A former 7th Cavalry sergeant, M. C. Caddie, seeks a postmaster job and recounts his role in a burial party sent to Little Bighorn a year after the battle. He claims the original Reno burial detail had failed to properly inter the dead due to lack of tools, and describes nearly having Custer's body misidentified as a private's.
Grand Forks Daily Herald · 14 December 1914 · page 7
IS SEEKING JOB
Forthcoming Session. Bismarck, N. D., Dec. 14.—M. C. Caddie of Fort Rice was in Bismarck recently in the Interests of his can didacy for the postmastership in the house of representatives at the com ing session of the legislature. Mr. Caddie Is one of the old timers of the state, having come here In the early seventies with the seventh U. 8. cav alry in which he was a sargeant at the time of his honorable discharge. it will be remembered that this regi ment was the one that was almost entirely wiped out.
See moreSee less
at the time of the Custer massacre. Sargeant Caddie was one of the men who were detailed to remain behind and guard the wa gon train when that was abandoned and the rest of the advance made with a pack train. At the time of the Battle he was about 50 miles from the scene of the engagement. Just about one year after this h« was a member of the party that went to the cattle field to bury the dead. Every history states that the Reno com mand which arrived after the battle buried the dead," but according to the story of Sargent Caddie it had been impossible for them to do this on account of the fact that they had been traveling light and had had no tools with which to dig in the hard soil of the prairie and only a little loose dirt had been gathered and thrown over the bodies, and when the second party arrived a, year later all the skeletons were as fully exposed to the weather as though there had been no attempt at. burial. It became the duty of Sargeant Cad die and party to identify the dead as J® possible and see that the graves of the privates were marked with the name and regiment to which they be longed. There was a very narrow escape from having General Custer's remains Interred as those of one of the privates and it was only through the efforts of Mr. Caddie that this was prevented. A body supposed to be that of Cus ter had been placed in a coffin and prepared for shipment when it was found that a blouse on the corpse had the name of another man on It. Mr. Caddie then found a stake with Cus ter a name on it at the head of an other skeleton and there could then be no mistake as to the identity of the corpse. The men of the Reno com mand had written the name of the general on a slip of paper, put the I paper in an empty cartridge and then pounded the open end of the cartI nafire into the stajce. When asked if he was positive that there could be no question as to the identity of the man buried he said there was no po** sible chance for a mistake. The body °t Custer was taken to West Point where it now remains, while the re mains of the other officers were taken to Leavenworth for flnal interment. Mr. Caddie says there is one thing about the Custer fight wliich very few people knew until a very short time ago. Gustave Korn was the com pany blacksmith and when the com mand was about a half a mile from the Indian camp Korn had to stop to tighten up the cinch on his saddle, -and when he came up to-the com mand again it was impossible for him to stop his mount and he ran right through the Indians'to where Colonel Reno was. His horse was shot five times and dropped dead Just outside of the breastworks. Korn was not wounded at all but was the first man to be killed at the battle of Wounded Knee In 1890. Mr. Caddie is now farming near Fort Rice where he has a fine place and is taking his rest after the strenu ous years of frontier and pioneer life.
A former Seventh Cavalry sergeant seeking a legislative postmaster job recounts his service, including being part of a party that buried Custer's dead roughly a year after the battle. He claims the earlier Reno command's burial was inadequate, leaving skeletons exposed when his group arrived.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 17 December 1914 · page 7
WANTS LEGISLATIVE JOB
Dead From Custer's Fight. Bismarck, N. D., Dec. 14.— (Spe cial).—M. C. Caddie of Fort Rice was in Bismarck recently in the in terests of his candidacy for the post mastership in the house of repre sentatives at the coming session of the legislature. Mr. Caddie is one of the old-timers of the state, having come here in the early seventies with the Seventh United States cavalry, in which he was a sergeant at the time of his honorable discharge. It will be remembered that this regi ment was the one that was almost entirely wiped out at the time of the Custer massacre. Sergeant Caddie
A sergeant who helped bury the dead a year after the battle describes how shallow burials left skeletons exposed and recounts the near-misidentification of Custer's body. He also notes that blacksmith Gustav Korn survived the battle unscathed only to die later at Wounded Knee in 1890.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 17 December 1914 · page 7
Sergeant Caddie, it had been im possible for them to do this on ac count of the fact that they had been traveling light and had had no tools with which to dig in the hard soil of the prairie, and only a little loose dirt had been gathered and thrown over the bodies, and when the sec ond party arrived, a year later, all the skeletons were as fully exposed to the weather as though there had been no attempt at burial. It be came the duty of Sergeant Caddie and party to identify the dead as far as possible and see that the graves of the privates were marked with the name and regiment to which they belonged.
