As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

January 1915

14 articles

The Chronicle=news · Trinidad, Colo.

The article recounts the naming of Fort Washakie, claiming Chief Washakie led allied Indian tribes against General Nelson Miles's troops in battles following the Custer massacre before being taken prisoner. It credits Washakie's later counsel for bringing peace to the region and names the fort in his honor.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Chronicle=news · 1 January 1915 · page 2

From Field and Farm. Tlie Last Stand.; Old Fort Wash akie was one of the historic forts around which clustered many great events in the Indian wars of .°>r>.and 40 years ago. It was In the vicinity of this post that was fought one of the great and final battles of the In itial! wars that followed the Custer massacre. General Nelson A. Miles was in chief command or the regu lar troops at the time and the Indians opposing hint were the Northern Cheyennes. Arapahoes and Shoshones.

See the clipping

The Sunday Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.

An elderly former soldier, now working at a Virginia Street undertaking establishment, recounts his 1876 army service, describing severe food shortages that forced his unit to eat mule meat. He claims he served under General Crook and arrived at the Little Bighorn battlefield two days after Custer's command was wiped out, alongside the commands of Reno and Miles.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

The Sunday Telegram · 3 January 1915 · page 9

if* a grievoiie mirneij to an classos, ; were on the trail of the rtdskins who had participated' in the Custer massacre. ! Scene of Custer SlassSwre "I wan serving in , the* command of general Crook at that time and' wo got to the scene of the massacre two days after the brave Custer and his men had then killed. We camped

See the clipping

The Punta Gorda Herald · Punta Gorda, Fla. · and 1 other paper

A Lakeland Telegram piece recounts a 1915 story about a newspaperman refusing a lawyer's request to suppress news of the Battle of Little Bighorn in 1876. The lawyer feared his wife would be devastated reading that their son, a lieutenant in Custer's regiment, might be dead, but the paper printed the news anyway, and the son survived.

The Punta Gorda Herald · 7 January 1915 · page 1

Here's One Which Beats That

It is odd how many persons there are who think they know how to run newspapers. There are hundreds of men in every city who insist on dictating to or advis ing a newspaper what to print and what not to print, and it is mazing the requests that come to every newspaper. This paper was even asked not to print any information regarding the tragedy here last Tuesday night. As though a story like that could be suppressed and kept from the out side world. St. Petersburg Inde pendent. We have one that even beats that.

See moreSee less

Away back yonder in 1876 when the whole nation was shocked by the dreadful news one day that General Custer had been killed and the seventh cavalry' almost annihilated by the Sioux in the battle of Little Big Horn, a

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • · · 24 November 1914

Daily Capital Journal · Salem, Oregon

A Salem society column profiles visitor Mrs. K. C. MacNew, noting that as a girl she was uniquely allowed to ride General Custer's horse Comanche, described as the sole survivor of the Custer massacre. The piece recounts her family's time in South Dakota where the horse was kept under a government-pensioned caretaker.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 11 days earlier.

Daily Capital Journal · 7 January 1915 · page 2

massacre, recorded in history as the Custer masHacre. This horso was given expert care during Its lifetime, and wan being looked utter by a professional caretaker, pensioned by the government and sent rroin Washington, 1). L., in

See the clipping

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

A 1915 feature recounts an old soldier's frontier army days, noting that a unit he once served alongside was later entirely wiped out in Custer's historic battle with Sitting Bull's Sioux at the Little Bighorn. The bulk of the story is his personal account of an 1871 skirmish with Comanches in the Texas Panhandle.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 8 January 1915 · page 1

R. Poundstone. """"m"m ini.i..,in,ira.,.,mi,iKi.i,m,t, , ,n.,i,.,m,i,,m." I 1 bin,,,,,,,,,,, imim.i mmmiui ii.iiiimimiiiiiii years later was completely wiped out during Custer's historic battle with Sitting Bull's Sioux in the valley of the Little Rig Horn, was sent to the Texas frontier, the wildest country in all the far west. He can tell you of dashing cavalry raids, hand-to-hand conttsts, sudden surprises and wearisome pursuits un til your brain whirls, but his story of the brush with the hostile Comanches on Catfish creek, Staked Plains of the Texas Panhandle, is more thrill ing than any writer of Wild West fiction ever imagined. It was early in November, 1S71, lUM

See the clipping

The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D.

