The report recalls John M. Carnahan, the Bismarck telegraph operator who in 1876 relayed the news of Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn after the steamer Far West arrived with dispatches. It details his career, the intense workload of transmitting the story, and his recent retirement on pension.
sacre Retires From Game. ON DUTY TWENTY-ONE HOURS Carnahan Sent Eighty Thousand Words In Two Shifts, and Receipts of His Office In Two Days Were $3.0C0. Newspaper Man Gave Carnahan Fifty Dollar Bill For Extra Work. John \I, Carnahan, thp Telegraph op erator who sent out from Bismarck, N. 1>.. one of the biggest stories the world ever read—the story of the Cus ter massacre on the Little Big Horn in July, 1870—has jus* retired on a pen sion and is planning to spend the rest of his days in Oklahoma on his Kay county farm, where he will raise chick ens pigs and other domestics.
See moreSee less
For seventeen years Carnahan was at the frontier station of Bismarck and when lie left there it was for Missoula, Mont., where he lived for twenty-four years. Previous to being stationed at Bismarck he was at La Crosse, Wis., and so after tifty years as an opera tor Carnuhan will draw a pension, and Oklahoma will have within its boun daries another veteran who helped make the history of the early days of the Indian west. The Bismarck garrison, including many friends of Carnahan, was in the Custer expedition. The operator and the post surgeon rode out from the [>ost with the expedition whan it started in June, 1876, to punish the Sioux Indi ans. They went twelve miles with the Seventh cavalry and thrti returned with the last dispatch General Custer ever sent It was addressed to Presi dent Grant and told of the plans for the expedition. On the night of July 5 the steamer Far West came down the river and tied up at Bismarck when most people were In bed. The Far West brought the wounded from Reno's command and the official dispatches which told of the complete annihilation of Cus ter’s outfit Flashed Word of Massacre. Carnahan was called from his bed ind found on his desk In the telegraph >ffioe a carpetbag full of official re ports of the fight and its results. He sized up the job, and his first wire ac tion was to flash the word east that the massacre had occurred. Then he settled down to the transmission of the official story to the department of war at Washington. For twenty-one hours he did not leave the key. Coffee and sandwiches were handed him now Rnd then during the long shift, and a wet towel was kept on his forehead. With the reports finished he fell into bed and for three hours slept the sleep of exhaustion; then he got up and re turned to the key. For two days the eastern papers had been clamoring for detailed news of the massacre, but Carnahan could not leave his official work, and until now there was no one to send It. He start ed In, however, and sent all he could find out to New York. Chicago and St. Paul papers. He sent as much story as he had strength to get and prepare, and that was the way the details of the disaster were sent out. Carnahan had sent 80,000 words in the two shifts, and the receipts of his office In those two days were $3,000. As fast as they could arrive special correspondents hurried to Bismarck to get the Intimate details of the big story. O’Kelly, a New York man, was the first big one on the ground, and Carnahan sent for twelve hours more on his stuff. There were 22,000 words, and the tolls on the special dispatch were $1,320. O’Kelly gave Carnahan $50 for his ex tra work, and the veteran operator still has that $50 bill. Carnahan Is the man who handled the official correspondence between President Grant and General Custef which preceded the Little Big Horn expedition and which has always been supposed to have caused the resent ment which drove Custer to reckless ness on the fatal ride. But that is a story Carnahan has never told. During the fifty-three years at the telegraph key many thrilling stories have passed through his hands, espe cially during the early days of his ca reer, when he was on the border be tween the north and south during the civil war.
A veteran telegraph operator named Carnahan recounts how he relayed the first detailed news of the Little Bighorn disaster to major newspapers, working exhausted shifts and sending tens of thousands of words. He also mentions handling the Grant-Custer correspondence rumored to have driven Custer's recklessness, though he has never told that story.
Bridgeton Pioneer · 1 April 1915 · page 8
ON DUTY TWENTY-ONE HOURS
President Grant and General Custef which preceded the Little Big Horn expedition and which has always been supposed to have caused the resent ment which drove Custer to reckless ness on the fatal ride. But that is a story Carnahan has never told. During the fifty-three years at the telegraph key many thrilling stories have passed through his hands, espe cially during the early days of his ca reer, when he was on the border be tween the north and south during the civil war.