See moreSee less
There was a very narrow escape from having General Custer's remains interred as those of one of the privates, and it was only through the efforts, of Mr. Caddie that this was prevented. A body supposed to be that of Custer had been placed in coffin and prepared for shipment when it was found that a blouse on the corps had the name of another man on it. Mr. Caddie then found a stake with Custer's name on it at the head of another skeleton, and there could then be no mistake as to the identity of the corpse. The men of the Reno command and written the name of the general on a slip of paper, put the paper in an empty cartridge and then pounded the open end of the cartridge into the stake. When asked if he was positive that there could be no question as to the identity of the man buried, he said there was no possible chance for a mistake. The body of Custer was taken to West Point, where it now remains, while the remains of the other officers were taken to Leaven worth for final interment. Mr. Caddie sayB there is one thing about the Custer fight which very few people knew until a very, short time ago. Gustav Korn was the company blacksmith, and when the command waB about one-half mile from the Indian camp, Korn had to stop to tighten up the cinch on his saddle, and when he came up to the command again, it was Impossible for him to stop his mount and he ran right through the Indians to where Colonel Reno was. His horse was shot five times and dropped dead just outside of the breastworks. Korn was not wounded at all but was the first man to be killed at the battle of Wounded Knee in 1890. Mr. Caddie is now farming near Fort Rice, where he has a fine place, and is taking his rest after strenuous years of frontier and pioneer life.
A man named Sonnie Winbush returns to Charleston after 37 years claiming to be the sole survivor of Custer's 'massacre' at Little Big Horn, describing how he was shot and nearly killed but clung to his horse's stirrups. He blames white outlaws for inciting the Indian uprising.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.
Wrong
The West Virginia News · 19 December 1914 · page 6
THE LONE SURVIVOR. After an absence of 37 years, Sonnie Winbush, a battle scarred Cherokee Indian, who claims to have fought with Custer at the battle of Little Big Horn, and claims to be the only survivor of the massacre, returned to Char leston last week, to renew old friendships, says the Gazette. Winbush was an old friend of Squire M. Gilchrist's and the two had not seen each other for 37 years until now. The squire did not recognize his visitor, but Winbush knew Gilchrist at once. When Winbush left Charleston in 1877 he went west, and joined the army, serving as a scout in Colorado under General Joe Hooker, and then joined Custer, fighting with him in his last fatal stand in the Platte valley mas sacre.
See moreSee less
He lays the responsibility for the uprising on white out laws, who he says incited the In dians and led them to the slaugh ter. “It is commonly believed that not a single man, and only one horse escaped from the massa cre,” Winbush said, “but that is a mistake. One man did get away. Perhaps you have seen pictures of the battle with the riderless horse tleeing from the red men. That horse was mine and 1 was in the saddle. The portrayal is unauthentic, and misleading. I was shot through the chest and arms, and knocked from my saddle. I fell under the horse's body, and the poor beast, frantic with fright, and galloping for dear life kicked me in the head, but I managed to grasp the stirrups and pull my self back into the saddle. I was desperately wounded and lost consciousness. When I came to
An elderly man named Winbush, bearing numerous battle scars, recounts escaping on his horse to a trapper's den where he lay recovering for five months. He claims Custer was deliberately lured into a fatal trap by corrupt Indian agents and other white outlaws whom Custer had exposed.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.
Wrong
The West Virginia News · 19 December 1914 · page 6
THE LONE SURVIVOR.
Here’s my guarantee—Go to anv drug store and got. a 50 cent bottle of Hod son’s Liver Tone. Take a spoonful to night and if it doesn't straighten you right up and make you feel fine and vigorous by morning I want you to go back to the store and get yoxir money. Dodson's Liver Tone is destroying the sale of calomel because it is real liver medicine; entirely vegetable, therefore it can not salivate or make you sick. I guarantee that one spoonful of Dod son’s Liver Tone will put vour sluggish liver to work and clean your bowels of that sour bile and constipated waste which is clogging your system and mak ing you feel miserable.
See moreSee less
I guarantee that a bottle of Dodson’s Liver Tone Will keep your entire family feeling fine for months. Give it to your children. It is harmless; doesn’t gripe and they like its pleasant taste. •Advertisement. > [myself I was lying on a pallet in a trappers den, where my faith ! I'nl horse had carried me. It was live months before I recovered t enough to leave the place.” Tears streamed down the old man’s cheeks as he spoke. Winbush is 68 years old. He hears inanv scars of battle. One eye was almost shot out, and yet hears an ugly soar. Four fingers are shot oft of his right hand. He wears a silver plate in his skull, where a bullet tore out a deep gash. His legs are bullet seatred, and his arms and chest seamed with bullet wounds. The old veteran says Custer was lured into the trap, which re sulted in the annihilation of his force by dishonest Indian agents of the government whom Custer had exposed, and other white outlaws. Men who have been condemn ed to death in the state of Ore gon will escape the noose by the very narrow margin of 157 votes out of a total of more than 200, 000. Oregon voted on an amend ment to abolish capital punish ment, and the result was so close that the official canvass was ne cessary -to determine it. The affirmative vote was 100,552 and the negative vote 100,395. Thirty-five deaths and 918 in juries were caused by baseball during 1914, according to figures published this week by a sport writer who kept a tabulation of the season’s record. Of the play ers who died from injuries 20 were hit by pitched balls, five struck by bats, four were in col lision, four overexerted them selves, one was hurt sliding at a base and one was killed in • a fight.
