Orderlies Edwin Peterson Citizen of Yankton Hans Lee Wives of the Officers— Mabel Henderson Grace Deem Katherine Tenney Leonora Boyd Ethel Stephenson Inez Taylor Ethel Belkamp Helen Stone Herder Myron Sharpe Lieutenant Wallace. Elmer McClure Mail Carrier Donald Lum Arickarees— Leonard Bakken Lee Combs Burton Boyd Adolph Soroos James Combs George Wright Donald Stephenson Sioux Harold Soroos ?nna.w?

See moreSee less

Beatrice Englert Charlotte Howard &quaws Grant Marsh, Capt. and Pilot of Dave Campbell, Pilot Far West Leslie Towne Homer Chaffee George Foulk, Engineer Vincent Carroll Capt. Baker Arohie DeLancey Lieut. Carlin Theodore Finney Curley, Indian Scout Albert Stephenson

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

The article recounts the 1879 killing of trapper Charles Walmsby by the Indian hunter Spo Pee near Cut Bank, and his subsequent trial and death sentence, later commuted to life imprisonment by presidential intervention. It notes the trial occurred only three years after the Custer Massacre, when little leniency was shown to Indians in Montana courts.

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 11 March 1915 · page 10

that Its object was robbery. Tho trial nf Spo Pee took place but throe years after tho Custer Massacre, nnd nt that time llttlo consideration wns shown tho Indian In Montana courts. Ho was condemned to die, But tho President of tlio United Staton Intervened and his sentence was com muted to life Imprisonment In tho De Leopold, but he renounced the honor In favor of his son Prince Wllhelm. tho father-in-law of King Manuel of Portugal. Prince Wllhelm also de clined to rule Roumanla and gave up his claim to his brother, Prlnco Fer dinand, who in October of last year came to the throne.

See the clipping

The North Platte Semi-Weekly Tribune · North Platte, Neb.

A veteran's serialized reminiscence describes troops discovering Cheyenne camps containing guns, equipment, furs and robes taken from Custer's slain men after the Little Bighorn fight. The soldiers burned the goods, buried their own dead secretly, and endured a grueling five-day winter march to Crazy Woman's Fork with wounded comrades.

The North Platte Semi-Weekly Tribune · 12 March 1915 · page 8

I'JRITTEN BY P. (Continued from Tuesday's issue.) Thoso Cheyenne Indians had been with Sitting Dull and Crazy Horse during tho fight with Custer, and we found guns and u largo amount of government equipment that that had been taken from Custer's men when massacred on tho Little Big Horn.

See the clipping

The North Platte Semi-Weekly Tribune · North Platte, Neb.

A veteran recounts the harsh conditions of General Crook's 1876 campaign, including burying frozen dead at Crazy Woman's Fork and enduring forty-two-below-zero cold at Pumpkin Buttes. He also notes that a scout's report placing Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse's camp on the Little Bighorn proved mistaken, as they were later found on the Belle Fourche.

The North Platte Semi-Weekly Tribune · 12 March 1915 · page 8

General Crook In the meantime had sent out scouts to locate if possible tho main camp of Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse. Ono scout returned and

See the clipping

Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.

A local theater's weekly program listing includes a Saturday film described as 'a story of the famous Custer Massacre,' shown alongside other serials and comedies. This 1915 advertisement reflects the event's transformation into popular entertainment decades after it occurred.

Yorkville Enquirer · 12 March 1915 · page 3

AT THE LYRIC PROGRAMME NEXT WEEK

and Grace Cunard. Also "Three Times and Out," an Imp Comedy, featuring King Baggot. Saturday?"*jusier s utsi scuui, a. story of the famous Custer Massacre. Admission: 5 Cts. and 10 Cts.

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

At Valley City, North Dakota, students staged a historical drama depicting Sioux, Arikara, and Crow tribes with Custer and Captain Grant Marsh as central figures. Marsh, the real steamboat pilot who had carried wounded soldiers from the 1876 campaign, attended the performance at nearly eighty years old.

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 13 March 1915 · page 2

CAPTAIN MARSH TAKES IN V. C. NORMAL PLAY

IN V. C. NORMAL PLAY Valley City, X. n March 13.—Sioux SArickarees, Cron.s and allied Indian tribes attacked this point this week and captured the interest of every resident, of the city, old settlers re called the tring times of the spy0"" ties, when the hostile red man »cign ed supreme over the Dakota prairies, and the younger generation readied Che maximum of excitement. But, tinlike in the pioneer days, not :i scalp was lost and there was no •fclood shed. Tho "Indiana" and "soldiers'' were the pupils in the practice department Of the state normal school here, and the event was their annual winter en tertainment.

See moreSee less

a drama of early Da kota history with ien. Geo. A. Custer and 'apt. Grant Marsh, who honor ed the cast by his prescncc, the cen tral figures. News conceming the play and its characters early in the week brought the doughty old captain from his hoinn in Bismarck to the normal school Ga in pus to witness the production. Al tnost eighty years old. It was the first tiine Captain Marsh had been on a campus and to the old pilot it was of as much interest as his presence lent interest to the play. When he re turned to his home it was to await the opening of the Missouri river so lie could again oly his boat where, lie had plied it for over half a cen tury while he became identified with many stirring and momentous his HO torical events.