An elderly pioneer, S. P. Blythe, recounts to a reporter his 1860s ox-train journey west, including a fight with Sioux warriors on the same ground where Custer later fell. The piece is a nostalgic human-interest profile of his long life as a frontier printer, not a direct account of the battle itself.
The Hood River Glacier · 1 April 1915 · page 6
S. P. BLYTHE TELLS OF PIONEER DAYS
ai toon aa tne Civil war was over Saumel P. Blythe, of Hood Kiver. joined the march toward the sunset across the great plains. He had served through the war. Hia party of west ward trekkera set out from St. Joe. Mo., with an ox train, heading for the ballatin valley, Montana, where they nurnoapf) to taka land n They had a tight with the Indians in Hthe Little Big Horn country, on about the same ground that later drank the U blood of Custer and his command. The Indiana were Sioux.
See moreSee less
They were beaten off after a stubborn struggle, the white men shooting from the shelter of their wagons, parked in a circle. Three of the white men were buried by moon littht after the Indians had been beaten off. Then the oxen were hitched up, and the men forced them with goad and whip as fast asthey could travel for 17
Northern Wyoming Herald and Garland Irrigation Era · Cody, Wyo.
A 1915 feature profiles Buffalo Bill Cody near his 69th birthday, describing his youthful vigor and sharp wit. He recounts confronting a man in San Diego who falsely claimed to be the sole survivor of the Custer massacre, bluntly calling him a liar.
Northern Wyoming Herald and Garland Irrigation Era · 2 April 1915 · page 3
; HERN WYOMING HERALD, FRIDAY. APRIL 2, I*ls. Colonel, I am the only survivor of the Custer Massacre." Quick as a flash, the Indian flghter will hurl back th* ugly monosyllable hat causae men to forget Sunday schools and all' that sort of thing. Br en in telling about thto type of falsi fier the former plainsman looks as he must have looked the time he killed Yellow Hand a Cheyenne chief, In u hand-to-hand fight. "Down In San Diego, not long ago, I ran into one of these fellows," the Colonel began, and when I pH through wl h him there waa nothing left to say.
See moreSee less
And I didn't talk very much either. "Some of my friends told me when I reached town that the only survivor of the Custer massacre lived there. I utes at a time. am?"
Northern Wyoming Herald and Garland Irrigation Era · Cody, Wyo.
An interview feature describes 68-year-old Buffalo Bill Cody being constantly pestered by fans and old-timers wanting to swap stories, showing his continued vitality and fame. Asked about the best Indian fighter, Cody praises Custer's bravery but notes he attacked what he thought was a village and ran into an army, unable to escape.
Northern Wyoming Herald and Garland Irrigation Era · 2 April 1915 · page 3
Aaked whom he thought was the beat Indian flghter our army has ever known the Colonel rallied: “All of them were good. It would be unkind to the others to pick one man and any ho waa the best. In fact, It can’t be done-” Custer was brave to a fault, but he attacked what he thought waa a village, ran into an army and could n" get away with It.’’ It does me good to talk with a man Ilk* Buffalo BiU. All hto life be has been on the frontier—a pony express rider, a scout, a leader of plainsmen, he has crowded into the years so many tempestuous hours, that one marvels that has has survived, let alone looking so youthful.
A newspaper item from 1915 muses that the Custer massacre remains a subject of endless, unsatisfying speculation because no soldier with Custer survived to tell the true story. It notes that claims from Sitting Bull's warriors or Crow scouts describing the battle have often been dismissed as fraudulent or unreliable.
Custer Weekly Chronicle · 3 April 1915 · page 3
Ever since the Custer massacre that tragic event has been the theme of profitless and in every way unsat isfactory discussion and yet fron tiersmen and men with a small knowledge of frontier events, never weary of raising the subject in some one of its ramifications whenever op portunity permits. With a total an nihilation of the little band immedi ately with Custer was destroyed all human knowledge of the details of that occurrence. True certain mem bers of Sitting Bull’s band and a Crow scout or two have occasionally appeared with a recital based upon what they alleged were facts, but in a number of instances such individ uals have been proven imposters while the remainder were under grave suspicion.
A 1915 newspaper profile praises General Hugh Scott's career-long skill with Native American peoples, tracing it back to 1876 when he joined Terry's column, of which Custer's Seventh Cavalry had been part before being wiped out at Little Bighorn. The article uses the battle as a biographical reference point rather than reporting on it directly.