A Nebraska dispatch reports the arrest at Edgar of a man calling himself 'Curly the Crow,' described as a former Indian scout and 'the last survivor of the Custer massacre.' He was being held to await extradition to Oshkosh, Wisconsin, on a charge of obtaining money under false pretenses.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 23 December 1914 · page 1
Former Indian Scout Arrested at Edgar Superior, Neb., Dec. 2li.—News bus been received here announcing the arrest of "Curly the Crow,” for mer Indian scout, and the last sur vivor of the Custer massacre. The former scout is said to he under ar rest at Edgar, awaiting the arrival of officials from Oshkosh, Wis.. where he is wanted on a charge of obtaining money under false pre tenses. "Curly the Crow” is known to pioneers through the west. Mrs. .1. Atherton went to Lincoln this morning to visit for a couple or days. The Beatrice Daily
A travelogue describes visiting Pine Ridge, Wounded Knee, and the Little Bighorn battlefield in Montana as tourist attractions, decades after the events. It recounts Custer's death with 276 men at the hands of Sitting Bull, Rain-in-the-Face and Crazy Horse, and mentions 'Curly' the scout as a guide for visitors.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Ogden Standard · 26 December 1914 · page 12
Montana. The Crow reservation 1 one of the easiest to reach of all western Indian reserves. In fact, the railroad from Omaha runs right through the town. The Indians ar on all sides. The famous battle field is only two miles from the sta tion. Old Indians who saw that ' l wave of G.000 wild Indians break over and inundute tho little band of blue-coated whites can be seen sitting around" In the sun. If one is lucky he can secure the services of Curly, the Indian scout, the only survivor of the Custer command, who for a consideration will con duct one over the battlefield, telling of the stirring events which oc curred upon every foot of the long hill.
See moreSee less
Mountains and prairies, rivers and lakes, canyons and peaeks, these are not the only attractions that tho West has to offer. There are the dians and their battlefields.
A 1914 newspaper travelogue describes Pine Ridge agency and the nearby Wounded Knee battlefield, where nearly 300 Sioux are buried under a monument. It recounts that the 7th Cavalry's attack at Wounded Knee avenged the earlier Little Bighorn massacre, in which Custer and 276 of his men were wiped out by Sitting Bull, Rain-in-the-Face, and Crazy Horse.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Sunday Telegram · 27 December 1914 · page 27
regiment "took revenge upon the Sioux for Iho roaseucre of the Little Big Horn, In which General George A. Custer and 276 men of his command were srlped out by the
The piece describes the Crow reservation in Montana as an easy-to-reach tourist destination near the Little Bighorn battlefield, accessible by rail from Omaha. It notes old Indians who witnessed the battle can still be seen, and mentions Curly, described as the only survivor of the Custer command, who guides visitors over the battlefield for a fee.
Held is only two iplloa from tho spttlon. Old Indians who. saw that wave of 0,000' wild Indians break, over and :iiiundate the little band of bluc-epnteflwhites cttnbeiiet>n Fitting around. in the Bun. If o.ne is lucky lie end secure the services of Curly, the Indian scout, the only I survivor of the Custer comtnand, 'g? who fpr -a consideration wllirapn-. duct one over the battlefield, telling Mk
The North Platte Semi-Weekly Tribune · North Platte, Neb.
A half-breed Indian who claimed to be the sole survivor of the Custer massacre and had visited North Platte several times was declared a fraud by the Oshkosh Herald. Investigators traveled to Montana, found the real Curly the Crow's grave under the name Ben McIntosh, proving the traveling claimant was an impostor.
The North Platte Semi-Weekly Tribune · 29 December 1914 · page 5
CLINTON, THE JEWELER Frank Beeler and Postmaster Ras mussen, of Hershey, were in town yesterday and were forced to re main until ono o'clock last night, hanging around wherever there was shelter. Tho people of Hershey and Sutherland don't visit North Platto so frequently since the inauguration of the extercmely por train service. Mr. and Mrs. II. G. Connett left last evening for their liomo In Chilcothe, 111., after spending several weeks in this city working on tho Connett mur der case. They remained for tho pre liminary hearing of Roy Roberts and then returned home.
See moreSee less
They will bo hero again for tho trial at tho next term of tho district court. "Curly, tho Crow," tho half breed Indian who has visited North Platto several times claiming to bo tho solo survivor of tho Custer massacre, Is pronounced a fakir by tho Oshkosh Herald. That paper says that Low ellen men mndo arrangements with "Curly" for a bear hunt near his ranch in Montana; that tho men went to Lodge Grass, Mont., Curly's home, nnd ascertained ho wns a fake, but did seo tho real "Curly, the Crow," and al so tho gravo of Ben Mcintosh, the name used by the impostcr