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

A newspaper report describes a school dramatization at a normal school depicting the Custer campaign, from the Seventh Cavalry's departure from Yankton to Crow scout Curley's escape and report to Captain Marsh. The piece also recounts how news of the Custer massacre first reached Fort Lincoln near Bismarck in record time of fifty-four hours.

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 13 March 1915 · page 2

of construction at the present time. II is estimated that in «i very short time there will be over a hundred sub scribers on this line. The work setting the poles is well under way at the present time and will be pushed as fast as possible that the line may first brought the news of the Custer massacre from the mouth of the little Big Horn to Fort Lincoln near Bis marck, then the western terininous of the Northern Pacific railroad, a dis tance of I.00U miles in the record time of nrty-four hours.

See moreSee less

It was from this point that the tragedy of tho Sioux was flashed to the world. The drama as presented by the pu pils here this week embodied the more important events of the Custer cam paign from the time of the seventh cavalry left Yankton until Curlcy, the Crow scout, made his escape from the carnage and reported to Captain Marsh in his own crude way the fate of the Custer army. The dramatiza tion of the Custer Campaign was made by Misses Susan W. Norton and Margaret C. Burns, critic teachers in the practice department of the nor mal school, who have been identified with the dramatization of Sakakawea, the Bird Woman, and The Ivast of the Mandans, also presented here during the past two years.

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A 1915 newspaper article recounts the 1876 Sioux campaign across Wyoming, Montana, and Dakota, describing Custer's march from Fort Lincoln and his death with 250 men at the Little Bighorn on June 25, 1876. It introduces the story of Captain Grant Marsh and the steamboat Far West, which carried supplies deep into hostile territory to aid wounded soldiers after the battle.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 17 March 1915 · page 2

Stillwater, Minn., March 15.—Editor Post: The great Sioux Indian war of ]87G was caused by the determination of the government to compel this an/*, all other Indian tribes to go upon re­ servations and live there. The Sioux under Chief Sitting Bull, were the leaders, in this rebellion against the government's orders, and the effort to subdue them was the occasion of the hut and greatest Indian war fought on this continent. The war was carried on under the general direction of iNel son A. Miles, the commander-in-chief of the regular army.

See moreSee less

Under him, and at the head of the somewhat meagre forces of cavalry were Generals Cus­ ter, Gibbon, MerN'tt, Terry and Capt. Moylan, Capt. Godfrey, Major Reno. Lieut. A. E. Smith and others. The warlike Northern Cheyennes were al­ lied with the Sioux and the whole of the then new and sparsely settled Northwest was ablaze with war. The scene of these sanguinary disturb­ ances included the then territories of Wyoming, Montana, Dakota, Colorado and Northern Nebraska and Western Minnesota. The people of today can have little conception of the awful con­ ditions prevailing in the valley of the Upper Missouri river and its tributar­ ies—the Yellowstone and the Big Horn —in the year 187G. It required all Qf the power of the government to put down the big Indian rebellion, and this was not accomplished until long after the death of General Custer and bis devoted band, Conditions Along River. 1 have written the above prelimi­ nary to give my readers some idea of ihe conditions then prevailing along the navigable Missouri river from tlio frontier forts along that stream in Da­ kota all the way up to the he^d of nav­ igation at Fort Benton, and also up the Yellowstone and Big Horn. Scouting parties were out all the tijne roaming arov.nd in scarch of hostiies, and theee detachments suffered severely at the hands of the Indians. Among the real­ ly astute Indian leadeis were Sitting Bull, Crazy Horse and Rain-in-the Face. The Battle of the Rosebud had been fought on the 17th of June, 1876, under the eye of Gen. Miles. Gen. Custer had left Fort A. Lincoln, at Bismarck, Dakota, with his troop of rough riders on the 17th of May, 1876. His command was the famous Seventh cavalry. On the 25th of June Custer found the Sioux Nation ip arms on the Littye Big ill'orn, with results that end ed in the death of himself and 250 of his men—all who were with him at the time. There were no wounded to be cared for after .ihe Custer slaught er, but there was much other lighting in the same neighborhood both before and immediately after, by other de­ tachments, under the leaders I have mentioned, and4t was to supply these various dotachments with ammunitfon, medicines, food, etc., that the steamer "Fur West" had boon loaded and sent a thpusaiM miles up the Missouri, Yel­ lowstone and Big Horn, cle&r up to the mouth of the Little Big Horn—far­ ther up than any steamboat ever had been before, and to within a few miles of the active hostilities. Capt. Grant Marsh was in command of the "Far West," and the boat was in great dan­ ger from the Indians, as the river was narrow, so narrow that the boat hard­ ly coifld be turned in it. Moreover, the freshet v/liich had enabled' them to ascend the Big Horn, was rapidly flowing out. Every day was precious, and the anxiety of all was very great. Meanwhile the wounded and crippled soldiers were coming in each day, un­ til the boat was a floating hospital. The following narrative of Capt. Grant Marsh's spectacular and daring flight