C. B. Carnahan, retiring after fifty years as a telegraph operator, is noted as the man who sent news of the Custer massacre at Little Bighorn from Bismarck in 1876. He worked 21 hours straight, sending 80,000 words, with the Bismarck office earning $3,000 in receipts over two days.

The Washburn Leader · 8 January 1915 · page 1

The old-timers of McLean coun ty will remember John M. Carna-j ban. During the last twenty four years hehas been manager of the Western Union Telegraph office at Missoula, Mont., and before that was at Bismarck. He has now retired after more 1 than fifty years of service at the key and will receive a pension. Car was the man who Dalian sent to the world one of the biggest news stories it has ever known—the tale of the Custer masi-acre on the Little Big Horn in July 1976. lie sat at tho key for 21 hours and during that time sent 80,000 words. The receipts in the Bismarck office in thosv two days were $3,000. Mr. Carnahan. will continue to live in Missoula^ and will raise

See the clipping

The Wallace Miner · Wallace, Idaho

A 1915 feature recounts how John M. Carnahan, Western Union operator at Bismarck, transmitted the first news of the Custer massacre to the New York Herald in July 1876. It details his career, his friendship with Custer's officers, and his retirement after 50 years of service.

The Wallace Miner · 14 January 1915 · page 6

FLASHED FIRST NEWS - OPERATOR LIVES IN MISSOULA - IS PENSIONED AFTER 50 YEARS' SERVICE

VN,if ' c <l8a 0 ® 0 n<>1 1 »»/ . m Carnahan Was the Man. In the fall of 1872 the Northern Pa c|Bo ral)way i, ne had been completed a3 f ar W est as Bismarck, N. D. Mr, Carnahan was asked to go to Bismarck and manage that office, and in the spring of 1873 he went there and the bi|i cha I )ter ln th0 stor y of hls eventful life began. For it was while he was at Bismarck that he sent to the world the account of the Custer massacre oh the Little Big Horn ln July, 1876.

See the clipping

The Wallace Miner · Wallace, Idaho

The article profiles John Carnahan, the Bismarck telegraph operator who transmitted the official dispatches about Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn to the world in July 1876. It describes how he worked for over 40 hours straight sending roughly 80,000 words after the steamboat Far West arrived with news of the disaster.

The Wallace Miner · 14 January 1915 · page 6

Steamboat Brings News to Bismarck. It was on the night of July 5 when Far West came down the steamboat the river to Bismarck. The Far West brought the wounded of Reno's coin mand and the official dispatches which told of the complete annihilation of the Custer command. On the morning of July 6 Mr. Carna han found on his desk in the telegraph office a carpet bag filed with official dispatches. There was an immense lot of them. He "flashed" the news to the east and then settled down to the : transmission of the official gtory to the department of war in Washington.

See moreSee less

II j was 8 o'clock in the morning of July 1 6 when he began his tremendous task. Not until 5 o'clock the following morn :

See the clipping

The Wallace Miner · Wallace, Idaho

A 1915 retrospective describes telegraph operator John Carnahan's marathon shifts sending 80,000 words of official Little Bighorn dispatches to Washington and major newspapers in July 1876. It also claims he handled prior correspondence between Grant and Custer at Bismarck that supposedly provoked the resentment driving Custer's fatal recklessness.

The Wallace Miner · 14 January 1915 · page 6

Has Had an Eventful Career. For two days the eastern newspapers had been clamoring for news, and there was no one to send it, Mr. Carnahan could not leave his official work, and there was no other telegraph operator within 200 miles. To the Herald, the Chicago Inter Ocean and the St. Paul Pioneer Press he sent as much of the news as he had strength to prepare. And that was the way the news of the Custer battle waj sent out. hat was tlie big news article in 'the career of John Carnahan.

See moreSee less

But In the professional secrets of 63 years at a telegraph key there must be many iln.ldents stored tip which would startle There the world if they were told. ' were many thrilling messages pass ing during the early years of his ser vire at the key—the years when he was on the border between north and south in the civil war. Mr Carnahan Is the man who handled offlclal correspondence between Prcsl dent Grant and Custer at Bismarck which preceded the Little Big Horn expedition and which has always been supp'sed to have caused the resent merit which drove General Custer to recklessness on that fatal ride.