The Washington Times · 4 April 1915 · page 7
QUICK TO MEET ENEMY
tall"' lieutenant he was sent to tho Plains In 1876 to Join "Terry's column," of which the famous Seventh Cavalry under General Custer had been a part before it was wiped from tho army rolls at tho battle of the Llttlo Big Horn, General Scott has persistently pursued the study of the "human equation" In every problem ho has tackled. Tnat. moro than unvthlntr else, his rellow officers say, explains his marveious success in aeanng wun savage Peoples and extricating them aa well aa the Government from difficulties.
John M. Carnahan, the telegraph operator who in 1876 transmitted the news of the Custer massacre from Bismarck, is retiring to his Oklahoma farm after fifty years in the profession. The article recounts how the steamer Far West brought word of Reno's wounded and the annihilation of Custer's command, which Carnahan then relayed by wire.
The Sunday Telegram · 4 April 1915 · page 11
[: .twentV-four years. Previous to being - - stationed at Bismax'ck he-was at La (Snosse, YV'is., and so after fifty years j , \ as an operator, Carnahan will draw V. tL' pension and Oklahomawill have I , ; wjtmn its oou<n<aan<?s another veter a* ;. anwho helped make the history of v tli'e early days of the Indian west, j last Message to Grant. , .The Bismarck garrison, including ; v many friends of Carnalian, was in the B .\ ' Custer expedition. The operator and . t^e post surgeon rode out from the ; p$st with.
See moreSee less
the expedition when It. " started in June, 1876, to punish the ,V. * Sioux Indians. Tljey went twelve miles ! I f " w^th the. Seventh cavalry apd then re-1 . i turned with the la?t dispatch General : . ' Custer ever sent,.,. Itfaya? jewjdre^d to President Grant and. told. of the plans for the expedition:' I On the night of July *5. the steamer I// 1 Far "West came down the r^ver,.^.nd tl^d up at Bismarck wfaem most-people |"v were in bed. The Fa rt West brought the wounded from Reno's command i and the oihcial di^ThtcheS. which told '
The article recounts how telegraph operator Carnahan worked twenty-one hours straight to send the official report of Custer's defeat to Washington, then relayed thousands of words to major newspapers. It notes the toll costs and the arrival of reporters like O'Kelly seeking details of the disaster.
The Sunday Telegram · 4 April 1915 · page 11
U in the ordinary household, flsh or ro Sent he Custer re Quits K ey jp . ~ " "'.r , ; tion was to flasli the* word east that
The piece recalls veteran telegraph operator Carnahan, who in 1876 relayed the earliest press dispatches about the Little Bighorn disaster to major newspapers, working two exhausting shifts and sending tens of thousands of words. It also notes he handled the earlier Grant-Custer correspondence long rumored to have fueled Custer's recklessness, a story Carnahan never told.
The Sunday Telegram · 4 April 1915 · page 11
President Grant and General Coster 1 wihictr.pEeceded the IAttle Big Horn l expedition and which has always been J supposed to have cwused the resent-ii merit which drove "Custer to recklesst neas on the fatalride. --But that is a >1 story Camahan has nqvcr told. n
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.
This article promotes American scenic and historic destinations as superior to European sites amid World War I, listing places like Yellowstone, the Rockies, and Gettysburg. It briefly mentions Custer's stand at Little Big Horn as a site of patriotic honor worth visiting.
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 8 April 1915 · page 4
honor 'han a vii»it to the scene of Gen. Custer's stand on the Little Big Horn? Surely the scenes made fam ous by a Fremont, a Crockett, a Houston, must pull against those of a Napoleon or a Bismarck. The one
A local band concert featuring the descriptive piece 'The Death of Custer' or 'Battle of the Little Big Horn' has been postponed from April 11 to April 25. The delay is due to needing more time to secure equipment and rehearse this difficult composition.
Saturday News · 8 April 1915 · page 5
UNTIL SUNDAY, APRIL. 25 tempted. The concert to be given by the Fourth Regiment band of this city and which was announced for the 11th of this month, has been post poned until the 26th. This change lA was made necessary by the fact that the proper equipment and parapher nalia for putting on the great de scriptive pifece "The Death of Cus ter," or the "Battle of the Little Big Horn," cannot be secured until Just before the 25th, hence the change in date. "The Death of Custer" is un questionably the most: realistic de scriptive arrangement published for band and its production requires all
John Carnahan, the telegraph operator who sent the first news of Custer's defeat from Bismarck in 1876, has retired after fifty years as an operator. The article recounts how he worked the key for twenty-one hours straight after the steamer Far West brought news of the massacre, relaying official reports to Washington and press dispatches to major newspapers.