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

This 1915 retrospective piece recounts Captain Grant Marsh's famous 1876 voyage of the steamboat Far West, carrying wounded soldiers from the Little Bighorn battlefield down the Big Horn, Yellowstone, and Missouri rivers to Bismarck. It credits the account to old St. Paul Pioneer Press dispatches and praises Marsh, Dr. Porter, and the pilots for their skill and endurance during the historic trip.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 17 March 1915 · page 2

Or. Porter Detailed. The steamer "Far We3t" was moor­ ed at the mouth' of the Little Big Horn She was the suppiy boat of the expedi­

See the clipping

The Wahpeton Times · Wahpeton, N.D.

This 1915 article profiles John M. Carnahan, the Bismarck telegraph operator who transmitted the news of Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn to major newspapers in 1876, and reports his retirement on pension after decades of service. It recounts how the steamer Far West arrived with news of the massacre and how Carnahan worked around the clock to send roughly 80,000 words despite being the only operator for 200 miles.

The Wahpeton Times · 18 March 1915 · page 2

{the eastern papers had been cla La Crosse, Wis., March 15 —imoring'for a story, but there was John M. Carnahan, who sent out' no one to send it. Carnahan could from Bismarck, N. D., one of the'not leave his offical work and biggest stories the world ever!there was no other telegraph op knew—the story of the Custer erator within 200 miles. He sent massacre on the Little Big Horn'as much story as he had strength to prepare. in July, 1876—has just been re

See the clipping

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

A 1915 article describes Dr. Beede of the Standing Rock Indian agency, a lecturer on Indian life, who wrote a dramatic verse account of the Little Bighorn battle from the Indian perspective, drawing on accounts from participants like Gall, Rain-in-the-Face, and Sitting Bull. The piece notes his drama is being considered for a Harvard Stadium production and mentions his other work about the Whitestone battle.

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 18 March 1915 · page 6

Following the story of the Custer fight, which is beautifully told in dramatic verse, the author gives the sources of his copious information. He tells of the divination ceremonies performed by Sitting Bull, the Great Medicine Man and Prophet of the Sioux before the battle also gives short sketches of Chief Gall, Rain-In the Face, Peji (now known as John Grass), and Echonka, all well-known Indians who were participants in the fight and a more extended account of Sitting Bull, himself, the unsub dued rebel and implacable enemy of the whites. The book is embellished by sketches of men and animals drawn by Indians themselves.

See the clipping

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

The report describes the 1863 Whitestone affair, in which General Sully attacked a peaceful band of Hunkpati Sioux who had not participated in the Minnesota uprising, killing innocents instead of the actual culprits. It references the Little Bighorn battle thirteen years later only as a chronological marker, while focusing mainly on Dr. Beede's career studying Indian life and history.

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 18 March 1915 · page 6

The Indians denied the story that they attacked Sully first, and Sully afterwards was reported as saying the battle was "all a mistake." Gen­|tion eralPope blamed him for it. Sibley had no part in the Whitestone bat tle, which occurred thirteen years be fore Gall and Crazy Horse with 800 Sioux and Cheyennes captured the central division of Custer's regiment (The at the Little Big Horn and killed every white soldier trapped within that fatal circle. There is a permanent interest among white people in the life of savage men, in his ideals, myths and racial characteristics.

See moreSee less

Dr. Beede, who has made ethnology a close study for many years, finds pleasure and instruction in observing the peculiarities of different races of men. He made a foot journey through Germany several years ago to study the types and the charac teristics of the German people. He declares that of all nations of the earth, the German community life is the most sensible, thrifty and suc cessful that the Germans get much more out of their social gatherings and customs than the English,

See the clipping

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

The passage recounts riverboat pilot Captain Grant Marsh's memories, including a minor discrepancy with Mark Twain's account of how a scout first reported the Custer massacre aboard the steamer Far West. Marsh also clarifies that the Whitestone Hill Indians were unrelated to those responsible for the Minnesota uprising, and mentions Curley, the lone Custer battle survivor, still being alive.

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 18 March 1915 · page 7

RIVER PIONEER

Captain Marsh says that one inci dent in that book is not exactly as he related it, in regard to the Indian who told the first news of the Custer slaughter to the officers of the "Far West" on the Little Big Horn short ly after the battle. The escaped In dian drew a sketch of the battlefield, showing Custer's soldiers trapped

See the clipping

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

A 1915 feature article profiles General Hugh Scott's career negotiating with Native American tribes through sign language and diplomacy. It mentions his 1877 failure to persuade Sitting Bull to return from Canada and face consequences for the Custer massacre, among other career highlights.