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

The obituary recounts the life of Paul C. Blum, a stagecoach express messenger and frontier figure who died in Cody, Wyoming. It notes his sister was married to Captain Edgerly of the Seventh Cavalry, who served under Reno during the Custer fight at Little Bighorn.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 14 January 1915 · page 3

PIONEER BLUM DIES RECENTLY

Stage line, which ran from Bismarck to Deadwocd," says D. F. Barry, the noted photographs-]', who «/as located here and at thevarious forts along the Missouri at that time, but who is now in Superior, Wis., "Paul, as he 1 was commonly called, was express messenger and sat with the driver, rifle in hand, ready for action. His sister, who was raputed as being one of the handsomest women with tno army, was the wife of Capt. Edgerley of the old Seventh Cavalry, with Re­ no on the hill in the Custer (iglit. In lSSf) Sitting Bull "refused to go with the Buffalo E'ill show unlns Paul went with him. Paul also spent, two years with Major McLaughlin at

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

A theater advertisement promotes the film "Custer's Last Scout," featuring Chief Rain-in-the-Face billed as the last surviving witness to Custer's command's massacre. The ad is part of a daily program listing at the Orpheum alongside other short features and comedies.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 15 January 1915 · page 7

ORPHEUM TODAY

Klaw & Erlanger’s Well known Play produced by the BIOGRAPH CO. ip 3 Parts “Woman Against Woman” A wonderful portrayal of woman’s inhumanity to woman, featuring an all star cast of players specially selected for this play by KLAW and ERLANGER. This picture is just long enough to portray all the pathetic and thrilling scenes necessary to make the play extremely interesting from begin ning to end without “padding” to alid an extra reel or two as some feature concerns would do to get the extra money. “Custers Last Scout” A great Military Drama of 2 Parts featuring Chief RAIN IN-THE-FACE, the last surviving witness of the Massacre of General Custer’s Command.

See moreSee less

WM. CLIFFORD and MARIE WALCAMP do some fine work in this feature. “Through a Knot Hole” A rip-roaring L-KO Comedy featuring RUBE MILLER and PEGGY PEARCE.

See the clipping

The Bottineau Courant · Bottineau, N.D.

John M. Carnahan, a longtime Western Union telegraph employee of Bismarck and later Missoula, Montana, has retired after 53 years of service. He is noted as the operator who first transmitted word of the Custer massacre at Little Big Horn to the world in July 1876.

The Bottineau Courant · 15 January 1915 · page 4

Western Union Telegraph Co. for over fifty-three years. Car nahan is the man who sent to the world over the wires the biggest news story it has ever known—the tale of the Custer massacre on the Little Big

See the clipping

Decorah Public Opinion · Decorah, Iowa

A local theater advertisement lists upcoming films including 'Custer's Scout,' described as a two-reel dramatization of Custer's last stand. The ad claims the story was told by 'the only living witness,' a dubious promotional claim.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Decorah Public Opinion · 27 January 1915 · page 3

Lyric UNIVERSAL TONIGHT: “The Gollinsby Pearls" :> reels, a drama of strange complica tions. “The Mystery of the Throne Hoorn'- 2 parts, Grace Cunard and Francis Ford. “For the Good of the Cause”, comedy, Eddie Lyons and Victoria Forde. "Two of a Kind , comedy. THlllSh.W: “The Master Key", No. 5, 2 reels, Hob Leonard and Ella Hall. This serial is getting better ail the time. Come out in spite of the cold weather. You will not regret it. “Dude HafTles,” Comedy. “The Heart of the Bradys.” Comedy. FRIDAY: “Fawns of Fate”, 2 l'eels, drama.

See moreSee less

‘ Those German Bowl ers”, comedy. “His Lordship pro posed,” Comedy. "Custer’s Scout”, 2 reels. A thrilling dramati zation of Custer's last stand as des cribed by the only living witness. HATI’ISDAY: “Shore Acres”. See special add on this big feature. Always a Good Program Matinee Thursday 11:4a. Suturda 1:16 to 5 p. m.

See the clipping

The Ogden Standard · Ogden City, Utah

An advertisement for a film called 'Custer's Last Scout' showing at the Oracle Theater, described as a dramatization of Custer's Last Stand featuring 'the only living witness.' The ad appears alongside an unrelated news story about Rockefeller testimony before Congress.

The Ogden Standard · 27 January 1915 · page 6

A thrilling dramatization of "Custer's Last Stand " .u (I' I only living witness. ' dcSCr'bed by the Famous L-KO Comedy.

See the clipping