Aberdeen Herald · 9 April 1915 · page 3
SENT WORD OF CUSTER'S FALL
Custer ex|iedltlon. The operator nuri the (lost surgeon rode out fmm the ikwi with the es|«dltlon when It started ill June. 187(1. to punish the Sioux Indi ans. They went twelve miles with the Beveiitb ccvalry ami then returned with the last dispatch 'ieucral Custer *ver sent. It was addressed to I'resl dent Grant and told of the plans for the expedition. On the night of July A the steamer Par West came down the river and tied up at Bismarck when most people were in bed The Par . West brought the wounded from Reno's command and the official dispatches which told of the complete annihilation of Cus ter's outfit
A 1915 article profiles a telegraph operator, Carnahan, who reportedly handled official correspondence between President Grant and General Custer before the Little Bighorn expedition. It notes this exchange has long been supposed to have caused the resentment that drove Custer to recklessness, though Carnahan has never told the full story.
Aberdeen Herald · 9 April 1915 · page 3
O'Keliy gave Cariialnin $.V) for his ex tra work, and the veteran operator sdli lias that $50 bill. Caruiiban 1s the man who handled the official correspondence. between I'resident tJrant and General Custer whlrti preceded the Little Big Horn expedition and which has always lieen sup|HM«ed to have caused the resent rnent which drove Custer to reckless ness on the fatal ride. But that is a story Caroahan has never told. During the flfty-three years at the telegraph key tnnny thrilling stories have (Hissed through his hands. es|te --tally duriug the early days of Ills ca reer.
See moreSee less
when he was on the border be tween the north and sontb during the civil war. Evidence. He—Didn't it ever occur to yon that i was In lore with you? She-Certain ly. Haven t you ever uoticed me laughing to myself? - Philadelphia ledger.
At a Bismarck ladies' suffrage meeting in 1915, steamboat captain Grant Marsh recounted his 1876 experiences piloting the Far West up the Missouri and Bighorn rivers during the Custer campaign. He described meeting the Crow scout Curly, the lone survivor to reach him, and recounted ferrying the wounded back to Bismarck.
Bismarck Daily Tribune · 11 April 1915 · page 3
Au afternoon of more than ordinary interest was spent at the home of •Airs. A. A. .Bruce, 420 Avenue B, on Wednesday-, when 25 people were pres ent to enjoy the program which the ladies of t'ne suffrage organization had in charge. The program was opened with, a solo by Mrs. Wm. V. Kiebert, who was followed by Captain Graut Marsh, who gave a most interesting descrip tion of his experiences at the time of the Custer massacre, when he was in charge of the Far West on its trip up tho (Missouri, in '76.
See moreSee less
The Captain pic tured localities, fixing in the minds of tho hearers a much clearer idea of the placs of Wagon Wheel Butte and other places of interest, and gave rea sons why certain points bear the names they do, also telling of his
A 1915 newspaper concert program lists musical selections performed at an event, including an orchestral piece titled 'The Death of Custer. The Battle of Little Bighorn,' described as a descriptive American and Indian fantaisie by composer Lee Johnson. The program also includes other classical works by Brahms, Rossini, Verdi, and Bizet.
The Monroe Journal · 13 April 1915 · page 2
IITEHMISSIOM 6Overture, William Tell, by Rossini 7Hungarian Dance No. 6, by Brahms 8Quartet From Rigoletto, by Verdi 9Selection From Carmen, by Bizet 10The Death of Custer. The Battle of Little Bighorn, a descriptive American and Indian fantaisie, by Lee Johnson
A real estate notice advertises reservation land near Fort Yates, North Dakota, opening for sale to settlers in May 1915. It recalls the fort's history as an army post during Sitting Bull's era and notes it was named for Captain Yates, killed in the Custer massacre.