South Bend News-Times · 19 March 1915 · page 4

Just Two Failures in .V.) Years. He made good in that war, with the loss ef about hah" of his lighters, a as a matter of fact there are only two notable instances in his years of life when Gen. Scott did not make good. In 1S77 fie failed to persuade the embittered edd Sioux warrior, Sit ting Hull, to return from his refuge in Canada and "take his medicine" for the Custer massacre, and in spite of three years of almost personal con tact, he never could bring the hoary old Apache, Geronimo, the last epic figure of the Indian race, to relax his misanthropic contempt for the white men who had shut him behind prison bars.

See moreSee less

"Two Indians whom I did not find it profitable to waste any words on," Gen. Scott once described them. Per haps it was because he "wasted no words" that Gen. Scott was received by Sitting Hull as a friend, and during his guardianship of the formal ami punctilious Geronimo was treated familiarly, almost as a "crony." Those other last leaders, TTed Cloud and Spotted Tail, were his sworn friends and put their trust In "Ills word,

See the clipping

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

The report recounts General Hugh Scott's early military service during the 1876 Sioux uprising and the 1877 Nez Perce campaign, describing his mission to Sitting Bull and later peacekeeping reputation with western tribes. It continues through his later career in Cuba and the Philippines, including his wounding in action against Moro fighters.

South Bend News-Times · 19 March 1915 · page 4

Perces were surrounded. Scott was de tached on the mission to Sitting Bull. An expedition against the Chey ennes in 1S78 and a few skirmishes,

See the clipping

Northern Wyoming Herald and Garland Irrigation Era · Cody, Wyo.

The article recounts how Buffalo Bill Cody rejoined the Fifth Cavalry in 1876 to campaign against Sitting Bull's Sioux, describing the three-pronged advance by Terry, Crook, and Gibbon. It notes Crook's battle at the Rosebud on June 17 and Custer's defeat at the Little Bighorn on June 25, with news reaching the East ten days later.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Northern Wyoming Herald and Garland Irrigation Era · 19 March 1915 · page 3

vary prod table season, one theatrical summsritly disbanded. It was Buffa lo Bill’s Own” then playing to crowd ed bouses, and the simple oxplaaa tlon of It alt was that the papers had Just announced a serious Indian war In the West, and that the Fifth Rent meat of cavalry had been ordered bom tbe southern plains to hasten to Gen. George Crook’s column ih Wyo ming. This wss the regiment which sis or seven years earlier. Cody had guided aa chief scout on the campaign against Tall Bull and the Southern Cheyennes, and now their old com rade could not bear the Idea of their again going campaigning without him.

See moreSee less

The wire# had flashed his message to Cheyenne within the hour after he read the news. The wires flashed back to him the answer from the reg iment: “Tour old position open to you. Join us here.” And for four days • there after he was eagerly welcomed by ev ery officer and man, aa much at home among them aa though they had nev er known a day apart. One week thereafter, under the or ders of General Sheridan, they had forded tbe North Platte and launched out Into the broad lands of the Sioux ordered to End tbe route by which tbe young warriors were quitting tbe reservation of Red Cloud and Spotted Tail in Northwestern Nebraska, sad riding away laden with rations, arms snd ammunition, to Join the great horde of “bostltea” under the renown ed medicine chief. Sitting Bull —Teton ka Eyo Tonka. Their rendezvous was a the heart of the glorious country between the Big Horn range and the Yellowstone. Three ootnmns, com manded respectively by Generals Ter ry. Crook and Gibbon, were closing h upon them from the east, south and west. With Terry rode the famous cavalry leader of the Civil war. Geo. Armstrong Custer. Hurrying to Join Crook, and assigned to the command of the Fifth Cavalry, came Wesley Merritt, famous even as Custer: and between those three slowly conccen tratlng columns larked the bands of Sitting Bull, wearily watching every more and waiting a chance to strike. On the 17th of June they swarmed on Crook’s force among the bluffs of the Roeebud snd brought him to a stand. On the 25th they overwhelmed Cus

See the clipping

Northern Wyoming Herald and Garland Irrigation Era · Cody, Wyo.

This 1915 article recounts the 1876 Little Bighorn campaign, describing how news of Custer's death reached Buffalo Bill Cody's Fifth Cavalry while they were scouting on the frontier. It details General Merritt's subsequent maneuvers to intercept Cheyenne warriors attempting to join Sitting Bull's forces.

Northern Wyoming Herald and Garland Irrigation Era · 19 March 1915 · page 3

Horn. Perhaps no man more delight edly heard ’Merritt’’* sudden order — a few days later—to face again north ward, ride like tbe wind and be ready to fight like tbe devil. Flight hun dred Southern Cheyennes, old antag onists of the Fifth had had a grand powwow at the Red Cloud agency, and oiienly declared their intention of starting to Join forces with their vic torious bretbern under Sitting Bull. Merritt's generalship was always fine: this day it was great. With just even companies he was In bivouac at t the moment close to Rawhide Ford of tn - Red Cloud La-aioie r- -i-: slx ly-flve miles southeast of the reserva tion.

See moreSee less

It wss just noon Saturday, the 'sth, He had promptly reasoned that the Indians would take the broad trail across the valley of the South Cheyenne where the Fifth had been scouting and chasing until Sheridan's order of recall reached them on the 12th. The route was now open. There

See the clipping

The Kemmerer Republican · Kemmerer, Wyo.

A Wyoming sheepherder named Ben McIntosh duped eastern newspapers by posing as Curly, the Crow scout said to be the sole survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn. The article clarifies that the real Curly, a Crow Indian, still lives on the Crow reservation and was present when Custer sighted the Indian forces on June 26, 1876.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Kemmerer Republican · 19 March 1915 · page 2

Sheepherder Puts One Over—Poses in Effete East as the Only Surviving Member of Ill-Fated Custer Party

THE KEMMERER REPUBLICAN Ben Mclntosh, a sheepherder of the country near Sheridan, Wyoming, captures the prize for monumental : nerve. The recent controversy over .the claim of a western rancher, who ;in the east posed as Rufus Steele, : the magazine writer and club man of San Francisco, takes on piker pro portions beside our hero of the Sherii । dan hills. Besides being a sheepherder by trade, Ben sometimes, when desiring • the friendly social life of larger cen ters of population than his trade pro . video in the hills, works as a dis ( penser of doughnuts and slabs of pie ( over lunch counters.

See moreSee less

In fact he at , one time owned a Inch wagon in Sher idan. , Ben put one over on the effete • East, and perhaps, in the broad and . presumably more or less wide west, . by posing as Curley, the scout, sole survivor of the Custer massacre. The story reads like a piece of fic * tion, but a Wyoming man vouchee for it and produced newspaper clippings to show how easy it is to ! make a supposedly wide-awake pre. l s and its readers ‘fall” for almost any kind of a tale. To begin, it should be understood I that there is a real Curly the scout, i . and he is the sole survivor of the Custer massacre. The real Curly । lives at Crow agency, on the Crow । ■ Indian reservation. The real Curly is! ; a full-blooded Crow and an honor to j . his tribe. As a youth he was a scout and happened to be with Custer’s com mand on the morning of the ill-fated ’ 26th of June, 1876, when the coni mander of the Seventh regiment ) sighted the allied Indian forces that I were to wipe out the command a little ! later. One of Custer’s officers had ] taken a liking to Curly. Me called th. - Indian boy aside and told him to ru . . as there was to be a fight again;- } overwhelming odds, with little chance! of any members of the command e caping. Curly took the advice, though 1 . he says frankly and honestly tod y ! . that he is sorry he did so. From nearby hill he saw Custer’s comm . d i overwhelmed, to the last man. Since that time Curly has had anj I ■ number of opportunities to go Ot ; with Wild West Shows, but he hi , spurned all such offers. He live quietly on the reservation. Curly i 1 following the rule of minding his ow. ) business. He is chosen to take charge i of the big roundup of Crow hors ■ । and cattle every spring and fall, ana no one, to see the hard-working Indi? in cow-boy outfit, would imagine the roundup boss had played an impoi I j part in the most thrilling fight i , Western history. So much for the real Curly the scout. Now enters Ben, .sheepherder. Sonu | one has told Ben that he rasemblti _ Curly, the scout. The sugextion is -; enough for Ben, who sees away to ■ capitalize it. If the real Curly is such I a plumb dinged fool that he will not I make £ood red gold by going out .• n . advertising himself and letting the public pay to gaze on his lectures and hear his voice, why should* not the - sheep herder play the part of Curly? Ben is a true economist. It displeases him to see so much potential wealth going to waste. Somebody might as well be getting the benefit of the red ■ Curly’s nation-wide fame. The next stage in the western . comedy finds the sheepherder on the lecture platform, telling eastern people that he is the real Curly. The stuff goes on. The newspaper men I are sent for. They arrive—eager . young men from journalistic school;! with freshly grabbed bunches of copy paper peering from their side pockroute by a prominent eastern au tomobile supply company which is to send out trains of trucks from Seattle in April for thi" . purpose. These signs will con tain all necessary information ■ for tourists. Thousands of peo ple will chose this route, which will be known as the “Wonder land Trail,” and will be charmed by the scenery. Many parts of Wyoming ar< destined at no distant date t become great tourist centers, as the wonderful scenery an I ; delightful summer climate will prove irresistable. Concerning pleasure resorts on national pre serves, a law was passed by Con cgress ju 4 before adjournment a ■ few weeks ago which should he , men. • ly the scout. above story.—Ed.]

See the clipping

The Kemmerer Republican · Kemmerer, Wyo.

A con man impersonating Curly, the Crow scout who survived Little Bighorn, tours American cities giving paid lectures with wildly inconsistent, fabricated tales of the battle. He claims to have personally fought off Sitting Bull to protect Custer, charging audiences up to 50 cents per show despite his stories changing from city to city.