Sioux County Pioneer · 23 April 1915 · page 1
HOMESTEADS AT FT. YATES FROM MAY 3 TO 17
And Indian Land Purchasers considored wi,l ennsidered simultanof McLaughlin, South Dakota. «n the Milwaukee railroad It' can also be reached from Solen or Tim nicr on the N. I'. railroad, as well as from Selfridge or Shields oil the Milwaukee railroad. Automobile and oilier conveyance can be secur ed at all these points. Fort Yates is one of the oldest, historic points in Western North Dakota, having been an army post in addition to liuMaii Agency head quarters during the stirring days a |iiart» of a century ago when Sit ting Hull and his tribesmen donned their war-paint ami resented the encroachment of the white man on their domain.
See moreSee less
It was named after Captain Vates, who lost his life in the Custer massacre. Since then our Indian brother has adopted the habits and customs of civilization, and the Standing Rock Sioux of today are among the finest. Indians ill existence, being educated, peace able, industrious and law-abiding citizens.
The Broad Ax · Salt Lake City, Utah · and 1 other paper
John M. Carnahan, the telegraph operator who flashed news of the Custer massacre to the world in 1876, has retired after more than fifty years of service. He retired on New Year's Day and now receives a pension granted by the company for his long service.
The Broad Ax · 24 April 1915 · page 5
SIRES AND SONS.
Custer massacre to the1 world In 1S76. retired on New Year's day, after active service of more than fifty yean. He has entered upon the enjoyment of the pension which the company granted for long service.
The Broad Ax · Salt Lake City, Utah · 13 March 1915
Hot Springs Weekly Star · Hot Springs, S.D. · 19 March 1915
The Broad Ax · Salt Lake City, Utah · 27 March 1915
The Broad Ax · Salt Lake City, Utah · 3 April 1915
Hot Springs Weekly Star · Hot Springs, S.D. · 9 April 1915
The Broad Ax · Salt Lake City, Utah · 10 April 1915
The Broad Ax · Salt Lake City, Utah · 17 April 1915
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The article recounts Lieutenant Ernest Garlington's Medal of Honor action at Wounded Knee in 1890, where he was severely wounded directing troops despite a shattered arm. It then backtracks to describe his 1876 commissioning into the 7th Cavalry just days before Custer's annihilation at Little Bighorn, and his subsequent journey west to join the regiment's survivors.
Evening Star · 25 April 1915 · page 54
ed, while serving as first lieutenant, 7th Cavalry." To help him remember it all, he has a permanent stiffness of the arm. This, however, was not the first time that Garlington's name had been on the nation's tongue; nor was it to be the last. A native of South Carolina, though appointed from Georgia, he was grad uated at twenty-three from the mili tary Academy June 15, IS76, and at once assignee! as second lieutenant in the famous 7th Cavalry, then com manded by the dashing Custer. Just ten days later, while young Garlington was preparing to go west to join the command, Custer and two squadrons of the 7th were wiped out by the Indians at the battle of the Little Big Horn.
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.
This is a real estate advertisement for western North Dakota land near Fort Yates, which briefly mentions the fort's history as a site connected to Sitting Bull's resistance and named after Captain Yates who died in the Custer massacre. The bulk of the passage promotes the region's soil, grazing land, coal resources, and settlement opportunities, unrelated to the battle itself.
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 27 April 1915 · page 2
'iu rter of a century ago when Sit tnii Bull and his tribesmen donned their war-paint and resented the en croachment of the white man on their domain. It was named after Captain Yates, who lost his life in the Custer massacre. Since then our Indian brother has adopted the habits and customs of civilization, and the Stand ing Rock Sioux of today are among the finest Indians in existence, being educated, peaceable, industrious and law-abiding citizens. Character of Soil.
Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D. · and 1 other paper
A promotional article for homestead lands near Fort Yates, North Dakota, describes the town's history as an army post and Indian Agency headquarters, noting it was named after Captain Yates who died in the Custer massacre. It also praises the Standing Rock Sioux as having since become peaceable, educated citizens.
Bismarck Daily Tribune · 28 April 1915 · page 1
Fort Yates is one of the oldest, his toric points in Western North Dakota, having been an army post in addition to Indian Agency headquarters during the stirring days a quarter of a cen tury ago when Sitting Bull and his tribesmen donned their war-paint and resented the encroachment of the white man on their domain. It was named after captain Yates, who lost his life in the Custer massacre. Since then our Indian brother has adopted the habits and customs of civilization, and the Standing Rock Sioux of to day are among the finest Indians in .existence, being educated, peaceable, Industrious and .law-abiding citizens.