The Kemmerer Republican · 19 March 1915 · page 2

THE KEMMERER REPUBLICAN ets. They admit they are not “up” on Western history. They know < there was a man named Custer and he was knocked out in one round by a red hope named Sitting Bull. No matter. Curly—the bogus Curly— will see to it that they get all the his tory that is necessary. So the sheep herder who looks like Curley and who comes from the country where “loa t- | ing” tenderfeet is the favorite indoor ivuucucei is me lavome inaoor and outdoor sport, proceeds to fill up ’ those bunches of copy paper until the , reporters telephone the office for more Hq tells the most fantastic ta?e about the fight on the little Big Horn.

See moreSee less

He tells how he stod off Sitting Bull himself for an hour and a half and > 1 ept the ferocious savage from sink ing his tomahawk in the prostrate Custer’s brain. At last human en durance can do no more. Sitting

See the clipping

The Monte Vista Journal · Monte Vista, Colo.

A soldier's home resident recalls the 1876 campaign against Sitting Bull and Sioux bands who left their reservation for buffalo hunting, prompting Custer and Crook to be sent to bring them back. The account describes troop movements across Wyoming, Montana, and the Dakotas during the summer-long campaign.

The Monte Vista Journal · 20 March 1915 · page 6

REMINISCENCES OF THE INDIAN WARS

A DARING DEED Chapter One The summer of 1876 was full of excitement to those who composed the campaign of the Sioux outbreak and defiance of the commands of the War department to remain on their Reservation. Sitting Bull and the young braves wanted buffalo, and against the wishes of Red Cloud and Spotted Tail, they set out. From the North, Brevet Brigadier Gen eral Geo. A. Custer was ordered to

See the clipping

The Monte Vista Journal · Monte Vista, Colo.

A reminiscence published decades later describes General Crook's 1876 campaign against the Sioux, Arapahoe, and Oglala, including news reaching the troops that Custer's command had been wiped out at Little Bighorn while Reno and Benteen were repulsed. It continues with the pursuit of Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse through the Black Hills and Yellowstone region.

The Monte Vista Journal · 20 March 1915 · page 6

A DARING DEED

But that wily Chieftain spread out his braves and drove all the game in front of him and burned all the grass so that our stock suffered rnr‘ forage-—-so much so that whole troops of cavalry were dismounted, and the horses were abandonéd to shift for themselves. Chapter Two Now came the crisis: Sitting Bull had escaped across the Yellow stone river into Canada, but we suc ceeded in cuttting off Crazy Horse, American Horse, Roman Nose and other chiefs with the greater num ber of the renegades who had slaughtered Custer’'s command. We

See the clipping

The Public Ledger · Maysville, Ky.

This 1915 article profiles a retiring telegraph manager, John M. Carnahan, recounting his 39-year career. It highlights his role in 1876 sending the first news of the Custer massacre from Bismarck, working 48 hours at the key and transmitting 8,000 words of details.

The Public Ledger · 20 March 1915 · page 3

SENT CUSTER TRAGEDY

church of tho United States. TWENTY-FIVE YEARS OF WORK FOR ALIENS. ing out of Bisiuurk, N. I)., the first nows of tho Custer massacre in 187(1. At that tlmo ho worked almost continuously at tho koy for 48 hours, with no ono to

See the clipping

The Dickinson Press · Dickinson, N.D.

The article reports that telegraph operator John M. Carnahan, who transmitted the news of the Custer massacre from Bismarck in 1876, has retired on pension after 50 years of service. It recounts how the steamer Far West brought news of Custer's defeat to Bismarck on July 5, 1876, and how Carnahan worked 21 hours straight to send the story and official dispatches to Washington.

The Dickinson Press · 20 March 1915 · page 4

C. G. Simpson sends the PRESS a copy of "The Great Divide," pub lished at Denver, Colorado, which contains an interesting story of the part taken by Two Moons in the Custer masacre. Two Moons led the Cheyenne tribe of Indians in this conflict in 1876. He is now 76 years of age and is reported as being in good health, complaining of nothing but his failing eyesight.

See the clipping

The Dickinson Press · Dickinson, N.D.

The article recounts how veteran telegraph operator Carnahan worked exhausting shifts in July 1876 to transmit the first detailed news of the Custer battle at Little Bighorn from Bismarck to major newspapers. It also notes that decades earlier Carnahan handled official correspondence between Grant and Custer, which some believed spurred Custer's recklessness.

The Dickinson Press · 20 March 1915 · page 4

Cbrnahiut had sent 80 0M %p^in the two shifts and the receipts of his office in thoae two days were $3,000. But before he turned in Carnahan sent a new story to the New Yjrk Herald, the Chicago Inter Ocean and the St. Paul Pioneer Press. For two days the eastern papers had been clamoring for a stroy, but there waB no one to send it. Carnahan could not leave, his -office work jand there WTJjo pther telegraph oper&tor wi$h 200^-miles. He sent as much story as he had strength to prepare.

See moreSee less

And th^t was, the: way the 'news of the Custer battlesent out. As fast as they could arrive special correspondents hurried to Bismarck "to get the intimate details of the great story. Carnahan "sent" for 12 hours on one story. When he had finished, the correspondent, O'Kelley, handed him a $50 bill. That was his personal perqisite, the tolls on the Special dispatch amounted to $1,320 there were 22,000 words. This was the longest of the news stories which Carnahan sent. Carnahan is the man who handled the official correspondence between President Grant and General Custer, at Bismarck which preceded the little Big Horn expedition and which has always been supposed to have catised the resentment which drov6 -Custer to recklessness on the fatal ride. But that is a story Carnahan has never told. During the fifty-three years at a telegraph key many thrilling stor ies have passed through his hands, especially during the early year/3 of his career, when he was on the bord er between the north and the south in the Civil war.

See the clipping

The Ogden Standard · Ogden City, Utah · and 1 other paper

The report profiles John M. Carnahan, the Western Union operator who in 1876 transmitted the official and newspaper accounts of Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn from Bismarck, Dakota Territory. It recounts his career, including riding out with the Seventh Cavalry's expedition, and notes his recent retirement after fifty years as an operator.

The Ogden Standard · 20 March 1915 · page 15

Sent Story of Custer's Massacre

John M Carnahan, one of the old est operators in tho service of tho Western Union Telegraph Company, the operator who for twenty-one hours without a rest sent the official and newspaper stories of the Custer

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • · · 21 March 1915

The Ogden Standard · Ogden City, Utah

This 1915 retrospective recounts telegraph operator Carnahan's career, focusing on how he relayed the news of Custer's defeat from Bismarck after the steamer Far West arrived with dispatches. It details his marathon shifts transmitting thousands of words to Washington and eastern newspapers in July 1876.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Ogden Standard · 20 March 1915 · page 15

jovial man around the city hall, tie near Cincinnati He Is forty-four years old. and has been serving the never walks through the corridors without being stopped many times, public since 1905. He was a iun his little remarks of good cheer are Cbinist before this, and still holds a always on his lips, and it was hard membership card In one of their or Cor me bo realize thai he had been ders, in 1888. while at work there robin ri oi hin alun hh sense stghl waB a premature explosion of pow sight.

See moreSee less

"How do I manage to tell whether der. This robbed him of his eye the prisoners are guilty.'" he said sight, not immediately, but grad ually. He was born in Carthage, former me a falsehood and gel away with it" 1 a suburb of Cincinnati, but re cently taken into the city After the prisoner gets before me I know explosion he practiced law, and in 1905 was appointed a justice of the not I ean tell from the tone of his peace in Carthage He served in this capacity in Carthage until 1909 A number ol Hum have tried to then this village waa annexed to Cincinnati. He served in the city ment very much, but even without my eyes he would be able to do equally as well as he does now " And just as "Judge" De Pinal thmks. I thought and everyone else thinks. Judge Bell divides his time on tho bench between tho civil and John M Carnahan, one of the old est operators in tho service of tho Western Union Telegraph Company, the operator who for twenty-one hours without a rest sent the official and newspaper stories of the Custer massacre, has been pensioned and allowed to return to his old home in Wisconsin, where he will raise chickens. During the later part of his career he has been in Montana and Dakota. At the time he was sent to the of fice at Bismarck, N. D., then the farthest west station on the North ern Pacific Railroad, it was called the worst town in the world. He objected, but the company appealed to his loyalty. All it asked was that he get the Bismarck office run ning right. If Carnahan would do that it would send him relief in a few weeks and he might return here. Carnahan yielded. He went to Bis marck In 1873. The company kept the promise after a fashion. It did send him relief, but not until 1890. For seveoteen years Carnahan re mained at the frontier station When he left it was for Missoula. Mont., where ho remained twenty-four years. At the beginning of the new year Carnahan, after completing more than fifty years' work as an operator, retired. At Bismarck Carnahan sent, out one of the biggest stories in this country the story of the Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn in July, 1S76. The Bismarck garrison, including many friends of Carnahan, was in the Custer expedition. The operator and the post surgeon rode out from the post with the expedi tion when it started In June, 1S76. to punish the Sioux. They went twelve miles with the Seventh Cav alry. Then they turned back with the last dispatch Custer ever sent The night of July 5 the steamer Far West arae down the river and tied up at Bismarck, when most people were in bed The Far West brought the wounded of Reno's com mand and the official dispatches, which told of the complete anni hilation of Custer's command The morning of July 6 Carnahan found on his desk iu the telegraph eftlce a carpel bag filled with offi cial dispatches He sized up his job. "flashed" the news to the East and then settled down to the transmis sion of the official story to the De partment of War in Washington It was S o'clock In the morning of July 6 that Carnahan started on his tremendous task. Until f. o'clock the following morning -twenty-one hours he did not leave the keys Coffee and a sandw ich were banded him now and then in the long shift and a towel was wet and placed at his head at Intervals. lie rolled on a bed at 5 o'clock. ment very much, but even without my eyes he would be able to do equally as well as he does now " And just as "Judge" De Pinal thmks. I thought and everyone else thinks. Judge Bell divides his time on tho bench between tho civil and

See the clipping

The Ogden Standard · Ogden City, Utah

This 1915 retrospective recounts how telegraph operator Carnahan sent the first news of the Custer battle (Little Bighorn) from Bismarck in 1876, working marathon shifts to relay tens of thousands of words to Eastern papers despite limited wire capacity. It also claims Carnahan handled official correspondence between Grant and Custer that supposedly caused resentment driving Custer to recklessness in the battle.

The Ogden Standard · 20 March 1915 · page 15

Grant and General Custer, at Bis marck, which preceded the Big Horn expedition, and which always has been supposed to have caused the resentment which drove Custer to recklessness on that fatal ride. But that is a story Carnahan has never told.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

At a Woman's Home Missionary Society Club meeting, a member named Dales spoke about the Sioux tribe's characteristics and her personal experiences living among them, noting her father had been the government agent to the Sioux at the time of the Custer massacre. The meeting also included a paper on disease among Native Americans and a song performed to the tune of 'Tipperary'.

Evening Star · 21 March 1915 · page 74

WOMAN'S HOME MISSIONARY SOCIETY CLUB

Tuesday at the home of Mrs. \V. A. I Paul, 79 R street northwest. Roll call j was responded to by the mention of j an Indian instrument and its use. Mr* ; Muirhead read a. paper cine Man arid Disease,' tion to the ravages c trachoma among the . _ _ bur Dales talked of the characterise of the Sioux, and personal experiences while living with that tribe, her father having been the government agent to the Sioux at the time of the Custer massacre. A song composed by Mrs. Paul was sung to the tune of "Tipperary." This club was organized nine years ago for the purpose of studying the various fields of home mission effort. Its meet ings are held semi-monthly at the homes of the members.

See the clipping

The Sunday Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.

The article recounts how telegraph operator Carnahan, stationed at Bismarck, received the official dispatches of the Custer disaster via the steamer Far West and spent over twenty-four hours transmitting the news to Washington and Eastern newspapers. It details his marathon telegraphy sessions in July 1876, sending some eighty thousand words about the annihilation of Custer's command.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Sunday Telegram · 21 March 1915 · page 22

years. At the beginning of the newyear Carnahan. after completing more than flfty years' work as an operator, retired. At Bismarck Carnahan sent out one of the biggest stories in this country?the story of the Custer massacre on the .Little Big Horn in July, t876. The Bismarck garrison, including many friends of Carnahan, was in the Custer expedition. The operator and the post surgeon rode

See the clipping

The Sunday Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.

The article recounts how telegraph operator Carnahan transmitted the news of Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn from Bismarck in 1876, working extreme hours to send dispatches to major Eastern newspapers. It also mentions his handling of earlier official correspondence between Grant and Custer, speculating it caused resentment leading to Custer's recklessness.

The Sunday Telegram · 21 March 1915 · page 22

Carnahan had sent eighty thousand words in the two sftifts and tho -*-* - ?- " ? i UV.CHJUJ ul in? gmcc in , iiiose wo I days were $3,000. But beforo bo quit. Carnahan sent a news story to three papers in the East. For two days the Eastern papers had been clamoring for a story, but there was no one to send it. Carndhan could not leave his official work, and there was no other tetegrapli operator within two hundred miles. Nor was there enough wire. To the New* York Herald, the Chicago Inter- ? Ocean and the St. Paul Pioneer Press he sent as much story as he i had strength to prepare. And that was the way the news of the Custer battle was sent out.

See the clipping

The Star-Independent · Harrisburg, Pa.

The report recounts how telegraph operator John M. Carnahan, stationed at Bismarck, transmitted the news of the Custer massacre to Washington in July 1876 after working the key for 21 straight hours. It notes his retirement in 1915 to a farm in Oklahoma, nearly 40 years after sending the famous dispatch.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Star-Independent · 22 March 1915 · page 3

Blackwell, Okla., March 22. John M. Carnahan, the telegraph operator who sent out from Bismarck, X. D., one of the biggest stories the world ever read—the story of the. Custer massacre 011 the Little Big Horn in July, 1576 —has just retired 011 a pension and is planning to spend the rest of his days in Oklahoma on a Kay county farm. For seventeen years Carnahan was at the frontier station of Bismar k. The Bismarck garrison, including many friends of Carnahan, was in the Custer expedition. The operator and the post surgeon rode out from the post with the expedition when it started in June, 187ti, to punish the Sioux Indians.

See moreSee less

They went twelve miles with the Seventh, Cavalry and then returned with the last dispatch General Custer ever sent. It was addressed to President Grant and told pf the plans for the expedition. On the night of July 3 the steamer Far West came down tiie river and tied up at Bismarck when most people were in bed. The Far West brought the wounded from Reno's command and the oflicinl dispatches which told of the complete annihilation of Custer's out fit.

See the clipping